May 8, 2007 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Creating Competitive Advantage Thru Intelligent Development Visit Us On the

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Energy Policy Act of 2005 Section 1221 & 368 Update Board Meeting – Los Cabos, Mexico December 7 & 8, 2006.
Advertisements

The three most important considerations for development of wind farms are: LAND with good to excellent wind resource CONTRACT to sell electricity produced.
Renewable Resources Development Report California Energy Commission Business Meeting November 19, 2003 Ann Peterson Project Manager Technology Systems.
RE-Powering America’s Land FFLC Call August 28, 2013.
Overcoming Barriers to Wind Development in Appalachian Coal Country Brent Bailey, Ph.D. Director, Appalachia Program The Mountain Institute An overview.
 Jeremy Turner, Executive Director Phoenix, Arizona May 21, 2010.
Integrated Assessment of Off-shore Wind A Research Partnership between: Grand Valley State University Michigan Alternative and Renewable Energy Center.
The Wider Offshore Industry - Introduction. Why Renewables? Mb/doe Gas Nuclear Oil Renewables Coal Incremental.
Wind has provided 35% of all new electric generating capacity in America since 2007 Data Source: AWEA, EIA, SEIA, SNL Nearly 81,000 MW of new generating.
North American Power Group Western Mine-Mouth Coal-Fired Power Two Elk.
Wind energy in NZ 20% wind by 2030 Eric Pyle, Chief Executive, NZ Wind Energy Association.
BOSTON CHICAGO DALLAS DENVER LOS ANGELES MENLO PARK MONTREAL NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO WASHINGTON Governors’ Wind Energy Coalition November, 2011 Competitive.
Small Farm Profitability: Is Wind Energy the Answer? 1
May 22-23, 2008 ACC BTA Workshop May 22-23, 2008 Regional Renewable Energy Transmission Initiatives Laurie Woodall K.R. Saline and Associates, PLC Arizona.
State of the Wind Industry Denise Bode CEO American Wind Energy Association.
US Renewable Energy Markets: Financial Perspective By Michael D. Ware Advance Capital Markets, Inc. Washington Council of Governments Washington, DC June.
Maine Wind and Ocean Energy Industry Initiative An Overview Jeff Thaler Visiting Professor, University of Maine Co-Chair, E2Tech November 15, 2011.
Energy Policy Levers. 2 State as a Taxing Authority Income tax credits or deductions Income tax credits or deductions Residential Alternative Energy Tax.
Montana Ambassadors Helena, Montana February 25, 2011.
Desert Sky Wind Farm January 2004 Welcome Desert Sky Wind Farm Pecos County, Texas.
GE Energy Asia Development Bank Wind Energy Grid Integration Workshop: Issues and Challenges for systems with high penetration of Wind Power Nicholas W.
Renewable Energy: Legal and Policy Issues Frank Prager Vice President, Environmental Policy Xcel Energy November 20, 2009 Frank Prager Vice President,
1 Utility Ownership of Wind Power: Why it makes sense now American Wind Energy Association May 17, 2005 Eric Markell Senior Vice President Energy Resources.
Fossil Gulch Wind Park Presented By Jeff Duff Vice President, Airstreams LLC Welcome.
Rocky Mountain Area Transmission Study Connecting the Region Today for the Energy Needs of the Future Rocky Mountain Area Transmission Study Recommendations.
Warren Lasher Director, System Planning October 4, 2014 Our Energy Future.
Approach to the Wind Resource Assessment for the Sixth Power Plan Northwest Power & Conservation Council Generating Resources Advisory Committee August.
Past Studies and Resource Diversity Western Renewable Energy Zones, a joint initiative of the Western Governor’s Association and the U.S. Department.
Successful Transmission Planning & Development in the West Kelly Barr Manager, Regulatory Affairs & Contracts Salt River Project Phoenix, Arizona June.
Andrea Coon WREGIS Administrator NARUC Annual Convention Anaheim, California November 12, 2007 Western Renewable Energy Generation.
Colorado Renewable Requirements, Policies, and Projects James Tarpey, Esq. Commissioner Colorado Public Utilities Commission 1560 Broadway, Suite 250 Denver,
[Legislative] [American policy] Passing of the Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act (PURPA) in Introduced competition within the supply sector.
Presented to American Society of Civil Engineers Oregon Section Environmental & Water Resources Group Dana Siegfried David Evans and Associates, Inc.
February 2, 2012 The Simple Truths of Economic Development CB RICHARD ELLIS Presented to: 2012 ACMA Winter Conference Presented by: John Lenio, Economist.
1 Renewable Energy at Closed Landfills June 17, 2009 Jim Christo Massachusetts Renewable Energy Trust.
ISAC Fall School November 30, 2012 Iowa’s Wind Energy Industry & Economic Impact.
Development of Micro-Hydro Projects Stacey Simms Associate Director, Programs CREA Energy Innovations Summit.
Wind Energy Update Larry Flowers National Renewable Energy Laboratory November 30, 2007 Salt Lake City, UT.
Lisa Linowes 2010 Mid-America Regulatory Conference Consumer Forum June 6 - 9, 2010 Kansas City, Missouri Wind Energy: An Assessment.
Are we ready for the future? Rep. Jeff Morris Washington State Chair Technology, Energy, Communications Committee.
Business Development ……Where To From Here? FPL Group Bank Meeting September 21, 2004.
CWAG ENERGY CONFERENCE BIG SKY, MT Collaborative Efforts to Find Solutions: A Case Study – The Mountain States Transmission Intertie (MSTI) Presented by.
Sixth Northwest Conservation & Electric Power Plan Draft Wholesale Power Price Forecasts Maury Galbraith Northwest Power and Conservation Council Generating.
California Energy Commission Renewable Energy Transmission Initiative (RETI) Part I Jeffrey D. Byron California Energy Commission Energy Action Plan (EAP)
Integrating More Renewable Energy in the Grid Bert Garvin Vice President, Regulatory Affairs July 21, 2008 NARUC Summer Meeting July 22, 2008.
1 Clean Line Energy National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates Charleston SC Annual Meeting June 2012.
Combined Heat and Power Workshop Report and Next Steps Power Committee Briefing 7/15/03.
Clean and Diversified Energy Initiative Rich Halvey Western Governors’ Association Legislative Forum Monterrey, N.L., Mexico.
City of Port Angeles Strategic Planning Workshop for Power Supply June 7, 2011 Scott Corwin Executive Director Public Power Council.
Renewable & Alternative Power Senate Energy, Utilities & Communications Committee Stuart R. Hemphill Director, Renewable and Alternative Power Southern.
Western Renewable Energy Zone (WREZ) Concept (as of 11/27/07)
Bob Anderson West Wind Wires Siting and Policy Wind Power Plants* 119th Annual Convention Anaheim, CA November 16, 2007 NARUC *transmission, too.
Rocky Mountain Area Transmission Study Steering Committee Meeting 2013 Case Alt 1 & 2 - Iteration 2 – Test Transmission Solutions Alt 3 & 4 – Iteration.
CLASS and New Revenue from Wind Power Projects Annual Conference Seattle 2009.
California Energy Action Plan December 7, 2004 Energy Report: 2004 and 2005 Overview December 7, 2004.
Wind Energy. WIND ENERGY What Makes Wind Global Wind Patterns.
Energy Policy Act – 2005 West-Wide Energy Corridors.
WGA Consultants Keyes & Fox LLP is a law firm that specializes in the renewable energy and distributed generation sectors. K&F has in-depth experience.
Wind Energy in the U.S. and Pennsylvania. 5/13 Questions of the day: 1. Where do we get our Energy in PA? 1. Where do we get our Energy in PA? 2. What.
LS Power LS Power is a power generation and transmission group
R ENEWABLE E NERGY IN T EXAS Jess Totten Public Utility Commission of Texas 1.
Where does the water go? Flow diagrams of U.S. and Western water use 1/2/2013.
Session 21 (R) Utility Scale Solar Development Land and Permitting Issues March 30, 2016.
Dr. Robert K. Dixon June 2017.
Summary of Learning Objectives
4/23/2018 Steering Committee Meeting 2013 Case Alt 1 & 2 - Iteration 2 – Test Transmission Solutions Alt 3 & 4 – Iteration 1 - Define Congestion.
FUEL CELLS.
Indian Energy Initiatives Panel
Building Across Boundaries: Developing Energy Projects On Or Near Tribal Lands And Resources Laura Abram Director, Government & Public Affairs First Solar.
Exploring Wind Energy.
Presentation transcript:

May 8, 2007 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Creating Competitive Advantage Thru Intelligent Development Visit Us On the Western Renewable Power Development Summit San Francisco, California Where The Wind Is In the West

2 I. Value Drivers in Selecting Wind Sites II. Factors Affecting Cost Structure of Wind Projects III. Most Promising Geographic Areas IV. Niches and Contrarian Opportunities V. Most Important Factors Affecting Development and Timing of New Projects VI. Outlook and Forecast Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc.

3 I. Value Drivers in Selecting Sites Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. A. Wind Resource Power Classification 3+ to 6  Direct Correlation to Capacity Factor and Revenue B. Availability and Abundance of Land to Support Large Projects  Benefit of Economies of Scale and Lower Cost of Power C. Transmission Interconnection on or Near to Site  Very Big Industry Issue Into The Future D. Environmental and Zoning Permitting Feasibility  County Zoning Ordinance –Nimby and Banana  Airports, Military Radar, Radio, TV, and Microwave towers  Waters of the State and U.S.  BLM or Federal or Tribal – NEPA  Avian Bird and Bat Migration Pathways, Wildlife Habitat

4 I. Value Drivers in Selecting Sites Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. E. Market Structure and Dynamics  Ease of Obtaining PPA from Creditworthy Off taker  Alternatives- Liquid Hubs and Financial Hedges  RPS vs. No RPS States, Value of RECS Utility Avoided Cost Structure  Which Fuels on the Margin?  The Penny Rule Where Gas Is Not on The Margin F.Timing – Full Cycle Development Costs  Policy Framework Vs. No RPS  Big Player vs. Smaller Developer  Financial Staying Power vs. Speed and Nimbleness  Size Matters Where There is No Policy

5 II. Factors Affecting Cost Structure Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. A. Other than the PTC, The most important Factors to Lower The Cost of Power are:  Wind Resource and Capacity Factor  Economies of Scale- Larger Projects  Capital Costs and LTSA/Warranties  Industrial Equipment Sales Tax Exemption  Property Tax Relief  In Specific Projects - Transmission Interconnection Cost And Associated Upgrades

6 II. Other Factors Affecting Cost Structure Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. A. Corn Field or Flat Pasture Vs. Mountainous or Semi-Mountainous Terrain  Total Costs in Mountainous Terrain Can Increase 20-30% Especially for New Transmission Line, Foundations Transportation, Road Building, and Logistics Supply Chain B. Long Haul Transportation Costs Can Now Approach 20% of the Capital Costs of a Wind Turbine.  Value of Transportation Survey and Optimization Through Best Port of Entry More Important. Timing Available Resources Is Also Key. C.Cost of Substation Components and Power Collection Copper Cable Are Also Escalating

7 III. Most Promising Geographic Areas Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. A.The Steering Group of the Western Interconnection Of the Western Governors Association’s Clean Diversified Energy Advisory Committee Expects:  In Their Reference Case an Incremental 16,723 MW’s of Wind by 2015 Added in Western States  In Their Hi-Renewables Case an Incremental 41,797 MW’s of Wind by 2015 Added in Western States B. For Perspective, The industry has an Installed Base of 11,603 MW’s of Which 8,143 MW’s are in Western States  The Industry installed 2,454 MW’s in 2006 and Seems Constrained to About 2,500-3,500 MW’s a year currently.  1,673 of the MW’s Installed in 2006 were in Western States

8  ERGO!-This is A Promising Geographic Area This is How We Prospect For Wind

9 Western States - Wind Installed Base MW’s End of 2006 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Texas 2768 New Mexico 497 Colorado 291 Wyoming 288 UT 1 Montana 146 Idaho 75 California 2,361 Oregon 439 Washington 818 Greater than 2,000 MW Greater than 400 MW Greater than 50 MW Zero to 50 MW NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 Nevada 0 Arizona 0

10 Western States – Wind MW’s Installed During 2006 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Texas 774 New Mexico 90 Colorado 60 Wyoming 0 UT 0 Montana 9 Idaho 0 California 212 Oregon 100 Washington 428 Greater than 200 MW Greater than 100 MW Greater than 50 MW Zero to 50 MW NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 Nevada 0 Arizona 0

11 III. Most Promising Geographic Areas Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. State GwH RPS In Effect 1. Texas 1,190 YES 10,000 MW BY Montana 1,020 YES 15% BY Wyoming 747 NO 4. Colorado 481 YES 20% BY New Mexico 435 YES 20% BY Idaho 73 NO 7. California 59 YES 20% BY 2017 Western States (In the Top 20) Ranked by Resource Potential > Class 3 Note: Oregon, Washington, Arizona, Nevada, Utah Not Ranked in the Top 20 States for Wind Potential in the U.S.

12 Western States - Corridor of Untapped Resource Potential Shown on Map Of Installed Base MW’s Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Texas 2,768 New Mexico 497 Colorado 291 Wyoming 288 UT 1 Montana 146 Idaho 75 California 2,361 Oregon 439 Washington 818 Greater than 2,000 MW Greater than 400 MW Greater than 50 MW Zero to 50 MW NO. 1 NO. 2 NO. 3 Swath of Untapped Resources Montana,Wyoming Colorado, New Mexico, West Texas

13 Western States - Corridor of Untapped Resource Potential Shown on Map of Resource Potential GwH Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Texas 1,190 New Mexico 435 Colorado 481 Wyoming 747 UT Montana 1,020 Idaho 73 California 59 Oregon Washington Greater than 1,000 GwH Greater than 400 GwH Greater than 50 GwH Zero to 50 GwH NO. 1 Swath of Untapped Resources Potential Resource No. 2 No. 3 Arizona Montana,Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, West Texas

14 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. IV. Niches and Contrarian Strategies A. High Level Strategic Thoughts  Large Developers Can Influence Policy Framework  Their Staying Power and Large Balance Sheets Enable Them to Assemble a Position, and Wait for the Market to Develop Where There Is None Example : Be in Idaho and Wyoming Before There is An RPS Example: Position in Likely National Interest Transmission Corridors Before there is Transmission Capacity (EPACT&FERC–890)  Smaller Developers May Be Better Off Working in Areas of Established Framework and Competing on Speed and Nimbleness Example: Texas, California, Colorado, New Mexico

15 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. IV. Niches and Contrarian Strategies B. Specific Ideas For Niche Projects  Look at Untapped Resources on Native American Lands Arizona Example : Gray Mountain Navajo Tribe  Magnitude of 3-5,000 MW’s of Class 3+ Possible in Arizona  Integrated Wind with Pumped Storage –Shaped Product  May Integrate Well with Hydro in the Northwest or in Northern California  Re-powering Opportunities in Tehachapi Area of California - Could be up to 4,000 MW’s By 2015 Especially with New Transmission, like Tehachapi/Antelope Transmission Project  Consider the Economics of Meter Towers in Some Areas of Arizona, Nevada, Utah, Idaho -Suited to Zoning in Vast Unpopulated Regions

16 Arizona - Gray Mountain Wind Energy Site

17 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. Most Important Factors Affecting New Project Development and Timing A.The Two Most Important Factors Affecting New Project Development are RPS and Interconnection  Given that most Western States now have an RPS, the next Step in Policy Framework is Interconnection Initiatives at State and Possibly Federal Level Which is most important? RPS or Interconnection? Answer: BOTH! This is Like the Analogy of a Rowboat with Two Oars, One Oar is RPS, and the Other is Interconnection, and the Rowboat Can’t Row on a Straight Path Without Both Oars.

18 Copyright Trintek 2007 w/Credits to Jon Sayer/Illustrationweb Getting in the Queue for RPS Without Interconnection Policy Is a Shocking Mess!

19 Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. The Importance of Integrated RPS and Interconnection Policy Framework A.Western States That Really “Get It”  Texas – SB 20 CREZ Zone Initiative $2-3 Billion, Fast Track PUC & CPCN with Cost Recovery  New Mexico- HB 188 Renewable Energy Transmission Authority (RETA)– 30 % Must Come from Renewables  Colorado-SB 100 Energy Resource Zones, PUC Must Fast Track CPCN  California-SCE Proposed Renewable Trunk Line Tehachapi/Antelope Transmission Project- Integrate Large Clusters at Reasonable Distance from 220 Kv+ Lines with Cost Recovery

20 Would You Rather Row In Circles Or…. Sail? Trintek Energy Consulting, Inc. = Wind Powered INTERCONNECTION RPS +

21 Outlook and Forecast Continued Development : Oregon, Washington, California  California in Particular (Especially Southern California) is a Net Importer  These will continue to be Established and Attractive Markets, but Maturing and Highly Competitive Accelerating Development : Texas, New Mexico, Colorado, Wyoming, Montana, (The Corridor of Relatively Untapped Resources)  Favorable Transmission Policy Framework + Untapped Wind Potential Makes Texas, New Mexico, and Colorado Compelling Markets  Montana and Wyoming Are Exporters and New Transmission Capacity Will Be Vied for By Both Coal and Wind Which May Slow Wind Development Emerging Development : Arizona, Nevada, Utah, Idaho  Smaller Wind Potential, But Well Positioned for Export to California  Possible Attractive Niches in These 3,000-5,000 MW Size States  Possibly Slightly Higher Return Opportunities without as Much Competition