Terror Management and Acculturation: The Effects of Mortality Salience on Acculturation Attitudes toward Culturally Close and Culturally Distant Immigrant.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Becoming the Man or Woman You Want To Be
Advertisements

Demographic, Economic and Social Predictors of Psychological and Sociocultural Adaptation of Immigrant Youth Colleen Ward and Jaimee Stuart Centre for.
The Effect of Mortality Salience on Attitudes Toward Women Meredith Cotton Stephanie Goss Hanover College.
Samantha Nicholas & Khrys Nugent Hanover College
Figure 1. A Trial in the Old-Unpleasant IAT Task
Culture, Communication Practices, and Cognition: Selective Attention to Content Versus Context Keiko Ishii Hokkaido University, Japan.
The Ostrich effect: Social representations of Immigrants’ identity by native adolescents and by immigrants from Ethiopian and the former USSR Adi Mana.
Terror management theory (TMT; Solomon, Greenberg, & Pyszczynski, 1991) Human beings are explicitly aware of the inevitability of death Human beings are.
The Acculturation of Arab Immigrants in the U.S. Presented by Mohamed Abu-Qaoud.
Culture and psychological knowledge: A Recap
12/04/2006 Understanding & Predicting E-commerce Adoption: An Extension of the Theory of Planned Behavior (MIS Quarterly March 2006) Presented by: Yasmine.
Perceived threat and dehumanization of ethnic minorities An experimental investigation Afrodita Marcu Supervisors: Dr Evanthia Lyons & Dr Peter Hegarty.
Genetic Factors Predisposing to Homosexuality May Increase Mating Success in Heterosexuals Written by Zietsch et. al By Michael Berman and Lindsay Tooley.
The 2004 Presidential Election and Terror Management Theory York College, CUNY Department of Psychology Admissions Open House November 11, 2004.
Mutual Intercultural Relations in Plural Societies John W. Berry Queen’s University, Kingston, Canada National Research University, Higher School of Economics.
Enjoyability of English Language Learning from Iranian EFL Learners' Perspective.
Social Sciences use research and data analysis to explain human behaviour – what people think, how and why they act the way they do.
Next >>.
Fear and Mortality-Salience increase Volunteering Elise Murray, Kellen Mrkva, Travis Pruitt, Emily Conron, Elizabeth Peterson, Darcia Narvaez Methods Study.
Cultural Differences in Approaches to Arbitration Peter B. Smith University of Sussex Brunel University May 24, 2013.
Mortality Salience Amplifies Moral Appraisal The School of Natural and Behavioral Sciences UNDERGRADUATE RESEARCH SYMPOSIUM APRIL 19, 2012 – FORT LEWIS.
Theory ( TMT ) Adapted from: Russ Webster Kansas State University Manhattan, Kansas Terror Management.
HSP3U Triology Sciences. C ANADIAN C ULTURE What does being a Canadian mean to you? How do you know you are a Canadian Citizen? What does Multicultural.
Reframing the Discourse: Advertising Rhetoric Fails to Combat Islamophobia Eric Van Steenburg Doctoral Student University of North Texas Society for Marketing.
Recent studies have revealed the importance of considering acculturation when investigating sexuality in East Asian individuals. The purpose of this study.
Acculturation of Immigrants in Canada: A Comparison Study Saba Safdar Paper presented at the Canadian Psychological Association Calgary, Alberta June 9.
1 Psychology 307: Cultural Psychology Lecture 22.
James Svolos, Odalys Urena, and Tekhara Watson Penn State Erie, The Behrend College.
Gender Differences In Relational Versus Achievement Influences On Self-esteem Rick L. Payne, B.A., B.S. Department of Psychology, University of Dayton.
LINDSAY MYERS DR. LEVON ESTERS DR. RENEE MCKEE DR. MARK TUCKER Acculturation Orientations of 4-H Adult Volunteers Toward Minorities.
Cultural Issues Pertemuan 11 Matakuliah: L0332 – Psikologi Konseling Tahun: 2009.
A Rough Guide to Immigrant Acculturation: Hassles, Stress, & Support Saba Safdar, Ph.D. Centre for Cross-Cultural Research, Psychology Department Presented.
Myers’ EXPLORING PSYCHOLOGY (6th Ed) Chapter 1 Thinking Critically with Psychological Science.
1 GROUP BEHAVIOR. 2 WHAT IS GROUP? 3 GROUP Group consists of several interdependent people who have emotional ties and interact on a regular basis (Kesler.
Introduction linkage between institutions and public policy people argue for our distinctive institutions because they allow government to things differently.
C ULTURE. T HE E LEMENTS OF C ULTURE Culture: is the total of knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors shared by and passed on by the members of a specific.
What happens when you leave your home and country? Immigration issues.
Identity Development in a Cultural Context Dr. Randal G. Tonks February 24 th, 2006.
1 Psychology 307: Cultural Psychology Lecture 22.
Terror Management Theory
The Influence of Mortality Salience on Cooperative Behavior in the Prisoner’s Dilemma James Svolos, Odalys Urena, and Tekhara Watson Penn State Erie, The.
Chapter 2 Culture. Chapter Outline  Introducing Culture  Defining Culture  Cultural Knowledge  Culture and Human Life  Cultural Knowledge and Individual.
Toward Understanding Parenting Identity in Mexican American and European American Families Michael M. Harrod Department of Sociology University of California,
ACCULTURATIO N MODEL FOR L2 ACQUISITION Rubén Ávila Jenny Miranda.
Refugee Identity During Re-settlement and Beyond Kiran Sidhu Education 856.
Psychology 307: Cultural Psychology
INTERGROUP RELATIONS IN PLURAL SOCIETIES PSYC 338.
What is a World View? MAKING SENSE OF OUR WORLD. How Do We Make Sense Of Our World?
Method Design 2 prime type (MS vs. Pain) x 3 age of object (New vs. 20 years vs. 100 years) Participants N = 288 Mturk workers males, age: M =
Acculturation Strategies and Arab Youth Cultural Identity Development: A Review Riham Al-Saadi University of Windsor References Aroian, K.J., Templin,
Methods Participants. Participants (N = 72) were predominantly female (n = 54), Caucasian (85.5%) and (SD = 3.41) years of age. Materials and Procedure.
Better to Give or to Receive?: The Role of Dispositional Gratitude
Eleni-Ilianna Mavropoulou & Kenneth E
Professor: Institute of Education
Socio-Cultural Influences
The self.
Seeking the Shield of Faith: The Influence of Defensive Theology on the Development of Religious Fundamentalism Following Mortality Salience Brian Lammert,
THE FIELD OF SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY
Chapter 6: Our Cultural Mosaic
The effects of MORTALITY SALIENCE ON SELF-REPORTED Health practices
Jacob A. Jardel Cameron University Dr. Jenel T. Cavazos
Jacob Jardel, Cameron University
How Do Psychologists Ask & Answer Questions?
Thinking of Safety Through a Different Lens
Chapter 9 Intercultural Adaptation 第九章 跨文化适应
Myers’ EXPLORING PSYCHOLOGY (6th Ed)
Maja Krtalic Personal Cultural Heritage Management of Croatian Expatriates in New Zealand Maja Krtalic
Cross-National Comparisons of Monetary Donations to
Presentation transcript:

Terror Management and Acculturation: The Effects of Mortality Salience on Acculturation Attitudes toward Culturally Close and Culturally Distant Immigrant Groups Darcy R. Dupuis & Saba Safdar Department of Psychology, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario Objectives IntroductionMethod Results Conclusions This research was designed to explore whether implicit existential concerns can influence the acculturation attitudes held by receiving society members. With hypotheses rooted in Terror Management Theory (TMT; Greenberg, Pyszczynski, & Solomon, 1986), this study examined whether mortality salience (MS) can affect Canadian citizens’ acculturation attitudes held toward culturally close (British) and culturally distant (Arab-Muslim) immigrant groups within six specific life domains. It was predicted that MS would result in (1) higher separation and lower assimilation held toward British immigrants and higher assimilation and lower separation held toward Arab-Muslim immigrants.  TMT maintains that, “cultural conceptions of reality serve the vital function of buffering the anxiety that results from awareness of human vulnerability and mortality” (Rosenblatt, Greenberg, Solomon, Pyszczynski, & Lyon, 1989, p. 681).  Culturally derived worldviews allow for individuals to perceive themselves as valuable beings in a meaningful world. When mortality is made salient, in order to guard against the potential for anxiety associated with thoughts of death, individuals are increasingly driven to maintain the conviction with which their worldview is held.  Acculturation attitudes of receiving society members involve the degree to which immigrants are expected to (1) maintain aspects of their heritage culture and (2) adopt aspects of the receiving society’s culture.  As cultures that are perceived as distant from one’s own may present a threat to one’s worldview, when mortality is salient there should be an increased tendency to be less welcoming of their culture and to value the group’s adoption of the receiving culture. On the other hand, those individuals who are culturally close tend to provide support for one’s worldview; thus, there should be a tendency to increasingly value their culture when mortality is salient. The same directional shift was expected within each acculturation domain. Hypotheses: 1. MS will lead to (a) higher separation and (b) lower assimilation held toward culturally close British immigrants. 2. MS will lead to (a) higher assimilation and (b) lower separation held toward culturally distant Arab-Muslim immigrants. 3. MS will not lead to significant shifts toward or away from integration or marginalization. 186 Canadian participants were randomly assigned to a 2 (mortality vs. control) × 2 (Arab-Muslim immigrants vs. British immigrants) between-subjects design. Participants were given a MS or a control prime embedded in a questionnaire package. The MS prime comprised two open ended questions (control questions involved failing an exam): “Please briefly describe the emotions that the thought of your own death arouses in you.” “Jot down, as specifically as you can, what you think will happen to you as you physically die and once you are physically dead.” Participants then completed a delay and distraction (PANAS-X & word search task) followed by the dependent measure: The Relative Acculturation Extended Model (RAEM; Navas et al., 2005) measure for receiving society members, targeting attitudes toward either British or Arab-Muslim immigrants. The RAEM measures 4 acculturation attitudes (Integration, Assimilation, Separation, Exclusion) and 6 domains of acculturation: labour and work, consumer habits and family economy, family, social, religious beliefs and customs, and ways of thinking (principles and values). W – labour/ work E - economic S - social relationships F - family relations R - religious beliefs and customs T - ways of thinking: principles and values British Arab-Muslim ▲- MS О - Control General Effects  ANOVAs on Euclidean distances revealed interactions between MS and immigrant group for assimilation F(1, 185) = 6.55, p =.01, η p 2 =.03, and separation, F(1, 185) = 6.06, p =.01, η p 2 =.03. Simple effects were significant for MS effects on separation, F(1, 185) = 5.93, p <.05, η p 2 =.03, and assimilation, F(1, 185) = 4.90, p <.05, η p 2 =.03, toward British but not Arab-Muslim immigrants (see right).  The culture maintained by British immigrants may provide symbolic validation for an Anglo- Canadian worldview in the face of MS. This may especially be the case because of the potential for symbolic threat that may be perceived within a multicultural society.  It is possible that social desirability may have mitigated the expected effects of MS on attitudes toward Arab-Muslim immigrants. This cannot be confirmed.  This study lends support to the notion that terror management processes may lead to divergence in the degree to which immigrants are expected to maintain their heritage culture and/or adopt the receiving society’s culture.  This research differs from past TM studies as it reveals that the need to validate one’s cultural worldview may lead to a desire for others in one’s home country to adopt and maintain aspects of culture consistent with one’s own worldview.  This research provides empirical support for the notion that symbolic terror management processes may be one route through which divergent expectations for distinct immigrant groups can arise within specific life domains.  Research may further examine whether enhancing the salience of a multicultural ideology can mitigate the observed effects (via enhancing the accessibility of a more inclusive or tolerant worldview). Domain Specific Effects  Expected interactions were significant for the family and the social relationships domains.  Social Relations: An interaction was observed for assimilation, F(1, 185) = 4.44, p <.05, η p 2 =.02. Simple effects did not reveal effects of MS on either immigrant group.  Family Relations: ANOVAs on Euclidean distances revealed interactions between MS and immigrant group for assimilation F(1, 185) = 7.30, p <.01, η p 2 =.04, and separation, F(1, 185) = 6.86, p <.05, η p 2 =.04. Simple effects revealed that MS led to higher assimilation toward Arab-Muslims F(1, 185) = 8.96, p <.01, η p 2 =.05 and higher separation toward the British F(1, 185) = 8.28, p <.01, η p 2 =.04.  Thus, the only significant shift in attitudes toward Arab-Muslims occurred within the domain of family relations (see below). Rosenblatt, A., Greenberg, J., Solomon, S., Pyszczynski, T., & Lyon, D. (1989). Evidence for terror management theory: I. the effects of mortality salience on reactions to those who violate or uphold cultural values. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 57(4), Navas, M., Garcia M. C., Sanchez, J., Rojas, A. J., Pumares, P., & Fernandez, J. S. (2005). Relative acculturation extended model (RAEM): New contributions with regard tot he study of acculturation. International Journal of Intercultural Relations, 29, *This project was funded by SSHRC - Canada Graduate Scholarship.