WP8: Valuation Online Deliverables Sumaila and all members of WP8 WP1 Workshop: Data Tools & Outreach May 16-19, 2006
WP8 team members Claire Armstrong, UiT, Norway; Ratana Chuenpagdee, CDC, Thailand; Moenieba Isaacs, UWC, South Africa; Kungwan Juntarashote, CDC, Thailand; Kevin Stephanus, UNAM, Namibia; Abbie Trinidad, PRIMEX-FAME, Philippines; Sheila Heymans, Namibia & UBC; Patricia Susan Alexander, UNAM; Jannike Falk-Petersen, UiT, Norway; Rashid Sumaila, UNAM&UBC.
WP8 objectives Provide social & economic data to the INCOFISH Db; Value marine ecosystem goods and services; Develop economic and social indicators of ineffective management; Develop policy options for sustainable coastal resources management; Publish at least 5 papers in the primary literature.
Economic & Social Database Coastal stakeholders by country; Economic information; –Ex-vessel prices by taxon by country by year; –Cost of fishing by country by gear type; –non-market values by country. Coastal institutions & management mechanisms by country; Global database summary by country.
Coastal stakeholders by country Fishers – subsistence, artisanal, recreational; Fishworkers; Fishing Industries; NGOs; Unions; Researchers – scientists, economists, social…; Fish “mammas” sellers/traders.
Ex-vessel prices Point portal to SAUP website;
Cost of fishing RegionCountryGear typeFixed costs Variable costs References/ notes AfricaNamibiaWet fish trawlers Freezer trawlers Purse seiners …………… AsiaThailandBottom trawl Driftnets Purse seiners ………………
Non-market: Data structure Title, year, author; Country and district; Ecosystem/species studied; Type of publication; Valuation technique used; Results; Policy implications/recommendations, if any.
Market Values Non Market Values Fisheries in US$ Tourism w/ Coral Reefs Coral Reefs in $US Application CountryCVMTC Thailand mPhi phi Belize527Belize 219Belize N. Antilles115Bonaire Philippines3.7Anilao Philippines5.5Mactan Island Australia136 millionGBR Indonesia3.8 billion Philippines52.7 million Jamaica7.49 million210 m Vietnam17.9 million Malaysia4.2Pulau Payar Mexico11 million Red snapper in Gulf of Mexico Philippines15 billionMER Cambodia233 million
Coastal Institutions Point portal to SAUP website;
Management mechanisms Mechanisms ThailandNamibiaSAfricaAngolaNorway Input RestrictionsGear restrictionsx???x Area Restrictions????x Time restrictionsx???x Entrance restrictionsx[1][1]x??x Bycatch restrictions?x??x Output restrictionsTAC ’ s?xx?x[2][2] IQs?xx?x Bycatch regulations?x??x Market mechanismsTaxes?x[3][3]??- ITQs?x[4][4]??x[5][5] Subsidies?x[6][6]??x[7][7] Management formsTop down?x??x Bottom up?-?x Local managementx[8][8]-?- Transparency of allocations ?-?x Catch MonitoringOffshore?x??x Onshore????x Inspectors aboard?x??-
Management mechanisms ThailandNamibiaSAfricaAngolaNorway Stock assessmentSingle speciesxxxxx Multispecies Ecosystemx Social parameters Economic parameters
Global database summary Country LSF catch (t) SSF catch (t) SSF values (US$) # SS fishersAqua (t) Albania 2, , Algeria 99,936 3,105 7,620,288 1,36299 Amer Samoa 2, , Angola 285,636 50, ,625,859 25,5000 Antigua Barb 1,435 2,527 5,933,263 1,0880 Argentina 675,093 8,184 20,084,235 1,69024,393 ………………
Summary of top ten countries Numbe r % Coastal population Large-scale fisheries production Small-scale fisheries production Aquacultur e production Fisheries and aquaculture employee# of tourism 1ArgentinaPeruIndonesiaChina Main France 2AustraliaChina MainJapan IndiaSpain 3BahamasIndonesiaIndiaEgyptIndonesiaUSA 4Bahrain Russian FedViet Nam Korea, SouthBangladeshItaly 5BangladeshChileChina MainGreeceViet NamChina Main 6BarbadosJapanChileTurkeyPhilippines United Kingdom 7BelgiumIndiaPhilippinesItalyMyanmarMalaysia 8BelizeNorwayUSA-AlaskaSpainNigeriaRussian Fed 9BeninUSA-AlaskaCanadaIndonesiaThailandGermany 10BrazilIcelandVenezuelaFranceRussian FedCanada
Thanks for your attention