Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability Bjarne S. Kallesøe Morten H. Hansen.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

National Aeronautics and Space Administration Wind turbines generate electric power from clean renewable sources. They must be robust and.

Advertisements

Light Rotor: The 10-MW reference wind turbine

EWEA Annual Event 2013 Vienna February, 4-7, 2013

Delft University of Technology Aeroelastic Modeling and Comparison of Advanced Active Flap Control Concepts for Load Reduction on the Upwind.

Investigation of Stability Issues for an Adaptive Trailing Edge System Leonardo Bergami MSc + PhD student, Risø DTU, Denmark Mac Gaunaa Senior Scientist,

Aeroelasticity : Complexities and Challenges in Rotary–Wing Vehicles

The potentials of the controllable rubber trailing edge flap (CRTEF) Helge Aa. Madsen 1, Peter B. Andersen 1, Tom L. Andersen 2, Thomas Buhl 1, Christian.

Power Flow Active Control of Aeroelastic Flutter for a Nonlinear Airfoil with Flap N.Zhao 1,2, Supervisors – Dr. Y.P.Xiong 1 and Prof. D.Q.Cao 2 1 School.

Nonlinear Model Reduction for Flexible Aircraft Control Design A. Da Ronch, K. J. Badcock University of Liverpool, Liverpool, U.K. Y. Wang, A. Wynn, and.

ASME 2002, Reno, January VIBRATIONS OF A THREE-BLADED WIND TURBINE ROTOR DUE TO CLASSICAL FLUTTER Morten Hartvig Hansen Wind Energy Department Risø.

European Wind Energy Conference and Exhibition 2010 Warsaw, Poland EWEC 2010 Warsaw April 2010 Aeroelastic Analysis of Pre-Curved Rotor Blades V.A.Riziotis,S.G.Voutsinas.

A Comparison of Multi-Blade Coordinate Transformation and Direct Periodic Techniques for Wind Turbine Control Design Karl Stol Wind Energy Symposium AIAA.

Disturbance Accommodating Control of Floating Wind Turbines

Hazim Namik Department of Mechanical Engineering

Gireesh Ramachandran Amy Robertson Jason Jonkman Marco Masciola

Alan D. Wright Lee J. Fingersh National Renewable Energy Laboratory

PROJECTS WITH POTENTIAL FUNDING

1 Adviser ： Dr. Yuan-Kang Wu Student ： Ti-Chun Yeh Date ： A review of wind energy technologies.

Aeroelastic Stability and Control of Large Wind Turbines

Computational Modelling of Unsteady Rotor Effects Duncan McNae – PhD candidate Professor J Michael R Graham.

Model Reduction for Linear and Nonlinear Gust Loads Analysis A. Da Ronch, N.D. Tantaroudas, S.Timme and K.J. Badcock University of Liverpool, U.K. AIAA.

FLIGHT DYNAMICS OF THE FLEXIBLE AIRCRAFT INCLUDING UNSTEADY AERODYNAMIC EFFECTS Grégori Pogorzelski (1,2), Roberto G. A. da Silva (1) and Pedro Paglione.

Design Process Supporting LWST 1.Deeper understanding of technical terms and issues 2.Linkage to enabling research projects and 3.Impact on design optimization.

Wind Modeling Studies by Dr. Xu at Tennessee State University

Aerodynamics and Aeroelastics, WP 2

NREL – Jason Jonkman MARINTEK – Ivar Fylling Risø-DTU – Torben Larsen

3D Dynamic Stall Modelling on the NREL phase VI Parked Blade ALVARO GONZALEZ XABIER MUNDUATE 47th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit Orlando,

Review of IEA Wind Task 23 OC3 Project Operated for the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy by the Alliance for.

Design Tools & Codes Technology Viability Jason Jonkman, Ph.D.

Smart Rotor Control of Wind Turbines Using Trailing Edge Flaps Matthew A. Lackner and Gijs van Kuik January 6, 2009 Technical University of Delft University.

Dynamically Variable Blade Geometry for Wind Energy

Identification of Eighteen Flutter Derivatives Arindam Gan Chowdhury a and Partha P. Sarkar b a Graduate Research Assistant, Department of Aerospace Engineering,

Recent and Future Research for Bird-like Flapping MAVs of NPU Prof. B.F.Song Aeronautics School of Northwestern Polytechnical University.

Innovation for Our Energy FutureNational Renewable Energy Laboratory 1 Gunjit Bir National Renewable Energy Laboratory 47 th AIAA Aerospace Meetings Orlando,

Wind Energy Program School of Aerospace Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology Computational Studies of Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR:

LOAD ALLEVIATION ON WIND TURBINE BLADES USING VARIABLE AIRFOIL GEOMETRY Thomas Buhl, Mac Gaunaa, Peter Bjørn Andersen and Christian Bak ADAPWING.

Voltage grid support of DFIG wind turbines during grid faults

Jason JonkmanSandy ButterfieldNeil Kelley Marshall BuhlGunjit BirBonnie Jonkman Pat MoriartyAlan WrightDaniel Laird 2006 Wind Program Peer Review May 10,

Integrated Dynamic Analysis of Floating Offshore Wind Turbines EWEC2007 Milan, Italy 7-10 May 2007 B. Skaare 1, T. D. Hanson 1, F.G. Nielsen 1, R. Yttervik.

REDUCTION OF TEETER ANGLE EXCURSIONS FOR A TWO-BLADED DOWNWIND ROTOR USING CYCLIC PITCH CONTROL Torben Juul Larsen, Helge Aagaard Madsen, Kenneth Thomsen,

TOWER SHADOW MODELIZATION WITH HELICOIDAL VORTEX METHOD Jean-Jacques Chattot University of California Davis OUTLINE Motivations Review of Vortex Model.

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF WIND TURBINE AERODYNAMICS Jean-Jacques Chattot University of California Davis OUTLINE Challenges in Wind Turbine Flows The Analysis.

OC 3 : Benchmark Exercise of Aero-elastic Offshore Wind Turbine Codes J A Nichols and T R Camp, Garrad Hassan and Partners Ltd. J Jonkman and S Butterfield,

Tim Fletcher Post-doctoral Research Assistant Richard Brown Mechan Chair of Engineering Simulating Wind Turbine Interactions using the Vorticity Transport.

EWEC 2006, AthensMartin Geyler 1 Hardware-in-the-Loop Development and Testing of New Pitch Control Algorithms EWEC 2006 Athens Martin Geyler, Jochen Giebhardt,

EWEC 2007, MilanoMartin Geyler 1 Individual Blade Pitch Control Design for Load Reduction on Large Wind Turbines EWEC 2007 Milano, 7-10 May 2007 Martin.

HELICOIDAL VORTEX MODEL FOR WIND TURBINE AEROELASTIC SIMULATION Jean-Jacques Chattot University of California Davis OUTLINE Challenges in Wind Turbine.

UPWIND, Aerodynamics and aero-elasticity

An Introduction to Rotorcraft Dynamics

AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting 2009

European Wind Energy Conference and Exhibition 2006 Athens, Greece EWEC’06 Athens 27 February-2 March 20061/16 Investigation of the Stability Bounds of.

Challenges in Wind Turbine Flows

Supervisor: Dr David Wood Co-Supervisor: Dr Curran Crawford

A Quantitative Comparison of Three Floating Wind Turbines

WIND TURBINE CONTROL DESIGN TO REDUCE CAPITAL COSTS P. Jeff Darrow(Colorado School of Mines) Alan Wright(National Renewable Energy Laboratory) Kathryn.

Modal Dynamics of Wind Turbines with Anisotropic Rotors Peter F

DEWEK 2004 Lecture by Aero Dynamik Consult GmbH, Dipl. Ing. Stefan Kleinhansl ADCoS – A Nonlinear Aeroelastic Code for the Complete Dynamic Simulation.

Wind Energy Program School of Aerospace Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology Computational Studies of Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines PRINCIPAL INVESTIGATOR:

Advanced Controls Research Alan D. Wright Lee Fingersh Maureen Hand Jason Jonkman Gunjit Bir 2006 Wind Program Peer Review May 10, 2006.

WIND TURBINE ENGINEERING ANALYSIS AND DESIGN Jean-Jacques Chattot University of California Davis OUTLINE Challenges in Wind Turbine Flows The Analysis.

Date of download: 6/26/2016 Copyright © ASME. All rights reserved. Flutter of Variations on a 5 MW Swept Wind Turbine Blade 1 J. Sol. Energy Eng. 2016;138(2):

Aerodynamic Damping (WP2)

Short introduction to aeroelasticity

INVESTIGATION OF IDLING INSTABILITIES IN WIND TURBINE SIMULATIONS

Talents of tomorrow: Aerodynamics and aeroelasticity

AAE 556 Aeroelasticity Lecture 6

UPWIND, Aerodynamics and aero-elasticity

Dynamic analysis of wind turbines subjected to Ice loads

Rotors in Complex Inflow, AVATAR, WP2

Conceptual research of a downwind turbine, based on a Suzlon 2

Presentation transcript:

Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability Bjarne S. Kallesøe Morten H. Hansen

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability2Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Introduction Why? Does the deflection of turbine blades effect the aeroelastic properties of the blades? What? Compare frequencies, damping and shapes of aeroelastic modes of motion for undeflected and steady state deflected blade How? Eigenvalue analysis 2 nd order Bernoulli-Euler beam and time simulations with Risø’s in-house aeroelastic simulation tool, HAWC2

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability3Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Background Large turbines with flexible blade

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability4Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Blade Model #1 2 nd order Bernoulli-Euler beam (2 nd B-E) 1 –Similar to Hodges and Dowell 2 –Extended to include the effects of pitch action, gravity and rotor speed variations –Furthermore, models for pitch action and rotor speed are derived –Quasi-static aerodynamic for non-linear steady state version –Unsteady dynamic stall model 3 for linear unsteady version 1) Kallesoe, B., Equations of motion for a rotor blade, including gravity, pitch action and rotor speed variations, Wind Energy, Vol. 10, No. 3, 2007, pp. 209–230. 2) Hodges DH, Dowell EH. Nonlinear equations of motion for the elastic bending and torsion of twisted nonuniform rotor blades. Technical Report TN D-7818, NASA, December ) Hansen, M., Gaunaa, M., and Madsen, H., A Beddoes-Leishman type dynamic stall model in state-space and indicial formulation, Tech. Rep. Risø -R-1354(EN), Risø National Laboratory, (available from August 2004.

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability5Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Blade Model #1 Edge-twist coupling of flapwise deflected blade Part of nonlinear equation of motion for edgewise blade motion: Linearized about deflected blade: Part of nonlinear equation of motion for torsional blade motion: Linearized about deflected blade:

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability6Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Blade Model #2 Risø’s in-house aeroelastic code (HAWC2) 1,2 –Time domain simulations –Combined Beam-element and multi-body formulation –BEM theory, extended to handle dynamic inflow, dynamic stall, skew inflow, shear effects on the induction and effects from large deflections –Stiff turbine except for the blades –No induction and tip loss 1) Larsen, T., Hansen, A., and Buhl, T., Aeroelastic effects of large blade deflections for wind turbines, Proceedings of the special topic conference ”The Science of making Torque from Wind”, 2004, pp. 238–246. 2) Larsen, T., Madsen, H., Hansen, A., and Thomsen, K., Investigations of stability effects of an offshore wind turbine using the new aeroelastic code HAWC2, Proceedings of the conference ”Copenhagen Offshore Wind 2005”, 2005.

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability7Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Test case: Overspeed NREL 5 MW reference turbine 1 –61.5 m blade –No structural damping –Rated rotor speed: 1.26 rad/s Operational conditions –wind speed: 10 m/s –0 deg pitch –Stepwise increase of rotor speed Method –First; Computer steady state blade deflection at different rotor speeds –Next; Compute aeroelastic frequencies and damping 1) Jonkman J., Nrel’s offshore baseline 5MW turbine. Technical report, NREL/NWTC, 1617 Cole Boulevard; Golden, CO , USA, 2005.

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability8Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Steady state blade deflection 2 nd B-E –Full non-linear beam –Quasi-static aerodynamic –Finite difference discretisation of spatial derivatives HAWC2 –High structural damping to suppress any modes with negative aerodynamic damping

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability9Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Unsteady blade motion 2 nd B-E –Linearized blade model –Linear unsteady dynamic stall model –Two cases: Linearized about the undeflected blade Linearized about the steady state deflected blade –Finite difference discretisation of spatial derivatives –Solve eigenvalue problem to compute aeroelastic frequency and damping HAWC2 –Measuring decay or growth of blade vibration amplitude, and measuring the dominating frequency

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability10Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Aeroelastic frequencies and damping Circles: undeflected blade Stars: steady state deflected blade Squares: HAWC2 Frequency Damping

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability11Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Second mode (First edgewise mode) Circles: undeflected blade Stars: deflected blade

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability12Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Second mode (First edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability13Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Second mode (First edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability14Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Second mode (First edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability15Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Circles: undeflected blade Stars: deflected blade

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability16Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability17Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability18Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability19Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability20Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability21Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fourth mode (Second edgewise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability22Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fifth mode (Third flapwise mode) Circles: undeflected blade Stars: deflected blade

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability23Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fifth mode (Third flapwise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability24Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fifth mode (Third flapwise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability25Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Fifth mode (Third flapwise mode) Green: undeflected Blue: deflected Wind Circles: undeflected Stars: deflected Blue: edge Green: flap Red: twist

6/01/2009Some effects of large blade deflections on aeroelastic stability26Risø DTU, Technical University of Denmark Conclusion Large blade deflection do effect the aeroelastic stability of a turbine blade Flapwise steady state blade deflection couples edgewise and torsional motion The extra torsional motion changes the aerodynamic forces, such that more flapwise motion is introduced in the edgewise modes The stability limit is reduced, but still well above normal operation.