Nonprofit Law in Plain English Board Legal Responsibilities and Liability Issues by Myles McGregor-Lowndes Centre of Philanthropy and Nonprofit Studies.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Policies for Nonprofit Boards Dan Rollman August 18, 2011.
Advertisements

Private & Confidential. Not for distribution. ©DWF LLP Title needs degree sign (°) added from the Insert/Symbol menu. This needs to.
A GIA is a contract between a surety company and a contractor (or subcontractor)/principal. A GIA is a standard, typical document in the construction.
Duties and Responsibilities of a Board Member
Copyright © 2012, Big I Advantage®, Inc., and Swiss Re Corporate Solutions. All rights reserved. (Ed. 08/12 -1) E&O RISK MANAGEMENT: MEETING THE CHALLENGE.
Mark Radford, Partner, Colin Biggers & Paisley, Australia Conflicts of interest faced by reinsurance brokers and duties owed by producing and placing brokers.
The Role of the Director Presented by David Spear State Manager SA/NT MAY 2013.
Exposure to Trustees, Officers Employees and The University Liability, Immunity, Indemnity and Fiduciary Issues 1.
Legal Responsibilities for Board Members of Nonprofit Organizations Or…all you need to know to stay out of trouble. Presented: July 2007 Prepared by: Elsbeth.
 Trustee must invest following the appropriate standard of care.  Personally liable for failure to do so.  But, trustee is not an insurer; only liable.
PARTNERSHIPS, CORPORATIONS AND THE VARIANTS PROF. BRUCE MCCANN SPRING SEMESTER LECTURE 1 DUTY OF LOYALTY PP Business Organizations Lectures.
Duties of a Trustee Chris Smail - Langer & Co /02/2011.
LEGAL CONSEQUENCES John Mullins 03/09/ POTENTIAL LIABILITIES IN SPORT Torts Law – negligence Contract law Statutory obligation - workplace health.
Running Your Club Corporate Governance Presentation.
Board of Director’s Training December 5, Board’s Ultimate Responsibility.
Presented by Julia Sweeney, Partner Fisher Jeffries p e w fisherjeffries.com.au BETTER GOVERNANCE FOR A CHANGING.
Governance Fundamentals Roles, Responsibilities and Expectation Setting for Stronger Staff and Board Partnerships 1 Local Government Commission November.
Governing a Tax-Exempt Nonprofit Corporation The Basics MPCC December 16, 2010.
Charities and trading Jane Lee, Partner Pannone LLP 18 th April 2012.
Governance & reporting considerations in the new world of NFPs & the ACNC +Dr Eva Tsahuridu – Policy Adviser, Professional Standards & Governance, CPA.
A Review of Board of Health Liability James A. LeNoury LeNoury Law Counsel to alPHa February 5th, 2015.
Fiduciary Responsibility Frye Financial Center Creating, Protecting and Preserving Wealth
Code & Constitution - South Somerset District Council Code & Constitution Ian Clarke Assistant Director – Legal & Corporate Services.
Title (edit on Master Slide) Subtitle. Title (edit on Master Slide) Subtitle Working as A Board TEAM for Successful Board Management Presenter: Deb Fritz.
WHAT EVERY NOT-FOR-PROFIT DIRECTOR SHOULD KNOW By REUBEN S. SEGURITAN 450 Seventh Avenue, Suite 1400, New York, NY Phone Fax
Understanding Your Roles and Responsibilities “Volunteers are the glue that holds the community together”
Directors’ Duties in the OnLine Environment July 2001 Carolyn Reynolds.
1 Presented by John Rogito Chweya. DELIVERABLES After the presentations, the following questions should be answered. i) Who is the Director and Board.
Presentation on Directors’ Role, Responsibility and Liabilities By L V V Iyer L V V Iyer & Associates Corporate Lawyers Hyderabad.
Risk Management Policy & Procedures An Overview for Staff Prepared by MSM Compliance Services Pty Ltd.
Councillor Community Fund Isabell Procter Director of Resources Francis Fernandes Borough Secretary.
Corporate Governance.  According to King III, the board should: ◦ be responsible for the strategic direction and control of the company; ◦ set the values.
Introduction of Governance Standards.  Refer ACNC Act  Regulations passed in June 2013  Apply from 1 July 2013  5 Standards  A ‘base-line’ not best.
For more information visit us at Small Charities Coalition Duties of a trustee Catherine Rustomji Head of Third Sector North, Hempsons.
OHS Seminar DO THE TIME – avoid the crime! Miles Crawley 8 June 2007.
DIRECTOR’S LEGAL LIABILITIES Doug Jackson Gungoll, Jackson, Collins & Box, P.C.
Page 1 John F. Levy Board Advisory (O): (908) (O): (201)
MODULE 2 INTRODUCTION TO DIRECTORS’ DUTIES ADB Private Sector Development Initiative Corporate and Financial Governance Training Solomon Islands Dr Ann.
The role and responsibilities of the EITI Board Members Lima, 23 February 2016 Christian Fr. Michelet.
Professional Liability Insurance Overview of Exposure and Insurance Physicians Professional Liability Insurance Accountants Professional Liability Insurance.
Be Prepared For Change Are you Prepared?. Be Prepared For Change Are you Prepared?
Parshotam Lawyers Barristers and Solicitors Level 2 Mid City Cnr Cumming St/Waimanu Rd GPO Box 131, Suva, Fiji Ph: Fax:
Volunteer Lawyers Service Board of Directors Duties and Liabilities Terrie-Lynne Devonish December 7, 2004.
Kate Neonakis Directors’ Liability in a Not-for-Profit Organization.
Welcome to the board Samantha LawryManager, Guidance and Education Manori GuntilakeCommunications Officer 9 March 2016.
1 RISK MANAGEMENT Presentation for the Sports Club Management Expo 17 th November, 2013 by Paul Horvath © SportsLawyer 2013.
The Malverns District.
Directors’ & Officers’ & Charity Trustees’ Insurance The Insurance Institute of Manchester Tuesday 14th February 2017 Phil Duffy.
UNIT 1: NATURE AND SCOPE OF COMPANY LAW
CONFLICTS AND CONFIDENTIALITY
Agenda What is Corporate Governance?
Corporations and Trusts Law
THE COMPANY – A SEPARATE LEGAL ENTITY
A Seminar in Board Governance A Presentation on behalf of the: Centre for Agricultural Governance in Agriculture (COGA) Kelowna, BC November 24, 2016.
by Paul Horvath © SportsLawyer 2013
Introduction of Governance Standards
CHOICE OF INCORPORATION
Guide to ethical obligations of in-house lawyers – for non-lawyer colleagues Notes:
Corporations and Trust Law Chapter 6 Directors Duties
Corporations and Trusts Law Chapter 3 Choosing a Business Structure
Guide to ethical obligations of in-house lawyers – for non-lawyer colleagues Notes:
Chapter 4 DIRECTORS DUTIES.
Board of Directors Roles and Responsibilities
Governance: Roles and Responsibilities
American College of Nurse-Midwives
INK 25: 10 Things to Know About Being a NFP Board Member
DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Retirement Benefit Fund, Trustee and Third Party Provider Insurance
A Review of Board of Health Liability
Appointing a Management Agent
Presentation transcript:

Nonprofit Law in Plain English Board Legal Responsibilities and Liability Issues by Myles McGregor-Lowndes Centre of Philanthropy and Nonprofit Studies Building Better Boards, Saturday pm 13/7/02

Further Information The information from which these slides are drawn come from the following working papers from the Centre: -Waller CPNS 2 -Sievers PONC 7 -McGregor-Lowndes PONC 11 To obtain an order form, visit the web site at

Corporate Governance is NOT just Duties under the Corporations Act 2001, Associations Acts, Trust Law Fiduciary Duties Due care and attention - negligence

Paradoxes Does it really matter? Who is responsible? Independence vs Team? Knowledge ? Representation? Does Conformance bring Performance?

SO – JUST TELL ME! Sources of Liability General Laws Specific Entity Laws –Company –Trust How to manage your legal duties and liabilities

JUDGES FAIL THE COMMON SENSE TEST Judges have failed to recognise the reality of associations of people They adhere rigidly to ancient protocols Causes problems for all types of nonprofit associations

GIFT OF THE CROWN The gift of “persona” is reserved for the Crown Delegated to government departments But judges still see nothing but a crowd of people without it!

What is the legal form of your association? Unincorporated association Incorporated association Company limited by guarantee Company limited by guarantee and shares Charitable Trust Co-operative Special Act of Parliament

Sources of Liability 1.General Statutes/Legislation 2.Specific Entity Law Common Law Statute Law

General Statutes Use of Corporation to catch “for profit” and “non-profit” organisations. Environmental, tax, workplace health and safety, collections, Trade Practices Act Officers as liable as the corporation An Act of Parliament Place Names Act

Executive officers must ensure corporation complies with Act (1) The executive officers of a corporation must ensure that the corporation complies with this Act. (2) If a corporation commits an offence against a provision of this Act, each of the corporation’s executive officers also commits an offence

“executive officer”, of a corporation, means a person who is concerned with, or takes part in, the corporation’s management, whether or not the person is a director or the person’s position is given the name of executive officer.

However, it is a defence for an executive officer to prove— –the officer exercised reasonable diligence to ensure the corporation complied with the provision.

Defences and Mitigation Usual to have a due diligence defence –Use of standards and legal compliance plans Requires documentation and evidence to show that there was an implementation process and monitoring. Line Managers sign off on a regular basis Use of computer programs to assist control major areas of exposure.

SPECIFIC ENTITY LAWS Entity is liable from its property –Members, directors, committee not primarily liable Trustees are liable –It is a relationship not an entity

Common Law Exception Piercing the Corporate Veil –Fraud –Avoid legal obligations –Groups

History of Duties The Charitable Corporation v Sir Robert Sutton 1742 Trustee standards –Imposed a high standard –All 50 responsible for breaches of trust, even though some did not participate – non-attendance –No excuse that honorary –Not a subjective test

Victorian Era Directors A director need not in the performance of his duties exhibit a greater degree of skill than reasonably expected of a person of his knowledge and experience Not bound to give continuous attention to the affairs of the company Director justified in trusting management to perform their duties honestly SUBJECTIVE

Australian 1990 Judicial Reform More objective standard General understanding of the business General financial understanding Friedrich’s case Daniels v Anderson Voluntary/executive/non-executive Statutory reforms

Daniels v Anderson 1.Directors keep abreast and exercise control – obvious risks cannot be blindly left to others 2.Monitor business, policies and finances – duty to inquire if suspicions. 3.Directors must be capable of monitoring – ignorance no excuse – suspicions must act 4.Added tort of negligence - carelessness

Specific Corporations Act Duties Public Company Duty to exercise the degree of care and diligence that a reasonable person would exercise in the same position in a company in the same circumstances ( s180 Corporations Act) Duty to exercise powers in good faith in the best interests of the company and for a proper purpose –Trustee exception (s181 Corporations Act)

Duty not to make improper use of their position as a director to gain advantage for the director or for anyone else s182 Corporations Act Duty not to make improper use of information obtained as a director to gain an advantage for the director or for anyone else s183 Corporations Act Duty not to delegate their discretionary powers to anyone else Duty to avoid conflicts of interest

The relevant provisions of the Corporations Act require, of a director of a company limited by guarantee in such a position, that: –the director discloses to the other board members the “material personal interest” which the director has in the subject matter of the discussion. –to fulfil this duty directors to make an initial standing disclosure of all material interests which are then taken, on an ongoing basis, to have been notified to all other board members.

Conflicts Corporate opportunities Misuse confidential information Personal profits Competing Bribes

Business Judgment Rule Defence against breaches of duty of care Directors should not be liable for decisions made in an HONEST, INFORMED and RATIONAL WAY. Good faith, proper purpose, no conflict, appropriately informed, rational Rational unless “no reasonable person”

There is more! Insolvent trading provisions –s 588G Corporations Law –Coy incurs a debt + there were reasonable grounds for suspecting that the company was insolvent or would become insolvent –confined to directors - but note wide def of directors –National Safety Council Case

It is expected that board members acting carefully and diligently must: be well prepared – read board papers in advance of meetings (and require staff to provide them) attend all meetings with only limited exceptions ask questions at those meetings and seek further information, especially if they do not understand the information presented

attend the office of the company to see that it operates as they are told it operates attend functions and activities of the company, for the same reason put in place systems to check the compliance by the company with laws, policies of the board and industry standards

Incorporated Associations Duties vary Some States already have the 588G test Part 5.7 body argument may be applicable Those Inc assoc which trade interstate- ARB

Trusts Trustees are personally liable for improper actions In certain circumstances the trustees may be indemnified from the trust fund Pure fiduciary duties Standard – “ordinary prudent man (sic) of business”– higher for investments! Loyalty to the trust deed and purposes

Duty to adhere to the terms of the trust Duty to keep and render accounts Duty to act personally Undivided loyalty –No conflict of interest and duty –No unauthorised benefit –No conflict of duty and duty Investment duties

Risk Management Risk Management is the term applied to a logical and systematic method to minimise losses and maximise opportunities. COMMON SENSE AS 4360 Aust Standard

Compliance Programs Primary aim is to fully comply with the law and eliminate all risk of breaching the law. Identify the specific penalties Determine how breaches could occur Design a program to eliminate breaches Ensure that the program is working and revised AS 3806 Australian Standard

R M vs Compliance Reduces and manages risk control with an eye on costs set your own standards Eliminates and prevents Can’t decline on the grounds of cost Standards set by Law and Courts

Director’s and Officer’s Insurance Part of a risk management strategy Usual for a $5m cap For the company in indemnification of its officers, officers directly and legal expense insurance Often officers pay some portion personally Who is covered?

What is covered? Claims made policy Run off cover -50% of cost Exclusions –Professional capacity –Personal injury –Claims by the organisation –Fraud & dishonesty –Fines –Environment

Disclosure Full disclosure of all relevant facts and circumstances must be made One mistake may void the whole policy for all concerned Be very careful

You should fully understand the nature and extent of the cover provided by the policy of insurance. Be aware of the obligations imposed upon them by the policy and take steps to ensure that they comply with those obligations. Seek appropriate advice from the organisation's lawyers and insurance brokers and ensure that those providing the advice have a sufficient understanding of the issues involved. Implement procedures to ensure that full disclosure is made to the insurer prior to taking out or renewing D&O insurance.

Implement procedures for identification of claims and potential claims and notification of claims and potential claims prior to expiry of the policy. As the protection provided by the policy is personal to the officer, they should take independent advice if they are uncertain about the nature and extent of cover provided or if they are not satisfied with arrangements made by their organisation. Importantly, be aware that if the organisation decides not to renew the insurance, the officer will not be covered in respect of claims subsequently made.

Dr Myles McGregor-Lowndes Centre of Philanthropy and Nonprofit Studies –Phone (07) –FAX (07) – –