Community-Based Health Insurance. Of all the risks facing poor households, health risks pose the greatest threat to their lives and livelihoods. A health.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
External Financing for Health Care: Takemi Working Group Recommendations to G8 Ravi P. Rannan-Eliya ECOSOC Annual Ministerial Review – Regional Ministerial.
Advertisements

Universal Coverage – Can we guarantee health for all? 3 – 4 October 2011, Kuala Lumpur Nossal perspective.
2 nd Conference of the African Health Economics and Policy Association (AfHEA) Saly – Senegal, 15 th - 17 th March 2011 Di McIntyre Chair, AfHEA Scientific.
Instructor’s Name Semester, 200_
HEALTH EQUITY: THE INDIAN CONTEXT Subodh S Gupta.
Policy Proposals Health Care Coverage, Costs, and Financing.
Preethi Pradhan Health Care Financing Preethi Pradhan
Patterns of voluntary enrolment in private vs. social health insurance in the Philippines: Is adverse selection or moral hazard a concern? S. Quimbo, J.
The Future of Medicare: Democratic and Republican Proposals.
The Affordable Care Act Reduces Premium Cost Growth and Increases Access to Affordable Care Before ACA, Small Employers Faced Many Obstacles to Covering.
Challenges for financing and providing long-term-care in Eastern Europe Johannes Koettl and Sarbani Chakraborty Europe and Central Asia Regions – Human.
The Health Care Industry Part 2 - Medical Insurance Karen F. Nichols, MSA School of Allied Health Professions University of Nebraska Medical Center.
Snapshots of World Health: Comparisons Around the Globe.
Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act: Timeline for Implementation Commissioner Kim Holland Oklahoma Insurance Department.
SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE ASSOC PROF PHUA KAI LIT, PhD FLMI School of Medicine and Health Sciences Monash University (Sunway Campus) & ASSOC PROF PHUA KAI.
Implementation challenges of health financing policy reforms: experiences from Sub-Saharan Africa Peter Kamuzora Institute of Development Studies University.
Medical Insurance in China How is it different from India? Medical Insurance in China Global Conference of Actuaries Mumbai, February 2010.
 Protects the standard of living of the survivors  At the policy holder’s death, the insurance company pays survivors the face value of a life insurance.
Healthcare Reform A look into the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and what it means to you. Presented by Bill Scuorzo President & CEO.
Health financing models. NHS Systems Strengths –Pools risks for whole population –Relies on many different revenue sources –Single centralized governance.
Health Reform: Guaranteeing Medicare’s future while protecting older adults and people with disabilities.
1 Health Insurance for the Poor in Developing Countries by Johannes P. Jütting Development Centre, OECD, Paris Presentation at the UN Department for Economic.
NIGERIA Country presentation: State of Health Care Financing by Chima A. Onoka and Chijioke I. Okoli Health Policy Research Group University of Nigeria,
Subsidized Private Health Insurance in Africa PharmAccess Foundation and Health Insurance Fund Programs Emily Gustafsson-Wright Brookings Institution and.
Inclusion and strengthening of social services as part of the agenda on ageing Rosemary Lane, Focal Point on Ageing United Nations Department of Economic.
(c) 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
Insurance Function in Health System Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences School of Medical Education Strategic Policy Sessions: 28.
SOCIAL SECURITY ORGANIZATION
Health Care Reform in America Facing Up:. President Obama and Healthcare Reform “Health care reform is no longer just a moral imperative, it’s a fiscal.
The Insurance Contract Section Understanding Business and Personal Law The Insurance Contract Section 35.1 Insurance Protection What Is Insurance?
Microinsurance, cooperatives and Takaful DFID Workshop May 22 nd 2006.
Kenneth Ojo & Paul Angbazo Partnership for Transforming Health Systems 2 (PATHS2) Abuja, Nigeria.
Health Financing. Objectives By the end of the lecture, students should be able to : 1. Explain health financing 2.Discuss how health is financed in our.
Classification of Health Insurances. Classifying health insurance Criteria for classifying health insurance: –Sources of financing. –Level of compulsion.
1 Healthcare Group of Arizona Director Anthony D. Rodgers State Coverage Initiatives - Summer Workshop ‘Pressing Forward: Cuts, Coverage, and Creativity’
The Challenges of Managing Microinsurance Schemes in Uganda Objective to analyze the challenges of managing micro- insurance schemes in Uganda. (i) Introduction.
Sources of Financing in Health Insurances. Sources of financing 1.Tax-financing 2.Social security contributions 3.Social health insurance premiums 4.Private-premiums.
Key issues in health care financing Di McIntyre. Objectives Introduce some key concepts Introduce a useful analytic framework Illustrate the analytic.
Return to Tutorials Tricia Neuman, Sc.D. Director, Medicare Policy Project Vice President, Kaiser Family Foundation For KaiserEDU June 2009 Medicare 101:
Health Insurance in low- income countries Where is the evidence that it works? Esme Berkhout Health policy advisor Oxfam Novib Oxfam International, Action.
Premium Calculation in Health Insurances. Method of premium calculation in health insurance 1.Community rated premiums. 2.Risk-related (Experience rated)
Copyright 2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies 21-1 The Health Care Industry Economic Implications of Rising Costs Why the Rapid Rise in Costs? Supply Factors.
Copyright © 2011 Pearson Education. All Rights Reserved. Chapter 2 The Insurance Mechanism.
How Health Reform Helps Missouri: Today and in the Future Brian Colby MO Health Advocacy Alliance.
Health Care Financing: Insurance Health Economic Course Series: 3 of 12
Chapter 27: Global Models of Health Care. Learning Objectives Compare the aging policies of Japan, Germany, England, and Canada with those of the United.
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
Copyright McGraw-Hill/Irwin, 2005 The Health Care Industry Quality of Care Limited Access Increasing Demand for Health Care Role of Health Insurance.
Background Nature and function Rationale Opportunities for TB control Partnering process.
 Agreed upon fees paid for coverage of medical benefits for a defined benefit period. Premiums can be paid by employers, unions, employees, or shared.
HEALTH FINANCING MOH - HPG JAHR UPDATE ON POLICIES Eleventh Party Congress -Increase state investment while simultaneously mobilizing social mobilization.
SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY Presentation to Health Portfolio Committee 7 June 2005.
Health Insurance Plans 2.4 Cost is a major concern Health care is over 15% of the gross national product Without insurance the cost of an illness can become.
Farid Abolhassani Social Health Insurance 15. Learning Objectives After working through this chapter, you will be able to: Define the principles of social.
Private Health Insurance
Farid Abolhassani The Changing World of Health Care Finance 13.
Ministry’s Vision for Universal Health Coverage Dr San San Aye Director (Planning) Department of Health Planning Ministry of Health National Dialogue on.
Overview of China’s health care reform Wen Chen, Ph.D., Professor Fudan School of Public Health March 21, 2016.
Views and Suggestions of Community Members on Micro Health Insurance MICROFINANCE COMMUNITY OF PRACTICE SOLUTION EXCHANGE,UNITED NATIONS, INDIA.
2nd African Decent Work Symposium: Yaoundé, Cameroon, 6-8 October THE SOCIAL SECURITY EXTENSION CHALLENGE: INCOME SECURITY AND HEALTH BENEFITS. Dr.
Health System Financing 1 |1 | Designing Health Financing System to Achieve Universal Coverage Ke Xu Health Systems Financing World Health Organization.
Key Challenges in extending social security. Social Security: key Challenges   Social Security as a human right? Or is it individual responsibility?
Chapter 27: Global Models of Health Care
Health Care Financing Health Economic Course Series
1 Microinsurance as a tool to extend Social protection Strengths and weaknesses Future perspectives Valérie Schmitt Diabaté Aly Cissé ILO / STEP, october.
Coordinator of Project management Unit of Global fund and MAP projects
Are You Totally Protected?. Who is USA Benefits Group? About the Company  USA Benefits Group is a nationwide network of health and life insurance professionals.
© Plan International Xu Jian, Country Health Advisor, Plan China Piloting Children’s Medical Insurance in Rural China: The Experience of Plan China.
Community Based Health Insurance Mutuelles de Santé Rwanda Case 1 Presented by Nicole Curti Kanyoko and Willy Janssen.
Presentation transcript:

Community-Based Health Insurance

Of all the risks facing poor households, health risks pose the greatest threat to their lives and livelihoods. A health shock adds health expenditures to the burden of the poor precisely at the time when they can afford it the least. One of the ways that poor communities manage health risks, in combination with publicly financed health care services, are community-based health insurance schemes

Community-Based Health Insurance These are small scale, voluntary health insurance programs, organized and managed in a participatory manner. They are designed to be simple and affordable, and to draw on resources of social solidarity and cohesion to overcome problems of small risk pools, moral hazard, fraud, exclusion and cost-escalation.

Community-Based Health Insurance It is voluntary in nature, formed on the basis of an ethnic of mutual aid, and covers a variety of benefit packages. CBHIs can be initiated by health facilities, NGOs, trade unions, local communities, local governments or cooperatives and can be owned and run by any of these organizations. They may be organized around geographic entities (villages, cities), professional bodies (i.e. cooperatives or trade unions) or around health care facilities.

CBHI: Deep Roots in History Community based health insurance schemes were amongst the first social protection institutions to be established in the industrial market economies. In the Netherlands, mutual health insurance societies were founded by the guilds during the Middle Ages. Doctors also established insurance funds to stabilize their own incomes. Community-based health insurance was also the earliest form of health insurance to be established in the USA. The first US health insurance program was founded in Baylor Hospital, in Texas in 1929 when a group of school teachers contracted with a local hospital to provide room, board and specified medical services at a pre-determined monthly rate.

CBHI: Deep Roots in History Other Examples Includes: –The Friendly Societies of the United Kingdom –The Mutual Benefit Associations of France, Belgium, Germany, Japan and Korea –The Fraternal Benefit Societies of Canada Over time, the growing political influence of these community-based institutions gave rise to social insurance programs, and ultimately to the spread of more elaborate social protection systems

Different Names for CBHI Micro-insurance, Community health finance organizations, Mutual health insurance schemes, Pre-payment insurance organizations, Voluntary informal sector health insurance, Mutual health organizations/associations, Community health finance organizations, Community self-financing health organizations.

Difference from other micro-finance schemes CBHIs differ from other forms of micro- finance in that they use an insurance mechanism, In credit schemes, members may avoid out-of-pocket payment when they need medical services. But they eventually should pay it in a later time.

Size of CBHIs Most CBHIs in developing countries are small –22% had less than 100 members, –33% had members, –28% had 500 to 10,000 members, –14% had 10,000 to 100,000 members –2% had more than 100,000 members.

Size of CBHIs In Sub-Saharan Africa, the majority of the CBHI schemes are small and came into existence only in the 1990s. Asia’s CBHI schemes are larger (with the smallest having several thousand members), older, and involve considerable cost-sharing with Governments. CBHIs play an important role in the health systems Latin American Countries. In These Countries CBHIs are closely linked to trade unions and social funds.

Contributions and Expenses Total annual member contributions from small CBHIs are generally less than $1,000 per annum, which limits their ability to cover major health risks. Total annual contributions of an average CBHI in West Africa is about $370, implying that one major hospitalization could deplete the CBHIs’ entire reserves. Member contributions are on the order of $1.5- $2.5 per capita per annum in Sub-Saharan Africa and rise to as much as $25 - $30 per capita per annum in low-middle income Asian nations (Philippines, rural China).

Health Cost Recovery The average share of health costs recovered by a CBHI is 25 percent, and very few CBHIs recover more than 50% of all health care costs. Despite the low rates of health cost recovery, there is strong evidence that CBHIs provide effective protection to scheme members by reducing out-of pocket health expenditures and improving access to health care

Coverage Less than 10% of the rural/informal sector population in the developing world participates in CBHIs. Even amongst the long-established schemes in India, Bangladesh, China and the Philippines, the covered population is less than a third of the total target beneficiary group. While coverage is low, the number of CBHI schemes is growing rapidly, and developing nation CBHIs are becoming powerful advocates for reform of the public health service.

Common Features Accessibility Self-management Revenue Dependency External Support Complementing the Public Effort

Premium Calculation For CBHIs, simplicity of contract requires that the premium be based on a community (rather than a household) rating. Normally, individuals in a CBHI don’t have the choice between various types of plans.

Six Building Blocks of Health Insurance Choice over participation Ownership of system Premiums Benefits package Risk management Provider payment

Choice over participation Voluntary Mandatory For all or for some

Choice over participation  Voluntary Mandatory For all or for some

Ownership of health insurance system Major possibilities: –Private commercial –Private formal non-commercial –Private informal non-commercial –National government –National quasi-governmental organization (Social Security Institutes, NHS) –Local governments

Ownership of health insurance system Major possibilities: –Private commercial –Private formal non-commercial  Private informal non-commercial –National government –National quasi-governmental organization (Social Security Institutes, NHS) –Local governments

Premiums Major possibilities: –Fixed amount per person, family, household, or group –Percent of wage –Other ability-to-pay related –Risk-related –Exemptions for disadvantaged –Subsidy for disadvantaged

Premiums Major possibilities:  Fixed amount per person, family, household, or group –Percent of wage –Other ability-to-pay related –Risk-related –Exemptions for disadvantaged –Subsidy for disadvantaged

Premiums Major possibilities:  Fixed amount per person, family, household, or group –Percent of wage –Other ability-to-pay related –Risk-related  Exemptions for disadvantaged  Subsidy for disadvantaged Sometimes these two are included

Benefits package Major possibilities: –“Insurable” risks—high cost items such as hospitalizations, surgeries, costly drug regimes and tests, rehab –“Predictable” risks—ordinary outpatient visits, low-cost drugs and tests, deliveries, preventive services –All risks—comprehensive coverage of all services –Deductibles and co-payments –Stop loss provisions for insurer –Exclusions

Benefits package Major possibilities:  “Insurable” risks—high cost items such as hospitalizations, surgeries, costly drug regimes and tests, rehab  “Predictable” risks—ordinary outpatient visits, low-cost drugs and tests, deliveries, preventive services  All risks—comprehensive coverage of all services  Deductibles and co-payments  Stop loss provisions for insurer  Exclusions

Risk management Major possibilities: –Pre-existing conditions excluded from coverage –Addressing adverse selection: group enrollment, waiting period, risk-rating premiums –Promoting/requiring prevention –Reinsurance –Bundling “predictable” with “insurable” risks

Risk management Major possibilities: –Pre-existing conditions excluded from coverage  Addressing adverse selection: group enrollment, waiting period, risk-rating premiums –Promoting/requiring prevention –Reinsurance –Bundling “predictable” with “insurable” risks

Provider payment Major possibilities: –Fee-for-service –Capitation –Global budgets –Case-based –Insurer ownership and management of provider

Provider payment Major possibilities:  Fee-for-service –Capitation –Global budgets –Case-based –Insurer ownership and management of provider

Failure of CBHI Many schemes do fail. Problems, such as weak management, poor quality government health services, and the limited resources that local population can mobilize to finance health care, can impede success.

Complementary Function of CBHIs CBHIs should be regarded as a complement to, not as a substitute for, strong government involvement in health care financing and risk management related to the cost of illness. Government, and its development partners, can support the growth of CBHIs by: –Ensuring that there is a satisfactory supply of appropriate health services, –Subsidizing start-up costs and the premium costs of the poor, –Assisting CBHIs build technical and managerial competence, –Helping to foster development of CBHI networks –Assisting CBHIs establish and strengthen links with formal financial institutions and health care providers to better manage covariate shocks and catastrophic health risks

Thank You ! Any Question ?