The Role of Parliament in the audit of public accounts.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Development of internal control: methodology and responsibility
Advertisements

The Role of Parliament in approving the budget World Bank Institute’s Parliamentary Staff Training Program.
INTOSAI Compliance Audit Guidelines (ISSAI )
Audit outcomes - Briefing to the Chairperson of the Department of Mineral Resources Portfolio Committee Presenters: Jan van Schalkwyk Corporate Executive.
Office of the Auditor General of Canada The State of Program Evaluation in the Canadian Federal Government Glenn Wheeler Director, Results Measurement.
Lessons Learned for Strong Project Delivery & Reporting Sheelagh O’Reilly, Kristin Olsen IODPARC Independent Assessors for the Scottish Government IDF.
Australia’s Experience in Utilising Performance Information in Budget and Management Processes Mathew Fox Assistant Secretary, Budget Coordination Branch.
The “Downstream Stages”: Budget Execution, Financing, and Control Training for Support PAC Staff Hilton Hotel, Windhoek, Namibia May 2012.
Internal Auditing and Outsourcing
GOOD GOVERNANCE, PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT + FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY Budget Management and Financial Accountability Rick Stapenhurst, World Bank Institute.
PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT Niall Johnston Parliamentary Consultant.
PAD190 PRINCIPLES OF PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT Module External Scrutiny and Oversight 1.
LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT AND GOOD GOVERNANCE
EAAPAC EAAPAC TRAINING FOR MEMBERS OF NEW PACs – JUBA SOUTH SUDAN February 6 – 8, 2013.
Romanian Court of Accounts years of existence.
Grosu-Axenti Diana Financial Inspection Director Financial Inspection vs External & Internal audit in Republic of Moldova.
Good practices from and for the EU accountability process Irena Petruškevičienė Vilnius, 17 October 2006.
Public Financial Management: An Introduction Training for Support PAC Staff Hilton Hotel, Windhoek, Namibia May 2012.
Strengthening parliamentary involvement in the Budget Process World Bank Institute’s Parliamentary Staff Training Program.
Audit of predetermined objectives Presentation: Portfolio Committee on Economic Development March 2013.
A SSOCIATION OF P UBLIC A CCOUNTS C OMMITTEES (APAC) Report on Implementation of SADCOPAC Conference Resolutions 2011 (Zimbabwe) and 2012 (South Africa)
SAI and Parliamentary Audit Committee Relations – Estonian Experience TÕNIS SAAR Director of Corporate Services National Audit Office of Estonia.
The Role of Parliament in the budget process. Overview Actors in the budget process Stages in the budget process Budgeting for the medium term.
CURRENT ISSUES & FUTURE TRENDS IN PARLIAMENTARY OVERSIGHT Rick Stapenhurst World Bank Institute.
International Symposium on the changing role of Parliament in the budget process: Experiences from PUIC Countries and EU Member States Cooperation between.
Relationship: PAC's, SAI's and Accountant General in Improving transparency and accountability process Contributions for discussion from Mozambique National.
PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE RELATIONSHIP WITH CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANISATIONS MEDIA AND GENERAL PUBLIC: KEY TO EFFECTIVE ACCOUNTABILITY Presented by Hon. V.
The Budget Process A simplified and generalized summary of budgeting in the public sector. Political Dynamics Actors in the budget process Stages in the.
HELPING THE NATION SPEND WISELY Public Sector Accountability and Auditing in the UK ROLE OF NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE & RELATIONSHIP WITH PARLIAMENT for Distinguished.
Supreme Audit Office (the NIK): Basic Facts Riga, 4 April 2012.
LEGISLATIVE-EXECUTIVE RELATIONS Rick Stapenhurst World Bank Institute.
A SSOCIATION OF P UBLIC A CCOUNTS C OMMITTEES (APAC) Report on Implementation of SADCOPAC / EAAPAC Accountability Conference Resolutions 2013 Hon Peter.
A SSOCIATION OF P UBLIC A CCOUNTS C OMMITTEES (APAC) Report on SADCOPAC Best Practices Guideline Hon Sipho Makama APAC General Secretary SADCOPAC CONFERENCE.
Harmonization project CAS project group (Chair, Slovakia, European Court of Auditors) CAS meeting Batumi, Georgia 27th of September 2011.
1 PRESENTATION TO JOINT RULES COMMITTEE ON THE OVERSIGHT AND ACCOUNTABILITY MODEL 19 MARCH 2008.
SEYCHELLES EXPERIENCE Hon. Nichole Barbe, PAC Member, Seychelles.
NATIONAL ASSEMBLY OF KENYA PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE (PAC) 2013 ACCOUNTABILITY CONFERENCE RESOLUTIONS IMPLEMENTATION STATUS OF RESOLUTIONS.
Compliance Audit Subcommittee Reporting Work Plan Copenhagen, Denmark 6th of May 2010.
SAI & PAC Relationship Perspective from the Maldives “The work of an SAI, and its relations with parliament are key factors in a strong chain of accountability.
Briefing to the Portfolio Committee on Economic Development Department on the audit outcomes for the 2013/2014 financial year Presenter: Ahmed Moolla October.
ARAPAC Annual Meeting Maldives 11 – 13 October 2012 The PAC – AG Relationship Presenter: Professor Peter Loney Legislative Leadership and Governance Group,
PUBLIC FINANCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY – MULTI STAKEHOLDER APPROACHES
Auditing of Performance A conceptual discussion. Auditing of performance To demonstrate and discuss the differences between auditing of performance information.
Session 1. Introduction to the Toolkit. Sub-objectives of Session 1. The purpose of the toolkit Outline of the contents How can we use the toolkit? The.
EUROPEAN COURT OF AUDITORS JULIA LINARES. BACKGROUND The European Court of Auditors was established by the Treaty of Brussels of 22 July The Court.
Summary of Resolutions & Best Practice Guide By Hon. Kagiso Molatlhegi, MP. BOTSWANA PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEE1.
INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT Module 5.1: External Scrutiny and Oversight 1.
Summary of 2015 OBI Results New Zealand A strong institutional framework supports extensive public availability of budget information and has helped New.
IMPLEMENTING SADCOPAC CONFERENCE RESOLUTIONS: the Case of Zambia Presented by Hon Vincent Mwale, Chairperson of the Public Accounts Committee of Zambia,
Cooperation with the Seimas Audit Committee Tomas Mackevičius Deputy Auditor General.
THE ROLE OF THE AUDITOR- GENERAL RP MOSAKA Business Executive: Parliamentary Services OFFICE OF THE AUDITOR-GENERAL.
Mandate of SCoAG and Parliamentary Environment within which it operates Presented By Adv M Masutha Chairperson of SCoAG 30 March 2010.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 32 – Financial Control Bilateral screening:
Institutional Aspects of the Parliamentary System Presentation by Douglas Millar, formerly Clerk Assistant and Director General of Chamber and Committee.
FIJI INSTITUTE OF ACCOUNTANTS Technical Workshop 20 th – 21 st March 2015 At the: Shangri-La’s Fijian Resort & Spa Presentation By: Hon. Balmindar Singh.
OVERVIEW OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS COMMITTEES
Audit of predetermined objectives
External audit and good financial governance
Optimizing the Effectivenes of CAPA: Keeping an Eye on Audit Reports
Parliament and the National Budget Process
Briefing to the Portfolio Committee on Health Audit outcomes of the health portfolio and health sector for the financial year October 2014.
LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT AND GOOD GOVERNANCE
INTRODUCTION TO PUBLIC FINANCE MANAGEMENT
External Audit Core PFM Training Program Sanjay Vani
years of existence.
Financing Budget oversight: Problems and Solutions.
Portfolio Committee on Arts and Culture 15 March 2010
Briefing to the Portfolio Committee on Defence on the audit outcomes for the 2013/2014 financial year.
Briefing to the Portfolio Committee on Department of Correctional Services on the audit outcomes for the 2013/2014 financial year Presenter: Solly Jiyana.
Presentation transcript:

The Role of Parliament in the audit of public accounts

Overview Audit and the ‘chain of accountability’ Types of supreme audit institutions The Lima Declaration Types of audit Interaction between auditors and parliament The role of parliamentary committees Follow-up mechanisms

Types of supreme audit institutions A public organization, independent of government and responsible for auditing and reporting government’s financial operations. Audit courts are independent of the legislative and executive branches and integral to the judiciary. Auditor generals are independent bodies that report directly to parliament and have no judicial function. The International Organisation of Supreme Audit Institutions (INTOSAI) has fundamental standards for national audit in the Lima Declaration of Guidelines on Auditing Precepts.

Lima Declaration: The supreme audit institution should… Be independent from audited entity and protected against outside influence. Have functional and organizational independence, guaranteed by the constitution. Have the financial means to accomplish its tasks. Self-determine its audit program. Have members with prerequisite qualifications and moral integrity. Report annually and independently to Parliament. Produce reports that are objective, clear, limited to essentials, precise and easy to understand. Audit all public financial

Types of audit Financial audit is traditional focus of public sector auditing. Auditor general model, financial audit focuses on the accounts of government departments using sampling techniques. Audit court model, emphasis on the legality of spending to see whether government revenue and spending have been used for approved purposes and departments have conformed to laws. Perform value for money or performance audits. ‘Three Es’ economy, efficiency and effectiveness.

An example of ‘value for money’ considerations in the health sector Hospital purchases inputs: staff, equipment, medical supplies; Transforms these inputs into outputs in services to community; The outcomes are effects on patient health. Performance auditing checks for economy, efficiency and effectiveness in this process, asking, respectively: 1. Are supplies, equipment and staff purchased for cheapest price? (economy); 2. Is adequate number of operations carried out with inputs? (efficiency); 3. Do operations improve patient health? (effectiveness). It can be summarized that the ‘Three Es’ require respectively spending less, spending well, and spending wisely.

Interaction with parliament Relationship varies between systems. Court model tradition, parliament uses audit information for a formal vote on the execution of a budget. Westminster tradition there is no formal vote on budget, parliamentary review generates recommendations for improving public spending. Supreme audit institutions have established parliamentary liaison offices and accompany related work of parliament on an ongoing basis. More recently, many supreme audit institutions have also developed a more ad hoc advisory function.

Role of parliamentary committees In Some Legislatures… Audit findings are not considered in detail, but most parliaments use committees to do so. The same committee responsible for approving budget also must consider audit reports. A dedicated public accounts committee is used for the scrutiny of audit findings. Sectoral committees, such as those responsible for health, education or defense, scrutinize relevant audit findings.

Public accounts committees First modern PAC in UK in 1861 Strong link with Auditor General Policy-neutral: focus on implementation Cross-partisan: opposition chairperson in 67% of PACs in the Commonwealth Hearings with accounting officers Increasing importance of value for money audit But: evidence says this system does not work well in many developing countries Delayed reporting Poor quality of reports Government non-response

Follow-up mechanisms Parliament’s recommendations and government’s implementation: 1. Committee reports must be followed by a formal government response. 2. A formal government response does not always ensure that the committee’s recommendations are acted upon. 3. A formal tracking report produced regularly by the audit institution systematically considers the implementation of each recommendation. 4. Instead of separate tracking report, some auditors include a chapter that reviews departmental action on previous recommendations in their annual audit report.

Concluding remarks External audit and parliamentary scrutiny are fundamental for holding government to account. Supreme audit institutions have evolved to different traditions - audit court and auditor general two main, but variations occur. Independence of supreme audit institutions is fundamental. Parliament engages with audit findings effectively through dedicated committee capacity. Follow-up mechanisms are important for ensuring that recommendations are actually implemented.