? How to tell South African development stories… …that enough people believe for the stories to be influential** **sufficiently influential to move development.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Asian Drivers and Poor Countries: The Research Agenda Jörg Mayer UNCTAD China and India: Whats in it for Africa? Paris, March 2006.
Advertisements

Comments on What are the constraints on inclusive growth in Zambia? Elena Ianchovichina and Susanna Lundström Arne Bigsten University of Gothenburg.
Better together … we deliver National Treasury Carbon Tax Workshop 1 November 2013.
March 2009 Emissions Trading in South Africa National Climate Change Summit Emily Tyler.
March 2009 Emissions Trading in South Africa National Climate Change Summit Emily Tyler.
Dialogue on long-term cooperative action to address climate change by enhancing implementation of the convention Second workshop Nairobi, 15 – 16 November.
The Economics of Climate Change Nicholas Stern 15 November 2006 Presentation to the Convention Dialogue, Nairobi.
Analysing university-firm interaction in the SADC countries: An initial overview Glenda Kruss SARUA workshop October 2008.
Derek Eaton Division of Technology, Industry & Economics Economics & Trade Branch Geneva, Switzerland “Designing the Green Economy” Centre for International.
THE NATIONAL CLIMATE CHANGE RESPONSE POLICY Mitigation System National Climate Change Response Policy 26 May 2015.
MITIGATION POTENTIAL AND EMISSION REDUCTION CONFIDENTIAL 1.
1 1 The climate change, the Oslo meeting ­- and so what? Olav Ljones Deputy Director General Statistics Norway
Copyright 2006 – Biz/ed Income and Wealth Distribution.
1 Dr. Christo Christov Energy Institute JSCo Sofia, Bulgaria Bulgaria GHG Emission Projections - Results and Methodological Problems Dr. Christo Christov.
Convention Dialogue, Thursday 16 November The EU’s Perspective on the Market Based Opportunities Peter Carl European Union.
Financing new electricity supply in the UK market with carbon abatement constraints Keith Palmer 08 March 2006 AFG.
Construction Management Practice Implications of the Theory of Construction Management.
Carbon Taxes, Climate Change, and Sustainable Development Tariq Banuri Stockholm Environment Institute June 2008.
Carbon tax policy BUSA submission to Carbon Tax Consultation November 2013.
Energy Security and Low Carbon Development in South Asia
ESPON Project TERRITORIAL TRENDS OF ENERGY SERVICES AND NETWORKS AND TERRITORIAL IMPACT OF EU ENERGY POLICY Álvaro Martins/Luís Centeno CEEETA Research.
Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions What Could “Nationally Appropriate” Entail in an Indian Context Srinivas K, & Tirthankar Mandal, CANSA, New Delhi,
OTB: CGE Leverage Points and Development First Modeling Tara Caetano Date: 7 November 2014.
New Employment Growth Path. Consideration should be given to changing the name to New Employment Growth Path as employment creation is the main objective.
ERC Andrew Marquard and Harald Winkler A Carbon tax for South Africa? Energy Research Centre University of Cape Town Presentation at a side event on PUTTING.
Green Action for Change: Some proposed changes following consultation Camden Sustainability Partnership Board 1 March 2011.
Michael Rogan & John Reynolds. Content International context International Labour Organisation SA context Income, wages & earnings over post-apartheid.
Socio-economic Implications of Mitigation Actions in the power sector including carbon taxes in South Africa Authors: B Merven, A Moyo, A Stone, A Dane.
Carbon tax policy BUSA submission to Portfolio Committee on Trade and Industry August 2013.
AFRICAN DEVELOPMENT BANK GROUP ENERGY STRATEGY 17th UPDEA CONGRESS Hammamet - 29th May 2012 AMADOU Zakou Manager, Energy Division 1.
Energy and Climate Change Strategy CITY OF CAPE TOWN Energy and Climate Change Strategy Shirene Rosenberg Environmental Planning Department.
2008 Electricity Distribution Maintenance Summit Stream 3A: Funding, Investment and Financial issues 10 June 2008 Theo van Vuuren Divisional Executive.
The economic and competitiveness dimensions of the draft Chilean INDC Andrea Rudnick Our Common Future Conference. Paris. July 8 th, 2015.
Mr Martin Crouch, ERGEG Electricity Regulatory Forum 2009 Florence, 5 June 2009 Status Review of Sustainable Development in the Energy Sector.
MIRPAL CONFERENCE ON REMITTANCES Remittances and economic development: the case of Kosovo 1 Borko Handjiski Economist Cholpon-Ata, Kyrgyzstan 11 th of.
Mitigation Action Plan and Scenarios Analytical tools: South Africa and MAPS experiences LEDS Collaboration in Action Workshop London, March 2012.
The Deep Decarbonization Pathways Project (DDPP) Investigating transparent national-scale pathways consistent with the 2°C target Henri WAISMAN – Iddri.
Better together … we deliver Sasol presentation on carbon tax to the Portfolio Committee on Trade and Industry 20 August 2013.
Presentation Pro © 2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. Economics: Principles in Action C H A P T E R 13 Economic Challenges.
Green growth - How a low carbon path can benefit the poor Christian Au Munich School of Philosophy, Center for social and development studies.
1 Invenergy. Harnessing the Wind Transmission System Typical Wind Park Electrical Transmission System.
30-Year National Transportation Policy Framework to the Future September 12,
Progress on the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) September 2012.
Click to edit Master title style New Zealand Presentation Seminar of Governmental Experts Bonn, 17 May 2005.
The Emissions Gap Report 2015 Geneva ♦ 6 November, 2015 What contributions do the INDCs make towards the 2 0 C target? How can the 2030 emissions gap be.
Pricing Carbon: Carbon Emission Trading Potential in South Africa Proposed Research Papers.
Click to edit Master subtitle style 6/13/12 Introduction and General Overview of the National Climate Change Response Policy and Framework for implementation.
Climate Change Mitigation in South Africa Addendum to main presentation 15 th September 2009.
Mediated Modelling Integrating the four aspects of well-being in Auckland to support Spatial Planning.
Ferrial Adam Energy and climate change campaigner GREENPEACE AFRICA PRESENTATION TO PORTFOLIO COMMITTEE: PROPOSED NATIONAL WATER.
Econ 215: Economy of Ghana National Income Accounting Lecture 2.
Economic Challenges Chapter 13 Section 3 Poverty.
Analysis of the Egyptian Labour Market with a Special Focus on MDG Employment Indicators Dr. Magued Osman.
Mexico 2050 Calculator Training Week – th August 2013.
Integrated Development and Climate Policies: How to realize benefits at national and international level? 20 – 22 September 2006, Paris, France Development.
COUNTY COUNCIL MEETING July 29, 2015 Summit County 2015 Climate Action Plan.
Understanding the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP 2010 Rev 2)
The Canadian Energy Research Institute and Friends of AIMS Present:
Canadian Energy Research Institute
Presentation for Plenary Session 2:
Mr JH Malan, Dr EA Steenkamp, Prof R Rossouw and Prof W Viviers
1. Introduction Over the past decade, the tertiary industry (Service sector) has been the largest and the fastest growing sector in China The tertiary.
Expert Workshop 4th March 2016, WIFO
Frank Czarnowski Not selling PlaceShapers Update
Macroeconomic Impact of Air Pollution Reduction
Economics: Principles in Action
6.1 Quality improvement Regional Course on
ADB’s experience with financing renewable energy projects
Competitiveness in a carbon-constrained world
PRESENTATION: SARPA CONFERENCE Role of NIASA
Presentation transcript:

? How to tell South African development stories… …that enough people believe for the stories to be influential** **sufficiently influential to move development trajectory to a climate compatible one ?

DDPP South Africa How do we use DDDP methodology to tell a credible development story that is consistent with 2DC ? 1.Primarily, it has to be about South African residents 2.It has to satisfy** interest groups to remain policy relevant 3.It has to tell a story that interest groups can believe **have not defined this, a first try would include the idea that… (a) members of interest groups HAVE to see themselves clearly in the story and (B) see themselves in an acceptable*** role ***significant efforts might be required to build acceptance based on building a shared understanding of external constraints

What do interest groups demand from “development” ? The very minimum we need to deliver to remain relevant: 1.Income (distribution) 2.Employment (non-grant based income) 3.Emissions pathway to avoid catastrophe EXOGENOUS, our Vision  models and expert judgment help paint credible pictures 4. Credible economic pathways that can deliver these  models and expert judgment help paint credible pictures

Phase 1 ONLY includes income** distribution …proxy for poverty reduction …used to show other services possible – Housing, services – Transport  ”development pathway” **employment information not available

Typical mitigation data

DASHBOARD – households

 given the above, and the emissions intensity of electricity, household emissions pathway can be calculated

Phase 2 adds skills profile

It’s about: - people -(and economic structure) 14,7 million people registered for tax 3,3 million taxpayers paid almost 99% of income tax 16 million receive grants +40% Indicative Stats

Match skills to economic sectors THREE relevant matches:  High skills high energy intensive  High skills low energy intensive  Low skills high energy intensive Show how all people can be employed in an economy with a credible economic structure – eSAGE linked to SATIM

An aside: who works in South Africa ?

Another aside: where is South Africa ? (…and do we disbelieve models if they tell us difficult things ? ) Source: United Nations, Get the data

ditto

Is it worth fine tuning if you’re on the wrong station ?