Human Rights Act 1998 The European convention on human rights The European convention on human rights The Convention rights The Convention rights How does.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS MECHANISMS
Advertisements

Data Protection & Human Rights. Data Protection: a Human Right Part of Right to Personal Privacy Personal Privacy : necessary in a Democratic Society.
Lesson Objectives: I will be able to explain the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy I will be able to consider limitations on the doctrine of parliamentary.
Sources of Law Chapter 1.2.
Constitutional and Administrative Law
CHAPTER 1 The sources and institutions of employment law.
PROTECTION OF RIGHTS.
Testing your knowledge
European Law.
The European Convention on Human Rights Please turn off your mobile Raise your hand if you have a question At the start of the lesson - STUDENTS SHOULD.
Equality and Human Rights Commission. Overview of the Morning EHRC – What we do Human Rights Inquiry Making sense of Human Rights Table sessions.
Human Rights 4 me presentation by Sofi Taylor Health Improvement Lead (Equality and Diversity) NHS GG&C Mental Health Services.
HUMAN RIGHTS BASED APPROACH See Me Brewing Lab Cathy Asante.
The Human Rights Act 1998 Mechanism Sections 1 and 2 of the HRA 1998.
Equality and Human Rights Commission Angus Cleary, Regional Manager North West.
ECHR: CASE LAW PERTAINING TO FREEDOM OF ASSOCIATON Dragan Golubovic Nessebar,
European Commission Taxation and Customs Union Brussels, 10 November Taxation of International Artistes and Community Law European Commission
Parliament and the Courts: the role of judicial review in the UK © Dr Nigel Forman CPS Seminar 15th March 2012.
THE HUMAN RIGHTS ACT AND THE UK POLICE SERVICE Click on slide-show icon When completed exit PowerPoint programme to return to the CD- ROM content.
Announcements Final Study Guide posted on course web page. Response Question due in Section tomorrow.
 starter activity The Christian Institute requested a judicial review into the BBC’s decision to screen Jerry Springer the Opera in January 2005 on the.
Identifying Human Rights The protections offered by the ECHR and the Human Rights Act 1998 Brayne & Carr: Law for Social Workers: 10e Chapter 3.
Place yourself in the room according to the structure below. Back of Room Front of Room Window Side Door side.
Course: European Criminal Law SS 2009 Hubert Hinterhofer.
Announcements -Final Study Guide will be posted the beginning of next week. -Thursday, May 31 class will be a review session.
European Labour Law Lecture 02A. First European document on this item and until now is the main protection for human rights in Europe because - Its wide.
Data Protection Privacy in the Digital Age: the UN General Assembly Resolution Sophie Kwasny, 16 October th International Conference, Mauritius.
Difference between criminal and civil law Learning Objectives Describe the difference between criminal and civil law and identify key features Explain.
SOURCES OF LAW A (very) BRIEF OUTLINE. SOURCES Common Law Equity Legislation – from UK and EU.
© Pearson Education Limited Printing and photocopying permitted National Public Services Unit 1 Government, policies and the public services © Pearson.
WEEK 12: Human Rights and Council of Europe. Key texts Morrison p King, The British Constitution Bingham, The Rule of Law, ch7 2.
LOOKING AT LAW AN INTRODUCTION. INTRODUCING….. Legislation Cases & how they work Civil Law & Criminal Law A contrast in attitudes to e.g. protection of.
Parliamentary Supremacy/Sovereignty. What is Parliamentary Supremacy (sovereignty)? Established in Bill of Rights 1689 Explained by Dicey (1885) – as.
International Human Rights Non-discrimination Article 14 – Prohibition of discrimination The enjoyment of the rights and freedoms set forth.
The following is a review for our Government exam on Notes #1-3.
Data protection and compliance in context 19 November 2007 Stewart Room Partner.
Mental Health, Poverty & Social Exclusion – -Day Conference organised by The Richmond Foundation - 8 th October, 2010 – MCC – Valletta. Legislation & Legislative.
Business Law 1 Lecture Two Sources of Law - Legislation.
International Human Rights Law WEEK 2: LEGAL INSTITUTIONS AND ENFORCING HUMAN RIGHTS.
RIGHT TO LIBERTY AND SECURITY Art. 5 ECHR Elizabeta Ivičević Karas Faculty of Law, University of Zagrebu.
European Government Today The European Union. U.S. Government Executive (President) Legislative (House of Representative and Senate) Judicial (Supreme.
EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS Regional protection of human rights.
The European Convention of Human Right Corso di inglese giuridico (M-Z) Prof.ssa C. M. Cascione Università degli Studi di Bari ‘Aldo Moro’ Lezione n. 10.
What are Human Rights? Short overview from M&LCSU Equality & Inclusion team.
VICTORIAN CHARTER OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES.
The Constitution contains 3 parts: the Preamble, the Articles, and the Amendments The Constitution contains 3 parts: the Preamble, the Articles, and.
Law LA1: Human Rights European Convention on Human Rights & the Human Rights Act 1998 Unit 1 AS.
Judicial Review and the Impact of Europe Lower 6 Politics.
Revision Session 2 Rights and Responsibilities – HUMAN RIGHTS.
Rule of Law: The state should govern its citizens in accordance to it’s set rules. Judicial Review: When the High Court oversees the decision of bodies.
History.... Right up until 1998 the UK did not have a bill of rights giving its citizens rights to certain basic freedoms. However, as early as 1950 the.
Introduction to Human Rights The Human Rights Act and Human Rights Based Approaches.
Corporate and Business Law (ENG). 2 Designed to give you knowledge and application of: Section A: Essential elements of the legal system A1. Court structure.
The Human Rights Act. Stephen Lawrence Lesson Objectives To describe what a right is. To identify the main contents of the Human Rights Act, To.
Privacy in the Digital Age: the UN General Assembly Resolution
Human Rights in Complaints Handling and Inquiries: Perspectives from the Equality and Human Rights Commission Jonathan Timbers – Policy Manager, Equality.
The rules and theory of human rights law Human Rights Act 1998
Objectives Explain and apply the main provisions of the Human Rights Act 1998 and relevant cases, with particular reference to sections 2,3,4,6,7 and.
Sources of Law: Statutes and Delegated Legislation
Objectives Discuss the European Convention on Human rights and the various Articles. Explain the role of the European Court of Human Rights. Explain the.
SOURCES OF LAW A (very) BRIEF OUTLINE.
The rules and theory of human rights law Bill of Rights
Creating the Constitution
The debate relating to the protection of human rights in the UK The need for a United Kingdom Bill of Rights.
The Constitution.
The Rule of Law and the Human Rights Act
The European Convention of Human Rights
Britain’s uncodified constitution
The European Human Rights System
U.S. Government King SS 6 October 29, 2014.
Presentation transcript:

Human Rights Act 1998 The European convention on human rights The European convention on human rights The Convention rights The Convention rights How does HRA 1998 work How does HRA 1998 work Taking proceedings under the HRA 1998 Taking proceedings under the HRA 1998 Taking a case to the ECHR Taking a case to the ECHR Impact of HRA 1998 Impact of HRA 1998

European Convention on Human Rights The preamble to the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) describes it as ‘an Act to give greater effect to rights and freedoms guaranteed under the European Convention on human rights The preamble to the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) describes it as ‘an Act to give greater effect to rights and freedoms guaranteed under the European Convention on human rights The United Kingdom (UK) signed up to the Convention in 1951 and was one of the first countries to do so. The United Kingdom (UK) signed up to the Convention in 1951 and was one of the first countries to do so.

European Convention on human rights In all, 45 countries have now signed up to the Convention including most of the east European. In all, 45 countries have now signed up to the Convention including most of the east European. The countries that have signed up to the Convention make up the Council of Europe. The countries that have signed up to the Convention make up the Council of Europe. The Council of Europe is quite separate from the European Union. The Council of Europe is quite separate from the European Union.

European Convention on Human Rights The Convention is divided into ‘articles’. Articles 2 to 14 set out the rights that are protected by the Convention. The Convention is divided into ‘articles’. Articles 2 to 14 set out the rights that are protected by the Convention. Over the years the Convention has been supplemented by a number of protocols that have been agreed by the Council of Europe. Over the years the Convention has been supplemented by a number of protocols that have been agreed by the Council of Europe. Some of the protocols just deal with procedural issues but some guarantee rights in addition to those included in the Convention. Some of the protocols just deal with procedural issues but some guarantee rights in addition to those included in the Convention.

European Convention on Human Rights The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) is the international court set up to interpret and apply the Convention. The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) is the international court set up to interpret and apply the Convention. It is based in Strasbourg, France and is made up of judges nominated by each of the countries that are members of the Council of Europe. It is based in Strasbourg, France and is made up of judges nominated by each of the countries that are members of the Council of Europe. Since 1966 people have had the right to bring cases against the British Government in the ECHR. Since 1966 people have had the right to bring cases against the British Government in the ECHR.

European Convention on human rights Because the Convention is now over 50 years old some of the language that it uses is quite outdated. Because the Convention is now over 50 years old some of the language that it uses is quite outdated. However, the ECHR has often stressed that the Convention is a ‘living instrument’. This means that as society and attitudes change, the ECHR will change and develop the way in which it interprets the Convention. However, the ECHR has often stressed that the Convention is a ‘living instrument’. This means that as society and attitudes change, the ECHR will change and develop the way in which it interprets the Convention.

European Convention on human rights The ECHR will, however, still tend to follow the precedents set by earlier cases - where it does not it will make it clear why it is not doing so. It is therefore important to look at past decisions of the ECHR. The ECHR will, however, still tend to follow the precedents set by earlier cases - where it does not it will make it clear why it is not doing so. It is therefore important to look at past decisions of the ECHR. The HRA requires the courts in UK take the ECHR’s past decisions into account when deciding cases under the HRA. The HRA requires the courts in UK take the ECHR’s past decisions into account when deciding cases under the HRA.

The Convention Rights Not all the rights set out in the Convention and its Protocols are incorporated into British law by the Human Rights Act Not all the rights set out in the Convention and its Protocols are incorporated into British law by the Human Rights Act The HRA only incorporates the rights in Articles 2 to 12 and in Article 14 of the Convention, plus those in the First and Sixth Protocols. The HRA only incorporates the rights in Articles 2 to 12 and in Article 14 of the Convention, plus those in the First and Sixth Protocols.

Which rights are incorporated Art. 2 - right to life Art. 2 - right to life Art. 3 - protection from inhuman treatment Art. 3 - protection from inhuman treatment Art. 4 - freedom from forced labour Art. 4 - freedom from forced labour Art. 5 - right to liberty Art. 5 - right to liberty Art. 6 - right to fair trial Art. 6 - right to fair trial Art. 8 – respect for privacy Art. 8 – respect for privacy

Which rights are incorporated Articles 9 &10 – freedom of thought and expression Articles 9 &10 – freedom of thought and expression Art. 11 – freedom of peaceful assembly Art. 11 – freedom of peaceful assembly Art. 1, Protocol 1 – right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions Art. 1, Protocol 1 – right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions Art. 2, Protocol 1 – right to education Art. 2, Protocol 1 – right to education

How does HRA 1998 work The HRA gives ‘greater effect’ to Convention Rights in two main ways: The HRA gives ‘greater effect’ to Convention Rights in two main ways: It makes it clear that as far as possible the courts should interpret the law in a way that is compatible with Convention rights. It makes it clear that as far as possible the courts should interpret the law in a way that is compatible with Convention rights.

How does HRA 1998 work It places an obligation on public authorities to act compatibly with Convention rights. It places an obligation on public authorities to act compatibly with Convention rights. It gives people the right to take court proceedings if they think that their Convention rights have been breached or are going to be. It gives people the right to take court proceedings if they think that their Convention rights have been breached or are going to be.

How does HRA 1998 work Interpreting the Law Compatibly Parliament makes laws but courts interpret them Parliament makes laws but courts interpret them when interpreting legislation the courts must do so in a way which does not lead to people’s Convention rights being breached. when interpreting legislation the courts must do so in a way which does not lead to people’s Convention rights being breached. the courts are now under a duty to develop the common law in a way that is compatible with Convention rights. the courts are now under a duty to develop the common law in a way that is compatible with Convention rights.

What Happens if the Courts cannot Read the Law Compatibly If the law is an Act of Parliament, the courts have no choice but to apply the law as it is, even though it breaches Convention rights. If the law is an Act of Parliament, the courts have no choice but to apply the law as it is, even though it breaches Convention rights. However, the higher courts (the High Court, the Court of Appeal and the House of Lords) have the power to make a ‘declaration of incompatibility’. However, the higher courts (the High Court, the Court of Appeal and the House of Lords) have the power to make a ‘declaration of incompatibility’.

What Happens if the Courts cannot Read the Law Compatibly a ‘declaration of incompatibility’ a ‘declaration of incompatibility’ is a statement that the courts consider that a particular law breaches Convention rights. It is meant to encourage Parliament to amend the law, but the courts cannot force the Government or Parliament to amend the law if they do not want to. is a statement that the courts consider that a particular law breaches Convention rights. It is meant to encourage Parliament to amend the law, but the courts cannot force the Government or Parliament to amend the law if they do not want to.

What Happens if the Courts cannot Read the Law Compatibly Secondary legislation is law made under the authority of an Act of Parliament. Secondary legislation is law made under the authority of an Act of Parliament. Where the courts find that an item of secondary legislation is incompatible with Convention rights, they have the power to strike the law down or not to apply it. Applies to all courts, not just the higher ones. Where the courts find that an item of secondary legislation is incompatible with Convention rights, they have the power to strike the law down or not to apply it. Applies to all courts, not just the higher ones.

Public Authorities The HRA requires public authorities to act in a way that does not breach Convention rights. The HRA requires public authorities to act in a way that does not breach Convention rights. The HRA does not define the term public authority, but it is clear that bodies like the police, local councils and government departments and agencies are all public authorities. The HRA does not define the term public authority, but it is clear that bodies like the police, local councils and government departments and agencies are all public authorities.

Public Authorities Private individuals and bodies will not be public authorities for the purposes of the HRA unless they are performing a public function. Private individuals and bodies will not be public authorities for the purposes of the HRA unless they are performing a public function. a private security company that has a contract with the Government to transport prisoners to and from court will be a public authority for the purposes of the HRA (and therefore under a duty to respect Convention rights) when it is transporting prisoners but will not be when it is guarding private property under a contract with a private organisation. a private security company that has a contract with the Government to transport prisoners to and from court will be a public authority for the purposes of the HRA (and therefore under a duty to respect Convention rights) when it is transporting prisoners but will not be when it is guarding private property under a contract with a private organisation.

Taking proceedings under the Human Rights Act 1998 proceedings against a public authority - a declaration that the public authority has breached Convention rights or is proposing to do so. proceedings against a public authority - a declaration that the public authority has breached Convention rights or is proposing to do so. If the breach is continuing - an order that the public authority should stop acting in a way that breaches their Convention rights. If the breach is continuing - an order that the public authority should stop acting in a way that breaches their Convention rights.

Taking proceedings under the Human Rights Act 1998 Compensation Compensation Application for judicial review. Court rules require an application for judicial review to be brought ‘promptly’ and in any event within three months of the decision or action being challenged. Where someone does not make an application for judicial review there is a one year time limit for starting proceedings. Application for judicial review. Court rules require an application for judicial review to be brought ‘promptly’ and in any event within three months of the decision or action being challenged. Where someone does not make an application for judicial review there is a one year time limit for starting proceedings.

Taking proceedings under the Human Rights Act 1998 Proceedings Against Private Individuals or Bodies Proceedings Against Private Individuals or Bodies As private bodies and individuals are not required by the HRA to respect Convention rights, it is not possible to take proceedings under the HRA against them. As private bodies and individuals are not required by the HRA to respect Convention rights, it is not possible to take proceedings under the HRA against them.

Taking a case to the European Court of Human Rights One must be a victim of a violation of one or more of the articles of the Convention. One must be a victim of a violation of one or more of the articles of the Convention. Before an application to the ECHR one must pursue any proceedings in the UK. Before an application to the ECHR one must pursue any proceedings in the UK. Application to the ECHR within six months of the conclusion of any court proceedings taken in the UK Application to the ECHR within six months of the conclusion of any court proceedings taken in the UK

Impact of Human Rights Act A form of higher law in UK A form of higher law in UK New rule of statutory interpretation- new way of thinking New rule of statutory interpretation- new way of thinking Sovereignty Sovereignty

Impact of Human Rights Act The purposive approach Compatibility with the Convention Rights Compatibility with the Convention Rights Courts to look at the purpose of the Convention Courts to look at the purpose of the Convention In case of incompatibility – courts are likely to make a ruling on the basis of the best interpretation In case of incompatibility – courts are likely to make a ruling on the basis of the best interpretation

Impact of Human Rights Act When determining the meaning of legislation courts may, where necessary be able to: When determining the meaning of legislation courts may, where necessary be able to: ‘read in’ extra words ‘read in’ extra words or even ignore words or even ignore words To make legislation compatible To make legislation compatible

Impact of Human Rights Act Sovereignty Sovereignty Provisions of the Convention apply to all courts Provisions of the Convention apply to all courts Supremacy of Parliament is limited by the HRA 1997 Supremacy of Parliament is limited by the HRA 1997