COMMENTS ON “HEALTH AND MORTALITY DELTA: ASSESSING THE WELFARE COST OF HOUSEHOLD INSURANCE CHOICE” BY KOIJEN, VAN NIEUWERBURGH, AND YOGO Mark J. Warshawsky,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Massachusetts HC Reform November 29, The Context The problem of the “uninsured” and “underinsured” is perennial issue Clinton Health Security Act.
Advertisements

Aging Seminar Series: Income and Wealth of Older Americans Domestic Social Policy Division Congressional Research Service November 19, 2008.
A New Take on an Old Issue: Surprising Demographics of Boomers Richard W. Johnson Urban Institute Presented at the National Human.
Keeping Seniors Connected to the Labor Market Benefits to working longer Work patterns and trends at older ages Work impediments at older ages.
1 How Deep is the Annuity Market Participation Puzzle? Joachim Inkmann, Tilburg University, CentER and Netspar Paula Lopes, London School of Economics.
MBAO Executive Compensation Executive Retirement Benefits Purpose of Retirement Benefits Income replacement at retirement Maintain standard of living.
Tom Gallagher Chief Financial Officer State of Florida Matthew Pararo Bureau of Deferred Compensation.
© 2015 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be copied, scanned, or duplicated, in whole or in part, except for use as permitted in a license.
The Honorable David M. Walker Comptroller General of the United States January 20, 2006 United States Government Accountability Office National Academy.
What Must You Know to Determine Retirement Savings Needs? 6 key questions.
The American Problem: Health Insurance Jennifer Bernstein Michael Berry Tom Chiang Ryan Lubitz Leanne Lundby.
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: 1.Old.
Retirement Income.
Australian Governments Economic Goals Low Inflation Strong and sustainable economic growth Full employment Equity in the distribution of Income External.
Presented by the Illinois Department of Insurance Andrew Boron, Director December 2014.
SOCIAL INSURANCE Chapter 7.
Comments on Rudolph G. Penner and Richard W. Johnson, “Health Care Costs, Taxes, and the Retirement Decision” Alan Gustman August 10, 2006.
Retirement Planning and Employee Benefits for Financial Planners
© 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. 3/1/2008 LCN Understanding Deferred Annuities.
PENSION FUNDS. PENSION PLANS 1.PUBLIC PENSION FUNDS Created by state, local or federal govt. 2.PRIVATE PENSION PLANS Created by private agencies including.
Regulating Withdrawals in Individual Account Systems Jan Walliser The World Bank Africa Region, PREM4.
Irwin/McGraw-Hill © The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved C HAPTER 18 Personal Finance Retirement Planning Kapoor Dlabay Hughes.
IT’S ABOUT THE PLAN AND WHAT WILL PAY FOR IT! BY NANCY A. DYKEMAN, CLTC, CSA FOR CERTIFICATION FOR LONG-TERM CARE CORPORATION NOVEMBER 28, 2012 More Arrows.
The Employability of Older People Ronald McQuaid Employment Research Institute, Edinburgh Napier University, Edinburgh, UK
Taxes, Inflation, and Investment Strategy
Health Insurance for Utah Children and Small Businesses November 15, 2006 Expanding Health Insurance Coverage for Utah’s Uninsured Citizens.
Major Retirement Income Sources 1.Social Security 2.Employer-sponsored retirement plans 3.Personal savings 4.Work (wage income)
PENSIONS IN TRANSITION: United States and Japan Robert L. Clark Professor of Economics North Carolina State University 19 September, 2002.
The Multipillar Pension System in the Russian Federation: Completing the Reform Moscow, November 1, 2011 Heinz P. Rudolph
Chapter 14 Annuities and Individual Retirement Accounts
County of Onondaga GASB Valuation Presentation Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEBs) December 5, 2007.
A presentation for the Women’s Institute for a Secure Retirement February 28, 2008 Barbara D. Bovbjerg Director Education, Workforce, and Income Security.
Susan A. Coronel LTC Director America’s Health Insurance Plans What is LTC Insurance and Where is the Market Headed?
The Impact of Health Expenses on Older Women ’ s Financial Security Juliette Cubanski, Ph.D. The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation AcademyHealth 2007 Annual.
Medicare, Medicaid, and Health Care Reform Todd Gilmer, PhD Professor of Health Policy and Economics Department of Family and Preventive Medicine 1.
Drake University – A Roundtable Discussion Longevity and Pensions March 26, 2012.
Options to Extend Health Coverage in Delaware. Key Background Observations n Preponderance of uninsured are working families with incomes between 100%
Choosing between Defined Benefit Plans & Defined Contribution Plans Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of Law University of Oklahoma August 15, 2005.
Financial Risk Management of Insurance Enterprises Finding the Immunizing Investment for Insurance Liabilities: The Case of the SPDA.
25 - 1Copyright 2008, The National Underwriter Company Determining Coverage Needs and Selecting a Long-Term Care Policy  What is it?  Pays for personal.
Choosing between Defined Benefit Plans & Defined Contribution Plans Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of Law University of Oklahoma Canada Cup – Toronto.
LONG TERM CARE Financing Long Term Care. THE NEED FOR LONG-TERM CARE SERVICES IN THIS COUNTRY IS EXPECTED TO INCREASE DRAMATICALLY.
The Role of Annuities in Public Retirement Systems Jeffrey R. Brown Presentation to World Bank May 3, 2002.
Tax Policy Options Sherry Glied, Ph.D. Mailman School of Public Health Columbia University
Investment Strategies for Tax- Advantaged Accounts Chapter 45 Tools & Techniques of Investment Planning Copyright 2007, The National Underwriter Company1.
1 Defined-Benefit and Defined-Contribution Plans of the Future; Don Ezra, FAJ, 2007 The Primary purpose; prompt new thinking by pension plan sponsors about.
TDFs (and BFs) over the Life and Business Cycles by Mark J. Warshawsky, Ph.D. DCIIA October 9, 2013.
RETAIL LONGEVITY/DECUMULATION – RETIREMENT PRODUCTS AND STRATEGIES Mark J. Warshawsky, Ph.D., ReLIAS LLC 59 th Annual Canadian Reinsurance Conference,
DubayView Graph # 1 OVERVIEW What is Crowd-Out and Why Do We Care About it? What Do State Officials Need to Know About Crowd- Out? What Does the Literature.
© 2008 Morningstar, Inc. All rights reserved. 3/1/2008 LCN Role of Immediate Annuities in Retirement.
PBGC & Pension Reform Douglas J. Elliott President Center On Federal Financial Institutions NASI Annual Conference January 20, 2006.
De-risk the Defined Benefit Pensions – Collaboration of all stakeholders.
Actuarial Research Corporation1 Inside the Black Box: Adjustments and Considerations for Public Policy Proposals AcademyHealth Annual Research Meeting:
“Questions for the New Federal Commission on Long-term Care” By Mark J. Warshawsky Commission Member May 23, 2013 LTC Discussion Group Washington, D.C.
For Financial Professional/Training Use Only – Not for distribution to the general public. Selling LTC Insurance in a Down Economy JimZuelsdorf.
Longevity Risk Management and the Development of a Life Annuity Market in Australia John Evans and Michael Sherris Australian School of Business University.
The Commonwealth Fund Alliance for Health Reform Washington DC Medicare as a Building Block for Health Reform: Should Americans Buy In? June 6, 2008 Steven.
250 W. Coventry Ct., # 202, Milwaukee, WI  (414)  Fax (414)   The Changing.
Are You Ready for Retirement? MSU Denver PD conference June 15, 2016 By Keith Fevurly, Sr. Lecturer in Finance.
Retiree Coverage Chapter The Vast Majority of Medicare Beneficiaries Have Some Form of Supplemental Coverage.
Reforming the Second Tier of the U.S. Pension System: Tabula Rasa or Step by Step? Sandy Mackenzie & Jon Forman for Savings and Retirement Institute Washington,
Deferred Income Annuities and QLACs
Started Business 1971 Nations Largest Privately Held Agency Catering to Retiree’s Needs.
Leslie E. Papke Michigan State University
21 Taxes, Inflation, and Investment Strategy Bodie, Kane, and Marcus
Long Term Care Protection Strategies
Presentation transcript:

COMMENTS ON “HEALTH AND MORTALITY DELTA: ASSESSING THE WELFARE COST OF HOUSEHOLD INSURANCE CHOICE” BY KOIJEN, VAN NIEUWERBURGH, AND YOGO Mark J. Warshawsky, AEI November 1, 2013 Personal Retirement Challenges and Financial Solutions, NBER Meeting

Focus of my Comments This is a multi-faceted complex paper with much methodology and several conclusions Empirical work is based on males age 51 and older in the HRS Focus on the following conclusion: “the unexplained variation in the degree to which households are annuitized, rather than the average level at which they are annuitized, is puzzling from the perspective of life-cycle theory,” which seems to arise from the “heterogeneity and inertia that arises from passive annuitization through private pensions.” I will add some perspectives from empirical trends in pensions, life, health and long-term care insurance, and some important methods and findings in the literature, which, to my reading, are not reflected in paper and might matter to the above conclusion

Trends in Pensions Over this time, US (and UK) has gone from many workers in private sector being covered by DB plans to few, as plans have been closed, frozen, and terminated At the same time, about half of traditional DB plans have converted to hybrid plans (owing to lower sponsor risk (see Pang and Warshawsky (2013) and employee desires) At the same time, about half of remaining traditional DB plans have a lump-sum choice and most participants take it; employers respond to employee desires Relatively few DC plans offer life annuities But both DB and DC plans are subject to minimum distribution rules past age 70- 1/2, not a life annuity, even though it may look like one Other non-annuity distributional forms are taken Unisex “pricing” of employer benefits; no underwriting Big distinction between private and public sector, including re indexation of benefits According to Gustman and Steinmeier, significant confusion between DB and DC plan exists among HRS respondents Probably also confusion on difference between immediate and deferred annuities Outside UK, underwriting of individual life annuities is not common, although it exists

Trends in Long-term Care Insurance Underwriting is significant issue for LTCI – at age 65, 25% are rejected, at age 75, 33% are rejected (Kemper, Spillman and Murtaugh (1995)); if anything, this has worsened with time Very few LTCI policies are sold with immediate comprehensive lifetime coverage; rather exclusion periods are long (up to year), 2 – 3 year coverage is common, inflation indexation is not universal, and daily benefit is often less than full nursing home rates in area. LTCI market has suffered a crisis in last seven years or so, with major insurers pulling out, current coverage being repriced upwards, and offered benefits shrinking, owing to lapse assumption mistakes by insurers and Federal Reserve policy Standard LTCI has a “fixed” premium for lifetime of policy, not a term structure Until 2013, unisex pricing was used, resulting in high loads for men Some coverage, especially since 2005, is a “partnership” with Medicaid According to Brown and Finkelstein (2007, 2008), lack of LTCI purchase owes to Medicaid crowd-out; some empirical support from across-state variation According to DeNardi, French, and Jones (2013), significant Medicaid coverage of retirees in middle-income and above brackets at older ages There has also been some “gaming” of Medicaid by the wealthy, albeit likely declining with time

Trends in Life Insurance Many types of coverage exist, both individual and group; variety is indeed significant in reality Some is classic term with fixed nominal dollar benefit and rising premium with age But significant coverage is also “declining term”, both in the individual market (especially to cover mortgages) and group, to greater or lesser extent Also, e.g., 20-year term (implicit cash value) First $50,000 of coverage is tax-free benefit from employer, not indexed Underwriting is significant in individual market Competition and marketing have increased and changed over time period, with Internet expansion

Trends in Health Insurance Retiree health insurance coverage from prior employer has disappeared almost completely in private sector; no accrual Some decline in active employee coverage from employers; also some decline in employer subsidy as costs have skyrocketed Shift to high-deductible plans with HSAs/HRAs, especially in late 2000s More coverage by public sector – Medicaid, CHIP, TAA subsidy Medigap policies standardized in 1990s, but with wide range of coverage Part D Medicare introduced in 2006; CMS website is now quite helpful and detailed; widespread coverage but not universal – non-coverage may be rational given persistence in drug usage Public sector still gives retiree health insurance to employees

Other Comments Bequest measurement in utility function seems non-standard; see DeNardi, French, and Jones (2010), Ameriks, Caplan, et.al. (2011), Abel and Warshawsky (1988) Health status measurement also seems non-standard; why not measure directly as in Brown and Warshawsky (2013) using the HRS Exclusion of HRS information on asset allocation may cause loss of power in tests, as theory (see Pang and Warshawsky (2010)) would posit that stock allocation should increase with age with laddered life annuity coverage (which also hedges LTCI risk, as noted by authors) Life care annuity is a solution to separate LTCI and annuity market problems Laddered immediate annuities, with fixed percentage SWs from increasing equity portfolio is a solution for retirement income problem; see Warshawsky (2012)