Towards a Pan-Canadian Consensus

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Integrating the NASP Practice Model Into Presentations: Resource Slides Referencing the NASP Practice Model in professional development presentations helps.
Advertisements

University of Oxford People Strategy – April 2014.
The Challenge and Importance of Evaluating Residents and Fellows Debra Weinstein, M.D. PHS GME Coordinators Retreat March 25, 2011.
Susan Tallett MB BS MEd FRCPC Professor of Paediatrics Member Safety Competencies Steering Committee June 2008 – PS Working Group Paediatric Chairs of.
Principles & Framework
Statewide Children’s Wraparound Initiative COSA Conference Presenters: Erinn Kelley-Siel Mary Lou Johnson Larry Sullivan.
Telling the Story of Canada’s Children A Comprehensive Approach to Accountability National Children’s Alliance November 26, 2004.
C3 Goals Students will: 1.acquire teamwork competencies 2.acquire knowledge, values and beliefs of health professions different from their own profession.
Update on Goals 1 and 2 Curricular Domain Curricular Domain – accomplishments to date Developed baseline information about current level of faculty.
Paramedic evidence-based education project (PEEP)
Bologna Process in terms of EU aims and objectives
Interprofessional Healthcare Education, Research & Practice Community Faculty Conference May 10, 2014 Dixiana Room 10:30-11:20.
Educational Outcomes: The Role of Competencies and The Importance of Assessment.
Dr. Dalal AL-Matrouk KBA Farwaniya Hospital
Adapting to Climate Change: Canada’s Experience and Approach Elizabeth Atkinson Climate Change Impacts and Adaptation Directorate Natural Resources Canada.
Implementing the new Australian Medical Council standards: The focus on Indigenous health Professor Michael Field Chair, Medical School Accreditation Committee,
Reformation of Surgical Education and Training
Conducting the IT Audit
Teen Mentoring Toolkit Permission to adapt as needed
Family Medicine Program By the end of this session, faculty will 1.Understand what is meant by competence and the competence trajectory expected during.
Eric R. Johnson Hillsborough County, (Tampa) FL
Project Human Resource Management
PROFESSIONALISM EDUCATION: POSSIBLE COMPETENCIES Barbara Barzansky, PhD, MHPE LCME Co-Secretary APHC Conference May 3, 2013.
ACGME OUTCOME PROJECT : THE PROGRAM COORDINATOR’S ROLE Jim Kerwin, MD University of Arizona.
TEMPUS IV- THIRD CALL FOR PROPOSALS Recommendation on how to make a good proposal TEMPUS INFORMATION DAYS Podgorica, MONTENEGRO 18 th December 2009.
Training of Process Facilitators Training of Process Facilitators.
HEALTH PROMOTING SCHOOL IN CONTEXT. HMIe Self Evaluation Series The Health Promoting School - Nov 2004 The characteristics of the Being Well-Doing Well.
Add presentation title to master slide | 1 New inspection methodology from September 2009 NATSPEC conference Lorna Fitzjohn May 2009.
Steps for Success in EHR Planning Bill French, VP eHealth Strategies Wisconsin Office of Rural Health HIT Implementation Workshop Stevens Point, WI August.
OPERATIONAL GUIDELINES Ensuring Ownership of PARSEL by Partners.
Teaching and Supporting Students with Vision Impairments An Australian Universities Teaching Committee Funded Project WAANU Conference March 2005.
Dr. David Mowat June 22, 2005 Federal, Provincial & Local Roles Surveillance of Risk Factors and Determinants of Chronic Diseases.
NIPEC Organisational Guide to Practice & Quality Improvement Tanya McCance, Director of Nursing Research & Practice Development (UCHT) & Reader (UU) Brendan.
© 2011 Partners Harvard Medical International Strategic Plan for Teaching, Learning and Assessment Program Teaching, Learning, and Assessment Center Strategic.
ENHANCING PATHWAYS INTO CARE MANCHESTER. KEY RECOMMENDATIONS FROM MANCHESTER MENTAL HEALTH AND SOCIAL CARE TRUST Data collection: – ensure consistency.
Professionalizing Mobility Management: Developing Standards and Competencies Julie Dupree, Easter Seals Association of Travel Instruction Conference August.
What could we learn from learning outcomes assessment programs in the U.S public research universities? Samuel S. Peng Center for Educational Research.
6 Key Priorities A “scorecard” for each of the 5 above priorities with end of 2009 deliverables – with a space beside each for a check mark (i.e. complete)
Guide for Rural Local Officials Evaluating Your Input into the Statewide Transportation Planning Process Developed by the National Association of Development.
Quality Assuring Deliverers of Education and Training for the Nuclear Sector Jo Tipa Operations Director National Skills Academy for Nuclear.
Health Quality Ontario: Health System Performance New Zealand Master Class March 25, 2014.
1 Implementing a Knowledge Cycle for Best Practices in Health Promotion and Chronic Disease Prevention Kerry Robinson, Vincent Turgeon, Dexter Harvey,
Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.
Mindset 2000 LtdSlide 1 Train to Gain Provider Support Programme October 2007 Self assessment - introduction.
University of Kentucky Center for Clinical and Translational Science (CCTS) November 2015 Stephen W. Wyatt, DMD, MPH Senior Associate Director Center for.
ESSB 6656 Overview and Scope of the Select Committee on Quality Improvement in State Hospitals April 29, 2016 Kevin Black, Senate Committee Services Andy.
Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Milestones are Coming: A Conversation with the Family Medicine Milestones Committee May 2013.
Standards and Competencies for Cancer Chemotherapy Nursing Practice in Canada: CANO/ACIO AN INTRODUCTION.
National Accreditation Forum, Vic Health Ms Margaret Banks, A/Senior Operations Manager 25 July 2011.
1 Achieving the Vision for a Health Literate Canada Presentation by Irving Rootman at Pan-Canadian Workshop on Health Literacy May 21, 2009, Gatineau,
GMC Approval of trainers in the UK Enid Rowland and Patricia Le Rolland.
Context and Problem Effects of Changes Strategy for Change Aim: To reduce the length of handover by standardising the quality of information transmitted.
European Agency for Development in Special Needs Education Project updates Marcella Turner-Cmuchal.
Conferenceboard.ca Aligning, Foreseeing, and Optimizing HTA in Canada 2016 CADTH Symposium April 12, 2016 Dr. Gabriela Prada Director, Health Innovation.
Critical Program Movement: Integration of STD Prevention with Other Programs Kevin Fenton, MD, PhD, FFPH Director National Center for HIV/AIDS, Viral Hepatitis,
Economics of Policing Shared Forward Agenda Economics of Policing Shared Forward Agenda.
CLER Pathways II January 28, 2016 PARTNERS IN MEDICAL EDUCATION, INC. Presented by: Tori Hanlon, MS, CHCP GME Consultant.
Project: EaP countries cooperation for promoting quality assurance in higher education Maria Stratan European Institute for Political Studies of Moldova.
Perspectives for the New-in-Practice Physician
NURS 3043 ELA 5 Transition to Practice
Title of the Change Project
Interprofessional Health care Teams
Improving the Garment Sector in Lao PDR:
Designing Effective Accommodation Plans in Clinical Placement & Internship Settings
Transformation of Medical Education in Canada
Summit 2017 Breakout Group 2: Data Management (DM)
Health Education England Workforce Strategy - Key Points
Health Education England Workforce Strategy - Key Points
Finance & Planning Committee of the San Francisco Health Commission
TLQAA STANDARDS & TOOLS
Presentation transcript:

Fatigue, Risk and Excellence:  Towards a Pan-Canadian Consensus on Resident Duty Hours

Towards a Pan-Canadian Consensus Funded in part by Health Canada, the project ran from March 2012 – May 2013; Public report released on June 27 Two central goals: To assemble the available evidence on the issue of resident duty hours in Canada and similar international contexts (or duty hours at large) To facilitate a national consensus-building process to come to pan-Canadian statements on issues, directions, and best practices

Collaboration Across Canadian Health Care The final report was developed by the National Steering Committee on Resident Duty Hours, a diverse group of medical educators, residents and experts from across Canada, including nine health care organizations

Project Phases The project was divided into three key phases, which together spanned the period from March 2012-May 2013. Phase 1 (March 2012-August 2012) Preliminary research and report development Phase 2 (June 2012-January 2013) Analysis and consultations with Expert Working Groups Phase 3 (January 2013-May 2013) Consensus Conference Final Report

Project Methodology A mixed-method, multi-phased approach was developed to guide research and analysis throughout the project, including Interviews with National Steering Committee members, National Survey of Residents, Postgraduate Deans, Program , Directors, and a Sample of Hospital Administrators, Analysis of Current and Historic Collective Agreements, Literature Review, Jurisdictional Review outside Canada, Six Expert Working Group Commentary Papers, and Canadian Consensus Conference on Resident Duty Hours.

A Way Forward for Canada Key Findings + 5 Central Principles + 5 Recommendations to Move Forward

Considering the Context of Duty Hour Regulations in Canada Canada has a unique landscape as pertains to resident duty hour regulations. The environment in Canada is marked by tremendous historical and geographic variability in the working environments faced by residents.

Key Findings Statements on the Impact of Resident Duty Hours and Resident Duty Hour Regulations Traditional duty periods present risks to the physical, mental, and occupational health of residents. Fatigue impairs cognitive and behavioural performance. A tired doctor is not necessarily an unsafe doctor. There is no conclusive data to show that restrictions on consecutive resident duty hours are necessary for patient safety. Successful efforts to improve patient safety and resident fatigue will need to be comprehensive, involving not only the regulation of resident duty hours alone.

Key Findings Statements on the Impact of Resident Duty Hours and Resident Duty Hour Regulations 6. There is no clear evidence that resident duty hour regulations have had a significant positive or negative impact on academic performance. 7. There is evidence suggesting suboptimal patient care and educational outcomes in surgery resulting from the restriction of resident duty hours. 8. Resident duty hour regulations necessitate reorganization of health human resources deployment and care delivery models. These changes have the potential for impact on the health care system.

5 Principles for a Collective, Pan-Canadian Response Residents have inter-related roles as learners and care providers. Residents are vital providers in a health care system that is collectively responsible for 24/7 patient care coverage Duty periods of twenty-four or more consecutive hours without restorative sleep should be avoided. Efforts to minimize risk and enhance safety are necessary and cannot be undertaken by addressing resident duty hours alone. Given the substantial variation in resident training needs, a tailored and rigorous model for resident duty hours and the provision of after-hour care is needed.

Recommendations to Move Canada Forward

Recommendation #1 Recognizing that there are many factors that contribute to resident fatigue, a comprehensive approach to minimize fatigue and fatigue-related risks should be developed and implemented in residency training in all jurisdictions in Canada. Residency education programs to develop fatigue risk management plans Create monitoring and enforcement mechanisms at a local level Develop a national tool-box of fatigue mitigation strategies and techniques

Recommendation #2 Educational approaches should be redesigned to leverage innovations and new approaches, to ensure appropriate training and acquisition of competencies in an era of increasing resident duty hour regulations. Encourage and catalogue pilot projects for a range of educational tools and innovative scheduling systems Re-design residency education to maximize teaching and learning opportunities, and minimize excessive service obligations Incorporate simulation experiences into programs as teaching tools Curricula to include self-assessment, fatigue management, and handover skills The Three sister colleges to review specialty training requirements to allow flexibility in training

Recommendation #3 Accreditation standards must be adapted to support planned modifications of the content and duration of resident duty, through the enforcement of fatigue risk management activities. Standards to specify that individual institutions must develop, and keep up to date, fatigue risk management plans (FRMPs) Standards should require education in effective self-awareness, handover and communication skills

Recommendation #4 An inventory of alternate models of scheduling and after-hours care provision should be created and disseminated to provide alternatives and benchmarks of scheduling and service delivery. A national evaluation framework to monitor the impact of changes to resident duty hours should be created.

Recommendation #5 An independent, pan-Canadian consortium devoted to the evaluation of resident duty hours in Canada should be created. Enable local decision-making through the provision of resources and measurement related to resident duty hours Consortium would have four key roles: Create and coordinate dissemination of national toolbox of resources Support the process of Fatigue Risk Management Plan creation/implementation Undertake science and evidence-based research on resident duty hours Knowledge translation and dissemination of scholarly evidence

Download the Final Report View the complete report to learn more about Project timelines and activities Project methodology A glossary of resident duty hours terminology Key research themes and findings Pan-Canadian principles Recommendations

Download the full report at www. residentdutyhours. ca Questions Download the full report at www.residentdutyhours.ca Questions? Contact the Project Secretariat at  RDH-HTR@royalcollege.ca