The Causes and Consequences of Rising Health Insurance Premiums Mark Pauly, Ph.D. Wharton School University of Pennsylvania.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
David Kleykamp Institute of the Americas and Department of Economics Tamkang University.
Advertisements

Massachusetts Health Care Reform June 6, The healthcare status quo is unsustainable Double-digit, annual increases in insurance premiums Half.
John M. Colmers Secretary Department of Health and Mental Hygiene How States Are Trying To Expand Employer Sponsored Health Coverage.
1 Improving the Tax Treatment of Health Insurance Katherine Baicker Professor of Health Economics Harvard School of Public Health.
Health Savings Accounts: Early Estimates Of National Take-Up Roger Feldman, Stephen T. Parente, Jean Abraham, Jon B. Christianson and Ruth Taylor
Prepared for the Committee for Health Care for Massachusetts December 14, 2005 ACTION COSTS LESS The Health Care Amendment Standards and Options for Reform.
Teleconference 2 1.Guest speakers in May 2.Policy Brief Project The Employer and Health Insurance.
Policy Proposals Health Care Coverage, Costs, and Financing.
The Affordable Care Act Reduces Premium Cost Growth and Increases Access to Affordable Care Before ACA, Small Employers Faced Many Obstacles to Covering.
Background on Employer- Sponsored Health Insurance in the U.S. Jim Reschovsky, Ph.D. Senior Researcher Center for Studying Health System Change (
Government and Health Care Roughly 15 cents of every dollar spent in US is on health care US health care spending equaled $5841 per person in 2002 Governments.
— A Proposal to Cover All Americans —. 2 Health Coverage Passport Charles N. Kahn III President Federation of American Hospitals National Congress On.
The Economics of Health Care Reform Allen C. Goodman Wayne State University Presented to Adult Learning Institute October 25, 2011
MEDICARE: PAST, PRESENT AND F UTURE James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Department of Sociology & Anthropology.
Government and Health Care Roughly 15 cents of every dollar spent in US is on health care US health care spending equaled $5841 per person in 2002 Governments.
The incidence of Mandated Maternity Benefits
Health Care Forecasting Conference James Baumgardner Deputy Assistant Director for Health Policy Congressional Budget Office February 19, 2009.
Presenter: Joseph Reid Paper: The Market for Health Care Date : 6/04/07.
Economic Challenges and New Medical Technologies Laurence Baker, Ph.D. Stanford University School of Medicine
1 Aggregate Supply The AS is the part of our national economy model where the production side is studied.
Regional economic distinctions are essential in better understanding New York’s economic challenges.
HEALTH AND PRODUCTIVITY MANAGEMENT H P M THINK GLOBALLY! BY: BRIAN D. HARRISON, MD DATE:9/28/04.
Ch. 8: The Self Regulating Economy Del Mar College John Daly ©2003 South-Western Publishing, A Division of Thomson Learning.
Ch. 16: Expectations Theory and the Economy
Katherine Baicker Professor of Health Economics, Harvard School of Public Health Implementation of the ACA: Insurance Expansions and the Value of Care.
The State of the U.S. Labor Market Office of Economic Policy February 3, 2015 Dr. Jennifer Hunt Deputy Assistant Secretary, Microeconomic Analysis.
1 Making Universal Health Care Work Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of Law University of Oklahoma “The Future of Employer-Provided Benefits” John.
Longwood University Personal Finance Scott Wentland Longwood University 201 High Street Farmville, VA
Health Reform: What It Means to Our Community. Health Reform: Key Provisions o Provides coverage to 32 million uninsured people by o Changes insurance.
CHCWG DRAFT March 2, 2006 Hearing from the American People: Preliminary Overview of Sources and Reports March 2006 Caution: Preliminary Data Do not cite.
Health Insurance for Utah Children and Small Businesses November 15, 2006 Expanding Health Insurance Coverage for Utah’s Uninsured Citizens.
Chapter 1 Why Study Public Finance?
The Affordable Care Act. What is it? Affordable Care Act was designed to: – Increase the quality and affordability of health insurance – Decrease the.
Health Reform and Young Adults What do you need to know? YOUR NAME HERE Your Organization Raising Women’s Voices Fall 2010.
1 Chapter 10 – Social Insurance II: Health Care Public Finance McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., All Rights Reserved.
Health Care Reform in America Facing Up:. President Obama and Healthcare Reform “Health care reform is no longer just a moral imperative, it’s a fiscal.
Health Care Reform: The Top 10 Things You Need to Know.
1 Chapter 4 Supply and Demand: Applications and Extensions.
Catastrophic health insurance and health savings accounts in the US February, 2008.
By: Michael Stubbs Daniel Stanley. Small Business Health Care Health insurance becomes harder to afford as the cost of health care increases in the US.
UllmanView Graph # 1 OVERVIEW Background and Basics of Cost-Sharing Designing Premiums Analysis of Impacts of Four States’ Premium Policies Implications.
Chapter 2 Measuring economic activity
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act Our Healthcare Reform Law Why do we need it? What does it do for us?
Domestic Policy Social Welfare and Health. 3 The Evolution of Social Welfare Policies  Most of our major federal social welfare programs were developed.
Copyright McGraw-Hill/Irwin, 2002 The Health Care Industry Quality of Care Limited Access Increasing Demand for Health Care Role of Health Insurance.
BALANCING LIMITED RESOURCES AND UNLIMITED EXPECTATIONS IN HEALTH CARE Colloquium on Workers Compensation May 2, 2003 Professor James C. Robinson University.
Health Care. Health Care Reform Insuring more people by changing the number The Million number is gone46-47 Million.
THE COMMONWEALTH FUND Karen Davis President, The Commonwealth Fund January 27, Health Savings Accounts.
Fairness and the Federal Tax Treatment of Health Insurance and Medical Care Mark Pauly Wharton School University of Pennsylvania Prepared for The President's.
The Self Regulating Economy Del Mar College, John Daly ©2002 South-Western Publishing, A Division of Thomson Learning.
The Best of the Second Best: Using Tax Breaks to Manipulate Health Insurance Mark V. Pauly, Ph.D. ARIA Meeting August 7, 2006.
April 12, REVISED 1 Catamount Health Financial Facts Under the Senate Bill Kenneth E. Thorpe Emory University.
Health Benefit Exchanges: Many Questions to Answer April 7, 2011 presented by Ed Ratledge Center for Applied Demography & Survey Research University of.
Comprehensive Health Care Reform in Vermont: The Policy and Politics Jim Maxwell, PhD Herb Olson, JD JSI Research & Training Institute, Inc. Vermont Department.
Health Care Chapter 21 McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
OHIO HEALTHCARE COVERAGE REFORM INITIATIVE April 2008.
Modeling Health Reform in Massachusetts John Holahan June 4, 2008 THE URBAN INSTITUTE.
The design of the tax system Chapter 12. A financial overview of the U.S government Amazingly, the U.S federal government collects 2/3 of the taxes in.
Will Employers and Employees Ever Come to Their Senses about Rising Insurance Costs? Mark V. Pauly The University of Pennsylvania.
1.02 ~ ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES AND CONDITIONS CHAPTER 2 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
Why Minimum Wage Should Be Raised Alex Tottle. Background Minimum wage laws were first instituted in 1938 by the US Department of Labor to create a limit.
U.S. Health Care System – Jenny Lee INEKO, Michigan Law School Student June 14, 2004.
1.02 ~ ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES AND CONDITIONS CHAPTER 2 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
Small Business Conversations
The Access Crisis: Are Employer Mandates Part of the Solution?
The U.S. Health Care System: An International Perspective
A QUESTION OF ACCESS.
Massachusetts Health Care Reform Mandates
Health Care Policy Public Policy.
Coverage and Changes in Spending Compared to Current Law, 2020
Presentation transcript:

The Causes and Consequences of Rising Health Insurance Premiums Mark Pauly, Ph.D. Wharton School University of Pennsylvania

Two Problematic and Puzzling Propositions 1. The bulk of the growth in health insurance premiums comes either from things that we do not want to control or from things we find very hard to control % of growth: costly but beneficial new technology Almost all of the rest: higher wages and profits, increased incidence of some diseases. Trivial: aging of the population (0.5%)

Two Problematic… 2. Workers almost always pay for almost all of their health insurance. They pay part through explicit premiums They pay the rest (the “employer contribution”) through lower growth in money wages. So the share doesn’t matter. Mandating that employers pay is a disguised employee mandate that makes workers take lower raises. No need to thank the boss (or thank for wages)

The Question In the face of these facts, what is good public policy? Define “good.” 1) not perfect; that is impossible and there are inevitably going to be tradeoffs. 2) any change should help to improve efficiency 3) any change should help to improves equity. 4) any change should be politically feasible.

Two Different Questions That Are Often Confused What causes health insurance premiums to be “high” (relative to income, GDP,etc)? What causes health insurance premiums to rise (faster than almost anything)? Focusing on the answers to the first question may not help with the second.

Why Are Premiums “High”? People get sick and want treatment. Some wages and profits are above average. “Inefficiency” (My guess: 15-20%) Administrative costs and insurer profit or surplus.

Why Are Premiums Rising (at 4-5% real rate per year, or more)? As noted, mostly because of beneficial but net costly new technology (including new ways to use old tech; also driven by quality effects on demand). Wages for non-doctors rising faster than average. Sometimes, increased incidence of some illnesses (more true now than in 1980).

The good news and the not-so-good news for Hawai’i Probably possible to close most of the gap with subsidies to basic insurance coverage for “tweeners” and expanding Medicaid to able-bodied adults. But the inexorable technology driven rise in premiums is going to offer stronger incentives to tweeners to avoid the mandate and will impoverish those who cannot avoid it. % uninsured in Hawai’i only slightly below PA.

Short run solutions Design a decent but basic policy for tweeners and Evel Knievels of health insurance. Subsidize fairly generously, thru vouchers Do not raise the subsidy by taxing premiums— shoots yourself in the foot. Tax income, french fries, anything with an inelastic demand or that you want people to do less of.

Short run solutions 2 (More tentative) Offer this policy in a well functioning individual market since self employed and part timers are not good group members. Permit choice but have a fallback insurer (state employee plan?)

Long run solutions Face facts: we are not going to IT or disease manage our way out of permanent premium growth. We will need to sacrifice. Try to develop a rational policy toward new technology and make sure the law does not inhibit. Would there be a market for a “prudent adoption” or “go slow” insurance policy?

Hope and Conclusions A few bittersweet hints that we may be coming in for a smooth landing in which premiums still grow but not as fast as income. Lower rate of introduction of new drugs. Current on-trend spending growth seems recently related more to the increased incidence of some disease than pure technology. We need to be able to have a civil conversation about hard things.