Trade Policies, Market Structure, and Manufacturing Sector Performance in Malawi over the period 1967-2002 Hopestone Kayiska Chavula Macroeconomic Policy.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Competitive Market in Public / Private Education.
Advertisements

formulation of national trade policies
Industrial Development Policies Industrial Policy and the Evolution of the Portuguese Economy Since the 1960s Lecture Slides Rui Baptista
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND ITS POLITICAL ECONOMY
Import Substitution Industrialization.  Premises: Development should be achieved by looking inwardDevelopment should be achieved by looking inward Promote.
Trade Rules in Services: Issues and Problems Carsten Fink, The World Bank EU-LDC Network Annual Conference Trade and Poverty Reduction Rotterdam, 30 and.
1 Etatism in the Turkish Economy, Domestic Developments Fail to satisfy economic independence- fast development Industrialization policy.
1 UNSD Workshop on Manufacturing Statistics 4-7 May 2009, Lusaka, Zambia Presented by: Blignaut Joshua Kadam’manja Economics Section; National Accounts,
African Economic Conference October 2011 Addis Ababa, Ethiopia Revisiting the Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment in Africa: the role of Institutions.
Locational Determinants of FDI: The Case of Vietnam Presented by Le Viet Anh Nagoya University, GSID, 1 st year PhD Student At JVEC’s Meeting 29 th May.
1 Lecture Five China and World Economy Xingmin Yin School of Economics.
Openness, Economic Growth, and Human Development: Evidence from South Asian countries from Middlesex University Department of Economics and.
Trade Policy Exports stood at 38% of GDP in 2007 Foreign affiliates account for roughly 50% of manufacturing output and Canadians have significant investment.
©2004 Prentice Hall9-1 Chapter 9: Formulation of National Trade Policies International Business, 4 th Edition Griffin & Pustay.
East and South East Asian NICs: class 3. Advantages of Export- Oriented Industrialization q Forces country to capitalize on its comparative advantage.
Latin America Class 4. Components of New Economic Policy Packages F creating macroeconomic stability by controlling public sector deficits F opening up.
The Impact of Syrian Trade Policies on Agricultural Trade Performance Basheer Hamwi.
Parallel Market Exchange Rate in Oil Exporting Countries: The Case of Iran Samila Amanyraoufpoor Seminar in International Business Dr. Louise Kelly.
International Trade “The Basics”.
University of Papua New Guinea International Economics Lecture 12: Trade Policy – The Developing World.
Amber Huber.  Government intervention to give economic opportunities to production sectors that wouldn’t have occurred without said intervention.  Three.
How can trade contribute to growth and jobs? The role of EU trade policy Signe Ratso Director Directorate General of Trade European Commission.
Infrastructure conference, May 06 South Africa’s Export Performance: Determinants of Export supply Lawrence Edwards and Bongani Johnny Based on Edwards.
Chapter 12 International Trade and Development Strategy
By Miriam W O Omolo Institute of Economic Affairs Monday 22 June 2009, Country Inn, Jaipur, India.
IDENTIFYING AND SELECTING INTERNATIONAL MARKETS. INTRODUCTION Before making an entry in the international market, a firm has to identify those markets.
Global Edition Chapter Nineteen The Global Marketplace Copyright ©2014 by Pearson Education.
Monetary Policy for Aid-Receiving Countries Matías Vernengo.
Monopolistic Competition
Trade Liberalisation. Micro Reform – Trade Liberalisation Trade liberalisation is about removing the barriers that are designed to restrict international.
Competition Policy and Development: Evidence from the Asian Region Presentation by Douglas H. Brooks June 27, 2006.
Trade and Protection vs Free Trade. Theory of Trade All countries have different combination of economic resources: land, labour and capital resources.
 1960 constitution  Economic planning framework  Started in 1960 and lasted in its proper sense until 1980  The coverege of plans are specified 
Mergers, Acquisitions and Export Competitiveness: Experience of Indian Manufacturing Sector Researcher: Mishra Pulak, Jaiswal Neha Publishing Year: 2012.
Pre and Post Reform Period in India: An Analysis
Life Impact | The University of Adelaide University of Papua New Guinea Economic Development Lecture 15: International Trade.
2 The Global Economy. Learning Objectives Distinguish among the basic theories of world trade: absolute advantage, comparative advantage, and competitive.
Why Do Countries Use Capital Controls? Prepared by R. Barry Johnston and Natalia T. Tamirisa - December 1998 Presented by: Alyaa Ezzat.
UK INNOVATION SURVEY 2005 CIS4 – Introduction and Guide A brief introduction to the survey Some description of the data and analytical results, special.
1 Trade related regulations in services sectors - Balkan experiences Nora Dihel OECD Trade Directorate.
Export Spillovers from FDI: Evidence from Polish firm-level data Andrzej Cieślik (University of Warsaw) Jan Hagemejer (National Bank of Poland)
1 CHAPTER 1: PRO-COMPETITVE EFFECT OF TRADE 1A: Imports as market discipline 1B: Empirical evidence 1C: Heterogeneity of firms, productivity, mark-ups.
Determinants of investment and innovation in Polish manufacturing industries. Forthcoming in Post-Communist Economies Michał Brzozowski.
May 2008Gunther Schnabl, Leipzig University & CESIfo1 Exchange Rate Stabilization and Growth in Small Open Economies at the EMU Periphery Gunther Schnabl.
Business Structure. 1- Primary sector business activity Businesses related to extraction of natural resources 2- Secondary sector business activity manufacturing.
Economic Environment of Business International Trade. GATT and the WTO.
Globalisation.
Import Liberalization, Productivity and Exports Mustapha Nabli World Bank November 25, 2004.
ECO 121 MACROECONOMICS Lecture Three Aisha Khan Section L & M Spring 2010.
7-1 Copyright © 2009 Pearson Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall Chapter Seven Governmental Influence On Trade International Business Part Three.
The Global Marketplace Global Marketing in the 21 st Century The world is shrinking rapidly with the advent of faster communication, transportation,
A2 External Influences Government policies affecting business.
Globalisation & Liberalisation. Introduction: Evolution of business refers to origin and growth of business activities over a period of time. Business.
FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT, OPENNESS AND EXPORT PROMOTION IN SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA By Nyambati R. Aori Paper to be presented at Center for the Study of African.
AdvantageDisadvantage 1 st Free Trade Area 2 nd Customs Union 3 rd Single Market 4 th Economic Union 5 th Monetary Union.
EXTERNAL INFLUENCES These are factors that the business can not control (External constraints) PESTEL Analysis is a part of the external analysis that.
What were the main problems for Chile?
International Trade, Foreign Capital Flow and Aid in Development
Plant Scale and Exchange-Rate-Induced Productivity Growth
Hong Kong’s Business Environment
Theories of International Trade and Investment
Revision Theme 4 Topic 4.1 International economics
BEC 30325: MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS
Presentation at the African Economic Conference
Responding to urban demand through domestic industry
BEC 30325: MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS
BEC 30325: MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS
BEC 30325: MANAGERIAL ECONOMICS
By Michael Mbate UN Economic Commission for Africa
Trade and Protectionism
Presentation transcript:

Trade Policies, Market Structure, and Manufacturing Sector Performance in Malawi over the period Hopestone Kayiska Chavula Macroeconomic Policy Division Economic Commission for Africa Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. African Economic Conference, 28th-30th October 2013, Johannesburg, RSA.

Contents Introduction. Economic policy regimes and manufacturing performance. Price mark-ups, trade and market structure hypotheses. Methodology and data. Empirical results. Conclusions.

Introduction Like many African countries Mw has gone through episodes of economic performance over the years; However, it is observed to have performed relatively better in the first fifteen years after independence than the other periods; Malawi’s manufacturing sector has remained relatively small and underdeveloped, and its performance remains dismal; The paper tries to evaluate the impact of changes in economic policies and market structure on the performance of the manufacturing sector in Malawi.

Economic policy regimes and mnfng. performance PeriodTrade Policy ActionsManufacturing Average Growth rates Import Substitution Industrialisation  Overvalued exchange rate system – fixed peg  Limited tariff protection  Non-tariff barriers to trade e.g. import licensing and implicit foreign exchange rationing.  Malawi-Botswana reciprocal trade agreement in  Active government involvement in manufacturing industries.  Low and stable inflation and interest rates % a SAPs Period  Periodic devaluation of the local currency and liberalisation of interest rates  Liberalisation of output prices and limited entry  Liberalisation into the manufacturing sector. 2.87%  Introduction of duty drawback system in  Introduction of surtax credit system in 1989  Bilateral trade agreements  Reduction in tariffs leading to a maximum of 75 percent in  Elimination of quantitative trade restrictions and foreign exchange rationing.  Abolition of exclusive monopoly rights  Privatisation of state-owned enterprises  Liberalisation of the financial sector and interest rates Complete Open Economy Regime and export promotion  Floatation of the local currency  Introduction of Export Processing Zones (EPZ)  Reciprocal bilateral trade agreement  Base surtax rate reduced to 20%  Malawi joined the COMESA free trade area  Privatisation of state-owned enterprises.  Liberalisation of industry and output/input prices % b

Price-cost margins and manufacturing output growth rate trends –

Price mark-ups, trade and market structure hypotheses Debate on competition and market structure in firm/industry performance; Inputs availability (Mw) play a significant ro in the performance of industry/firm; Increase in demand has a positive impact on performance; Imports lead to low p-cost margins due to increased competition; Export market tends to compel monopolists (oligopolists) to be more competitive in pricing;

MethodologyandData Methodology and Data Y=price-cost margin (performance) MC=market concentration X=vector of factors determining conjectures B= vector of barriers to entry e=elasticity of demand p=policy variables

Methodologycont…. Methodology cont…. ; ;, DU = dummy variables for structural breaks Fink= finance working capital

Data Firm level panel data from NSO through NES, ; 141 firms under 14 four digit ISIC industries; Exports and imports are at industry level.

Empirical Results 1 st carried out the Clemente-Montanes-Reyes unit root test to establish structural breaks; Results showed significant structural breaks in –1982 : LR effect of economic instability before adopting SAPs –1991: could be due to accumulation and continued effects of SAPs. Dummy variables were constructed based on these structural breaks to capture the policy effects on performance.

Panel Data Regression Estimates Variables Model FGLS Model FE(Robust) Model FGLS Model RE (Robust) Hhi 0.128*** (0.000)0.175*** (0.000)0.091*** (0.000)0.157*** (0.000) Imp-0.044*** (0.000)-0.330*** (0.000)0.014 (0.425)-0.086** (0.021) Exp (0.528)-0.064*** (0.006)0.025 (0.174)-0.055** (0.019) Rmtrs *** (0.000)-0.488*** (0.000)-0.186*** (0.000)-0.241*** (0.000) Skill-0.031* (0.065)0.038 (0.565)0.019 (0.644)-0.081** (0.015) fink *** (0.001)-0.096* (0.106)-0.165*** (0.001) (0.226) Mes (0.748)0.090 (0.525)0.090 (0.362)0.274** (0.017) Klr 0.129*** (0.000)0.081* (0.100)0.255*** (0.000)0.084** (0.029) Dem (0.566) (0.750) (0.650) (0.997) Tariff0.008 (0.835)0.058 (0.314) (0.401) (0.144) Dummy (0.927) Dummy ** (0.031) Intercept 1.727*** (0.000)2.958*** (0.000)0.924 (0.183)2.234** (0.047) Hausman test 47.09*** (0.0000)27.19*** (0.0000)50.19*** (0.0000)15.34 (0.1202) Wooldridge test (AR1) 6.729** ( (0.4223)3.423* (0.0693)17.230*** (0.0001) Wald test1.3e+05*** (0.000)1.6e+05*** (0.000)1.5e+05*** (0.0000)- Breusch & Pagan LM *** (0.0000) Observations Groups

Empirical results cont….. Policy changes and strategies led to two significant structural breaks (in 1982 and 1991) Mainly attributed to the country’s economic crisis in the late 1970s and early 1980s, and the accumulation and continued effects of the SAPs; Price-cost margin increased with the degree of market concentration in an industry; Imports and exports are found to have a negative and significant impact on the firms’ performance in line with economic theory especially during the import substitution/protectionist and post-liberalisation periods.

Conclusions International trade has considerable impact on domestic profitability looking at the effects of import and export intensity; Calling for export performance enhancing policies and import discipline; Emphasis on technological transfer of emerging technologies, the associated knowledge and expertise; Deliberate efforts to enhance the availability of factor inputs (raw materials, skilled labour & financing capital & access to loanable funds).