5th PRC-ADB Knowledge Sharing Platform Sustainable Vocational Training towards Industrial Upgrading and Economic Transformation Beijing and Guangzhou,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Public Private Partnerships What are They? Theory and Practice Carlo Cottarelli Deputy Director, Fiscal Affairs Department, IMF February 2008.
Advertisements

COMMONWEALTH YOUTH PROGRAMME AFRICA CENTRE COMMONWEALTH SECRETARIAT Youth Enterprise Development and Youth Employment Experiences and Lessons from Commonwealth.
ITU Regional Seminar on E-commerce Bucharest, Romania May 2002 National E-commerce Strategies for Development Dr. Susanne Teltscher United Nations.
Why do Governments Intervene in Education? NZ. Rationales for Intervention Notre Reine de Nkolso, Yaounde, Cameroon.
Session 6: Public-Private Partnership in ADB Trevor Lewis Senior Infrastructure Specialist (Public Private Partnerships) Secretariat, PPP Community.
June 3 rd, 2014 Athens public meeting - Presentation on Infrastructure financing Vicky D. Kefalas, MBA Head, Investments & Development Projects Consolidated.
Universal Coverage – Can we guarantee health for all? 3 – 4 October 2011, Kuala Lumpur Nossal perspective.
 Definitions & Background  P3 Markets – Global & Canadian  Canada’s Infrastructure Deficit  P3 Policy Debate and Drivers  Why the debate matters 
Shipbuilding Institute of Polytechnic Surabaya SHIPS Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect.
Public-Private Partnerships in Urbanization: High Level Workshop
HEALTH PPPs An introduction Is there a recipe for success?
Towards the Romania of PRINCIPLES OF PROGRAMMING The social and macroeconomic policy of Europe is the policy of Romania EU projects represent a.
Cambodian Group Presentation Mekong Institute Khon Kaen, Thailand September, 2010.
Part 2: Key Challenges and Potential Policy Framework leading to clearer, more diverse, more effective public and private roles – Introducing the discussion.
Facilitating PPPs in Asia
Sustainable Vocational Training towards Industrial Upgrading
The Enabling Environment: How can governments encourage PPPs? Recent Australian Initiatives Michael Schur, November 2014 Disclaimer: The views expressed.
Skills for Employment CIDA Policy context and Programming guidelines ACCC Forum–Edmonton, June c.
ROLE OF DIFFERENT STAKEHOLDERS AND HYBRID FINANCIAL MECHANISM OF MHI Public Private Partnerships or PPPs as Means of Financing Infrastructure in MHI Projects.
Capacity Building Program for EAs/IAs on Successful Project Design and Implementation November 2013  ADB Headquarters, Manila, Philippines Improving.
ADB Support of Public Procurement Reform Presented By: Amr J. Qari, Procurement Specialist Seventh Regional Public Procurement Forum, May , 2011.
Overview Summary from Africa and ASEAN assistance Dr. Peter Pembleton, UNIDO.
Public-Private Partnerships: State of Practice and Research Needs The 14 th Annual Public Private Partnership Conference World Bank, Washington, DC September.
Using alternative financing tools to improve agribusiness finance by Yan Zhang UNCTAD Caribbean Rural Development Briefings
Financing Urban Public Infrastructure
23/08/20151 European Investment Bank EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK Urban Development Projects 29 th May 2009 Barbara Lemke Urban Planner Projects Directorate.
© Atos KPMG Consulting 2003 PPPs IN HEALTH CARE: AN INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE Emmett Moriarty Senior Health Sector Specialist.
Background of PPP Negotiation
Education in a Changing World: Implications for TVET Yidan Wang Beijing, China December 2, 2013 Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those.
Competitive Funding for Higher Education Richard Hopper Senior Education Specialist The World Bank Baku, Azerbaijan – May 13, 2009.
Essentials for Building a Competitive Services Sector Ramesh Chaitoo Essentials for Building a Competitive Services Sector Ramesh Chaitoo.
Contracting for the Delivery of Education Services Suzanne Roddis, EdInvest
Partnership for Market Readiness (PMR) and Carbon Market Developments
P UBLIC -P RIVATE P ARTNERSHIPS IN M ONGOLIA Now and Futures Prospects E.Enerelt, ADB June 6, 2014.
Carbon Business Office
Information Seminar on the Framework for Public Private Partnerships in Ireland Alexander Hotel, Dublin 3 rd June 2003.
 Cluster development as an approach to industrial development has been successful in countries like China, India, South Korea, Malaysia  In at least.
Local Governmental Debt, Fiscal Risks and Their Management Framework Liu Shangxi Research Institute for Fiscal Science, Ministry of Finance, PRC Disclaimer:
ADB Support for PPPs Qian Ying, Director and Craig Sugden, Principal PPP Specialist East Asia Regional Department Disclaimer: The views expressed in this.
Development and Transfer of Technologies UNFCCC Expert Workshop On Technology Information Technology Transfer Network and Matchmaking Systems: a LA & C.
Integrating BIC Reforms into the PRSP in Malawi Johannesburg, 25th May 2006 Angela N. Zeleza, Economist Joana Henseler, Economic Advisor Ministry of Economic.
ADB’s SME Development Assistance Presentation by: Neil Wallace Senior Financial Management Specialist Asian Development Bank 28 October 2009.
Financing for Development United Nations Risk Mitigation for Mobilizing Private Sector Investments in Infrastructure in Developing Countries Pradeep Singh.
Demand-Side Financing : International Experience Harry Anthony Patrinos World Bank Government and Non-Government Participation.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Asian Development.
Public Private Partnerships (PPPs) and The World Bank
Strategic Opportunities for TVET: Experience and Directions of ADB Support Sofia Shakil Senior Education Specialist East Asia Department, Asian Development.
18/10/2008PHD Task Force on Skill Development1 SKILL DEVELOPMENT Bridging Skills Deficit & Promoting Employability PHD Chamber Task Force on Skill Development.
PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP FOR CLEAN AIR CHINA GAS HOLDINGS LIMITED August 2013 Eric Leung Wing Cheong Deputy Managing Director Chief Financial Officer.
Seethapathy Chander Asian Development Bank Beijing, 25 November 2014 Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those of the author, and do not.
Kiichiro Fukasaku Development Centre
Public–Private Partnerships in Health Carmen Carpio Senior Operations Officer
The Role and Impact of Public-Private Partnerships in Education Harry Anthony Patrinos Felipe Barrera-Osorio Juliana Guaqueta The World Bank 2009.
Managing Risk in Financing Agriculture - Expert Meeting Johannesburg 1-3 April 2009 Synthesis of the Expert Meeting “Johannesburg Findings”
Ayumi Konishi Director General, East Asia Department Asian Development Bank CCICED Annual General Meeting 2015 Forum G20 and Green Finance 11 November.
CAI-Asia is building an air quality management community in Asia Investment Implications of the Action Plan Sustainable Urban.
Conference of State Secretaries on Skill Development : Bridging Skills Deficit & Promoting Employability Skill Development : Bridging Skills Deficit &
Mortgage Finance Opportunities and Challenges By Taimur Afzal, Chairman ASSOCIATION OF MORTGAGE BANKERS (AMB) March 25th
PPPs and Public Procurement
Albanian VET Strategy and Action Plan for the period
DIRECTION OF TVET POLICY IN LAO. PDR
Korean Experience with Skills for Economic Growth
ADB’s CORPORATE STRATEGY
The Government Role in BOT
Public-Private Partnership for Clean Air Municipal Natural Gas Distribution Infrastructure Development Projects Hisaka Kimura Principal Investment Specialist.
a. Financing b. Designing c. Construction d. Operating
Growth, Transformation and Poverty in the PRC and ASEAN
Financing PPP Projects
Rural Partnerships between Small Farmers and Private Sector
Seventh Regional Public Procurement Forum, May , 2011
Presentation transcript:

5th PRC-ADB Knowledge Sharing Platform Sustainable Vocational Training towards Industrial Upgrading and Economic Transformation Beijing and Guangzhou, People’s Republic of China 2-5 December, 2013 Michael Latham CFBT Principal International Consultant - Asia Disclaimer: The views expressed in this document are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Asian Development Bank (ADB), its Board of Directors, or the governments they represent. ADB does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this document, and accept no responsibility for any consequence of their use. By making any designation or reference to a particular territory or geographical area, or by using the term “country” in this document, ADB does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

Defining Public-Private Partnerships A PPP refers to a contractual arrangement between public (national, state, provincial, or local) and private entities through which the skills, assets, and/or financial resources of each of the public and private sectors are allocated in a complementary manner, thereby sharing the risks and rewards, to seek to provide optimal service delivery and good value to citizens. – Public-Private Partnership Operational Plan , ADB

Differs from traditional model of service delivery: PPP model = public financing + private delivery Compared to… Traditional model = public financing + public delivery

Key Elements of PPPs 1.Formal arrangement between public and private sector 2.Private delivery of public services 3.Public agency ultimately responsible for service delivery 4.Arrangement often based on explicit contract 5.Focus on outputs/outcomes, not inputs 6.Risk sharing between public and private sectors.

Potential Benefits/Risks of PPPs Benefits Efficiency Quality of service delivery Specialized skills Overcome public service operating restrictions rules Innovative service delivery Focus on comparative advantage Increased access, particu- larly for the poorly served Transparency Sustainability Risks Complex arrangements Require considerable design, implementation and monitoring capacity Inadequate regulatory environments Lack of competition in some markets Quality of service delivery

Classifying PPPs in TVET  PPPs widely used around the world at all levels of education  PPPs can involve private sector contributing to public sector and vice versa  Many different forms of PPP: –Industry linkages –Infrastructure PPPs –Demand-side financing initiatives –TVET support services

Classifying PPPs in TVET Industry LinkagesInfrastructure PPPs Demand-side Financing Support Services Curriculum/program development Student/job placement Staff exchanges Training of TVET instructors Applied research and consultancies Private representation on governing/advisory boards Centers of Excellence Private provision of equipment, land, staff, curriculum, etc Philanthropy Private finance, design, construction and operation of teaching facilities and workshops Equipping and maintenance of workshops Scholarships/training vouchers Incentives for private providers: free land, soft loans, subsidies, tax/ customs duty exemptions Introduce competitive contracting of course/ program delivery to private TVET institutes Private management of public TVET institutes Private involvement in TVET strategy development - eg. national training agencies Private quality assurance systems Standard setting Skill certification Private information and testing services

Examples of Education and Training PPPs TypeExamples Basic/Secondary EducationTVET Type 1: Service Delivery PPPs: Contracting for the Delivery of Education/Training Services Education Service Contracting, Philippines Foundation Assisted Schools, Pakistan Gyanodaya Senior Secondary Schools, India Promoting Private Schooling in Rural Sindh, Pakistan (World Bank Project) Skills Contracting Program, Lao PDR (ADB Project) Reform of Technical and Vocational Training, KSA Specialist Skills Contracting Program, Lao PDR (ADB Project) Basic/mid-level Skills Training Program, Nepal (ADB Project) Mid-Level Skills Training Project, Timor- Leste (ADB Project) Type 2: Private Management of Public Schools or Institutions Concession Schools, Colombia Independent Schools, Qatar Charter/Contract schools, USA Khazanah Trust Schools, Malaysia Partnership Schools, NZ Free Schools, UK Penang Skills Development Center, Malaysia (Hybrid)

Examples of Education and Training PPPs TypeExamples Basic/Secondary EducationTVET Type 3: Infrastructure PPPs Private Finance Initiative, UK PPPs for new school property, NZ Alberta Schools Alternative Procurement/New Schools Project, Alberta, Canada New Schools PPP, NSW, Australia PPP for School Infrastructure Project, Philippines Southbank Institute of Technology, Queensland, Australia ITE College West, Singapore Build-Transfer-Lease Program, South Korea Lao National Institute of Hospitality and Tourism, Lao PDR (Proposed) Type 4: Voucher or Subsidy Programs PACES Voucher program, Colombia Voucher scheme, Chile Voucher Scheme, Qatar Senior High School Voucher Program, Philippines (Proposed) Training Assistance Voucher Program, Lao PDR (ADB Project)

Challenges to Implementing PPPs in Education and Training –Traditional focus on infrastructure –Government resistance to private sector/PPPs –Procurement issues - contracting –Modality and project time horizon –Bankability of the potential projects –Lack of appropriate Policy frameworks –Need for incentives that support innovation –Awareness/experience in designing and implementing PPPs –Need for ‘advisory’ work

Conclusion – 1 Different Types Perception that PPPs only relevant to infrastructure and ‘hard‘ infrastructure – eg. roads, energy Not so: ‒ Various types of PPPs – service delivery, management contracts, vouchers, ancillary services ‒ Education PPPs are significant in infrastructure space:  In 2008, educational facilities made up 47.6% of signed deals/37% of value of signed deals in Republic of Korea  In 2012, the education sector was third largest in terms of value of signed deals under UK PFI program (£7.7 B)  In 2012, education was first in terms of deals and second in terms of deal value in Europe

Conclusion – 2 PPPs in TVET PPPs are generally well suited to the TVET sector because: ‒ Relatively stable/predictable demand growth ‒ Large and growing private sector in many countries ‒ Relatively short project lead times ‒ Less technically complex infrastructure than other sectors ‒ Seasonal nature of business operation ‒ Fewer safeguard/land clearance issues

Conclusion – 3 Summary 1.Many potential PPP models 2.Context important – country governance, financial management/administrative capacity, size and nature of non-government sector, fiscal situation, etc 3.Not a panacea 4.PPPs do not mean government shirking its responsibilities – different policy tools 5.Good design, regulation and implementation are critical