Entrepreneurship and Public Policy Lecture 7: Three Examples of Regulation: Environmental, Labor Market, and Workplace Safety Regulation.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Businesses, Workers, and the Law
Advertisements

Capitalism and Free Enterprise
Taxes & Government Regulations
Law I Chapter 18.
Nearly 50 American workers are injured every minute of the 40-hour work week and almost 17 die each day (OSHA) In 2003: 111 million workers at 7 million.
Employment Law and Ethics Marketing Dynamics Copyright © Texas Education Agency, All rights reserved.
ECONOMIC EVALUATION OF POLLUTION PREVENTION PROJECTS CHAPTER 11.
Prentice Hall © PowerPoint Slides to accompany THE LEGAL ENVIRONMENT OF BUSINESS AND ONLINE COMMERCE 5E, by Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 20 Employment.
New HR Challenges in the Dynamic Environment of Legal Compliance By Teri J. Elkins.
1 REGULATION (B) When/Where Government Regulation of Business is Justified (produce benefits in excess of costs) in a Market Economy.
Equal Employment Opportunity Principles of Discrimination Law.
Legal Issues in HR OS352 HRM Fisher Sept. 4, 2003.
Workplace Safety and Health Program
Entrepreneurship and Public Policy Lecture 8: The Implications of the U.S. Health Insurance System for Entrepreneurship.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 31 Employment and Worker Protection Laws.
This material was developed by Compacion Foundation Inc and The Hispanic Contractors Association de Tejas under Susan Harwood Grant Number SH SH0.
Safety and Health Programs
Environmental Health Unit: Lesson 1 - Introduction Objective: TSWBAT identify issues of how the environment affects our personal health on a daily basis.
OSHA Long Term Care Worker Protection Train the Trainer Program Part 1: Introduction.
Chapter 18.  Criminal Law: crime against the state  Civil Law: person commits a wrong, not always a violation of law  Plaintiff-the harmed individual,
LEGAL ASPECTS OF INDUSTRIAL HYGIENE. Industrial Hygiene  The science and art devoted to the anticipation, recognition, evaluation, control and management.
Chapter 3- American Free Enterprise
CHAPTER 22 Employment Law
Copyright © 2004 by Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved. PowerPoint Slides to Accompany BUSINESS LAW E-Commerce and Digital Law International Law and Ethics.
24 Legal and Ethical Considerations. 24 Legal and Ethical Considerations.
Objective 3.01 Understand employment law
Alternative policy approaches Environmental standards Standard allowable levels of various pollutants are established by legislation or regulatory action.
1. 2 Creating an Agency Relationship Agency is a relationship in which the agent agrees to perform a task for, and under the control of, the principal.
Chapter 25 Employment - Related Injuries I. Requiring A Safe Workplace A.Occupational Safety & Health Administration Act of 1970 (OSHA)-prevent injuries.
Providing Equal Employment Opportunity and a Safe Workplace
Chapter 12 Workplace Legal MattersSucceeding in the World of Work Laws About the Workplace 12.1 SECTION OPENER / CLOSER INSERT BOOK COVER ART Section 12.1.
Hospitality Operations Objective 4.02 – Human Resources.
Misc. Employment Law Agency Law Energy & Environmental.
Environmental Health and Safety (EH&S) Supplier Awareness Training ISR Systems Danbury, CT 2011.
Employment-Related Injuries Chapter 24. OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration Primary representative of protective agencies Primary representative.
Occupational Safety & Health The nature & extent of workplace safety and health problems The organization and functions of OSHA Accident behavior Safety.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 7-1 Defining Competitiveness Chapter 7.
Entrepreneurship and Public Policy Lecture 4: Role of Regulation in Entrepreneurship Public Policy.
Ch 14 Managing Human Resources in Organization
 A market economy is based on capitalism, a system in which private citizens own the factors of production.  Capitalism thrives on competition, the.
Unit 8 Special Topics in Emergency Service Occupational Safety and Health Chapter 13.
Special Topics in Emergency Service Occupational Safety and Health 13-1 Chapter 13.
Essentials Of Business Law Chapter 28 Employment Law McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2007 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Chapter Outline 16.1Overview Of Workers’ Compensation Laws 16.2.Workers’ Compensation Benefits Medical Benefits Disability Benefits Total Disability Benefits.
Legal UNIT B HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT 4.01 Summarize labor laws and regulations that affect employees and management.
Regulation and Antitrust: The Role of Government in the Economy
Regulatory Administrative Institutions MPA-517 Lecture-4 1.
Environmental Protection and Workplace Diversity Job.
Human Resources: Objectives 1. Describe work environment of desired career positions 2. Relate environments to hiring policies and procedures. 3. Describe.
Preventive Emergency Planning Emergency Plans should focus not just on response but on reducing risk Emergency Planning that focuses on risk should consider.
Understand responsible actions for conducting business. 1.
 Safety- protecting employees from injuries caused by work- related accidents  Health- employees’ freedom from physical or emotional illness.
Rulemaking Part III. 2 Executive Orders Regulating Rulemaking What is the president's authority over rulemaking? What about for independent agencies?
Introduction to OSHA (Part 1)
Chapter 12 Employment Relationships and Labor Law Copyright © 2015 McGraw-Hill Education. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without.
Section 15.2 Employee Rights. Section 15.2 Employment Rights The government has passed laws to protect the rights of employees to: health and safety fair.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin © 2005 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. 7-1 Defining Competitiveness Chapter 7.
© 2010 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice-Hall 1 EMPLOYMENT, WORKER PROTECTION, AND IMMIGRATION LAWS © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc., publishing.
THE OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ACT Brendon Clair.
Laws Relating to Employment Conditions and Benefits Section 21.1.
© 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved Employment Law: New Challenges in the Business Environment, 5e Moran Chapter 20 Occupational Safety.
TORTS: A CIVIL WRONG Chapter 18. TORTS: A CIVIL WRONG Under criminal law, wrongs committed are called crimes. Under civil law, wrongs committed are called.
Presentation Pro © 2001 by Prentice Hall, Inc. Economics: Principles in Action C H A P T E R 3 American Free Enterprise.
Chapter 7 Employment Law Halsey/McLaughlin, Legal Environment You will be able to answer the following questions after reading this chapter: What is an.
Archie B. Carroll Ann K. Buchholtz
Chapter 5 Workers and The Law Chapter 5.2.
Introduction to OSHA (Part 1)
Legal and Regulatory Risk
Modern Economies In this lesson, students will identify characteristics of modern economies. Students will be able to define and/or identify the following.
Laws Relating to Employment Conditions & Benefits
Presentation transcript:

Entrepreneurship and Public Policy Lecture 7: Three Examples of Regulation: Environmental, Labor Market, and Workplace Safety Regulation

EPP – Lecture 7 -2 Spring 2009 In This Lecture, We Review the Following Questions in Three Substantive Regulatory Areas What concerns drive regulation in this area? How does the regulatory environment distinguish between large and small firms? How have regulatory policies affected small businesses? Do small firms respond differently to regulation?

EPP – Lecture 7 -3 Spring 2009 Lecture Overview Area 1: Environmental regulations Area 2: Labor market regulations Area 3: Workplace safety regulation

EPP – Lecture 7 -4 Spring 2009 Focus of the Environmental Regulations Environmental regulations attempt to reduce the negative effects of manufacturing on environment and people’s health –For example, without regulations firms would overpollute (negative externality) Historically regulations targeted large polluters, but over time smaller firms have attracted attention too

EPP – Lecture 7 -5 Spring 2009 Components of the Regulatory System Surrounding Environmental Protection Regulation Enforcement –Government enforcement mechanisms –Liability or citizen enforcement mechanisms

EPP – Lecture 7 -6 Spring 2009 Environmental Regulations Often Impose Different Requirements on Firms of Different Sizes Small firms are rarely exempt from the overall regulation, but may be exempt from certain requirements Over 50 regulations are tiered based on either firm size or the amount of pollution released (SBA, 1995) Small firms may be required to meet less stringent emission or treatment technology standards Small firms may be relieved from some paperwork requirements

EPP – Lecture 7 -7 Spring 2009 Other Regulatory Characteristics May Create Disadvantages for Small Firms Grandfathering provisions allow older firms to postpone compliance Large firms may have possibility to tailor regulations to their experiences and capabilities (regulatory capture)

EPP – Lecture 7 -8 Spring 2009 It May Be Costly for Small Firms to Comply with Environmental Regulations Relative cost of compliance may be higher for small firm than for large firms –Pollution reducing equipment may increase the minimum scale of production –Economies of scale in discovering and understanding environmental regulations and in complying with required paperwork Evidence on the role of regulatory interventions on the minimum efficient size of a plant is mixed –Some firms found ways to convert environmental regulations into competitive advantage (save inputs so input production costs go down) –More costly to enter the industry since firms may learn over time about more efficient compliance

EPP – Lecture 7 -9 Spring 2009 There May Be Asymmetries in Enforcement among Small and Large Firms Limited enforcement budgets may cause agencies to focus enforcement efforts on large firms Large firms may be influential so that they directly or indirectly influence enforcement priorities Ultimate impact on large firms may be smaller if they can successfully defend themselves against legal action Environmental groups are more likely to target large firms (presumably because their concern about reputation will make them more likely to settle)

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Tort System is an Alternative to Active Regulatory Oversight Firms face liability for release of pollutants into the environment –Example: superfund program: imposes liability for the clean up of hazardous waste sites Small firms accounted for the majority of businesses potentially liable for clean up Regulation may allow citizens to bring enforcement action Liability based approach may be more effective for firms that have “deep pockets”

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 The Evidence About Combined Effect of Regulation on Small Firms Is Mixed May vary by industry and type of environmental regulation Compliance cost asymmetries that disadvantage small firms may be offset by statutory and enforcement asymmetries that favor them Some find that that environmental laws place larger burden on small manufacturing plants Large firms may benefit because less competition from small firms, as fewer small firms are entering the market No clear answer about differential impact on small versus large firms

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 There Are Many Areas for Future Research on Environmental Policymaking Since major environmental initiatives were formulated with large firms in mind, we need to understand whether a different approach to regulation is needed to deal with operations of small firms We know very little about the effect of trends in environmental regulation on small firms (I.e. voluntary enforcement agreements) What are the relative benefits and costs associated with regulation

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Lecture Overview Background on the regulation and entrepreneurship Area 1: Environmental regulations Area 2: Labor market regulations Area 3: Workplace safety regulation

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Employment Policies Regulate Relationships between Employers and Employees Regulation restricts ways in which businesses interact with prospective, current and former employees Addresses concerns that one party might intentionally or unintentionally impose harm on the other –Discrimination against certain groups of current, or potential employees that denies them access to jobs or fair wages –Hostile or unsafe work environment –Exercise of market power to drive down wages –Lost wages due to job loss, workplace injury –On employer side: loss form theft of intellectual property or a client base

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Size Threshold Often Used to Exempt Small Firms From Employment Regulations Examples of thresholds –Family and Medical Leave Plan (exempts firms with less than 50 workers) –Americans with Disabilities Act (15 workers) –Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (100 workers) –Occupational Safety and Health Act (11 workers) –Age Discrimination in Employment Act (20 workers) –Civil Rights Act of 1964 (15 workers) –Fair Labor Standards Act (2 workers) Employers that fall below the size threshold cannot be sued, fined, charged or otherwise reprimanded under the aegis if the law. These employers are not subject to record keeping associated with these laws

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Most Enforcement of Employment Regulation Happens through Court System An employee who believes that his or her employer has intentionally harmed him or her has the right to file a civil suit and seek damages from the employer Federal, state and local regulations increase the risk of litigation by giving a government agency the authority to investigate firm behavior –Equal Employment Opportunity Commission investigates employee complains against firms in the areas of antidiscrimination and may bring suits Employer may use the court system to enforce an employment agreement if an employee fails to live up to the terms of a contract

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Court Litigation May Depend on Firm Size Focus of court litigation may depend on the resources available to firms –Employees may be more likely to go after large firms with deep pockets –It is easier to identify statistical irregularities in large firms –On the other hand, larger firms may have stronger incentives to spend substantial resources on defense Difficult to establish who faces greater burden of litigation –Pendell and Hinton (2007) suggest that the legal costs per dollar of revenue are substantially greater for small businesses than they are for large businesses

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 More Research Is Needed Little empirical research that documents the effects of employment regulation in general and the effects on small businesses in particular Little evidence of the effectiveness of the exemption thresholds More careful consideration of unintended consequences of policy and regulation in the workplace is warranted The benefits of staying below a certain size threshold might induce some firms to limit growth

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Lecture Overview Background on the regulation and entrepreneurship Area 1: Environmental regulations Area 2: Labor market regulations Area 3: Workplace safety regulation

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Regulates Employers Safety standards –Falls, explosions, fires, cave-ins, machine and vehicle operations and maintenance Health standards –Exposure to health hazards through engineering controls and use of personal protective equipment

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Several Reasons to Expect the Risk of Injury to Be Higher at Small Firms Smaller firms may expect lower savings from preventing injuries, since there is little or no experience rating in workers compensation insurance More likely to employ high-risk workers Less likely to realize economies of scale Less likely to be inspected, reducing the marginal benefits of compliance

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 OSHA Regulatory Approach Considers Size of the Firm Exempts establishments with fewer than 11 workers from regular “programmed” inspections Considers firm size when assessing penalties for violating safety and health standards

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 KRI Research Highlights Opportunities for Improving the Regulatory Environment It has long been known that small establishments have higher fatality rates than larger establishments KRI research examined the distinction between small firms and small establishments to determine the role that firm size plays Study found that small, single-establishment firms have much lower fatality rates than small establishments that are part of larger firms This points to a need to distinguish between small firms and small establishments in policymaking and in research Also suggests that targeted regulatory enforcement might be useful

EPP – Lecture Spring 2009 Discussion: Example of Food Safety Regulation Reasons for regulations –What are the costs of regulations? –What are the benefits of regulations? –Do you think possibility of exempting small businesses in this industry is justified in terms of costs and benefits of regulation? Enforcement –What are the pros and cons of government enforcement of regulations? –What is the role of civil enforcement in uncovering the case? –Would this violation be uncovered in case of the small firm? Do firms have incentives to self-regulate and/or comply with regulation? Does it depend on firm size?