The Ongoing Negotiations on Agriculture: Some Observations

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
DOHA and the EU. Intro Trade of industrial goods Trade in services Trade in agricultural goods Trade and the Environement.
Advertisements

RISWTO Public Symposium1 World Trading System and Development: Issues and Challenges Nagesh Kumar RIS
RIS South Centre Panel at WTO Public Symposium 1 WTO, Development and Developing Countries: Ten Years After Nagesh Kumar RIS
WTO Symposium Geneva, May 2004 Trade, agriculture, and world poverty: Will the Doha Agenda deliver pro-development trade rules?
The Benefits of a New WTO Agreement for Agri-food Trade Shiferaw Adilu Alberta Agriculture and Food.
Non-Agricultural Market Access Pakistan Institute of Development Economics.
State of WTO Agricultural Negotiations Meeting on the Integrated Assessment of Trade Liberalization in the Agriculture Sector February 2003 Note:
The Multilateral Trading System: Opportunities and Challenges for the East African Community (EAC) Countries Anne Kamau Ministry of Trade Department of.
Twenty-Five Ways to Improve the Derbez Draft International Food and Agriculture Trade Policy Council
HEAD: Roberto Azevêdo (Director-General) WHEN : 1 st JANUARY 1995 WHERE : GENEVA,SWITZERLAND WITH : 159 MEMBER COUNTRIES, TAJAKISTAN INDUCTED IN MARCH.
WTO AGRICULTURAL NEGOTIATIONS Portfolio Committee Agriculture and Land Affairs April 2003 Günter Müller Directorate: International Trade National Department.
1 UNCTAD Virtual Institute Study Tour Course on Economics of Commodity Production and Trade Agriculture and the WTO Geneva, February 2010 United Nations.
WTO Agriculture Negotiations Outstanding Issues for Developing Countries Tim Ruffer Oxford Policy Management
Some aspects of the Doha work program Baku, Azerbaijan February 2015.
EU-LDC NETWORK CONFERENCE Trade and Poverty Reduction ISSUES FACING DEVELOPING COUNTRIES IN THE ONGOING WTO NEGOTIATIONS IN AGRICULTURE ’ ‘A POVERTY REDUCTION.
International Business 9e
Developing Countries and the Doha Round Agricultural Negotiations Lecture 29 Economics of Food Markets Alan Matthews.
The Doha Round – background and issues Lecture 25 The Economics of Food Markets Alan Matthews.
AGRICULTURAL POLICY REFORM IN THE WTO The Road Ahead.
What needs to be done to make Doha a Development Round? ATDN - Meeting, , Berlin Marita Wiggerthale Deutschland.
Intellectual Property Rights, Services and Trade Facilitation CARSTEN FINK African/LDCs Ambassadors Seminar on Post-Hong Kong Assessment of the Doha Round,
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL ENVIRONMENT and EXPORT CREDITS UPDATE
AUSTRALIA’S DOHA ROUND AGENDA. TODAY’S DISCUSSION  briefly, the WTO and Australia  what was decided at Doha  what has happened since Doha  Australia’s.
May19,2005 NAPC_TPD by: Mahmoud Babili1 Multilateral trade negotiations and Agricultural policies in the developed economies.
Trade Remedy Laws and Agriculture Anita Regmi David Skully 1 Paper presented at the Free Trade Area of the Americas, The WTO, and New Farm Legislation:
WTO Agreement on Agriculture: What’s it all about? What should be our advocacy?
DOHA DEVELOPMENT AGENDA. BACKGROUND Doha Ministerial Conference 2001  Background: Seattle, Millennium Round Ambitions, limits of Built-in-Agenda  Doha.
The WTO negotiations: Will developing countries benefit from a new agreement?
Negotiations on Agriculture State of Play by Surabhi Mittal WTO &The Doha Round : The Way Forward 6-7 April, 2006.
Options for Modalities and Treatment of Special Products.
IPC Seminar Multilateral Trade Negotiations: Update on The Doha Development Round MARCELO REGUNAGA Hanoi – October 2005.
One law firm around the world One law firm around the world Status of GATS Negotiations David Hartridge Hanoi, Vietnam August 5, 2003.
The Draft SADC Annex on Trade in Services UNCTAD Secretariat Sub-regional Conference on Improving Industrial Performance and Promoting Employment in SADC.
Seminar on: The WTO Doha Development Agenda Dr. Kui-Wai Li APEC Study Center City University of Hong Kong November 2, 2005 Economism is a Paradigm of “More.
POSSIBLE MODALITIES FOR THE SPECIAL SAFEGUARD MECHANISM (SSM) By: Raul Q. Montemayor National Business Manager Federation of Free Farmers Cooperatives,
1 Tariff Liberalisation Under SAFTA An Indian Perspective By Pranav Kumar CUTS International Jaipur
1 GATS & the Doha Agenda Negotiations on Services State of Play.
The Doha round of WTO talks Waqas Latif BBA(Hons) Osama Qadri BBA(Hons) Mohammad Ali Jinnah University.
UNCTAD 1 OVERVIEW OF THE DOHA WORK PROGRAMME ISSUES TO BE CONSIDERED BY DEVELOPING COUNTRIES Commercial Diplomacy Programme UNCTAD
The Doha Development Agenda: Issues of Process and Substance Parr Rosson Texas Cooperative Extension Texas A&M University System American Agricultural.
1 Overview of the Doha Work Programme Implications for the Developing Countries Commercial Diplomacy Programme UNCTADWWW.UNCTAD.ORG/COMMDIP December 2001.
DOHA NEGOTIATING AGENDA Update on State of Play and Developing South Africa’s Negotiating Position.
ACHIEVING AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT THROUGH AGRICULTURAL TRADE What do Developing Countries Need From Trade Negotiations? By Percy W. Misika 29 February.
WORKSHOP ON MARKET ACCESS IN THE DOHA WORK PROGRAMME Ministry of Foreign Trade & International Cooperation and UNCTAD Guyana, September 2002 WTO NEGOTIATIONS.
Vietnamese Perpective On Poverty Alleviation Through Aquaculture Export Development Lam Quoc Tuan Asia Trade Initiative NACA AquaMarkets 2003 Accessing.
Agriculture Negotiations: Moving Forward Ashok Gulati IFPRI Director in Asia WTO and The Doha Round: The Way forward ICRIER-SRTT Conference 6-7 April,
DEPARTMENT: AGRICULTURE AGRICULTURAL TRADE NEGOTIATIONS GERDA VAN DIJK SENIOR MANAGER: INTERNATIONAL TRADE PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE FOR AGRICULTURE 22 FEBRUARY.
1 DOHA WORK PROGRAMME CURRENT SITUATION AND ISSUES FOR PAKISTAN Presentation at the EC-Pakistan TRTA Seminar at Islamabad By Dr. Manzoor Ahmad Ambassador.
SERVICES NEGOTIATIONS Said EL HACHIMI World Trade Organization.
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT TOTAL (trillion $) PER CAPITA ($/person) WORLD37.07,600 U.S ,300 France1.525,400 Spain0.818,900.
1 Development Dimension in July Package : Concerns of South Asia Posh Raj Pandey CUTS, New Delhi 17 September 2005.
The Aid for Trade Agenda Ivan Mbirimi Economic Adviser Commonwealth Secretariat Commonwealth Secretariat/TRALAC Meeting on Post-Hong Kong Issues Cape Town,
Economic Environment of Business International Trade. GATT and the WTO.
An overview of the Doha Development Agenda CARSTEN FINK Trade Policy and WTO Accession A Training of Trainers Course for Russia and the CIS March 22, 2006.
WTO Status of Negotiation, July 2004 Framework... and Beyond Debra Henke USDA/ Foreign Agricultural Service.
UNCTAD/CD-TFT 1 Commercial Diplomacy & TrainForTradeModule 11 Important Issues to be considered by Policy Makers and Trade Negotiators Issues concerning.
Twenty-Five Ways to Improve the Derbez Draft International Food and Agriculture Trade Policy Council
WTO Hong Kong Ministerial Gains & Losses for India Pradeep S. Mehta CUTS International Jaipur, India
Update on Multilateral Trade Negotiations “The July Package” PRESENTATION TO SELECT COMMITTEE 09 November 2004.
Non-agricultural market access negotiations Marc Bacchetta ERSD WTO.
WTO Doha Round: Status and Issues Stephen Censky, American Soybean Association International Oilseed Producers Dialogue XI Meeting Berlin, Germany June.
Multilateral Trade Negotiations: Update on The Doha Development Round A European Perspective Dr Rolf Moehler.
INTERNATIONAL TRADE POLICY
International Economics
WTO’s Doha Development Agenda and South Asian Agriculture
INTERNATIONAL TRADE POLICY
MGT601 SME MANAGEMENT.
The EU-US Agricultural Framework Agreement
Status of GATS Negotiations
The Doha Development Agenda: Issues of Process and Substance
Presentation transcript:

The Ongoing Negotiations on Agriculture: Some Observations Parthapratim Pal TERI

Difference in Role of Agriculture in Developed and Developing Countries

The Objective of AoA Given these problems, it was felt before the Uruguay Round that there was an: “urgent need to bring more discipline and predictability to world agricultural trade by correcting and preventing restrictions and distortions including those related to structural surpluses so as to reduce the uncertainty, imbalance and instability in world agricultural markets.” Ministerial Declaration launching the Uruguay Round.

The focus of the Agreement are on three broad areas. They are: With these objectives, the AoA intended to bring agricultural trade under the disciplines of a multilateral trading system by: Reforming trade in agricultural sector. Making policies more market-oriented. Reducing the distortion present in the agricultural trade sector by substantial and progressive reductions in agricultural support and protection. The focus of the Agreement are on three broad areas. They are: Market Access Domestic Subsidies Export Subsidies

Experience with UR AoA…Agriculture has remained a distorted sector Explicit non-tariff barriers were removed in most cases. However, tariff remained very high, World average agricultural tariff is around 60%, while average industrial tariff is less than 8%. Also tariff peaks and tariff escalation is widespread in agriculture. Increasingly other WTO measures like SPS and Anti-dumping are used as protectionist tools by many countries. Most importantly, there has been no meaningful reduction of subsidies Price volatility in agriculture has not declined for most crops

Share of Developing Countries in World Agricultural Exports by Region, 1990-2003(Percentage)   1990 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 All Developing Countries 39 39½ 40 41½ 42 41 of which: Africa 6 5½ 5 4½ Developing Asia 15 16½ 16 15½ Latin America and the Caribbean 17½ 18 17 Middle East 2 2½ Source: WTO Secretariat, TN/AG/S/19

Movement of Price Indices During the WTO Implementation Period

Volatility of International Commodity Prices

Some Interesting Figures from FAO

Food Security Map of India Source: (MSRF)

Special Products ‘Special Products’ (SPs) can be defined as ‘agricultural products of particular importance to farming communities in developing countries for reasons of food security, livelihood security and rural development’ SPs will attract lower level of tariff reduction commitment than other agricultural products. Special Products is a component of WTO’s Special & Differential (S&D) provision Special Products should not be confused with ‘Sensitive Products’

Why do we need Special Products? Role of Agriculture in developed and developing countries are different An open trade regime may threaten food and livelihood security because: Secular decline in commodity prices Increased Volatility It was realized during the Uruguay Round that free trade regime may not contribute to food security and self-sufficiency in food is important. Supply uncertainty, Thin market Argument Foreign exchange constraint Political economy of food dependence

Special Safeguard Mechanisms Special Safeguard Mechanisms or SSMs are a set of provisions through which a WTO Member country can temporarily impose higher than bound tariff rate on the import of a particular product if there is a surge of import or a sudden dip in import price of that product. A similar provision called the ‘Special Safeguards’ (SSG) was available in the Uruguay Round AoA but only a handful of WTO Members (39 out of 149) were given the right to use it. The new SSM provisions will be available to all developing and least developed country Members of WTO.

Why SSMs? To tackle the international price volatility of agricultural commodities-surges in imports can threaten (otherwise viable) domestic production base In a tariff only regime, international price volatility gets directly transmitted to domestic markets Agricultural Market Access Negotiations will lead to lowering of the tariff overhang (the gap between bound and applied tariff rates). No other form of safeguards available.

Some Questions Remain Country Eligibility? Product Eligibility? Linkage with Special Products, Sensitive Products? Proof of Injury Requirement? Should SSM be only Tariff based or can QRs be temporarily imposed? Possible loopholes and need for additional domestic regulations

SP and SSM: Final Thoughts Both Special Products (SP) and Special Safeguard Mechanism (SSM) are useful defensive mechanisms. However, a lot will depend on the details. Developing countries must ensure that developed countries do not use these concessions to lower the level of ambition of agricultural negotiations It must be kept in mind that these instruments cannot be used against imports from Regional trading partners.

Key dates Mentioned in the Doha declaration Formulas and other “modalities” for countries’ commitments: by 31 March 2003 Countries’ comprehensive draft commitments: by 5th Ministerial Conference, 10-14 September 2003 (in Cancún, Mexico) Stock taking: 5th Ministerial Conference, 10-14 September 2003 (in Cancún, Mexico) Deadline: by 1 January 2005, part of single undertaking.

The Actual Progress Article 20 Negotiations The Doha Development Round In Search for the still elusive MODALITIES Text: Original deadline was 31st March 2003 - Missed The Harbinson’s Text (March 2003) -Rejected The Derbez Text (September 2003) - Rejected The July Framework- July 2004 – BREAKTHROUGH “July Approximation” (July 2005) - Failure Hong Kong –December 2005 –Limited Progress April 2006- New Deadline for Modalities - Missed

Final Words Negotiations on agriculture moving very slowly, the HK Ministerial is a Modest Success: Small Defensive Gains and No Major Losses. But the hard bargaining begins now Developing Countries must link tariff reduction to subsidy reduction The G20 Initiative is a Key Movement. It is important that they stand together Two Key Questions : Should we be defensive or aggressive? India’s negotiating strategy- Running with the hare and hunting with the hounds? Finally, bigger threat to Indian agriculture seems to be coming from Regional trading Agreements rather than WTO Agreement on Agriculture.