IHY Conference “The Sun, the Heliosphere, and the Earth” Bad Honnef, May 14-18 2007 HELIOSEISMOLOGY Maria Pia Di Mauro INAF- Istituto di Astrofisica Spaziale.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 The Sun as a whole: Rotation, Meridional circulation, and Convection Michael Thompson High Altitude Observatory, National Center for Atmospheric Research.
Advertisements

Our Star, the Sun Chapter Eighteen.
Solar-like Oscillations in Red Giant Stars Olga Moreira BAG.
Probing the Sun in 3D Karen Harvey Prize Lecture Boulder 2009 Laurent Gizon Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, & Goettingen University, Germany.
1 B. Klecker Max-Planck-Institut für extraterrestrische Physik, Garching, Germany Kennebunkport, MN June 9, 2010 SOHO OVERVIEW.
Prospects for asteroseismology of solar-like stars T. Appourchaux Institut d’Astrophysique Spatiale, Orsay.
Are inputs to standard solar models correct? OR The problem with solar abundances Sarbani Basu Yale Univesity.
Observational properties of pulsating subdwarf B stars. Mike Reed Missouri State University With help from many, including Andrzej Baran, Staszek Zola,
Exoplanet- Asteroseismology Synergies Bill Chaplin, School of Physics & Astronomy University of Birmingham, UK EAHS2012, Oxford, 2012 March 15.
Seismology of the Sun and solar-like stars Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard Institut for Fysik og Astronomi, Aarhus Universitet.
Solar Convection Simulations Bob Stein David Benson.
Spectrum Estimation in Helioseismology P.B. Stark Department of Statistics University of California Berkeley CA
Physics 681: Solar Physics and Instrumentation – Lecture 20 Carsten Denker NJIT Physics Department Center for Solar–Terrestrial Research.
Properties of stars during hydrogen burning Hydrogen burning is first major hydrostatic burning phase of a star: Hydrostatic equilibrium: a fluid element.
Helioseismic Magnetic Imager and Why We Study Helioseismology Junwei Zhao W. W. Hansen Experimental Physics Laboratory, Stanford University, Stanford,
Equation-of-State Challenges Werner Däppen University of Southern California Los Angeles.
ASTEROSEISMOLOGY CoRoT session, January 13, 2007 Jadwiga Daszyńska-Daszkiewicz Instytut Astronomiczny, Uniwersytet Wrocławski.
Inversion of rotation profile for solar-like stars Jérémie Lochard IAS 19/11/04.
1.B – Solar Dynamo 1.C – Global Circulation 1.D – Irradiance Sources 1.H – Far-side Imaging 1.F – Solar Subsurface Weather 1.E – Coronal Magnetic Field.
Are recent solar heavy element abundances consistent with helioseismology? Sarbani Basu H.M. Antia.
The Sun By: Tori and Caitlin. SHINNING STAR The Sun is the star at the center of the Solar System. It has a diameter of about 1,392,000 km, about 109.
The Sun’s internal rotation Michael Thompson University of Sheffield
Comparing solar internal rotation results from MDI and GONG R. Howe 1, J. Christensen-Dalsgaard 2, F. Hill 1, R. W. Komm 1, J. Schou 3, M. J. Thompson.
An Introduction to Helioseismology (Local) 2008 Solar Physics Summer School June 16-20, Sacramento Peak Observatory, Sunspot, NM.
Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College1. Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College2 Doppler/ Sunspots/ Interior.
Solar Physics & upper-Atmosphere Research Group University of Sheffield Linear and non-linear waves and oscillations L1: Examples for waves Robert von.
Future of asteroseismology II Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard Institut for Fysik og Astronomi, Aarhus Universitet Dansk AsteroSeismologisk Center.
Scientific aspects of SONG Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard Department of Physics and Astronomy Aarhus University.
Limits on Solar CNO From Session 13 IAU - XXVIII GA Aldo Serenelli Institute of Space Sciences (CSIC-IEEC) Bellaterra, Spain Beijing.
Meridional Circulation from ring-diagram analysis Irene González Hernández and the GONG++ team National Solar Observatory Tucson, Arizona.
Supergranulation Waves in the Subsurface Shear Layer Cristina Green Alexander Kosovichev Stanford University.
Our Star, the Sun Chapter Eighteen. The Sun’s energy is generated by thermonuclear reactions in its core The energy released in a nuclear reaction corresponds.
Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College1. Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College2 Solar Interior/ Nuclear Fusion.
Variations in rotation rate within the solar convection zone from GONG and MDI R. Howe 1, J. Christensen-Dalsgaard 2, F. Hill 1, R.W. Komm 1,
An Introduction to Helioseismology (Global) 2008 Solar Physics Summer School June 16-20, Sacramento Peak Observatory, Sunspot, NM.
Imaging Solar Tachocline Using Numerical Simulations and SOHO/MDI Data Junwei Zhao 1, Thomas Hartlep 2, Alexander G. Kosovichev 1, Nagi N. Mansour 2 1.W.W.Hansen.
Travis Metcalfe (NCAR) Asteroseismology with the Kepler Mission We are the stars which sing, We sing with our light; We are the birds of fire, We fly over.
Rabello-Soares, Bogart & Scherrer (2013): Comparison of a quiet tile with a nearby active region (5 o to 8 o away) with a quiet tile with no nearby.
The Sun as a whole: activity as seen by helioseismology
1 Global Helioseismology 2: Results Rachel Howe, NSO.
Flows in the Solar Convection Zone David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National Space Science and Technology Center 2004 July 21 David Hathaway NASA/MSFC National.
Global Helioseismology NSO/LPL Summer School June 11-15, 2007
Asteroseismology A brief Introduction
Jim Fuller Caltech/KITP ACOUSTIC OSCILLATIONS IN RED GIANTS.
台灣清華大學, 物理系 Helioseismology (II) Global and Local Helioseismology ( , 北京 ) 周定一 Dean-Yi Chou.
The Sun. Heat Transport in the Sun Conduction Convection Radiative Diffusion.
Solar Modeling Sabatino Sofia Department of Astronomy Yale University New Haven, CT, USA.
The Sun as whole: activity as seen by helioseismology A.C. Birch (Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research)
Rachel Howe.  Why do we need to continue observing?  Why ground-based?  Requirements for a new network.
1. Short Introduction 1.1 Overview of helioseismology results and prospects.
Flows and Cycles Large scale flows and stellar magnetic cycles Markus Roth Wiebke Herzberg René Kiefer Ariane Schad Guy Davis (UoB) Retreat of the Stellar.
Thomas Hackman: Stellar differential rotation1 Detecting stellar differential rotation NORDITA – Solar and stellar dynamo cycles Thomas Hackman,
Inferred rotation rate. Fits to tachocline Kosovichev fit Kosovichev (1996; ApJ 469, L61)
Universe Tenth Edition Chapter 16 Our Star, the Sun Roger Freedman Robert Geller William Kaufmann III.
Seismic Probing of the Dynamics of the Solar Interior Michael Thompson University of Sheffield.
Differential Rotation of coronal BP and Source Region of their Magnetic Fields H. Hara NAOJ 2011 Jun 29 Leverhulme – Probe the Sun 1 st Workshop at MSSL.
Helioseismology for HMI Science objectives and tasks* Data analysis plan* Helioseismology working groups and meetings *HMI Concept Study Report, Appendix.
Rachel Howe.  Rotation profile  Rotation changes over the solar cycle  The torsional oscillation  Tachocline fluctuations  Frequency and parameter.
Helioseismology Jørgen Christensen-Dalsgaard
From temporal spectra to stellar interiors (and back)
Asteroseismology of Kepler
SUN COURSE - SLIDE SHOW 7 Today: waves.
Bell Ringer The outer layer of the Sun’s atmosphere is actually hotter than the interior of the Sun. Explain why you believe this is so.
HMI Investigation Overview
Introduction to Space Weather
Charles Hakes Fort Lewis College 1.
Helioseismology Solar 5 min oscillations Discrete frequencies
Theory of solar and stellar oscillations - I
Forward Modeling for Time-Distance Helioseismology
The Centre of the Solar System Earth Science 11
Presentation transcript:

IHY Conference “The Sun, the Heliosphere, and the Earth” Bad Honnef, May HELIOSEISMOLOGY Maria Pia Di Mauro INAF- Istituto di Astrofisica Spaziale e Fisica Cosmica Rome (Italy)

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May The story..... Periodic Motions P  5 min of the absorption lines of the photospheric spectrum (Leighton et al. 1962) PULSATIONS OF THE PHOTOSPHERE!!!

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Normal Modes Acoustic waves trapped in resonant cavities  p modes Normal modes n radial order l harmonic degree mazimuthal order (Ulrich 1971, Leibacher & Stein 1972)

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May The proof Deubner 1975

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May One Million of indipendent modes excited. Each mode with a different tone!! These data from the SOI/MDI instrument on board the SOHO satellite 1024x1024 points over visible disk 1-minute cadence or better These data from the SOI/MDI instrument on board the SOHO satellite 1024x1024 points over visible disk 1-minute cadence or better Patches of the solar surface oscillate up and down

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Mode trapping Eigenfunction oscillates as function of r when

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Properties of solar oscillations   Modes are excited stochastically by convection   Periods « τ th  adiabatic approximation   Modes are damped by convective flux and turbulent pressure perturbations   Amplitude  low v r  15 cm/s  <  I  I  10 -6

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Helioseismology Study of oscillations in the Sun in a similar way as geoseismology is the study of earthquakes Study of the solar oscillations observed at the surface to probe the structure and the dynamics of the Sun The technique is very similar to trying to determine the shape of musical instruments from the sound they make.

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Why helioseismology?   Frequencies depend on the structure of the star  (r), p(r),   (r), c(r) but only 2 independent functions: e.g.  (r) and c(r)   Frequencies can be measured with accuracy (10 -5)   Basic physics addressed -Equation of state, opacities, neutrinos, general relativity, fluid dynamics   Stellar physics addressed -Stellar evolution, differential rotation, origin of solar magnetism, nature of spatial and temporal inhomogeneitities   Solar-terrestrial physics addressed -Origin of magnetic storms

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Local Helioseismology Structure and dynamics of pieces of the solar interior & changes with time Travel time of running sound waves Helioseismic Methods Global Helioseismology Structure & dynamics of the longitudinally averaged solar interior & changes with time Frequencies of p modes

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Notable Successes of Helioseismology   Depth of the solar convection zone (Christensen-Dalsgaard 1985)   Opacity   Neutrino Problem   Diffusion of helium and heavy elements (Basu et al. 1996)   Helium abundance   Relativistic effect in the core (Elliot & Kosovichev 1998)   Internal Dynamics

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May HELIOSEISMIC APPROACHES ModelObservables Forward approach Inverse approach Aim of inversion: to make inferences about localized properties of the solar interior

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Forward Approach: Comparison MDI l<1000 (Rhodes et al. 1998) and Model S

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May ACTUAL SOUND-SPEED DIFFERENCE SUN-MODEL S

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Turbulent diffusion Christensen-Dalsgaard & Di Mauro 2007 in press

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May New solar surface abundances Asplund et al. (2004 A&A 417, 751) Improvements:   Non-LTE analysis   3D atmosphere models Montalban et al Grevesse & Noels 1993 Unfortunately this model has a too small CZ and lower He abundance than inferred one!!

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May RELATIVE DENSITY DIFFERENCES SUN-MODEL S

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May EQUATION OF STATE First adiabatic exponent  1  5/3 in the interior except in the H and He ionization zones   MHD (Mihalas, Däppen & Hummer 1990)- chemical picture Pressure ionization (Partition equation) NonRelativistic Electron degeneracy Excited states Coulomb correction in the Debye-Hückel approximation   OPAL (Rogers, Swenson & Iglesias 1996) - physical picture Pressure ionization Relativistic Electron degeneracy(OPAL2001) Excited states Partition equation and degree of ionization Coulomb correction (many-body quantum physics) Electron exchange Quantum diffraction

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May EOS in the interior Inversion of data with l  100 Di Mauro & Christensen-Dalsgaard 2001

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May EOS in the surface Difference between SUN and Model S MDI data l <1000

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May HELIUM ABUNDANCE IN CZ G GY cannot be directly obtained by spectroscopy G GY by solar Models matching L  Y  Now: Helioseismic inversions REFERENCEDATA Y MHDY OPAL Basu & Antia (1995) HLH 100  l    Kosovichev (1996) BBSO 4  l    Richard et al. (1998) MDI 0  l    Basu (1998)MDI l    Di Mauro et al. (2002) MDI l   

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Internal Rotation Di Mauro et al. 1998Howe et al r c /R = / (Di Mauro et al 1997) tachocline Rotation breaks spherical simmetry of the Sun and splits the frequency of oscillations

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May The Solar Cycle  Activity grows and decays over 11 years  Zones of magnetic activity move towards the equator  Bands of slower and faster rotation also migrate, ahead of the magnetic bands Deviations from the mean rotation profile as a function of latitude and time Howe et al. 2000

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Differences between inversions of data taken at successive times reveal the “torsional oscillation” MDI OLA 0.99 R0.95 R 0.90 R 0.84 R TORSIONAL OSCILLATIONS

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Torsional oscillations of whole CZ Differencing rotation inversions at successive 72-day epochs relative to solar minimum (1996) shows equatorward and poleward migration of torsional oscillations Vorontsov et al Science

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Tachocline Oscillations Howe 2006 The rotation rate appears to show quasi-periodic oscillations of 1.3 year period near the base of the convection zone at mid-latitudes

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May ROTATION IN THE CORE MDI l < 100 (Schou et al. 1998)+   IRIS l=1-3 (Lazreck et al. 1996; Gizon et al 1997, Fossat 1998)   GONG l=1-3 (Gavryuseva & Gavryuseva 1998)   BISON +LOWL l=1-4 (Chaplin et al. 1999)   GOLF l=1-2 (Corbard et al. 1998) Di Mauro et al. 1998

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Solar Gravity Modes detected with GOLF!!! Garcia et al on Science last week News!!! News!!! 10 years of observations from GOLF Observed g mode is consistent with a model with a rotation rate 3 or 5 times higher than radiative interior

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Conclusion Magnetic fields EOS 2D model Rotation Convection Diffusion Non adiabatic effects Longer series of oscillations data g modes Improve model Observations

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May The future… SDO Solar Dynamics Observatory, HMI (local helioseismology) NASA launch: 2008 to understand variation of magnetic fields dynamical processes and solar structure and its impact on Earth SO Solar Orbiter ESA Launch: 2013 VIM (local helioseismology at high latitude) to study, by approaching as close as 45 solar radii, the polar regions and the side of the Sun not visible from Earth PICARD CNES Launch: 2009 PREMOS (low l and g modes) to study of the Earth climate and Sun variability relationship DYNAMICS Dynamics and Magnetism from the Internal core to the Chromosphere of the Sun, Turck-Chieze et al. Saclay, (France) Launch:???

Maria Pia Di Mauro - IHY Conference Bad Honnef, May Co-ordinated Action funded by FP6 the 6th Framework Programme of the European Union Objective: Bringing together the European research groups active in helio- & asteroseismology. Start date: April 1, 2006 Duration: 48 months Coordinator: Oskar von der Lühe, Kiepenheuer-Institut für Sonnenphysik, Freiburg European Helio and Asteroseismology Network More information