Presented to: Eastern RTO/ISO Conference Washington, DC May 11, 2005 The Importance of Teamwork in Multi-Jurisdictional Energy Market Monitoring William.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Demand Response Commissioner Suedeen Kelly June 3, 2008.

Advertisements

2007 Goals. Introduction Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC) will be primarily defined throughout the 2007 year by Electric Reliability.

Presented to: A Decade of Restructuring: Where Do We Stand? Bruder, Gentile & Marcoux, L.L.P. Washington, DC March 11, 2004 FERC’s Compliance Initiatives:

FERC Policy Agenda Energy Bar Association Washington, D.C. November 4, 2004 Pat Wood III, Chairman Federal Energy Regulatory Commission.

ERCOT: A Work In Progress Board of Directors Austin, TX July 16, 2002.

Highlights of the 2004 State of the Market Report New York Electricity Markets David B. Patton, Ph.D. Potomac Economics Independent Market Advisor May.

2004/05 Winter Energy Market Assessment November 18, 2004 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Disclaimer:

California Independent System Operator Corporation Overview of ISO Renewable Resource Program Karen Edson Vice-President of External Affairs October 9,

Regional Transmission Organizations: The Future of Transmission? Dave Edwards 4/17/2004.

George Godding Director DMC Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Federal Energy Regulatory Commission USEA/USAID Energy Partnership Program Brasilia,

George Godding Director DMC Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Federal Energy Regulatory Commission USEA/USAID Energy Partnership Program Brasilia,

Utility Regulation March 10, 2011 Raj Addepalli Deputy Director, Electric, Office of Electric,Gas and Water New York State Department of Public Service.

The Continuing Evolution of U.S. Electricity Markets

Electric Power Infrastructure: Status and Challenges for the Future Mark Lauby Director, Reliability Assessments and Performance Analysis.

Overview of LMP Markets Features of ISOs / RTOs David Withrow Senior Market Economist Fall 2007 Meeting of the NARUC Staff Subcommittee on Accounting and.

North American Electricity Markets APEX Paris, France October 15-16, 2007 Kenneth Laughlin, PJM.

Presented to: Euro Gas/IEA Conference Paris, France 13 June 2005 The Role of Regulators in Liberalized Energy Markets William F. Hederman, Director Office.

Presented to: Carnegie Mellon University Pittsburgh, PA December 16, 2004 Market Monitoring and Wholesale Power Transmission Issues William F. Hederman,

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission George Godding Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Federal Energy Regulatory Commission EISG – April 18,

PJM © PJM Overview ARIPPA Valley Forge, PA November 8, 2007.

Presented to: Annual Membership Meeting and National Energy Restructuring Conference Washington, DC March 31, 2004 Monitoring Price Integrity: A Critical.

H.B. “Trip” Doggett President and Chief Executive Officer Tab 4: Proposed 2013 – 2017 Strategic Plan – Redline Board of Directors Strategic Planning Event.

Presented to: University of Virginia Law School Charlottesville, VA March 25, 2004 Market Monitoring’s Key Role in Modern Economic Regulation William F.

FERC’s New Reliability Initiatives Kevin Kelly Director, Policy Analysis, OMTR Federal Energy Regulatory Commission NARUC Annual Meeting Nashville, TN.

©2004 PJM 1 STATE OF THE MARKET REPORT 2003 Joseph E. Bowring Manager PJM Market Monitoring Unit FERC Briefing Washington, D.C. April 14, 2004.

THE PJM INTERCONNECTION STATE OF THE MARKET REPORT 2001 Joseph E. Bowring Manager PJM Market Monitoring Unit Federal Energy Regulatory Commission June.

Presented to: Gas Storage Conference Ziff Energy Group Houston, TX February 2, 2005 Natural Gas Storage Market Issues: A Federal Perspective William F.

Presented to: NARUC Joint Panel Consumer Affairs/Gas Committees Washington, DC March 9, 2004 Natural Gas Market Monitoring and Recent Price Increases William.

George A. Godding, Jr. Director, Management and Communications Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Comments are the speakers and do not necessarily.

Managing Multiple RTOs within State Boundaries Gary W. Gillis Vice Chairman Kentucky Public Service Commission.

Presented to: Goldman School of Public Policy University of California, Berkeley October 22, 2004 High Power Analysis: Building a New Team In An Established.

ANRE ROMANIAN ENERGY REGULATORY AUTHORITY - ANRE Challenges in transitioning to a liberalised, competitive market – Romanian experience.

ENERGY REGULATORY AND MARKET DEVELOPMENT FORUM November 4, 2010 The Honorable Philip D. Moeller Commissioner Federal Energy Regulatory Commission “ENERGY.

Insight Information Company ONTARIO POWER SUMMIT Policing the Market: Upholding Conduct & Performance Harry Chandler Director, Market Assessment & Compliance.

Update - RTOs and Capacity January 28, Purpose of Presentation Update the Commission on issues related to – (1) Ameren Missouri – potential Local.

Presented to: Edison Electric Institute Transmission Pricing and Market Design School Madison, Wisconsin July 21, 2004 Federal and RTO Monitoring of Energy.

Office of Market Oversight & Investigations USA Electricity Markets Monitoring From OMOI’s Perspective George Godding Director, Mgmt. & Comm. Office of.

1 Independent Market Monitoring in the Midwest ISO Presented to: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission David B. Patton, Ph.D. Independent Market Monitor.

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Role Of The Market Monitor: ISO New England Dr. Hung-po Chao Director, Market Monitoring FERC Open Meeting Washington,

Presented to: EarthSat/PIRA Spring 2004 Energy Conference New York, NY May 18, 2004 Gas Market Monitoring: Past Winter Update William F. Hederman, Director.

June 17, Strategic Framework Business Definition and Strategic Issues Board of Director’s Meeting June 17, 2003 ERCOT Strategic Planning Task Force.

PJM©2009 PJM Confidential DOCs # RIC 2009 Nuclear Power Plant/Electric Grid Regulatory Coordination and Cooperation Transmission Operator’s Perspective.

Successful Restructuring: The Way Forward Mark Bennett Senior Manager of Policy Electric Power Supply Association Restructuring and the Wholesale Market.

©2005 PJM 1 STATE OF THE MARKET REPORT 2004 Joseph E. Bowring Market Monitor FERC Briefing April 13, 2005.

Presented to: 19 th World Energy Congress Sydney, Australia September 8, 2004 National Energy Market Monitoring in the United States Surveillance Nationale.

IWWG Annual Conference Wind Management at MISO July 22, 2011.

Summer Energy Market Assessment 2005 May 4, 2005 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Disclaimer: This Report.

1 NAUSCA Summer Meeting Boston June 30, 3009 David W. Hadley Vice President State Regulatory Relations Midwest ISO.

MISO Wisconsin Relationship Public Service Commission Randel Pilo, Assistant Administrator August 7, 2008.

FERC Staff’s Report on Demand Response and Advanced Metering.

Illinois Wholesale Market Update December 10, 2003.

Market Monitoring: The Role of OMOI and MMUs Presented to: Energy Markets at the Crossroads Springfield, Illinois December 12, 2002 By: Lisa L. Carter.

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Role of Market Monitoring at the NYISO John P. Buechler VP – Market Structures FERC Open Session Washington, D.C.

Office of Market Oversight & Investigations Comments by the speaker do not necessarily reflect those of the Commission Data Collection And Access At FERC.

Southeast Europe Electricity Market Monitoring Workshop – Athens, Greece Roles and Approaches to Market Monitoring from the USA Regulator’s Perspective.

California Energy Action Plan July 17, Energy Action Plan Natural Gas Actions Status Report David Maul California Energy Commission Staff And Richard.

Planning for Texas’ Energy Future Select Committee on Electric Generation Capacity and Environmental Effects Bob Kahn President & CEO February 6, 2008.

Presented to: “Ethics and Changing Energy Markets: Issues for Engineers, Managers and Regulators” University of Notre Dame October 28, 2004 “Energy Market.

Role Of ERC in the WESM To enforce the rules and regulations governing the operations of the WESM and monitors the activities of the Market Operator and.

Energy Markets at the Crossroads Illinois State University Institute for Regulatory Policy Studies 12 December 2002 Springfield, Illinois Vito Stagliano.

Presented to: 23 rd National Regulatory Conference Marshall-Wythe School of Law Williamsburg, VA May 12, 2005 Energy Options in a Hybrid Market World William.

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 1 Overview of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Roland W. Wentworth Office of Markets, Tariffs and Rates.

2015 NARUC Winter Meeting Nick Wagner – Iowa Utilities Board 1.

Endless Possibilities RTO/Regulatory Update for East Origination September 18, 2001.

FERC’s Division of Reliability Federal Energy Regulatory Commission – Open Meeting Washington, DC October 6, 2004 Joseph H. McClelland Director, Division.

Earthsat/Pira Conference Houston, Texas December 5, 2005 Natural Gas Market Monitoring, Natural Gas and Electric Price Indices, What is New at FERC? Matthew.

Enron Government Affairs Status Report to EWS 1 September 2001.

Shir Consultants Regulation and Market Monitoring in Electricity Markets Dariush Shirmohammadi Shir.

6th Asian Roundtable on Corporate Governance Theme II, Session 2 Ensuring Capacity, Integrity and Accountability of Regulators and Supervisors Jaweria.

Wholesale Electricity Marketing & Trading Fundamentals

Presentation transcript:

Presented to: Eastern RTO/ISO Conference Washington, DC May 11, 2005 The Importance of Teamwork in Multi-Jurisdictional Energy Market Monitoring William F. Hederman, Director Office of Market Oversight and Investigations Federal Energy Regulatory Commission WH-5/11/05

2 Outline FERC Strategy OMOI Organization Delineation of Responsibilities Diversity of MMU Models Markets Overview Program and Policy Options (Views expressed are Hederman’s, not the Commission’s.)

3 FERC has 3-prong strategy. Effective Rules Infrastructure Rules Enforcement Competitive Markets Just & Reasonable Outcomes Strategic Approach

4 Energy Market Progress Requires: Integrity AND Public Confidence In That Integrity

5 OMOI has 3 essential processes to “Trust and Verify”. Professionally skeptical Diverse (private/public sectors, disciplines) Highly skilled Team-oriented C O I OutsIdeOutsIde FERCFERC

6 * Report to Board *Discuss Emerging *Report to PUCs Issues/Trends *Regional State of Market *Watch for Anomalous or *Mitigation Inappropriate Market Behavior *Supply Detailed Market Data *Confer on Market Developments Evaluations *Analyze Markets *Contribution to Market Design *Report to Commission *Coordinate with all MMUs *National State of the Markets *Seasonal Look-Aheads *Audit -Market Participants -RTO/ISOs *Enforce Regulations *Monitor Non-RTO Areas and Fuels (esp., Natural Gas) *Market Surveillance Reports/Market Snapshots *Order Development *EQR Implementation *Coordinate With Other Federal Agencies RTO/ISO Market Monitors FERC OMOI Feds and Monitors share tasks and have distinct tasks.

7 Common Market Metrics - MMUS Category MetricNYISOPJMISO-NECAISOMISOTotal Energy Market Metrics DA and RT Prices 1 Price Duration Curve 4 All-in Price 4 Volatility Congestion Costs 3 Secondary Market Metrics Capacity Market Volume and Price 2 Load Metrics Load Duration Curve 5 Imports and Exports 5 Offer Sufficiency 2 Generation Metrics Outages and Deratings 5 Generation by Fuel 2 Additional Market Metrics Virtual Transactions 2 Spot Market Activity 1 RSI Duration Curve 4 Reserve Margin OMOI and Market Monitors agreed to add this metric at June 22 MMU meeting. Net Revenue Analysis 4 Total Status of MMU Common Metrics from State of the Market Presentations

8 There is no dominant market monitoring model PJMISO-NENYISOCAISOMISOSPPERCOT Internal Monitor Reports to: Employees President and Board of Managers Employees ISO CEO & Markets Committee of ISO Board of Directors Employees (Note 1) Director, Corp. and Market Risk Management Employees General Counsel (Note 2)Employees (Note 3) CEO External Monitor Reports to: Contractor Markets Committee of ISO Board of Directors Contractor (Note 4) Markets Committee of NYISO Board Contractor (Note 5) FERC and ISO Contractor Markets Committee of the MISO Board Contractor Compliance Committee of Board of Directors Texas PUC employees (Note 6) Texas PUC Other Monitor Reports to: NYPSC staff NYPSC Market Surveillance Committee CEO and Board of Governors Contractor Texas PUC Notes: (1) Lead for: real time, physical audits; (2) No Internal Monitor, staff liaison to the External Monitor; (3) Skeletal staff now, change likely; (4) Lead for: longer term, analytics; (5) Limited role setting DEC reference prices; (6) Pending legislation would require ERCOT to Fund, through administrative fees, an independent market monitor (contractor) that would be hired by the PUC and would report directly to the PUC

The relevant markets and jurisdictions are complex. Natural Gas & Electric Market Space Gas Supply Trading Venues Futures (NYMEX) Electronic Platforms Bilateral Trading Voice Brokers Pipelines & Storage Players Delivered Market Physical Nat Gas Generation Transmission & Pumped Storage Delivered Market Phys Electric Power Gas to fuel power generation RTO’s & ISO’s Price Contributors -Fixed price buyers & sellers -Speculators Price Takers -Indexed price buyers & sellers Source: FERC-OMTR&OMOI 9 Nat Gas & Electric Derivatives Nat Gas & Electric Clearing

10 There are many dimensions to crafting Market Monitoring programs and policies. Monitor Qualifications (none/independent judgment/minimum/certification) Monitor Reporting Requirements - FERC- RTO Board - PUCs- RTO Management Monitor Independence/Incentives Monitor Confidentiality Restrictions Inter-monitor/Agency Interaction Responses: Timeliness/QA-QC Just a few examples:

11 There is lots to discuss. Questions and Answers