Velondriake “live with the sea” Community-Based Managed Protected Area Madagascar Campaign FIJI BROP WORKSHOP.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
To live with the sea Towards community-centred marine conservation in Andavadoaka.
Advertisements

Welcome to Volunteer Management
Strengthening MPA Management through Local Communities Philippine Environmental Governance Project (EcoGov)
Indianapolis, Indiana Offender Notification Meetings.
INCREASING IMPACT Understanding Measurements of Impact in Evaluation June 2013 Jennifer Farley.
“Strengthening MPA Management through Local Communities” Philippine Environmental Governance Project (EcoGov)
Session 12 Theory of Change. Session Objectives Module 1, Unit 3, Session 12 By the end of this session, campaign managers should be able to: Define a.
Plan’s Global Campaign to unleash the power of girls and secure a brighter future for all.
April 6 -8, 2004 First International Environmental Health Conference Shanghai, China California – China Environmental Health Training Program.
Justice freedom security S t a k e h o l d e r C o n f e r e n c e – M a r c h NATIONAL PROSECUTING AUTHORITY The NPA’s role in Crime Prevention.
ANGKANA “ TAO” MAKVILAI Tiger Conservation Pride Campaign in HKK wildlife Sanctuary, Thailand CRITICAL ANALYSIS PRESENTATION.
“Strengthening MPA Management through Local Communities” Philippine Environmental Governance Project (EcoGov)
Bindoy MPA sites Location 3 kms from the shoreline and a crystal clear water ideal for swimming,snorkeling and diving within the mantalip reserve.
EXCELLENCE AND SUSTAINABILITY BUILDING COMMUNITY CONNECTIONS.
Corporate Management. Requirements Candidates need to display a knowledge of the language of corporate or strategic management and have an understanding.
Where have all the fishes gone?
Hinunangan Pride Campaign ARMANDO ORDIZ GAVIOLA CRITICAL ANALYSIS PRESENTATION.
CHCCD412A Cluster 1.  s/pdf_file/0006/54888/CHAPS_Community- Services-Pathway-Flyer_v 4.pdf
Community Driven Development in Natural Resource Management in Romania From biodiversity project to country- wide forestry sector reform.
Training of Process Facilitators Training of Process Facilitators.
First, let’s make sure we understand what the SWAT Movement is all about.
By Prof. OSSAMA RASSLAN Secretary General, Egyptian Society of Infection Control.
Preliminary theory of change for the South China Sea Project Cluster Neeraj Negi Reference Group Meeting Bangkok, Thailand September 27, 2010.
Fiji Locally Managed Marine Area (LMMA) Network.
“Strengthening MPA Management through Local Communities” Philippine Environmental Governance Project (EcoGov)
The Social Marketing Strategy As a result of the Threat Ranking… Target AudienceBehaviour Change Fishermen (Pirogue owners) 1.Follow the Dina (local law)
Gaana Balbar Set our taimen free CRITICAL ANALYSIS PRESENTATION.
Fundamentals of Evaluation for Public Health Programs ROBERT FOLEY, M.ED. NIHB TRIBAL PUBLIC HEALTH SUMMIT MARCH 31,
Efforts being made by the Government of Sri Lankato promote responsible Small scale fisheries & the rights of small scale fishing communities Shantha Bandara,
Philippines 2 First University Phase Welcome to Week 5!
Topic 6 Community based fisheries management Michael King Coastal Fisheries Policy and Planning Course, 28/01/08 – 8/02/08, Apia, Samoa Secretariat of.
The Philippine Reef Rangers….. The Philippine Reef Rangers…. ….removing barriers.
Elaina Todd Guam Southern Watersheds Campaign CRITICAL ANALYSIS PRESENTATION.
Collaborative Fisheries Management. 14 th May 2014.
China Wetlands Cohort First University Phase: Week 6 (12/6/10 – 12/10/10)
Crosswalk of Public Health Accreditation and the Public Health Code of Ethics Highlighted items relate to the Water Supply case studied discussed in the.
UJUNG KULON NATIONAL PARK, BANTEN, JAVA Campaign for Sustainable Agriculture.
The importance of tackling discards: A fisheries policy perspective Luke Warwick – Defra, Environmentally Responsible Fishing.
Community Board Orientation 6- Community Board Orientation 6-1.
Federal Advisory Committee on Juvenile Justice (FACJJ) 2009 Annual Request for Information (ARI) Presented by CSR, Incorporated August 2009.
1-2 Training of Process Facilitators 3-1. Training of Process Facilitators 1- Provide an overview of the role and skills of a Communities That Care Process.
Writing a Good Survey 1Module 2, Unit 4, Session 7.
Hunt for consumption not to extinction Pride Campaign Santi “Joy” Saypanya CRITICAL ANALYSIS PRESENTATION.
A tool for assessing the feasibility and impact potential of Rare project plans BRAVO: Barrier Removal Assessment and Viability Overview Chuuk Lagoon Campaign.
Session 3 SMART Objectives. Setting smart SMART Goals Daniel Hayden Internal Discussion October
14. STEP 3: ACTIONS, COMPLIANCE, FINANCE & FINALIZE 14. Step 3.3–3.5 Management actions, compliance, finance & finalize EAFM plan Essential EAFM Date Place.
PEP2 Methodology for Social Marketing Milestones November 2010 – March 2011.
Inspiring Pride in The Nam Et – Phou Louey National Protected Area Nam Et – Phou Louey National Protected Area, Pride Work Plan.
Session on Improving governance of the MCs CF Retreat 930 to 1100 am, April 5, 2011 Boljoon, Cebu.
Community Plan Implementation Training 2-1 Community Plan Implementation Training 2-1.
Pride’s 2.0 Process 1.Focus on priority conservation targets & key threats 2.Align campaign components (targets, threats, audiences, objectives, etc) 3.Align.
Module 2, Unit 6 Objective Setting & Monitoring. Review – open ended questions.
Kathy Corbiere Service Delivery and Performance Commission
Session Objectives Did we meet these objectives? Module 2, Unit 4, Session 1 Use the brainstorming function in Miradi to isolate the factor chains of the.
Selecting and communicating high level impact measures DANIEL HAYDEN AND AMIELLE DEWAN RARE CCNET RALLY APRIL 2013.
Threats and threat to focus Target Audience Me, my Vision and Campaign Solution Location and Biological Importance Lead Agency Team and Site Partners Pride.
Rare Program for Sustainable Fishing in the Philippines Strengthening MPA management through local communities Pride English Program 2 (PEP-II)
Key issues Why – objectives: CBM (in this case) but be clear on each stakeholder’s objectives What is their involvement – level of participation identified.
Laely Nurhidayah Indonesian Institute of Sciences–LIPI (Jakarta) IUCN Colloquium 7-12 September 2015.
Community’s Rights and Coastal Resource Management: Small- Scale Fisherfolk’s Struggles and Initiatives in Thailand by Wichoksak Ronnarongpairee, Federation.
Large Ungulate Population increases Gov. officer become aware of the wildlife conservation laws and their importance. They further become aware that the.
Preliminary theory of change for the South China Sea Project Cluster
SPC - FAO Discussion on developing a Concept Note
Illegal killing, trapping and trade of birds
EMFF Funding opportunities for the environment
SPC - FAO Discussion on developing a Concept Note
CEAFM in Coastal Communities in Fiji
CEAFM in Coastal Communities in Fiji
MIHARI: Fisher knowledge, awareness and behaviour change for the conservation of dugongs and seagrass - The MIHARI network of locally managed marine.
Presentation transcript:

Velondriake “live with the sea” Community-Based Managed Protected Area Madagascar Campaign FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Geographical location

The Site (Velondriake) Spans over 700 km 2, 40km of coast, 23 villages Incorporating: Coral reefs, mangroves, sea grass beds, baobab forests, spiny forests. Community based MPA Network coordinated management system Dina (local law and limited national recognition) Vezo (indigenous, nomadic, only recently monetized economy) Extreme social and economic isolation Total dependence on marine resources / no alternatives! Absolute poverty (under 2$ a day) Management was piloted as a fisheries management tool, in order to enhance fisheries revenue (especially octopus) FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

The Strategy The social marketing campaign will target community leaders, MPA management, local fishermen and the migratory Saraha people to increase compliance and enforcement of the Dina in the Velondriake MPA, in particular in relation to beach seine netting and poison fishing. The desired behavior change will be the consistent enforcement of the Dina through reporting of illegal activities, participation to Dina enforcement meeting and appropriate fining of poachers (both local and migratory). The campaign will also aim to convince the local community to invite the Fisheries Control Agency to help with patrolling and enforcement of the Dina. FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Velondriake theory of Change FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

CR Conservation Result Increase fish population in the most threatened villages to 20% by 2014 FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

K Knowledge Changing minds Challenge/Threat: Lack of full commitment from protected area managers and community leaders. Lack of knowledge about the effect of destructive fishing to fish recruitment by resources users. Solution: Leadership training and effective management skills to leaders; awareness raising to community members and fishermen using destructive fishing. CR Conservation Result FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

A Attitude Changing hearts Challenge/Threat: community leaders are not willing to execute their role, local fishermen are not involved in the management action and destructive techniques users do not comply to the Protected area Solution: leaders will feel more responsible of the Velondriake management success; awareness raising will help community members to understand that they also have an important role to play with the Dina enforcement and migrates will understand the objective of the implementation of the MPA and its Dina. K Knowledge CR Conservation Result FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

IC Interpersonal communications Changing the dialogue Challenge: Lack of empowerment among community leaders and community members in resources management and Dina enforcement. Solution: Community dialogue about collaboration between managers/leaders and community members to improve management plan and level of trust. A Attitude K Knowledge CR Conservation Result FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Barrier Removal BR Changing the incentives Challenge: nepotism between community members and fear of migrants fishermen by local community in term of Law enforcement Solution: Blue ventures staff will help for community dialogue and Fishery controller agency will help to enforce the Velondriake Dina to offenders. IC Interpersonal Com. A Attitude K Knowledge CR Conservation Result FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

BC Behavior Change Changing behavior Challenge: Local leaders and community members are not enforcing the Dina, local and migrants fishermen don’t comply to the Velondriake Dina by using destructive methods for fishing Solution: Complete Dina enforcement by leaders; participation of community members and destructive methods users should stop beach seine or modify their net and use them only in the surface. BR Barrier Removal IC Interpersonal Com. A Attitude K Knowledge CR Conservation Result FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

BC Behavior Change TR Threat Reduction BR Barrier Removal IC Interpersonal Com. A Attitude K Knowledge CR Conservation Result Changing level of threat Challenge: Fish population are declining due to destructive fishing Solution: Reduce beach seine net users and Eliminate the use of poison fishing. FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Concept Model FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Threat Ranking FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Factor chain FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Factor Chain & Results Chain FIJI BROP WORKSHOP

Target audience Community leaders (village elders, MPA management, village presidents) Fishermen (age 15-35) and pirogue owners Local and migratory beach seine netters Barriers to Behavior Change FIJI BROP WORKSHOP Desired behavior change Enforce the Dina (collect evidence, have meetings and give fines) Sign a letter of support to invite Fisheries control Raise awareness about the Dina Comply with the Dina Report fishermen who use destructive fishing techniques (poison and beach seine nets) and compliance with MPA zoning Raise awareness about the Dina Stop the use of beach seine nets or use them only on the water surface Barriers to BC Fear that fisheries control may override them? Fear of FCA to sanction the community and creating conflict Some community leaders use/own beach seine nets Don’t consider the environmental Dina as important as it is not linked to ancestors (tabu) Don’t always recognize the MPA management as the right leaders Consider it their tradition and right Will get less money

Management Options FIJI BROP WORKSHOP management options you considered and which ones you chose (5min) Objective 1: Reduce poison fishing 1.Work with the Velondriake management committee and community leaders to determine how people will investigate cases of poison fishing and enforce the Dina on poison fishers, and fish buyers 2.Night armed youth patrol to check activities from shore Objective 2: Reduce beach seine netting 1.Gear Exchange for local fishermen and also with migrant Saraha people. Once local fisherman stop the practice, it will be easier for communities to call fish enforcement agency or enforce the Dina. 2.Fisheries Control Agency (Ministry of Fishing and Agriculture) to raise awareness and enforce DINA and national fishing legislation. Train community leaders to report cases of beach seining to Fish Enforcement Agency. 3.Lobby Mayor and Gendarmerie for gendarme presence in Bevato to protect local population from Saraha thereby enabling them to enforce Dina. 4.Work with the Velondriake management committee and community leaders to determine how people will investigate cases of beach seine netting, resolve conflicts and enforce the Dina on beach seine fishers Impact Feasibility

BRAVO (Barrier Removal Assessment Viability Overview ) FIJI BROP WORKSHOP TBD TBD TBD

Questionnaire results FIJI BROP WORKSHOP xx Xx xx Results from preliminary pilot questionnaire (N160): 30 elder or village president, 15 pirogue owners, 8 V. Community committee members 95% of people think that the marine resources in the Velondriake area are decreasing 28% (40) of people cited beach seine netting as one of the reasons for decreasing marine resources 30% (43) of people cited poison fishing as one of the reasons for decreasing marine resources when asked to evaluate Almost nobody has ever enforced the Dina in relation to Poison fishing and beach seine netting but almost everybody says that they are willing to attend a meeting to enforce it in the future 4 people say that they have reported someone breaking the Dina before (2 once and 2 3 times) 28 people say they have given a warning to someone about breaking the V. Dina

Questionnaire results FIJI BROP WORKSHOP xx Xx xx Insert some of the most interesting results from your survey here, particularly results that may have helped you validate your assuptions about the barrier removal strategy (5min) Results from preliminary pilot questionnaire (N160) Level of trust for different sources of information: Velondriake Committee: 26% trustworthy 58% somewhat trustworthy 8% not trustworthy Fisheries controller: 49% not trustworthy 32% somewhat trustworthy 8% trustworthy Elders: 55% somewhat trustworthy 21% trustworthy 14% not trustworthy Blue Ventures 24% trustworthy 53% somewhat trustworthy 13% not trustworthy

Questionnaire results FIJI BROP WORKSHOP xx Xx xx Insert some of the most interesting results from your survey here, particularly results that may have helped you validate your assumptions about the barrier removal strategy (5min) Results from preliminary pilot questionnaire (N160): n people who can name the Dina n people who can name the forbidden behaviortotal% poison fishing small mesh size killing juvenile

BROP (Barrier Removal Operational Plan) & partners FIJI BROP WORKSHOP xx Xx xx Insert info on your barrier removal strategy (in other words “what needs to happen on top of the campaign for the campaign to be successful?”). Share where you are at (if you have them: timeline, budget, RACI chart); what makes you think this strategy will be successful (share examples from elsewhere if you have them); how will success be measured?) You can insert up to 3 slides for this section (10min) BR strategy: Fisheries Control Agency (FCA) to come and help patrol the Velondriake MPA and help enforce the local Dina (which is also considered national law). Fisheries Control Agency (FCA) have already said that they will be willing to do so provided that there is local support for their intervention. The strategy is therefore for the campaign to raise awareness and support and get the village leaders to sign a letter of support/invitation for FCA to come and patrol the area (within 6 moths from start of the campaign?). Outstanding questions All details of FCA involvement still need to be agreed and formalized: timing (when to start patrols, frequency of patrols) FC involvement in the raising awareness campaign Vessel (by BV?) and crew (FCA) Evidence collection and prosecuting procedures Communication (reporting of illegal activities, collaboration with MPA and village leaders) Costs (vessel, per diem, fuel, other?) Potential funder PACP (Projet d’Appui aux Communautes des Pecheurs)

Risks & questions FIJI BROP WORKSHOP xx Xx xx what do you think are the weaknesses of the strategy, your doubts and outstanding questions (3min) This is your opportunity to share your concerns and ask questions for the group to discuss later during the day People with beach seine nets may opportunistically use them because they have them Conflict amongst community members and leaders may slow things down or mean the Dina can not be enforced Enforcement may lead to social and political unrest People with beach seine nets may not be able to afford not to beach seine. Would it be better to ban beach seine net use altogether or to ask people to use them only on the surface? Political elections may coincide with campaign period