Heart and Mind Connections: Integrated Strategies for Greater Health Client Summit Sessions July 17, 18, 20 Teleconference phone:
2 Agenda Connection Between Heart Disease and Mental Health: Joe Hullett Northrop Grumman Newport News Wellness Initiative: Steven Apostoles Pratt & Whitney Stress Management Seminar Program: Tracy Newmark, Amy Wilson Discussion
3 Why Heart Disease? Human cost: No 1. killer of Americans and a leading cause of disability Financial costs: Key contributor to rising health care and disability expenditures and a prime cause of decreased productivity
4 The Costs of Heart Disease and Mental Health Heart disease is often associated with a mental health diagnosis, which may not be properly diagnosed or may be undertreated. There is a significant difference in medical health costs for individuals with coronary artery disease (CAD): In one study, the costs to the employer for the physical health care of CAD patients without co-morbid behavioral health diagnoses was $883 per member per month. These costs rose 54% to $1,358 per member per month for CAD patients with depression or anxiety. 1 Individuals with CAD who were treated with selective antidepressants for six months were: 91% more likely to experience a significant reduction in the cost of hospital inpatient services 72% more likely to experience a significant reduction in the cost of office-based services in the treatment of their disease 2
5 About Heart Disease and Mental Health Depression, anxiety, hopelessness, pessimism, hostility and anger have all been linked to heart disease. 3,4,5 Depression and anxiety disorders may affect heart rhythms, increase blood pressure, alter blood clotting, and lead to elevated insulin and cholesterol levels. These risk factors often predict, and are a response to, heart disease. 6 People with heart disease are more likely to suffer from depression than otherwise healthy people; conversely, people with depression are at greater risk for developing heart disease. 7 Those who have heart disease and who are depressed have an increased risk of death after a heart attack compared with those who are not depressed. 8
6 Fighting Heart Disease: The Role of Behavioral Health Experts Emotional, psychological and behavioral intervention and support is essential in helping to prevent or manage heart disease. Behavioral experts can: identify and manage behavioral health contributors that can impact heart health, such as depression, anxiety and chronic stress support those who are living with heart disease promote and help sustain a healthy lifestyle
7 Initiative Components Client summit CD toolkit Costs of heart disease and mental health diagnoses Information about the heart and mind connection Organizational/program considerations Communication tools Staff information and training Affiliate information and training Behavioral Health Management article
8 Service Options Offered by ValueOptions Standard: 24/7 assessment and referral Employee assistance program (EAP) Stress reduction counseling Depression screening Intensive case management Support for family and support systems Primary care physician (PCP) behavioral health consultation Educational programs Enhanced services: Lifestyle coaching Tobacco cessation Nurse line Integrated care
9 Benefits of an Integrated Cardiovascular/Behavioral Health Program Increased referral rate to the EAP and mental health/substance abuse program Decreased overall health care and disability costs Enhanced productivity Reduced absenteeism Improved employee/member perception of organization’s commitment to their health and well-being
10 Newport News Wellness Initiative
11 Plan All employees and dependents may participate (on their own time) Participation is entirely voluntary and results are confidential Four on-site wellness coordinators located throughout the yard Clinic, Buildings 901 & 600, SPF Shop Focus on early detection, prevention and risk reduction
12 Initiatives Health risk appraisal (HRA) On-site screening/health fairs Flu shots Risk-reduction programs Heart health Cancer/diabetes prevention Weight management Nutrition/exercise Stress management Work/life balance
13 Design Based on the seven benchmarks of the Wellness Councils of America: 1.Capturing Senior Level Support 2.Creating Cohesive Teams 3.Collecting Data 4.Crafting an Operating Plan 5.Choosing Appropriate Interventions 6.Creating Supportive Environments 7.Carefully Evaluating Outcomes
14 Building Support Sought senior level leadership commitment, including the Sector President, Senior VP of Programs and VP of Human Resources Obtained buy-in from senior union officials Tailored approach to address concerns of the various managers
15 Creating a Cohesive Team Chose our team well Sought and received corporate support Chose vendor who is willing to engage Selected steering group committed to oversight “A committee is a cul de sac down which great ideas are lured and then quietly strangled.”
16 Collecting Data to Drive Initiative Organizational Needs Demographic information Health risk appraisals Health screening data Medical claims Disability Absenteeism Ergonomics Employee Interests Focus groups Individual interviews/simple surveys Meetings
17 Operations Plan Vision Goals Objectives Marketing Timeline Itemized budget Evaluation plan
18 Intervention Choices Awareness Education Lifestyle modifications support Healthcare providers collaboration Incentives/disincentives Screenings Flu shots Ergonomics Job design/accommodation Return to work Workplace stress reduction
19 Creating Supportive Environments Establishing multiple permanent yard sites that provide privacy Including dependents Scheduling off-shift hours Roving health screens Engaging Food Services to provide healthy choices Aligning organizational, HR and health promotion policies/practices Benefit plan design Coordinating with provider and community resources Balancing high touch with high tech
20 Consistently Measure Outcomes Number of study years Number of subjects Number of separate interventions Percentage change in sick leave Percentage change in absenteeism Percentage change in medical costs Percentage change in workers compensation costs
21 Concerns Developing metrics to support ROI Loss of momentum both at the Sector and Corporate Engagement by healthcare providers Duplicate programs provided by healthcare providers (HRA) increase costs Integration with other benefit programs
22
23 Pratt & Whitney Pratt & Whitney is a world leader in the design, manufacture and service of aircraft engines, industrial gas turbines and space propulsion systems. 40,000 employees worldwide, 20,000 domestic HealthTime SM, the Employee Wellness Network is managed by the Global Medical Department. Contracts with Health Fitness Corporation (HFC) HFC is a leader in corporate-based health improvement and has successfully implemented employee health management strategies in numerous Fortune 100 corporations.
24 Vision, Strategy, Focus To protect and enhance the health of Pratt & Whitney employees. Identify and reduce preventable health risks through on-site programs Help employees understand and obtain quality health care Promote a healthy culture Focus: Cardiovascular disease Cancer Mental health (promotion and increased utilization of available EAP services) Influenza (flu shot program)
25 ValueOptions EAP Synergy P&W researched available resources to meet established wellness goals. EAP contract hours –On-site and off-site counseling services –Seminars on various subjects Requested a stress management seminar. Participants would learn new ways to deal with everyday stress, manage time and balance work/ family issues Communication tool for promoting EAP services
26 “Managing Stress for Life” 18 seminars at domestic P&W facilities September 2005 through January 2006 Accommodated time constraints and shift workers One session videotaped –DVD produced –Webcast uploaded to HealthTime SM Web page on company intranet Satisfaction surveys given to participants –134 surveys returned (14 events) –Data analysis completed Stress Management Seminar
27 95% of participants ranked their satisfaction at a 5 or above (on a scale of 1-7) Participant Survey
28 93% of participants ranked the usefulness of the information at a 5 or above (on a scale of 1-7) Usefulness of Information
29 88% of participants ranked the handouts and materials at a 5 or above (on a scale of 1-7) Handouts and Other Materials
30 91% of participants reported that they increased their knowledge or improved their skills 84% of participants reported that they will be making a behavior change Learning, Knowledge, Behaviors
31 Stress Seminars at Pratt & Whitney Health Risk Category Potential Health Care Cost Savings Per Employee Who Reduces Their High Risk Status Stress$1,179 High Blood Glucose $22,650 HFC Results Calculator Potential Program Savings: Stress Seminars at Pratt & Whitney
32 “Well done, kept everyone’s interest and spurred many conversations after.” “This seminar was highly informative and will certainly help with dealing with stressful situations in the future.” “I feel that these resources should be communicated more often. Not just me, but many people don't know about this or are hesitant about utilizing (the) EAP.” “Good introduction to stress, but I think more specific details on the very best ways of dealing with stress would be even more beneficial. Possibly real examples and back up ideas.” Participant Comments
33 Communication tool for ValueOptions EAP services EAP utilization increased 38% from 1Q 2005 to 4Q 2005 Used data analysis to determine need for continuation of annual seminars UTC EH&S Health Promotion Outreach Award Summary
34 Discussion
35 Resources American Heart Association: National Business Group on Health’s business case for cardiovascular health: pdf ValueOptions’ cardiovascular health initiative: pages/index.htm
36 Sources 1 ValueOptions/IHCIS Comorbidity Study, Group Health Incorporated, 3 Williams R.B. Neurobiology, cellular and molecular biology, and psychosomatic medicine. Psychosom Med, 1994; 56: Denollet J., Brutsaert D.L. Personality, disease severity, and the risk of long-term cardiac events in patients with a decreased ejection fraction after myocardial infarction. Circulation. 1998; 97: L.D. Kuzansky, K.W. Davidson, and A. Rozanski. The Clinical Impact of Negative Psychological States: Expanding the Spectrum of Risk for Coronary Artery Disease. Psychosom Med, May 1, 2005; 67(Supplement_1):S10-S14. 6 National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute 7 Nemeroff CB, Musselman DL, Evans DL. Depression and cardiac disease. Depression and Anxiety, 1998; 8(Suppl 1): Frasure-Smith N, Lesperance F, Talajic M. Depression and 18-month prognosis after myocardial infarction. Circulation, 1995; 91(4):