Module 4: Association Personnel – The Executive Director Presented by the Southern Early Childhood Association

Topics to be Presented… Employment contracts for the Executive Accountability of the Executive Director Assessment of the Executive Director Relationship between the Board of Directors and the Executive Director

The Executive Director is… …the person in a nonprofit corporation ordinarily responsible for management of the day-to-day affairs of the nonprofit corporation and responsible for the implementation of policies set by the Board of Directors.

* DISCUSSION * How does your organization choose or hire its Executive Director? What are the specific job responsibilities of your association’s Executive Director position?

Why is it beneficial to have an employment contract for the Executive Director? Serves as a quality control mechanism Simplifies performance evaluations Minimizes misunderstandings between the Director and association officers Shows a commitment to professionalism Help associations retain qualified executives

Executive Director contracts include… Names of contracting parties Statement of mutual agreement Type of association Title of position Term of agreement Duties of the Executive Boundaries of authority Benefits Termination procedure Impact of mergers Indemnification Renewal provision Nonassignability Arbitration procedure Control of association materials State laws Signatures and dates of signing

* DISCUSSION * Does your association have a written employment contract with its Executive Director? If so, what stipulations are included in this contract? If your association does not maintain such a contract, draft a sample one now based on the criteria discussed in this presentation.

Other Compensation Options for Small Associations Bonuses Deferred compensation Pension plans Life and disability insurance Continuing education benefits Professional association memberships

Accountability In most associations, the Executive is the only staff person directly accountable to the Board of Directors. Chain of command: Board of Directors > Board Chair > Executive Importance of open communication

* DISCUSSION * What does the chain of command for your association look like? Draw it as a diagram, and clearly indicate the lines of accountability in your organization.

Assessment of the Executive Director Primary responsibility of the Board of Directors Board sets the standards by which the Executive is evaluated Assessment should give Board the ability to recognize management problems early in their course, and initiate corrective action

* DISCUSSION * What is the evaluation process for your association’s assessment of its Executive Director? Who performs the evaluation, on what standards is it based, and how is the information presented to both the Executive and the Board after the evaluation?

Benefits of Evaluating the Executive Director 1. Clarifies responsibilities 2. Ensures Board compliance 3. Ensures organizational goals are being met 4. Continues professional development for the Executive 5. Ensures a formal and documented evaluation process 6. Encourages stability in the Executive position 7. Provides written record of Executive performance 8. Assists in developing Executive priorities 9. Provides opportunity for the Board to express their satisfaction!

Tips for Conducting Evaluations Conduct the evaluation regularly Fully document the evaluation process and its results Clearly specify the staff’s role in the evaluation Utilize more than one assessor Employ clear standards for evaluation, and avoid personal attacks

Steps for Developing an Assessment System 1.Establish criteria for performance appraisal. 2.Design an appraisal form that reflects the performance categories to be assessed. 3.Break each main category into specific tasks on which the Executive can be rated. 4.Determine who will make the assessment. 5.Determine how the assessment forms will be compiled into a report for the Board. 6.Determine how the assessment outcomes will be reported to the Executive.

Your evaluation system should answer three questions about your Executive: 1.What are the special strengths that this person has demonstrated in this position? 2.What are the areas for which improvement is indicated? 3.What are the kinds of management and/or organizational development activities that should be carried out in the future?

Categories of Executive Competency 1.Basics in management and leadership 2.Planning 3.Organizing 4.Leading 5.Coordinating Activities and Resources

The Role of the Executive Director in their own Evaluation Initiate definition of the activities to be assessed Build on the Executive’s existing system Use self-ratings in the overall assessment Include reports and external indicators Contract with an outside firm

* DISCUSSION * Based on all of the standards and criteria just presented, how would you revise your assessment procedures to provide a more thorough and helpful evaluation of the Executive Director for your association?

How Can the Executive Manage Their Relationship with the Board? Three methods the Executive can use to help the Board govern MORE and manage LESS: 1.Use a comprehensive strategic plan that has been developed in conjunction with the Board 2.Provide the Board with appropriate and sufficient material prior to Board meetings 3.Facilitate Board and Board committee discussions to improve focus

* DISCUSSION * Does your organization function in the manner which is most effective at allowing your Board of Directors to govern and your Executive Director to manage? What could be done to improve this relationship for the future?

One Final Management Option: Association Management Firms Executive “sharing” among associations Economical for smaller associations Be careful to avoid conflicts of interest among the firm’s clients and protect the confidentiality of own association’s financial records

Resources consulted for this presentation: Jerald Jacobs. Association Law Handbook. 3 rd Edition. Washington, DC: American Society of Association Executives, The Nonprofit Board Book: Strategies for Organizational Success. Revised edition. Arkansas: Independent Community Consultants, Carter McNamara. Field Guide to Developing and Operating Your Nonprofit Board of Directors. Minneapolis, MN: Authenticity Consulting, www.BoardSource.org Minnesota Council of Nonprofits www.mncn.org

Any final thoughts or questions?