©The Work Foundation Stephen Bevan Director, Centre for Workforce Effectiveness The Work Foundation & Honorary Professor Lancaster University The Clinical.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Effectiveness & Cost-Effectiveness of Collaborative Care Depression Treatment in Veterans who screen positive for PTSD Domin Chan, MHS, PhC Northwest HSRD.
Advertisements

Gender differences in well-being in older age James Nazroo and Anne McMunn UCL
Depression in adults with a chronic physical health problem
Implementing NICE guidance
Health, work & well-being
Mental Health: assessment and rehabilitation Dr Doreen Miller FRCP FFOM Managing Partner Miller Health Management.
Reducing Alcohol-Related Harm in Older People: A Public Health Approach Sarah WaddMarch 2014.
Rehabilitation What is it? Does it work? Is it cost effective?
REACH Healthcare Foundation Prepared by Mid-America Regional Council 2013 Kansas City Regional Health Assessment.
Based on the paper by Kirrin Gill, Rohini Pande, and Anju Malhotra International Center for Research on Women (ICRW) Women Deliver for Development Photo.
Potential for interventions in the early years to tackle health inequalities Karen MacNee Health ASD.
Supporting people in Dorset to lead healthier lives Commissioning the Dorset Community Persistent Pain Management Service Why is it so Painful to Commission.
A FOCUS ON SENIORS SUICIDE PREVENTION. DEMOGRAPHICS.
Keynote address: Musculoskeletal conditions as a challenge for policy making Professor Paul Emery President of EULAR Professor of Rheumatology, University.
©The Work Foundation Stephen Bevan Director, Centre for Workforce Effectiveness, The Work Foundation Honorary Professor, Lancaster University Mental Health.
Ken Jacobs UC Berkeley Center for Labor Research and Education February 2012 Retirement Age and Inequality.
Economic Analysis and Management Todd Wagner, PhD.
Active inclusion of the labour market- how can we be more effective? Sigrún Sigurðardóttir Vocational Rehabilitation Consultant Ása Dóra Konráðsdóttir.
The burden of RMDs on patients and their families The value of early intervention, prevention and better management of RMDs Marios Kouloumas Chairperson.
The Social Benefits of Early Childhood Education and Care Analytical Review prepared on behalf of NESSE by Helen Penn Cass School of Education, University.
Clinical Lead Self Care and Prevention
The Effects of Poverty on Female-Headed Households Tammy Howard University of Tennessee at Chattanooga BSW Social Work Program Spring 2007 SOCW 376.
Social Europe EU Employment and Social Situation Key facts and figures.
Dr. Birgitte M. Blatter Work related interventions improving return-to-work of workers with MSDs and some Dutch examples.
Rehabilitation in the Workplace - Supporting self-management - Stephen Bevan The Work Foundation Lancaster University, UK © The Work Foundation, 2015.
Health Risk Management. Today’s Presentation Define Health Risk Management (HRM) Our vision The bottom line impact of poor Health Risk Management The.
Implementing NICE guidance
Occupational health nursing
The Business Case for Bidirectional Integrated Care: Mental Health and Substance Use Services in Primary Care Settings and Primary Care Services in Specialty.
Janice Berry Edwards, PhD, LICSW, LCSW-C, BCD, ACSW
County Durham Planning Unit – Strategic Plan on a page
EMPLOYMENT & DISABILITY Joan O’Donnell Disability Federation of Ireland Presentation to Centre for Independent Living National Leader Forum.
Perspectives on the Age Wave: Key Issues, Solutions, and Opportunities Robyn Golden, LCSW Director of Older Adult Programs Rush University Medical Center.
Employment: a cure for mental illness? Silje Endresen Reme PhD and psychologist Uni Research Health & Oslo University Hospital.
HOW TO EVALUATE OUTCOMES OF REHABILITATION Matti Tuusa Training and Information Manager Rehabilitation Foundation, Pakarituvantie 4-5 Po Box 39,
Working for Wellness; Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) Employment Support Services “The total loss of output due to depression and chronic.
Health promotion and disease prevention: key policies for regional development Michael Hübel Head of Unit, Health Determinants, Directorate-General for.
A Coming of Age: Constructive Scenarios for a Shifting Population Linda Boyes and Jim McCormick Scottish Council Foundation.
The New Mental Health Strategy for England Dr Hugh Griffiths National Clinical Director for Mental Health.
Working Conditions, Health and Reward at Work of European Older Workers Thierry Debrand (*), Pascale Lengagne (**) (*) (**)
A Practical Perspective to Understanding HIV and Employment By: Le-Ann Dolan Program Director Canadian Working Group on HIV and Rehabilitation (CWGHR)
MENTAL HEALTH NEEDS ASSESSMENT for the Bristol Population
What are the economic consequences of adult ill- health in Russia? Marc Suhrcke WHO European Office for Investment for Health and.
® Introduction Changes in Opioid Use for Chronic Low Back Pain: One-Year Followup Roy X. Luo, Tamara Armstrong, PsyD, Sandra K. Burge, PhD The University.
 Goal of Equity in Income distribution: is to have a more equitable (fairer) distribution of income. That means productive income is divided among the.
“Fit for Work Ireland” The Institute of Physical Therapy & Applied Science Croke Park April 2014 John Church – CEO, Arthritis Ireland.
5 Ways to achieve parity in mental health Karen Turner Director of Mental Health, NHS England 9 th December.
HealthWorks Training Feel free to ask questions as we go along.
Reforms: Views from a Rehabilitation Provider 2016 Nikki Brouwers Managing Director The Interact Group
The Power of Volunteering. Give Happy Live Happy! Presented by Sue Noble CEO Volunteering Victoria.
Annual Report 2013/14. The causes of the causes  The social determinants of health underpin the stark inequalities in health in Camden and Islington.
Health Insurance Plans Intro to Health Science Unit One Lesson 5 Diversified Health Occupations pages.
Dementia Care - a Forward View and a note on the Nottinghamshire Healthcare Strategy Professor Martin Orrell Director, Institute of Mental Health 1.
Australia's welfare - biennial report since 1993 Explores welfare using a life-course approach, starting at childhood and then moving through youth to.
Helping people with mental health problems gain and retain employment – what works? Dr Bob Grove Director, Employment Programme.
Institute For Safety, Compensation and Recovery Research Presentation to Safety Culture from the Regulators' Perspective Symposium Dr Andrea de Silva,
Copyright 2005 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Foundations of Therapeutic Exercise Chapter 1 Introduction to Therapeutic Exercise and the Modified Disablement.
Evelina London Child Health Programme Integrating services Claire Lemer 29 th April 2014.
Improvements needed in the care of people living with Dementia.
만성질환자 관리 : 재활 세브란스병원 간호부장 김 현 옥.  Political Trends  Economic Trends  Demographic Trends  Technological Trends  Societal Trends  Professional Organization.
Overview of Education in Health Care
Public Health in Scotland Why it matters Health and Social Care Analysis, Scottish Government, February 2016 All references available on request.
Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and a Workplace Intervention for workers on sickness absence due to mental disorders.
Health Related Quality of Life after serious occupational injuries and long term disability Presenter: Ibishi Nazmie MD,PhD University Clinical Center.
by Spanning the Silos in Health of Investment Decision-Making
Global burden of diseases
Healthy Workplaces for All Ages
Healthy Workplaces for All Ages
Nuzhat Ali, National Lead MSK Health
Social prescribing in County Durham
Presentation transcript:

©The Work Foundation Stephen Bevan Director, Centre for Workforce Effectiveness The Work Foundation & Honorary Professor Lancaster University The Clinical and Work Benefits of Early Intervention for MSKs’

Context Ageing Workforce Later Retirement More Chronic Ill-health among working age citizens Burden of MSDs in workforce Widening Health Inequalities & a recognition that ‘Work’ is a social determinant of health ©The Work Foundation

Musculoskeletal Disorders in the EU Workforce a

Employment rates (working age, England) Just 50.7% of individuals with MSDs are in employment compared to 71.6% of individuals without MSDs 41.9% of people with back problems are in employment Those with MSDs are more likely to work part time Over 32% of working age people with MSDs have co- morbid depression Over 60% of people working with MSDs are the primary income-earner in their household Source: TWF/Health Survey for England, 2015

Key Issues A diagnosis of a chronic illness should be no impediment to leading a healthy and fulfilling working life Well-timed workplace & healthcare investments among working age people deliver sustainable returns in terms of productivity gains and social inclusion ©The Work Foundation

Potential Benefits of Early Intervention Better treatment. The quicker an individual receives a diagnosis, the more rapidly they can get access to appropriate treatment which can stabilise or control their symptoms; Reducing the risk of developing co-morbid conditions. For many people with chronic conditions issues like pain, fatigue, depression or anxiety can become a significant issue which can increase healthcare costs and reduces functional capacity; Aiding a return to activities of daily living. Early intervention can ensure people with chronic conditions can become more self-reliant and rely less on health and social care services; Staying in or returning to work. People whose health conditions are being well-managed are more likely to remain economically active, continue to pay taxes and be less reliant on welfare payments Early Intervention is cost effective. An investment not a Cost ©The Work Foundation

Early Intervention for MSK Why focus on early healthcare interventions for working people? Does early intervention improve work ability – assessing the evidence? Case studies of early intervention successes What lessons can stakeholders draw from this evidence? From evidence to action – taking the next steps ©The Work Foundation

Methodological Considerations ©The Work Foundation The methods which have been used to estimate indirect costs – especially productivity gains or losses The measure of ‘return to work’ (RTW) being used The choice of comparator interventions used in drawing conclusions about cost-effectiveness

Example: Early Back Pain Intervention Over 120 patients with high risk of acute back pain randomly assigned to ‘early’ and ‘usual’ treatment groups ‘Early’ group received 3 months of physical therapy and cognitive behavioural therapy, including coping skills training, relaxation and biofeedback 12 month follow-up after the main intervention the study captured data on self-reported pain, health status, healthcare resource utilization and work days lost Rogerson et al, 2010

Results No difference in self-reported pain & health status (both improved) Health visits by ‘Early’ group declined but among ‘Usual’ group they increased Mean sick days for ‘Early’ group was 13.6 days and for the ‘Usual’ group it was 25.8 days Cost utility ratio for the ‘Early’ group revealed a cost of $49,593 per QALY gained: for the ‘Usual’ group it was $71,001 per QALY gained

Early Intervention Can… Reduce sick leave and lost work productivity among workers with MSDs by more than 50 per cent. Early intervention is commonly more cost-effective than ‘usual care’; Reduce healthcare costs by up to two-thirds; Reduce disability benefits costs by up to 80 per cent; Reduce the risk of permanent work disability and job loss by up to 50 percent; Reduce the risk of developing a co-morbid mental illness Deliver societal benefits by supporting people with work- limiting chronic conditions to optimise their functional capacity and remain active at work and maintain economic independence

Actions for Stakeholders

Job Quality - A Message From HILDA Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) Survey Analysis (Butterworth et al, 2011) of seven waves of data from 7,155 respondents of working age (44,019 observations) from a national household panel survey. Longitudinal regression models evaluated the concurrent and prospective association between employment circumstances (unemployment and employment in jobs varying in psychosocial job quality) and mental health, assessed by the MHI-5

Psychosocial Job Quality (1) 1. My job is more stressful than I ever imagined 7. My job is complex and difficult 8. My job requires learning new skills 9. I use my skills in current job 10. I have freedom to decide how I do work 11. I have a lot of say about what happens 12. I have freedom to decide when I do work 4. I have a secure future in my job 5. Company I work for will be in business in 5yrs 6. I worry about the future of my job 3. I get paid fairly for the things I do in my job Job demands & complexity Job control Job security Effort- reward fairness Source: Butterworth et al, 2011

Psychosocial Job Quality (2) “As hypothesised, we found that those respondents who were unemployed had significantly poorer mental health than those who were employed. However, the mental health of those who were unemployed was comparable or more often superior to those in jobs of the poorest psychosocial quality.” Source: Butterworth et al, 2011

Improving Employment Outcomes for Those with MSDs Workforce health as a ‘Human Capital Asset’ ‘Work’ should be a clinical outcome of care The need to prevent premature work loss Interventions to support independent living Cost effectiveness of early interventions – making the case for investment Joining up the work of Healthcare, Social Insurance & Employers – and placing patients at the centre of their care