Chilled water Meyrin consolidation Study 1 st Part Many thanks for their contribution to: Pasquale Alemanno, Fortunato Candito, Alexander Putzu.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Improve Facility Operation through Commissioning-A Case Study Mingsheng Liu, Ph.D., P. E. University of Nebraska.
Advertisements

Lindbergh Field International Airport New Terminal Bill Mahoney LSW Engineers.
Learning Outcomes Upon completion of this training one should be able to: Identify open loop and closed loop campus-type hydronic water system applications.
University of Iowa Indoor Practice Facility Outside-the-box HVAC Lincoln Pearce, PE – KJWW Engineering David Hahn – University of Iowa Chilled Water Plant.
Heat pumps and their economics. There has been fluctuations before Johnson Controls2.
Objectives Finish with ducts and fans Define project topics.
Upon completion of this training one should be able to: Identify different types of hydronic heating systems Identify key components in a simple hydronic.
Heat and cold generation Meyer Hospital Florence Meeting, 8-9 May 2003.
UTSW Thermal Energy Plants, Power Generation and Electrical System What do we do to meet the Emission Reduction, Energy usage Reduction and Electrical.
Overall issues for adequate design for high-ambient temperature operation by: Samir Hamed Petra Engineering Ind. Co. Rtoc member.
Active beams versus VAV with Reheat Analysis of May 2013 ASHRAE Journal article Ken Loudermilk Vice President, Technology & Developement.
44 th Annual Conference & Technical Exhibition By Thomas Hartman, P.E. The Hartman Company Georgetown, Texas Sustainable Chilled Water.
UTSW Thermal Energy Plants, Power Generation and Electrical System What do we do to meet the Emission Reduction, Energy usage Reduction and Electrical.
Presentation Outline Introduction CHP Analysis Electrical Analysis Acoustical Analysis Thermal Storage Analysis System Optimization Analysis Conclusion.
M. Battistin – 1 st September 2009 EN/CV/DC 1 M. Battistin (EN/CV/DC) 1 st October 2009 ATLAS cooling Group - Thermosiphon solution for ATLAS ID cooling.
Lecture Objectives: Model HVAC Systems –HW3 Asignemnet Learn about eQUEST software –How to conduct parametric analysis of building envelope.
Chilled Water Systems Total Cost of Ownership
Examples of Commissioning Cost Savings Commissioning for Sustained Building Performance September 29, 2011 Marriott Birmingham, AL.
1 Multi-use Facility. 2 Occupancy – 140 persons Building Characteristics Single story 20,000 square feet (250’ x 80’) Standard construction.
Water piping design.
Grundfos FLOW THINKING Air conditioning the Grundfos Way.
Overview of Liquid Cooling Systems Peter Rumsey, Rumsey Engineers.
1 Medical Office Building. 2 Occupancy – 400 persons 8 a.m. – 5 p.m. Monday - Friday Building Characteristics Three stories 40,000 square feet (200’ x.
Lecture Objectives: Finish with HVAC Systems Discuss Final Project.
THE DISTRICT COOLING NETWORK THAT OUTPERFORMS NATURALLY PAGE ENERGY IS OUR FUTURE, WE MUST SAVE IT! EEMOD’S Nantes – 15 / 09 / 2009 > Overall chiller system.
Lindab Solus - Simply the natural choice.... lindab | comfort Chilled beam revolution! + Save up to 45 % cooling energy!* + Installation and investment.
Lecture Objectives: Specify Exam Time Finish with HVAC systems –HW3 Introduce Projects 1 & 2 –eQUEST –other options.
NOVO ETS IMPROVING YOUR ORGANIZATIONS’ ENVIRONMENTAL, HEALTH AND SAFETY PERFORMANCE ENERGY MANAGEMENT IN THE CONTEXT OF GREEN PRODUCTIVITY.
Re-Commissioning of the Water Cooling System at Université de Sherbrooke Department of Buildings June 2008.
N O R T H A M E R I C A C O M M E R C I A L TDP
November 2004 Low Hanging Fruit Low Cost Energy Efficiency Opportunities in Cleanrooms.
Lecture Objectives: Finish boilers and furnaces Start with thermal storage systems.
IMPROVING COOLING SYSTEM EFFICIENCY WITH PRE-COOLING AJ Schutte 15 August 2012.
19 th November 2010EN/CV/DC Thermosiphon project IV review - Overall cost estimation and planning Michele Battistin Elena Perez Rodriguez 19 th November.
J. Direito - M. Battistin – 28 th May 2010EN/CV/DC J. Direito, M. Battistin (EN/CV/DC) 28 th May 2010 Detector Cooling Project III Thermosiphon Workshop.
1 BREC Air-cooled water chillers BREF Air-cooled water chillers with free-cooling system 1602A A A A A 3202A A A -
The Data Center Challenge
1 BROOKHAVEN SCIENCE ASSOCIATES NSLS – II CFAC Review Conventional Facilities Briefing Chilled Water and Temperature Stability Chris Channing Sr. Project.
Announcement Course Exam November 3rd In class: 90 minutes long Examples will be posted on the course website.
1 Hospital Building and Campus Piping. 2 Hospital Building Occupancy – office and patient areas Patient areas: 24 hours per day Office areas: 8 am – 5.
Lecture Objectives: Differences in Conduction Calculation in Various Energy Simulation Programs Modeling of HVAC Systems.
EUROPEAN ORGANIZATION FOR NUCLEAR RESEARCH Design of the thermosiphon Test Facilities Thermosiphon Cooling Review A. MORAUX PH Dpt / DT Group CERN SEPTEMBER.
HW2 AHU problems: Book: 8.5, 8.25, 8.27, 8.28, 8.22 Cooling Cycles Problems: - Book: 3.1 (page 69), - Book: 3.5 ((page 70), - Out of book: Same like 3.5.
Hilario J. Negrón (787) ext 3223 (787) Measuring Operational Efficiency.
110 th November 2010EN/CV/DC Detector Cooling Project - advancement status of Work Package N3 Thermosiphon project Michele Battistin 18 May 2011.
CV Activities for PSB-LIU POPS-B (new MPS for the PSB-LIU) B 245 PSB Demi water cooling plant Stefano Moccia, EN-CV Meeting 07/03/16.
Enhancing The Efficiency Of New And Existing Cooling Systems Dr Robert Lamb CEng FInstR Group Sales & Marketing Director Star Refrigeration Ltd.
WELCOME. Glycol Refrigeration A most basic definition of refrigeration is taking heat from someplace we don’t want it and moving it to someplace where.
Update on the PSB Cooling and Ventilation Systems
Lecture Objectives: Discuss HW3 parts d) & e) Learn about HVAC systems
Lecture Objectives: Learn about thermal storage systems
Design of the thermosiphon Test Facilities 2nd Thermosiphon Workshop
The Data Center Challenge
ARAC/H/F Air-cooled water chillers, free-cooling chillers and heat pumps Range: kW.
Lecture Objectives: Discuss Final Project
Lecture Objectives: Continue with Sorption Cooling
Cooling systems for HL-LHC (WP17.3)
COOLING & VENTILATION INFRASTRUCTURE
Lecture Objectives: Answer questions related to HW 4
Lecture Objectives: Discuss HW3 parts d) & e) Learn about HVAC systems
Lecture Objectives: Answer questions related to HW 4
Energy Efficiency in District Coiling System
Objectives Learn about Cooling towers Cooling cycles.
Air Conditioning System-1
Lecture Objectives: Discuss HW4 parts
NRL NRL - Welcome to the NRL Sales Training Program
NRL NRL - Welcome to the NRL Sales Training Program
NRL NRL - Welcome to the NRL Sales Training Program
NRL NRL - Welcome to the NRK Sales Training Program
NRL NRL - Welcome to the NRL Sales Training Program
Presentation transcript:

Chilled water Meyrin consolidation Study 1 st Part Many thanks for their contribution to: Pasquale Alemanno, Fortunato Candito, Alexander Putzu

Outline Loads Proposed layouts System design Parameters “variations” Savings strategies Summary / Conclusions

Loads summary table Courtesy of F. Candito and A. Putzu

Present layout of Installed Cooling Power 378 kW kW 227 kW kW kW 50 kW Eau Perdu Total installed Cooling Power 4640 kW Courtesy of P. Alemanno

Actual cooling power used (Summer) 300 kW 43 m³/h 630 kW 90 m³/h 700 kW 100 m³/h 100 kW 14 m³/h 300 kW 43 m³/h 2195 kW (960 kW buildings kW PS) 315 m³/h Besides POPS (12/18° C), production is 6/12° C. Distribution flows calculated assuming 6 ° C ΔT. Total cooling power: 4225 kW.

Central Plant production/distribution Central Plant: ΔT 6 °C m³/h 249 m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN 65 5 MW cooling tower, axial fans. Centrifugal Chillers with VFD compressors. Chiller staging control. Primary/Secondary (VFD). No buffer tank. Two sets of chilled water pumps.

Two Main Plants production/distribution Summer Plant “PSB area”: ΔT 6 °C m³/h 249 m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN 65 Plant “PS area”: ΔT 6 °C m³/h

Two Main Plants production/distribution Winter (based on 50% load) Plant “PSB area”: Shut down 124 m³/h DN 150- DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN m³/h DN 65 Plant “PS area”: ΔT 6 °C m³/h 193 m³/h DN 200

Standard flow vs Low flow 4225 kW cooling COP 6 -> 5 MW tower Condenser water inlet 25 ° C ( 21 ° C w.b.) Standard flowLow flow Chilled water Supply T (°C)66 Chilled water ΔT (°K)68 Condenser water ΔT (°K)510 Chilled water flow (m³/h) Condenser water flow (m³/h)861430

Standard (kW)Low flow (kW)Standard -> Low flow Chiller705753Higher lift due to higher condenser temperature, Chilled water pump17574Same pipes and accessories size ΔP=K*Flow 1.85 Cooling tower fans9060Tower 30% smaller Condenser water pump7035Smaller pipes, ΔP about the same, half flow TOTAL Power Comparison

Central Plant production/distribution Central Plant: ΔT 8 °C m³/h 187 m³/h DN m³/h DN 150-> m³/h DN m³/h DN 100-> m³/h DN 250-> m³/h DN 200-> m³/h DN 100->80 10 m³/h DN 65->50

Further analysis: Impact on AHUs (fan power with bigger batteries and/or different control valves). General considerations Low flow about 10% less power “hungry”. Assuming VFDs for cooling tower fans and chilled water pumps and constant condenser water flow, even at part load the chilled water system benefits from “Low flow”. Anyway, part load analysis needed with actual manufacturer data for cooling towers and chillers. Low flow can be used with standard flow (bigger) tower size, therefore approach can be reduced: colder condenser water. Higher lift will be offset by colder condenser water inlet. Keeping same piping size and tower as in standard flow conditions, would allow for future system expansion with a careful choice of new chiller parameters.

Further savings strategies Increase Chilled water supply temperature 6 °C -> 8 °C. This would represent a saving of about 7% on chiller power. Chilled water temperature reset at part load: about 0.5%- 1% /°C chiller power reduction. Reset condenser water temperature as w.b. falls: about 1% /°C chiller power reduction. Is there a real need for 6°C chilled water setpoint? Put in place all the means to monitor chilled water ΔT and energy consumption. Keep the ΔT as close as possible to design value: system balancing use of two way control valves, avoid unnecessary water bypasses, no three way valves (just for minimum flow and remote locations), shut off clients not using water, verify that the instrumentation is placed and calibrated well in order to avoid excessive valve opening, verify batteries cleanliness.

Foreseen budget for a central plant (VERY preliminary) Main componentsEuros Hydraulics and accessories for main plant (3 condenser pumps, 3 evaporator pumps, 4 distribution pumps, 2 cooling towers, piping and accessories) 1,200,000 3 Chillers600,000 Electricity400,000 Main distribution piping600,000 Terminal loads modifications (AHU batteries, heat exchangers,…) 500,000 Civil Engineering? Total3,300,000 + ?

Conclusions/Future study development Low flow system seems a better choice. Review the need of 6 °C chilled water supply temperature. Monitor the loads during the next summer and winter. Try to get an idea of future system expansion needs if any. Meet Chiller manufacturer (end of this month) for better understanding: equipment size, load split (1/3 + 2/3, 50%/50%, else….), VFD compressors, Cooling power redundancy (1 air cooled chiller as a backup during cooling tower maintenance or main chillers failure?), the phase out of HFC refrigerants in favour of more “green” refrigerants like HFO. Collect info from Cooling tower manufacturer (variation of size, fan power, approach…). Identify Life cycle costs (purchase price, installation, operation, maintenance,..) CE study for central plant vs two main plants. Heat exchanger economizer, heat recovery?