Community Based Monitoring System for Access to Basic Minimum Services, Kerala D Narayana Slim Haddad Smitha Aravind Katia Mohindra Access to Health Care.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Global Child Poverty Study Sierra Leone Report to the Regional Workshop in Abidjan 12 th -14 th February 2008.
Advertisements

Policies and Procedures for Civil Society Participation in GEF Programme and Projects presented by GEF NGO Network ECW.
Area Profiles Worcestershire Partnership Management Group David Onions Corporate Business Intelligence and Performance Manager.
HEALTH EQUITY: THE INDIAN CONTEXT Subodh S Gupta.
Social Protection in India: Two Initiatives K.P. Kannan, Member National Commission for Enterprises in the Unorganised Sector, New Delhi, and Fellow, Centre.
NRHM DISTRICT ACTION PLANS PARTICIPATORY & EVIDENCE BASED PLANNING PROCESS.
Access to Health Care and Basic Minimum Services in Kerala, India An overview of the project A CDS-UdeM Action-Research Initiative.
India Case Study ICDS and TINP. Context In the 1960s, the GOI initiated intervention measures to deal with food shortage and protein deficiency In the.
CIVICS.
Government of India Policy Reform in Family Welfare Program of India : Community Mobilization & Community Participation under Reproductive & Child Health.
1 Who are the Beneficiaries of the Poverty Alleviation Programs in Rural India? Takahiro Sato (Osaka City University) A Preliminary Analysis on the Consequences.
Moving towards the goal of Universal Health Coverage (UHC) in Bangladesh Md. Ashadul Islam Director General Health Economics Unit Ministry of Health and.
UGANDA NATIONAL PANEL SURVEY PROGRAM DECEMBER 2013 By James Muwonge, Uganda Bureau of Statistics Uganda Bureau of Statistics.
Key Challenges for Women’s Leadership in Local Government Ratna M. Sudarshan Director, Institute of Social Studies Trust, New Delhi.
Child Care Systems Reforms In Eastern Europe and Central Asia Why we need to focus on children below three years Sofia conference November 2012 Jean-Claude.
Local Police Planning and Scrutiny ACC McCormick, Local Policing East
Integration of Agricultural Statistics System in India A Presentation By Dhrijesh K Tiwari Fourth International Conference on Agriculture Statistics,
9/2/20151 Ohio Family and Children First An overview of OFCF structure, membership, and responsibilities.
Presentation on SOCIAL AUDIT ( )
J. Finnish Aid in a PRSP context Helsinki workshop 19 th – 21 st May 2003 Day 3: Consultants & Researchers.
Land in the SDGs discussion Annual World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty 24 March 2015 Washington DC.
Decentralised Planning in Uttar Pradesh. 2 The Previous Process The decentralised planning process was actually implemented in the State from financial.
Poverty Ms. C. Rughoobur Africa Statistics Day 18 November 2013.
2 Economical Information  Afg/US$  GDP in US$ (Mn)  Population Growth 2.03  GDP/Capita (US$) 500  GDP Growth Rate 17.1  Inflation Rate.
Ryve Prekorogja 13 June VET Vocational Education and Training.
SEILA Program and the Role of Commune Database Information System (CDIS) Poverty and Economic Policy (PEP) Research Network Meeting June 2004, Dakar,
Role of CBOs towards Inclusion - P. Stephen, IRCDS.
Universalisation of Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) in Tripura A presentation by Shri S.K.Panda Principal Secretary, Government of Tripura.
GUIDELINES FOR INTEGRATING POPULATION INFORMATION INTO IDPs Taking Population Trends Seriously in your IDP PRESENTED NOLWAZI DLAMINI
Governance and Usefulness of Data Generating Through LLPMS IBRAHIM KHALIL UPAZILA NIRBAHI OFFICER DAUDKANDI, BANGLADESH.
LEAD NURSE EVENT 29/1/09 CENSUS INFORMATION/FEEDBACK.
National Conference on “Water and Sanitation for All in Madhya Pradesh: Opportunities and Challenges” Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh 23rd September, 2010 At :
L&R Social Research The Implementation of Gender Budgeting in Austria Lessons Learned from Existing Initiatives Peter Prenner & Claudia Sorger L&R Social.
Capacity Building and Information Technology under BRGF Ministry of Panchayati Raj Government of India 14 October, 2007.
Mainstreaming Ageing: Key Operational Challenges Dr. Ann Pawliczko Population and Development Branch Technical Support Division United Nations Population.
Access to Health Care and Basic Minimum Services in Kerala, India The CBHSS Sali, 18 juin 2004 D. Narayana, S. Haddad.
Progress update on developing Health Sector Strategic Plan (HSSP IV) Joint Annual Health Sector Review Technical Review Meeting Wednesday 5 th.
Welcome to Save the Children’s Presentation on Household Economic and Food Security of Extreme Poor me to Save the Children’s Presentation on Household.
GOVERNMENT OF TRIPURA TRIBAL WELFARE DEPARTMENT Presentation by Mr. L.H. Darlong, Secretary.
31st Jan- 2nd Feb, 2007CHF best practice WS, Golden Tulip Hotel, DSM 031st Jan - 2nd February Mtwara Mikindani Muncipal Council Preparing for the.
Integrating the poverty agenda into the SOA A Rural Perspective Annette Johnston.
1 REPUBLIC OF MOZAMBIQUE MINISTRY OF WOMAN AND SOCIAL ACTION “A policy dialogue and a south-south learning event on long term social protection and inclusive.
The RDI Governance System Vasileios Pitsinigkos Head of Managing Authority of Eastern Macedonia - Thrace Region.
Policies and Procedures for Civil Society Participation in GEF Programme and Projects presented by GEF NGO Network ECW.
th September 2009 MIS-Workshop Presented by: A.K. Bhatnagar District Informatics Officer, Shivpuri Strengthening of MIS in District Shivpuri.
Strange Bedfellows: Building and Maintaining Collaborations between, among, and within State agencies for PROMISE Grant partnerships.
@NHS_WLG The ageing workforce - responding to the challenge.
Institutional Change and its Impact on the Poor and Excluded: The Indian Decentralisation Experience D Narayana, Centre for Development Studies, Trivandrum,
Learning Lessons from Experience: good practice case studies Inclusive Education Title : Identification and referral of the Children with disabilities.
Investing in Children’s services - Improving outcomes across Europe 26 November 2015, Paris, ChildONEurope seminar esn-eu.org.
1 CENSUS August 2011 SECRET. 2 Outline of Presentation  Census Benefits  Previous Censuses Difficulties and Outcomes  Census 2011 Key Dates.
MBULU DISTRICT COUNCIL COMMUNITY PARTICIPATION CHF DR. GURISHA J. W. DMO - MBULU.
Presentation on “national award for the BEST GOVT
DAMIAN O’SULLIVAN JULY 9, 2015 Marginalized Groups in Mysore’s Panchayati Raj Institutions.
By Muhammad Ali Khan Future of Local Govt In Pakistan.
Tanzanian German Programme to Support Health Monitoring and Evaluation Susanne Pritze-Aliassime.
A CATALYST FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT FOR A BETTER LIFE FOR ALL1 CAPRICORN DISTRICT MUNICIPALITY DISTRICT-WIDE HIV AND AIDS RESPONSE PROGRAM 02 DECEMBER.
1 MONITORING OF THE INDICATORS OF MDG: EXPERIENCE OF THE KYRGYZ REPUBLIC Turdubayeva Chinara Chief of the Division of Consolidated Works and Information.
Theo van der Loop Senior Expert on Mission for ILO
Interstate statistical committee
General process of discussion
Fiscal Decentralization to Rural Governments
District Disaster Risk Reduction Managment Plan
Decentralised Health Planning: “The Process of Conversion of key Community Health demands into Budget” Regional Consultation on Community Action for Health.
EVALUATION IN THE PUBLIC SECTOR
Summary.
KIRIBATI IW R2R PROJECT OUTLINE OF PRESENTATION: PROGRESS
Radanar Ayar Association
Stocktaking of Early Childhood Development (ECD)
Presentation transcript:

Community Based Monitoring System for Access to Basic Minimum Services, Kerala D Narayana Slim Haddad Smitha Aravind Katia Mohindra Access to Health Care and Basic Minimum Services in Kerala, India Sali, 18 June, 2004

SH/2003 Two Objectives u Intervention: Health Solidarity Scheme u Monitoring: Community Based Monitoring System

SH/2003

Implications of Panchayati Raj/ Municipalities as the Third Tier of Governance in India's Federal Structure State Panchayat Raj Zylla P. Block P. Gram P. Gram Sabha Municipality M. Corporation M. Council Nagar P. Ward meetings Autonomous Councils for Tribal Areas Union Source: Figure 2, Mathew, G and Mathew, A (2003)

SH/2003 Salient Features of Local Governance u Persons chosen by direct election to fill seats u Seats shall be reserved for Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribes u One-third the number of seats reserved for women u Offices of chairperson shall also be reserved for women / SC or ST u Plan for economic development and social justice

SH/2003 Planning and monitoring at panchayat level u Development projects identified from Gram sabha u Working groups formulate projects and monitor implementation u Need to go beyond- to monitor impacts u Sectoral allocation of funds u In most of the cases equal distribution of fund among wards irrespective of the needs

SH/2003 Planning/Monitoring without data u India has an elaborate statistical system u But hardly any data available below the district level u Decentralized governance calls for database at the local level u Line departments carry out regular surveys u But hardly any database at the Panchayat level

SH/2003 Community Based Monitoring System for Access to Basic Minimum Services- Outcome u Set of relevant information and available longitudinal measures through population-based information systems. u Increased knowledge of characteristics of vulnerable populations- poor, women and tribes. u Improved evidence-based planning and skills. u Feedback on implemented programs

SH/2003 Distinguishing Features- Partnership Development/ Participation u Participation as the foundation u Steering Committee u representatives from state/district governments, local govt., local NGO, research team u discusses all issues and approaches u Local Coordination Committee u representatives from local government, NGO, women’s groups, research team u all issues placed before the committee, discussed, suggestions taken in

SH/2003 The need for a database in the Panchayat u Survey of surveys showed lack of a database u Many surveys but hardly any systematic use of data u How a survey became a census u A database built up, analysis going on

SH/2003 Interaction with the Working Groups u Preliminary results of the census presented before WG members u Encouraging response- general recognition that information was of great value u The challenge of transferring the know how of building database and using u Decision to set up a Resource Group (KRG)

SH/2003 The Kottathara Resource Group (KRG) u KRG set up but met after 5 postponements and delay of six months. u The meeting aiming at familiarizing the members with the database did not take place after two postponements u Current thinking of LCC- KRG not workable

SH/2003 Interaction in Gram Sabha (Village Assembly) u Presentation of indicators: u First time the population were exposed to such process u Very well received. u The database seen as an important input for planning u Gathering information on a regular basis seen as very useful for local planning u Monitoring? u Questions repeatedly asked: u What can be done with the data? u What is next?

SH/2003 Working Reports u 7 Profiles: 1. General Profile; 2. Poverty Profile 3. Health Profile 4. Access to Basic Services 5. Gender Profile 6. Tribal Profile 7. Financial Protection u Sources u Database u Other available secondary sources

Project Products (reports) CBMS CBHSS Working group report Review of tribal schemes « Goat » report Guiding principles CBHSS Survey of Health facilities Health information system Survey of colonies Profiles Survey of surveys

Working group meeting on CBMS Monitoring population needs and project impacts: a practical example. Kottathara Panchayat Office November, 13, 2003 Access to Health Care and Basic Minimum Services in Kerala, India

SH/2003 Case study u Database: u CBMS Household survey (April, 2003) u Data available to date: wards 2, 3, 4, 5, 6. u Indicator used for the example: u Households receiving any of the following benefits: u Agricultural, Widow, Old Age, Child, Disability, Other

SH/2003 The monitoring process u Part 1: What is the current situation? u How many households? u Where are the households that are receiving benefits? u Who are the households that are receiving these benefits? u Part 2: What is the progress? u Monitoring changes u in needs, inequalities

Part 1: What is the current situation?

SH/2003 Households receiving benefits

SH/2003 Where are the households receiving benefits?

SH/2003 Who are the households receiving benefits?

SH/2003 Who and where? Percentage of households receiving benefits

Graph. presentation Percentage of households receiving benefits

Part 2: monitoring change

Monitoring progress: the before – after approach

THANK YOU