Łukasz Goczek, Dagmara Mycielska WNE UW.  Central concept  Definition  The aim of the paper  Main hypothesis  Verification strategy  Results.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Cointegration and Error Correction Models
Advertisements

Financial Econometrics
Macroeconomic Policies in Open Economy
1 Central Bank Macroeconomic Modeling Workshop Jerusalem, October 2009 Discussion on Financial Shocks and Optimal Monetary Policy in Small Open Economies.
Dejan Krušec PhD Student European University Institute Rethymno, Rethymno, Outline of research in the area of EMU – Current state.
EXCHANGE RATE RISK CASE STUDY ROMANIA STUDENT: ŞUTA CORNELIA-MĂDĂLINA SUPERVISOR: PROF. MOISĂ ALTĂR.
Vector Autoregressive Models
International Fixed Income Topic IVA: International Fixed Income Pricing - Hedging.
ESDS Conference London November 2006 A Cointegration Analysis of EMU Convergence of the CEEC5 EU Accession Countries ANDREY DAMIANOV MSc FCCA MBA Oxford.
Katarina Juselius Department of Economics University of Copenhagen.
What Explains Germany’s Rebounding Export Market Share Stephan Danninger (IMF Research Department) Fred Joutz (George Washington University) September.
Obstfeld, Shambaugh & Taylor (2005).  Hypotheses Regimes with fixed exchange rates will experience less monetary policy autonomy. Regimes with restrictions.
Vector Error Correction and Vector Autoregressive Models
The role of inflation expectations in the New EU Member States Student: DORINA COBÎSCAN Supervisor: PhD. Professor MOISĂ ALTĂR Bucharest, 2010 THE ACADEMY.
The problematic natures of the EMU project Malcolm Sawyer University of Leeds.
Statistics II: An Overview of Statistics. Outline for Statistics II Lecture: SPSS Syntax – Some examples. Normal Distribution Curve. Sampling Distribution.
„The OCA Theory and its Application to Central and Eastern European Countries“ Zuzana Kucerova Technical University of Ostrava Faculty of Economics.
The Role of Financial System in Economic Growth Presented By: Saumil Nihalani.
Exchange Rates Theories Asset Approach. Goods flows and Capital flows When there is not much international capital flows, TB>0  Currency appreciation.
Chapter 18 Exchange Rate Theories. Copyright © 2007 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved Topics to be Covered The Asset Approach The Monetary.
Expectations and Macroeconomics Chapter Introduction We have put together a complete model of aggregate demand, supply and wage adjustment.
Richard M. Jacobs, OSA, Ph.D.
Advantage of Fixed Exchange Rate Regime in Latvia Konstantins Benkovskis Head of Monetary Research and Forecasting Division.
Political Economy of European Monetary Integration Europe in World Economy 2015 Vladan Hodulak.
Jarir Ajluni. Background Background: The Korean Miracle Key Achievements of the Korean Economy  Growth. (GDP per capita doubled 11 times during 1960.
Interest Rates. An interest rate is the rate at which interest is paid by a borrower for the use of money that they borrow from a lender. For example,
Exchange rates and exchange rate regimes International Finance
International capital market integration International macro, miniterm III, January 2007.
2 LIBERALIZATION, PRODUCTIVITY AND AGGREGATE EXPENDITURE: FUNDAMENTAL DETERMINANTS OF REAL EQUILIBRIUM EXCHANGE RATE Juan Benítez Gabriela Mordecki XI.
Chapter 24. The open economy with fixed exchange rates ECON320 Prof Mike Kennedy.
THE COLLAPSE OF PURCHASING POWER PARITIES DURING THE 197Os Jacob A. FRENKEL Mahmood AL-Shammari Part one ( )
Monetary Policy and Exchange Rate Pass-through: Theory and Evidence Michael B. Devereux and James Yetman.
DETERMINANTS OF INFLATION IN ROMANIA Student: COVRIG NICOLAE Supervisor: Prof. MOISĂ ALTĂR.
OPEN ECONOMY MACRO AND THE EXCHANGE RATE (1) Up to now, we have ignored the exchange rate: i.e. the price of foreign currency in terms of domestic currency.
Should the CNB Devaluate the Exchange Rate? 23/06/2010 Dubrovnik Marina Tkalec - Maruška Vizek 16 th Young Economists’ Seminar Should the Croatian National.
Discussion of “Fiscal Shocks and the Real Exchange Rate” by Agustin S. Bénétrix & Philp R. Lane Davide Furceri OECD, University of Palermo Banco de Espana.
Challenges for Inflation Targeting in EM in View of the Current Global Crisis by Leonardo Leiderman Berglas School of Economics, Tel-Aviv University, Israel.
KYIV SCHOOL OF ECONOMICS MACROECONOMICS II November-December 2013 Instructor: Maksym Obrizan Lecture notes V # 2. CHAPTER 10. Money, Exchange Rates, and.
Doctoral School of Finance and Banking Bucharest Uncovered interest parity and deviations from uncovered interest parity MSc student: Alexandru-Chidesciuc.
The Academy of Economic Studies Bucharest The Faculty of Finance, Insurance, Banking and Stock Exchange DOFIN - Doctoral School of Finance and Banking.
Why Do Countries Use Capital Controls? Prepared by R. Barry Johnston and Natalia T. Tamirisa - December 1998 Presented by: Alyaa Ezzat.
Esds Economic and Social Data Service ESDS International Annual Conference LONDON November 30 th, 2009 Giorgio Castagneto Gissey, BSc University of Warwick,
Exchange rate economics: A carry on in France Michael Metcalfe Head of Global Macro Strategy June 2007.
26-1 Economics: Theory Through Applications This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported.
DETERMINANTS OF SPREADS OF ROMANIAN SOVEREIGN BONDS - an application on the EMBIG spreads – Student: BERBECARU CLAUDIA-FLORIANA Supervisor: Professor MOISĂ.
ECON 511 International Finance & Open Macroeconomy CHAPTER THREE The Monetary Approach to Flexible Exchange Rates.
Mobile: Macroeconomics & The Global Economy -Term III Ace Institute of Management Session 10: The Mundell-Fleming.
Convergence of Government Bond Yields in the Euro Zone: The Role of Policy Harmonization Denise Côté and Christopher Graham International Department 28.
NURHIKMAH OLA LAIRI (LAILUOLA) Ph.D International Trade Student Id :
The AD-AS Model Lecture 14 – academic year 2013/14 Introduction to Economics Fabio Landini.
Exchange Rate Regimes: Is the Bipolar view correct? Stanley Fischer Class: International Finance & Open Macroeconomy Dr. Nayef N. Al-shammari Date 5th.
EFFICIENCY AND IMPACT OF ECB POLICY ANNOUNCEMENTS KERSTIN BERNOTH & JURGEN VON HAGENZ FOR EUROPEAN INTEGRATION STUDIES AND UNIVERSITY OF BONN, INDIANA.
BY ABU BAKARR TARAWALIE AND CHRISTIAN R. K. AHORTOR A Paper Prepared for the Third Annual Conference on Regional Integration in Africa (ACRIA3) Dakar,
MLI28C060 - Corporate Finance Seminar 1. Question 1. What are the eight contemporary currency regimes as defined by the IMF? Provide examples where possible.
Preconditions for Inflation Targeting in an Emerging Economy: The Case of India Presented By Ankita Mishra Authored By Vinod Mishra & Ankita Mishra Australian.
MONEY SUPPLY AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN SRI LANKA (An Empirical Re - Examination of Monetarist Concept)
E NTE PER LE N UOVE TECNOLOGIE L’ E NERGIA E L’ A MBIENTE The causality between energy consumption and economic growth: A multi-sectoral analysis using.
An Introduction to Error Correction Models (ECMs)
Seðlabanki Íslands Is inflation control more difficult in very small open economies? The Challenges of Globalisation for Small Open Economies with Independent.
Financial Econometrics Lecture Notes 4
Exchange Rate Theories
Ch8 Time Series Modeling
Monetary Policy Transmission Mechanism in Zambia
Is there Causal Association between Exchange Rate and Inflation in Africa? A Panel Granger Causality Analysis Mamo Girma   African Economic Conference.
ECON 511 International Finance & Open Macroeconomy CHAPTER FIVE
Interest Rate Linkages within the European Monetary System: A Time Series Analysis 授课教授:杨奕农 学 生:文仲琴.
The Determinants of FDI Inflows to Greece
Presentation transcript:

Łukasz Goczek, Dagmara Mycielska WNE UW

 Central concept  Definition  The aim of the paper  Main hypothesis  Verification strategy  Results

 The assumption of full monetary policy independence in an open economy with floating exchange rates lies at the heart of most analyses concerning Polish economy.  Numerous studies of the monetary policy independence that are based on the now classical concepts of "impossible trinity" and the theory of optimum currency areas show that the primary long-run cost of participation in a common currency area is the loss of independence of the monetary policy.

 Under capital mobility, a country that wants to pursue an independent monetary policy, oriented toward the domestic economy, must allow its exchange rate to float.  If, on the other hand, the country fixes its exchange rate, it must follow the monetary policy of the anchor country. Because monetary policy is determined abroad, the country has in this case effectively lost monetary policy independence.

 Monetary policy independence is understood as the ability of the central bank to set interest rates independently of international rates.

 In the paper, we analyze if monetary policy in our focus economy, Poland, was ‘determined’ abroad - that is, was dominated by the policies of the larger monetary area.  4 explanations for this hypothesis: ◦ two endogenous (growing financial integration, global inflation component) ◦ two exogenous (fear of floating, inflation targeting errors).  Goczek, Mycielska, 2012.

 The main hypothesis of the paper:  Poland currently has no de facto independence in monetary policy, and changes in the Polish monetary policy are largely a consequence of the monetary policy changes led by the ECB.

 According to the target zone models the interest rates may diverge persistently under a flexible exchange rate regime only if the domestic policies are credible and the monetary authority primarily targets domestic economic variables such as inflation and output.  Therefore the size and the length of the deviation then can be used to measure the degree of monetary policy independence. That may be interpreted as the degree to which the domestic interest rates follow international interest rates.

 If a steady state relationship exists between interest rates in the two monetary areas, and furthermore one country adjusts to this relationship, while the other does not, then this is evidence in favor of monetary dependence of the adjusting country on the non-adjusting one.

 Cointegration testing of nominal interest rates in Poland and the EMU.  Based on the results of cointegration testing a Vector Error Correction Mechanism (VECM) model is constructed.  The model is then used to test several parametric hypotheses concerning the speed and asymmetry of adjustment between interest rates in Poland and EMU that allow determining the causality between monetary policies of both currency areas.

 Bivariate data: WIBOR and EURIBOR 3m rates  Date span: Floating of złoty (1st April 2001) till the 30th of April 2013  Frequency: daily, weekly, and monthly. Monthly results are given.

Figure 1. Three-month WIBOR and EURIBOR interest rates ( ). Source: Own

 Let us consider two time series for domestic and international interest rates that form a bivariate data vector X­ t given by: (1)  The domestic interbank interest rate (WIBOR_3M) is denoted by r t, the international interbank interest rate (EURIBOR_3M) is denoted by r t *. The two variables are used to form a Vector Autoregressive (VAR) model described by the following equation:  (2)

 If P is of reduced rank, then there exists coefficient matrices so that:  And eq. (3) can be transformed to the VECM form, contingent of the first order of integration of the data: (4) The first RH term is the cointegrating vector showing the steady state relationship between the interest rates forming uncovered interest rate parity.

 If the matrix is of rank one, this means that a single cointegrating vector exists. Then the cointegrating vector can be rewritten to be:

 All the diagnostics and the strategy are outlined in more detail in the paper.  The diagnostic tests gave no grounds to question the specification.  Out of all testing the models showing least favorable to our hypotheses were chosen (always on the safe side of the main hypotheses)  During these selections a model with most conservative predictions was selected. Most of the rejected models have shown a much higher degree of Polish monetary policy dependence.

 As a robustness check the same methodology was used to examine the relationship between WIBOR and LIBOR rate, since the dependence of Polish interest rates on the LIBOR is smaller.  The LIBOR term is insignificant in the cointegrating equation. The variance decomposition exercise shows that there was no relationship between LIBOR and WIBOR. This allows us to argue, that the methodology correctly permits to discriminate between dependence and independence in domestic monetary policy.

 Based on the above it can be concluded that the empirical hypotheses investigation has brought the following results: 1. There exists a positive risk premium for investing in Poland. 2. There are no grounds to reject the hypothesis of no nominal interest rate convergence between Poland and the Eurozone. There exists a steady state in which the risk premium for investing in Poland does not diminish.

3. The results allow for arguing that the degree of monetary independence in Poland is low, but it does exist to a certain extent. At the same time Polish interest rates adjust to the changes in interest rates in the Eurozone for a given disequilibrium to the steady-state. 4. As expected, the international interest rates do not depend on the changes in monetary policy in Poland. 5. The hypothesis of a one-to-one relationship between interest rates between Poland and the Eurozone should be rejected.

 Based on the empirical results it could be argued, that small open economies like Poland, fully integrated financially with a monetary area, do not lose much monetary independence when they decide to enter a common currency area.  This is due to the fact that it is impossible to enjoy this independence while being so dependent on financial flows from the major financial area and a country cannot lose something that it does not have in the first place.

 The confirmation of the hypothesis of a very low monetary independence in Poland in the empirical model shown in the paper allows arguing that the EMU joining could potentially have smaller costs than it was argued in the NBP (2009) report, in which it is assumed a priori that Poland enjoys full monetary independence.

Thank you