1 Short selling and clearing and settlement in Europe: relations and implications Daniela Russo and Simonetta Rosati.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Copyright© 2003 John Wiley and Sons, Inc. Power Point Slides for: Financial Institutions, Markets, and Money, 8 th Edition Authors: Kidwell, Blackwell,

Advertisements

1 Regulating Short Selling: The European Framework(s) and the Regulatory Arbitrages Giampaolo Gabbi and Paola Giovinazzo.

1 Financing Techniques for Short Sellers Stuart McCrary.

1 Regulating Short Sales in the 21 st Century Houman B. Shadab Associate Professor of Law New York Law School.

1 Short Selling Consistency in South Africa David E Allen, Robert J Powell and Abhay K Singh.

Reverse Transactions Complex (hence long paper) Lack of clarity in existing standards for repos and gold swaps; securities lending and gold loans not discussed.

Development of a Mongolian MBS Market Workshop on Housing Finance 28th June 2011 Presented by Jim France.

Importance of Functioning Repo and Securities Lending Markets 7 th Summit for an Enlarged Europe.

CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT THE COMMODITISATION OF CREDIT RISK TRENDS IN CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT.

1 Why the World Bank Successful Privatisations are Useful for the Audit of Privatisation? The World Bank rich experience worldwide through providing technical.

ACSDA Leadership Forum CDS Financial Risk Model Summary of Key Financial Risk Controls Nauman Mahmood, Managing Financial Risk Director October 9,2007.

CPSS-IOSCO Principles for FMIs and TM Assessments Ana Giraldo

Offshore Transmission Giles Stevens Head of offshore electricity transmission.

FMI Principles Relevant issues for CSDs

The role of ACER In the Regional Initiatives Steve Gordon Head Of the Gas Department North West Regional Initiatives 2011.

A DTCCThomson Reuters Company Omgeo Industry Relations Briefing on T+2 in Europe Thomas Trepanier Director of Relationship Management Americas Region.

S.D. INDEVAL / Securities Clearing and Settlement System

Copyright© 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.1 Power Point Slides for: Financial Institutions, Markets, and Money, 9 th Edition Authors: Kidwell, Blackwell,

Collateralized Borrowing and Lending Obligation

Page 1 © 2011 Thomas Murray Ltd. Shortening the Equity Settlement Cycle: Prospects, Hurdles and Goals of a Global Move to T+2 March 2011.

1 Role and Responsibilities of CSD in China's Investor Protection Scheme SHEN Bing Panel Discussion at 16 th Annual Meeting of ACG Bali, September 20,

Clearing and Settlement Risk Management

Clearing and Settlement  Tarmiden Sitorus Deputy Director Bank Indonesia Conference on Development of Indonesian Government Bond Market July

Risk Management in Financial Institutions (II) 1 Risk Management in Financial Institutions (II): Hedging with Financial Derivatives Forwards Futures Options.

The Repo Market International Fixed Income. Readings Repo’s gone global and hip Innovation is the key Merrill Lynch guide to international repo.

Copyright © 2002 Pearson Education, Inc. Slide 9-1.

Chapter 13 Financial Derivatives. © 2004 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved 13-2 Hedging Hedge: engage in a financial transaction that reduces.

Designing a New and Balanced Financial Market Structure in Post-Crisis Asia: Policy Recommendations for Strengthening Banking Industry and Developing Corporate.

Developing Corporate Debt Market in India The 3 rd Invest India Debt Market Round Table May 6, 2003 Rakesh Mohan Deputy Governor Reserve Bank of India.

Economics 330 Money and Banking Lecture 18 Prof. Menzie Chinn TAs: Chikako Baba, Deokwoo Nam.

Pricing in the world financial markets Husniddin Rahmatullaev.

1 Is There A Room For Regulatory Improvement? Facts Need for Improvement? A Few Ideas Kristijan Polenak, member of MSE Board Partner, Polenak Law Firm.

ISSUES SURROUNDING THE DEVELOPMENT OF MUNICIPAL AND CORPORATE BOND MARKETS IN ZAMBIA “DEVELOPING GOVERNMENT BOND MARKETS IN SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA” WORKSHOP.

ACSDA Seminar Next Challenges in Depository, Clearance and Settlement Services - CCP Opportunities - Margarida Baptista November 15, 2002.

NAVIGATING REGULATION ACI Moscow 17 th March 2011 Robin Poynder, Head of FX & Money Markets, EMEA.

4. Money market International financial services 1

Understand financial markets to recognize their importance in business. Types of financial markets Money market, Capital market, Insurance market,

Overview of the Financial System

Chapter 14 Financial Derivatives. © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.14-2 Hedging Engage in a financial transaction that reduces or eliminates.

13-1 Hedging Hedge: engage in a financial transaction that reduces or eliminates risk Basic hedging principle: Hedging risk involves engaging in a financial.

Currency Futures Introduction and Example. 2 Financial instruments Future contracts: –Contract agreement providing for the future exchange of a particular.

SECTION IV DERIVATIVES. FUTURES AND OPTIONS CONTRACTS RISK MANAGEMENT TOOLS THEY ARE THE AGREEMENTS ON BUYING AND SELLING OF THESE INSTRUMENTS AT THE.

© 2004 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved 13-1 Hedging Hedge: engage in a financial transaction that reduces or eliminates risk Basic hedging.

Copyright © 2010 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 14 Financial Derivatives.

1 Financial Market Development: Sequencing Of Reforms To Ensure Stability Presented By V. Sundararajan Fi fth Annual Financial Markets And Development.

SUPERVISION FRAMEWORK FOR CLEARING AND SETTLEMENT SYSTEMS: MAIN ELEMENTS AND SOME ISSUES TO INCLUDE IN THE OVERSIGHT OF THE SYSTEMS Global Payments Week.

Chapter Two Overview of the Financial System Slide 2–3 Function of Financial Markets Allows transfers of funds from person or business without investment.

Financial Institutions and Markets Fall 2009 Dr. Andrew L. H. Parkes Day 10 “How do financial markets work?” 卜安吉.

CHAPTER 11 FUTURES, FORWARDS, SWAPS, AND OPTIONS MARKETS.

Investment Analysis Lecture1 Introduction: Financial System, Institutions & Instruments Nadir Khan Mengal 5/4/2010.

Issues in Market Transparency for Credit Derivatives: Price, Volume, and Exposure Information Presented to the IMF-FSB Users Conference 8 July 2009 Christopher.

The Importance of National Payments Systems in Reducing Market Risk S.W.I.F.T. Regional Conference in Central and Eastern Europe Prague, Czech Republic:

Currency Futures Introduction and Example. 2 Financial instruments Future contracts: –Contract agreement providing for the future exchange of a particular.

CHAPTER FIVE How Securities Are Traded Cleary / Jones Investments: Analysis and Management.

Chapter 2 An Overview of the Financial System. © 2013 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved.2-2 Function of Financial Markets Perform the essential.

Suffolk County Council Securities Finance Date: 19 th January, 2009 Location: Ipswich.

Money and Banking Lecture 33. Review of the Previous Lecture Central Bank Roles Objectives Inflation Growth Financial System Interest rate and exchange.

Risk Management Lecture1 Introduction: Financial System, Institutions & Instruments Nadir Khan.

082SIS52 Ryu Soo-hyun. Money Market  Money Market - Subsection of fixed income market - financial market for short-term borrowing & lending - provides.

Presentation On Capital Market Regulatory Framework.

Washington 2008: G20 policies to fix the fault lines

Principles for Recovery and Resolution of a Financial Market Infrastructure ACSDA Senior Leadership Summit – November 16 & 17, 2015.

An Overview of the Financial System

CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT

Unravelling Ariadne's MiFID II Thread: Pre- and post-trade transparency for non-equity markets JORGE YZAGUIRRE SCHARFHAUSEN.

CHAPTER 7 Money Markets.

FINANCIAL DERIVATIVES/SNSCT/MBA

Investor protection and MIFID

Update on Assessment and Disclosure Initiatives

Presentation transcript:

1 Short selling and clearing and settlement in Europe: relations and implications Daniela Russo and Simonetta Rosati

2 Reading Questions 1. What are the relations between short selling and settlement fails 2. What are the main factors determining settlement fails? 3. What are the consequences of fails? 4. When does a short sale transaction give rise to a settlement risk? 5. What are the measures and rules in place to address short selling and settlement fails? 6. In particular, what are the measures to prevent fails? 7. And, what are the measures to discourage fails? 8. And what are the measures to mitigate effects of fails? 9. What are the relations between short-selling market discipline and settlement discipline? 10. How do short sales have any impact on effectiveness of market discipline?

3 Short selling and settlement fails Shirt selling may result in a non-delivery of traded assets on the settlement date (i.e. settlement fails). This could, in turn, has the potential to degenerate into systemic risks, which ultimately may undermine confidence in the use of the relevant market infrastructure and of the related financial market segment (e.g. repo market).

4 Main factors determining fails Operational risks (e.g. breakdown suffered by Bank of New York un 1985) Liquidity problemsn of major investors Lack of incentives to avoid fails

5 Main consequences of fails Credit risks for major market players (in case they have paid for the delivery of assets that will not be delivered) Liquidity risk of major market players (due to the need to buy the non delivered assets in the relevant market) Systemic effects that will contribute to increase the fails and prolong their duration

6 Short sale and settlement risk Naked short selling is considered more prone to settlement risk because of the limited time available to find the assets needed for the settlement Additional settlement risk can be created by strategic fails (i.e. fails provoked by the unwillingness to borrow assets, when their costs is more costly than the cost of the fail)

Measures to prevent fails Use of automated procedures for transmission and matching of settlement instructions Use of Central Counterparties More information/transparency on the transactions that are likely to fail Liquidity optinmisation measures 7

8 Measures to discourage fails Increase the cost of fails Forbid short sales

9 Measures to mitigate fails Forced buy-in procedures (i.e. procedures where the SSS buys the non-delivered securities on behalf of the failing party) Forced sell-out procedures (i.e. procedures where the collateral of the failing part is sold to complete the transaction in favour of the selling party)

10 Relations between short selling and market discipline Approaches largely complementary ( having an effective discipline for settlement of short selling transactions is the first pillar for an effective short selling regulatory regime (IOSCO, 2009)) This raises questions of co-ordination between relevant authorities

11 Conclusion This article provided insights into: Relations between short selling and settlement fails Causes and effects of settlement fails Market discipline on settlement fails and short selling The effects of market discipline for settlement fails on short sale regulation