ISO Exhibit 13 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Technical Conference on Connecticut Infrastructure Reliability and Operability Committee Update Hartford,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Southwest Rhode Island Transmission Supply Study Long Term Needs and Solutions.
Advertisements

NERC TPL Standard Issues TSS Meeting #146 Seattle, WA August 15-17, 2007 Chifong Thomas.
Study Committee Representatives Annual Report December, 2012
March 26, 2014 Transmission Coordination and Planning Committee 2014 Q1 Stakeholder Meeting.
Presented to PGDTF February 11, 2015
October 16, 2009 RPG Meeting ERCOT RPG Project Review Update Jeff Billo.
Public Service Company of New Mexico
Brief on HVDC 2015 Brief on HVDC 2015
Kansas Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Conference Wind 2007 RFP Update John Grimwade - Sr. Director Strategic Planning and Development September.
Reporting the Economics of Reliable Energy Ralph Fehr, P.E. Engineering Consultant Reliability of the U.S. Power Grid.
Arrowhead  Weston Transmission Line Project Dave Van House Minnesota Power.
Electric Transmission and Economic Opportunities Richard W. Caperton Senior Energy Policy Analyst.
KURTEN SWITCH PROJECT (BRYAN/ COLLEGE STATION AREA UPGRADES) Technical Advisory Committee December 1, 2005 Transmission Services.
Houston Region Import Capacity Project August 27, 2013 Regional Planning Group Meeting.
1 1 Substation Asset Strategy Kevin Dasso, Senior Director Engineering and Operations IEEE/PES Annual Substations Committee Meeting April 7, 2008.
MARCH 31, 2014 Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
Technical Advisory Committee December 6, 2010 Summary of the CREZ Reactive Study Warren Lasher Manager, Long-Term Planning and Policy.
NOVEMBER 11, 2014 PUBLIC VERSION Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
AUGUST 19, 2014 PUBLIC VERSION Maine 2014 Outage Coordination CONTAINS CRITICAL ENERGY INFRASTRUCTURE INFORMATION – DO NOT RELEASE.
1 Project Overview n Review current and future problems n Develop Solutions that will provide the customer with high quality reliable power n Test the.
IMPERIAL VALLEY CONFERENCE July 21, SOLICITATION RENEWABLES PORTFOLIO STANDARD.
October 12, 2007 ERCOT Regional Planning Group Meeting RPG-CREZ Task Force Status Report Warren Lasher System Assessment.
Year 2006 Report “Better” Managed and Controlled Transmission Grids using Advanced Technological Concepts Aty Edris EPRI Power Delivery & Markets
Review of progress and future work SQSS Sub Group 2 August 2006 DTI / OFGEM OFFSHORE TRANSMISSION EXPERTS GROUP.
1 Power Quality Mary Santori, P.E. Senior Engineer September 12, 2013.
ISO New England Regional Update Wholesale Electricity Markets & State Energy Policy Seminar Connecticut Business & Industry Association December 14, 2010.
THE TRES AMIGAS SUPERSTATION IIEA - Dublin October 8, 2010 UNITING THE NATION’S ELECTRIC POWER GRID.
Houston Area Dynamic Reactive Project March 11,
Report on the NCTPC 2006 Collaborative Transmission Plan Mark Byrd, Manager – Transmission Planning Progress Energy Carolinas, Inc January 25, 2007.
Section 3 TRANSMISSION & DISTRIBUTION US Bulk Power Transmission System Transmission & Distribution (T&D) Components New T& D Technologies This product.
JACKSBORO TO WEST DENTON 345-kV PROJECT Presentation to Technical Advisory Committee April 8, 2004 Transmission Services Operations.
Karl Stahlkopf Vice President, Power Delivery, EPRI University of Wisconsin October20, 2000 EPRI’s ISO Membership Package EPRI’s ISO Membership Package.
© New York Independent System Operator, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Michael Swider Manager – Research & Development New York Independent System.
U.S. Energy Information Administration Independent Statistics & Analysis ERUS 2014 Bulk Power and Reliability Proposed Changes to Form EIA-411.
1 ISA&D7‏/8‏/ ISA&D7‏/8‏/2013 Systems Development Life Cycle Phases and Activities in the SDLC Variations of the SDLC models.
Reliable Power Reliable Markets Reliable People Performance Targets for the Customer Interconnection Process January, 2008.
Energy Gateway Update for Wyoming Infrastructure Authority January 27, 2009 Darrell Gerrard Vice President Transmission System Planning.
LAREDO PLANT RMR EXIT STRATEGY Presentation to Board of Directors March 16, 2004 Transmission Services Operations.
Transmission Planning Informational Workshop Montpelier, VT September 19, 2005 Allocating the Cost of New Transmission in New England Stephen J. Rourke.
Transmission Equivalence Richard V. Kowalski Manager, Transmission Planning ISO New England.
20th Century Electric Transmission Grid
ATC Planning Zone Meeting Teresa Mogensen Director, Transmission Planning & Service Scott Barnhart Manager, Transmission Planning.
Forming a Cost Assignment/ Cost Recovery Team RMATS Steering Committee January 13, 2004.
THE TRES AMIGAS SUPERSTATION ABB Western Utility Executive Conference September 28, 2010 UNITING THE NATION’S ELECTRIC POWER GRID.
Proposed Analytical Approach - Modeling Phase 3 - Formation of new team December 9, 2003 Steering Committee Presentation.
Order 1000 Implementation in PJM – Challenges and Opportunities Jodi L. Moskowitz Senior Director – Transmission Development & Strategy October 13, 2015.
SPP.org 1. Final Report: Reliability and Economic Assessments Stakeholder Meeting December 1, 2008 Austin, TX.
Outage Planning Subcommittee Mark Wilson. Outage Planning Subcommittee Created to address Market Participant concerns with existing rules and procedures.
ERCOT TAC11/2/ CREZ Study Update ERCOT TAC 11/2/2006.
TRANSMISSION CONSTRAINTS KENNETH A. DONOHOO, P.E. Manager of System Planning, Technical Operations
G 200 L 200 ISO NEW ENGLAND T H E P E O P L E B E H I N D N E W E N G L A N D ’ S P O W E R. Southwest Connecticut RFP Markets Committee November 14, 2003.
TRANSMISSION INFRASTRUCTURE IMPROVEMENTS — Current Projects — The Center for the New West “ The Sun Valley Energy Roundtables 2006” November 30 – December.
Coordinated Planning Concept (For Discussion Only) revised 11/30/04 07/01/04.
Update on the North Carolina Transmission Planning Collaborative January 30, 2007 For the North Carolina Utilities Commission and the North Carolina Public.
May14, 2010 RPG Meeting Houston Import Study Update Jeff Billo.
ERCOT Transmission Planning Process Overview and Recommendations November 6, 2002.
June 11, 2010 RPG Meeting Houston Import Study Update Jeff Billo.
PJM© Market Efficiency RTEP Proposal Window PJM TEAC 1/9/2014 – Market Efficiency Presentation.
Black Start Service in New England System Operator’s Perspective Robert B. Burke ISO New England Inc. July 23, 2002 IEEE - Chicago, Illinois.
Flynn & Associates1 SF LAFCO Energy Consultant(s) RFQ Overview of Critical Issues and Flynn & Associates’ Expertise April 19, 2002.
Reliability Must Run Workshop RMR Study Process May 24, 2016.
Transmission Planning in ERCOT- Overview
ISO New England System R&D Needs
Massachusetts Electric Restructuring Roundtable
CMPLDWG Composite Model with Distributed Generation Approval
2040 Long Range Transportation Plan Update
Building A Northeast RTO: A Measured Approach
CMPLDWG Composite Model with Distributed Generation Approval
M. Kezunovic (P.I.) S. S. Luo D. Ristanovic Texas A&M University
Presentation transcript:

ISO Exhibit 13 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Technical Conference on Connecticut Infrastructure Reliability and Operability Committee Update Hartford, Connecticut January 6, 2005 Stephen G. Whitley Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer ISO New England Inc.

2 Need for the 345 kV Loop Without the 345 kV Loop: –Bulk system reliability criteria cannot be met –Cascading blackouts could occur –System operators will need to resort to “pre-cautionary” load shedding to maintain overall grid stability

3 Inefficiency Costs of Existing Transmission System Estimated annual inefficiency costs for Connecticut (2005) –RMR Agreements:$240 Million* –GAP RFP:$33 Million –Congestion:$4 Million –Running uneconomic generators:$31 Million –Total:$308 Million * Includes agreements in effect and pending

4 Reliability and Operability Committee Committee Members: –ISO New England –Project Applicants: Connecticut Light and Power and United Illuminating Process: –ROC established: June 2004 –Interim Reports: August 16, October 8 –Final Report: December 20

5 Objective Determine maximum technological feasible use of 345 kV underground cable Meet operability and reliability requirements of the bulk power system in Southwest Connecticut and New England

6 Scope of Investigation An unprecedented amount of technical study conducted on this project due to: –Extreme weakness of the Southwest Connecticut system –Immediate and pending need for transmission upgrades Exhaustive technical analysis conducted –Harmonic frequency scans –Dynamic voltage analysis Multiple lengths of underground cable evaluated

7 Methods of Investigation World-wide experts employed –GE, PB Power, Shawnee Power, EnerNex, Teshmont, ABB, EPRI Solutions, and K & R Consulting Consulting team designed to work in parallel fashion –Engineers and consultants worked thousands of hours to complete necessary studies –Provide review of each others’ work –Expedite study completion

8 General Findings As the length of underground cable increases, so do the variables that must be considered –Studies show high sensitivity to load levels, load types, amount of capacitance, etc. –Highly volatile and unpredictable results demonstrated –Operating in this manner is unprecedented world-wide Weakness of the Southwest Connecticut system limits the amount of underground cable that can be used –Voltage peaks/durations adversely impact existing system equipment –Ability to install new substation capacitor banks to solve local area problems

9 General Findings, cont. ROC has identified solutions that will work: –4 linear miles of underground cable –13 linear miles of underground cable –24 linear miles of underground cable if mitigating measures employed Substitute cable type (XLPE for HPFF) to reduce capacitance and harmonic effects Extensive replacement of substation surge arresters and utilization of higher voltage rated equipment (circuit breakers rated 500 kV rather than 345 kV) Maximum use of 345 kV underground cable: 24 linear miles

10 Other Studies and Determinations KEMA –KEMA report in October suggested use of C-Type filters to mitigate harmonics issues and add undergrounding –Suggested further study to verify results –ROC conducted further study and determined C-Type filters help in some cases and hurt in others –KEMA approach would not be technologically feasible solution to add 345 kV underground cable

11 Other Studies and Determinations, cont. ABB –ABB proposed direct current (DC) project to be embedded in an alternating current (AC) system –ROC determined ABB approach would: Not mitigate Southwest Connecticut reliability issues Be a high risk, first of its kind multi-terminal “network” DC application Result in unacceptable complexity Cost nearly double and would be less likely to get any support for regional cost recovery The reasons above apply to the multi-terminal installation –Another option was for a less complex installation but it did not meet the project objectives

12 Next Steps Cost review for Bethel-Norwalk project (Phase I) –Regional vs. local allocation –NEPOOL Reliability Committee meeting February 2 –Stakeholder meeting February 7 Cost review for Middletown-Norwalk (Phase II) –Regional vs. local allocation –Stakeholder meetings to be scheduled upon receipt of cost application Reliability review of final Phase II design –NEPOOL Reliability Committee –ISO New England