Different Types of Financing – The European View Martin J Fleetwood – Partner Secretary, Rail Working Group
The European Market European Union consists of 27 Member States European Union opening up competition within its Member States Most Member States share a common track gauge and loading gauge Expansion of cross-border services has occurred Majority of rail services still operate within a Member State More operators entering the market and needing rolling stock assets Large number of banks competing to provide asset finance
Main Operators in the European Rail Market Old Order –State Railways Long term players Access to Government backed funding Ability to borrow on financial markets New Operators –Franchises/Concessions and Open Access Medium to short term players – higher risk Government support? Look to financial markets for main funding
Financing European Railway Rolling Stock - I Rail finance market maturing –15 years since UK rail privatisation –Private operators in Germany for over 5 years More value in the asset than the corporate –Rolling stock has a residual value –Railway company may be saddled with debt Asset finance becoming more important –Loan to asset value is very important –Banks benefit from internal rating model under Basel II
Financing European Railway Rolling Stock - II Expertise of lender is required –Standard rather than specialist equipment –Interoperability of equipment Ability to recover rolling stock –Different jurisdictions English based Common Law e.g. England and Wales Roman Germanic Civil Law e.g. Germany and Switzerland Napoleon Civil Law e.g. France and Spain –Physical Access to assets Emergence of ROSCOs (Rolling Stock Leasing Companies)
Role of ROSCOs Purchases rolling stock and leases to Operators Obtains bank finance to enable purchases –Often syndicated loan finance required –Bank finance over longer term than operating lease Ensures consistent cashflow available from Operator to support transaction –Possible Government support for new trains Has team of experts to assess leasing risks –Residual risk in asset –Ability to re-lease after existing lease expires –Maintenance reserve required as part of lease rental –Assets moving across borders / legal jurisdictions Able to lease with or without maintenance package
Role of Banks Finance to ROSCOs –Consistent cashflow of ROSCO to support repayment profile –Risk may be spread over a number of assets and a number of countries –Amount of finance generally requires syndicated loans Finance to Operators –Not much appetite for lease finance or loans to support purchase of rolling stock –Preference to set up own ROSCO Finance for PFI/PPP schemes
PFI/PPP Schemes Government procures new rolling stock fleet –Specifies requirements of new trains –Availability based payments Consortium bids to provide new trains –Manufacturer part of consortium –Consortium required to obtain finance Equity and shareholder loans Syndicated loan finance Government guaranty of minimum usage / level of availability payment if no default by Consortium Consortium effectively becomes a ROSCO for that fleet of trains