Pathways to Housing … The Experiences of Sponsored Refugees and Refugee Claimants in Accessing Permanent Housing in Toronto Robert Murdie Geography Department.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Experiences of Discrimination: The Impact of Metropolitan and Non- Metropolitan Location Brian Ray, University of Ottawa Valerie Preston, York University.
Advertisements

Does Geography Matter? Variations in Perceived Discomfort and Discrimination in Canadas Gateway Cities Brian Ray, University of Ottawa Valerie Preston,
Immigration and Homelessness Research in Toronto, Peel Region, and Hamilton Dr. Kenise Murphy Kilbride, Co-Principal Investigator Dr. Steven Webber, Co-Principal.
Immigrants and Housing: Recurrent Themes from the Canadian Literature, Robert Murdie Valerie Preston Magali Chevalier Sutama Ghosh Geography Department,
Multiple Facets of Housing Discrimination Sutama Ghosh York University.
Place and Economic Activity: Key issues from the area effects debate Nick Buck ISER, University of Essex.
Local Immigration Partnerships: Systems Planning to Help People.
Buy to let and the reconfiguration of Londons housing market Steve Wilcox University of York.
Opening Doors to Affordable Housing CHCWA Council Meeting April 2014.
European Research Conference Access to Housing for Homeless People in Europe York, 21st September 2012 Casas Primeiro / Housing First in Lisbon José Ornelas.
Housing Solutions: The Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) Program Robin Ambroz Deputy Director of Programs Nebraska Investment Finance Authority.
1 Prairie Metropolis Centre Symposium January 23, 2009 Line Porfon, Executive Director, Policy and Urban Affairs Lora Pillipow, Director, Strategic Policy.
The New Economics of Migration. This is a theory that is more applicable to LDCs than to advanced economies. Basic proposition: Migration decisions are.
Towards a Sustainable Private Rented Sector in the UK Lessons from Abroad What we have learned? Kath Scanlon and Christine Whitehead.
The institute for employment studies What’s different about university cities? Marc Cowling.
RFSC update - NRRF Overview Refugee Family Support Category (RFSC) Key statistics Invitation to Apply (ITA) Update on Tier Two queue RFSC sponsor.
Recent Inward Migratory Trends to Edinburgh – Challenges and Opportunities Nick Croft – Corporate Projects Manager (Equalities, Diversity and Human Rights)
Citizenship andStrategic Research Immigration Canadaand Statistics 1 Citizenship & Immigration Canada Information Sources.
 Why the survey was devised – Interlink in partnership with TLI project and Salford City Council  Information collected from January till April’13 
Key questions for Age UK staff seminar What is ‘sheltered/ retirement housing’ - who lives in it? Who is it for? What does it offer older people in terms.
Through Collaboration and Commitment The story of Ottawa’s record investment in housing and homelessness We see a city where everyone has a place to call.
What are the Economic Impacts on Communities as They Change from Black to Latino? Terra Bennett Sandra Kim Michael Park Economics 116 Professor Conrad.
1 WELL-BEING AND ADJUSTMENT OF SPONSORED AGING IMMIGRANTS Shireen Surood, PhD Supervisor, Research & Evaluation Information & Evaluation Services Addiction.
EUROPEAN DATA CENTER FOR WORK and WELFARE your direct access to EUROPEAN COMPARATIVE DATA - opinions - - indicators and statistics - - policies and institutions.
Meeting future demand for rental housing for lower income older Australians: social or market sector supply? Andrew Jones Housing Policy Research Program,
Immigration as a Supply Side Policy.
Migration, Communities and Services: learning from the project Christine Whitehead LSE London Migration and the Transformation of London LSE London 27.
Kathleen Dunmore Three Dragons 13 October 2010 Modelling demand for older persons accommodation.
YOUTH DEMOGRAPHICS IN THE CITY OF TORONTO Toronto Community and Neighbourhood Services: Social Development and Administration Division.
2000/2001 Household Budget Survey (HBS) Conducted by The National Bureau of Statistics.
Toronto and Region Toronto differs from its metropolitan region in urban form, housing market characteristics and population composition. Despite the.
Searching for 'generation rent': Identifying niches in the private rented sector Ben Pattison Housing and Communities Research Group 9 th April 2015.
Financing the Deal Presented By Rob Curry – Cleveland Housing Network J. David Heller – The NRP Group LLC May 20, 2004Page 1.
Public Attitudes to Housing Results from Ipsos MORI On-Line Panel Poll 31 st May 2010.
Bowen Island Affordable Housing Needs. What is a housing needs assessment? Current housing situation Future trends Gap between demand and supply at various.
Employment Research Institute 1 The Employability of Senior Workers: The Importance of Social Networks Dr Kaberi Gayen, Dr Emma Hollywood, Professor Ron.
HOUSING EUROPE 1 CECODHAS European Liaison Committee for social housing August 2008 CECODHAS MISSION CECODHAS is the European Committee for social housing,
1 Immigrant Economic and Social Integration in Canada: Research, Measurement, Data Development By Garnett Picot Director General Analysis Branch Statistics.
Social Housing. Definitions  Landlord: a person who owns a property and rents it to someone else  Rent: A tenant's regular payment to a landlord for.
How can local initiatives help workless people find and keep paid work? Pamela Meadows Synergy Research and Consulting Ltd and National Institute of Economic.
Statistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics CanadaCitizenship and Immigration CanadaStatistics.
Roomers and Boarders: Melissa Scopilliti, University of Maryland, Maryland Population Research Center; Population Division, U.S. Census Bureau.
Household food insecurity among low-income Toronto families: Implications for social policy Sharon Kirkpatrick & Valerie Tarasuk Department of Nutritional.
Inclusion of Roma communities: Issues and research directions Migration Research Seminar Manchester Metropolitan University Monday 9 th July 2012 Philip.
Single households and housing costs Free choice or market constraints M. Leussink J. Smeets.
Who is a Refugee?. A Refugee is a person who  Is outside his or her own country  Has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of:  race,  religion,
Greg Halseth and Marleen Morris Co-Directors Housing Needs in Prince George: An Opportunity for Community Growth and Revitalization unbc.ca/community-development-institute.
HOUSING SOCIALE PER CHI? Judith Allen Professor of Housing and Regeneration University of Westminster England.
Updating Household Projections for England Bob Garland.
Nova Scotia Immigration International Post Graduate Students.
Welcoming Communities Initiative. The Welcoming Communities Initiative (WCI) a collaborative, multidisciplinary, province- wide network of university.
Halifax Housing Needs Assessment Planning & Development CDAC October 28, 2015.
SOCIAL HOUSING: VISION 2020 Dr Tim Brown Independent Consultant: HPPR Senior Research Associate: Housing & Local Government: DMU 16 October.
Poverty and social exclusion in urban and rural areas of Scotland Nick Bailey 1, Kirsten Besemer 2, Glen Bramley 2 and Maria Gannon 1 1 University of Glasgow.
Poverty and social exclusion in urban and rural areas of Scotland Nick Bailey 1, Kirsten Besemer 2, Glen Bramley 2 and Maria Gannon 1 1 University of Glasgow.
Wootton Bridge Parish Council Housing Needs Assessment 2013 Report summary.
Student Generation from Various Housing Unit Types
What do the data and research really tell us?
The Housing Market.
Ather H. Akbari Saint Mary’s University and Azad Haider
Economic Analysis for Managers (ECO 501) Fall: 2012 Semester
Housing Studies Association, York 2012 Catherine Davie
Non-EIA Rent Assist November 2017.
Key Issues Why do services cluster downtown? Where are people distributed within urban areas? Why are urban areas expanding? Why do cities face challenges?
Developing a Strategic Approach to Housing for Older People
Presentation to council budget committee, October 15, 2018
Understanding Tenant Needs
Since 2003, the number of children and youth aged 0 to 24 years who entered Canada as economic immigrants has increased. The number of children and youth.
In 2012, 257,887 immigrants became permanent residents of Canada
Immigration: Logistics, The point system and Settlement
Presentation transcript:

Pathways to Housing … The Experiences of Sponsored Refugees and Refugee Claimants in Accessing Permanent Housing in Toronto Robert Murdie Geography Department York University

Objective Compare the housing experiences of sponsored refugees and refugee claimants in Toronto Why? Relatively little research on housing access by refugees Assumption that the two groups are monolithic Differences in labour market success between sponsored refugees and refugee claimants Renaud et al (2003): Ones Bad and the Other Ones Worse: Differences in Economic Integration Between Asylum Seekers and Refugees Selected Abroad... the important finding is that refugee claimants are disadvantaged over landed refugees once all other factors are taken into account.

Working Hypothesis Refugee claimants will experience a more difficult pathway to housing than sponsored refugees and will be less well housed, at least in the initial stage of settlement Sponsored Refugee Refugee Claimant Permanent Housing

Research Design Interviews with key informants Focus group with IRHTG (Toronto) Individual interviews (20 sponsored refugees, 24 refugee claimants) Reputational (snow-ball) sample Semi-structured questionnaire 35 interviews transcribed

The Sample: Selected Characteristics Sponsored Refugees Limited no. of countries More time outside home country Larger households Older Less education Weaker facility in English LESS human capital Refugee Claimants Wide range of countries Less time outside home country Smaller households Younger More education Stronger facility in English MORE human capital

The Sample: On Arrival Sponsored Refugees More Arrived with partner and/or children Knew friends and/or relatives in Toronto before arrival Were met on arrival MORE social capital Refugee Claimants Fewer Arrived with partner and/or children Knew friends and/or relatives in Toronto before arrival Were met on arrival LESS social capital

Initial Housing Experience Sponsored Refugees Temporary housing more likely with family and/or friends than a shelter Average time to find permanent housing:.8 months Refugee Claimants Temporary housing more likely in a shelter than with family and/or friends Average time to find permanent housing: 7.2 months

First Permanent Dwelling Sponsored Refugees More likely to locate in a neighbourhood with co-ethnics High-rise apartment Rent from private landlord Larger Units Less likely to share with non-family members Refugee Claimants Less likely to locate in a neighbourhood with co-ethnics Diversity of housing Rent from private landlord Smaller Units Much more likely to share with non-family members

Current Dwelling 50% of sponsored refugees and 30% of refugee claimants did not move from first permanent dwelling Refugee claimants Number in high-rise apartments doubled and a minority gained access to social housing Increased unit space – more two bedroom apartments Fewer sharing with non-family members Paid less rent than sponsored refugees Increased dwelling and neighbourhood satisfaction High proportion of both groups indicated that housing and getting housing were not what they imagined before coming to Canada (Expected lower rents and more govt. assistance)

Affordability

Summary and Conclusion Refugee claimants experienced a more difficult pathway to housing than sponsored refugees (confirms Renaud et al). Sponsored refugees found permanent housing much more quickly than refugee claimants (social networks) Claimants generally improved their housing position over time and narrowed the gap with sponsored refugees Affordability is a serious problem for both groups Both groups relied heavily on informal sources (social capital) for housing information and help. Is the strategy of relying on friends and relatives a viable long term solution for acquiring affordable, good quality rental housing, especially when the supply of such housing is limited?