Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Capital Markets and Green National Green Building Underwriting.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
July 07 Ted Brandt Chief Executive Officer Marathon Capital, LLC Consolidation in North American Wind Sector.
Advertisements

Beyond LEED for New Construction: Recommendations for Change Patrice Frey Director of Sustainability Research National Trust for Historic Preservation.
S. L. King & Associates, Inc. Engineers Planners Managers Aviation Safety, Security & The Environment Asset Management and Planning of Utilities Infrastructure.
Commercializing Swiss Re’s Sustainability Commitment via Innovative Financing Options.
Planning for LEED ® Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED and related logo is a trademark owned by the U.S. Green Building Council and is.
Embedding Energy Management – Carbon introduction Insert site / company name and logo here Insert presenter/s names here This publication was funded by.
Energy Efficiency Strategy. THE ENERGY WHITE PAPER Energy White Paper sets out four key goals for energy policy to: Cut the UK’s carbon dioxide emission.
July 18, 2013 David Gilford, Assistant Director Energy and Climate Change Action Lab: The New York City Perspective.
 $2 000 billion: the total value of the real estate assets that should be disposed of by 58 European banks within 2 years, according to the IMF. EMBA.
CANADIAN ENERGY POLICY ISSUES Peter Love Adjunct Professor, Sustainable Energy Initiative York University Canadian Society for Ecological Economics November.
Greening America’s Congregations Through Energy Efficiency ENERGY STAR ® Tools, Technical Support and Public Recognition.
Hydropower Development: Experience of Nepal
LEED Leadership in Energy & Environmental Design.
Green Real Estate/ Energy Efficiency Real Estate Webinar Series.
Connecticut’s Energy Future Removing Barriers to Promote Energy Sustainability: Public Policy and Financing December 2, 2004 Legislative Office Building.
New Live Learn Residence Hall. Current Grove With general placement of new building Create a reinvigorated role for The Grove in campus life.
Energy Project Development A Discussion on State and Federal Incentives Presented By Dennis Plaster, General Manager.
Promoting Energy Efficiency In Buildings in Developing countries.
Sustainable Prosperity: An Introduction to the Strategic Plan By: Brian P. Sheehan Director of Sustainability City of Charleston.
Less is More: SEE Action and the Power of Efficiency Hon. Phyllis Reha Commissioner, Minnesota PUC Co-Chair, SEE Action Customer Information and Behavior.
Total Energy Usage As A Measure of Building Performance 30% Building Energy Savings Through an Energy Lifecycle Approach to Building Construction, Retro-fitting,
US Renewable Energy Markets: Financial Perspective By Michael D. Ware Advance Capital Markets, Inc. Washington Council of Governments Washington, DC June.
1 | Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energyeere.energy.gov Kathleen Hogan Deputy Assistant Secretary for EE Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.
Resource Efficiency Opportunities in the Building Sector
Chapter 1 The Nature of Real Estate and Real Estate Markets Copyright © 2010 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.McGraw-Hill/Irwin.
Viticulture– Carbon introduction Site / company name and logo here Presenter/s names here This is an Agrifood Skills Australia Ltd project developed in.
City of Melbourne MELBOURNE - TOWARD NET ZERO GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS BY 2020 What do low emission futures look like?
Community owned forests conference Missoula, June 2005.
Green, Energy and Buildings INSERT YOUR LOGO HERE.
Green Mortgage Backed Securities (MBS) MTS is comprised of leading environmental groups, governments & companies. It uses high leverage activities to achieve.
Bill Harrison New Jersey Chapter February 3, 2009.
Developing and Integrated Energy Conservation and Renewable Strategy Renewable Energy Leadership Summit June 7, 2005 Lenox, MA.
*Green City “Briefing” presentation to the City Council Summer 2008 GCGC GCGC * Project Location is confidential.
Retro-fitting Commercial Buildings A Financing Perspective Date: April 2011 Prepared by: Carbon Solutions Group.
NEET Workgroup #3 - Residential Subgroup Snohomish County PUD November 2008.
Beyond Mandates, Does Green Pave the Way? Marlene Santos Vice President, Customer Service Florida Power & Light Company October 17, 2009.
ERES 2010 Arch. Simone Spreafico Engagement Director, Investment, Engagement Director, Investment, Advisory & Valuation Division Advisory & Valuation Division.
Michael R. Walker Research Director IGCC Financing Project Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University PH: , FX:
Bill Harrison Cleveland - Akron Chapters Joint Meeting March 16, 2009.
Developing a Framework for Offset Use in RGGI Opportunities and Risks Dale Bryk, NRDC and Brian Jones, MJB&A – Northeast Regional GHG Coalition RGGI Stakeholder.
Page 1 Greenhouse Gas Risk Solutions Commercializing Swiss Re’s Sustainability Commitment.
ESG Integration in Real Estate The European investors’ view UC Berkeley, 2 December 2010 Hans Op ‘t Veld Head of Listed Real Estate PGGM.
Energy Efficiency Action Plan Kathleen Hogan Director, Climate Protection Partnerships Division U.S. Environmental Protection Agency NARUC Winter Meetings.
Electricity Transportation Heating Allocation of 6.2 GtC/yr Electricity: 40% Fuels used directly: 60% 60% of Global Carbon Reduction Needed in 5-10 yrs.
COLBOURNE COLLEGE PRESENTED BY SADEKE SMITH SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT.
1 Energy Efficiency Programs For Local Governments & Community Partners Christina Prestella Program Manager, Government & Community Partnerships PG&E September.
Green Strategies, Inc. Global Climate Change: A Social Issue that all Responsible Investors Must Address Global Climate Change: A Social Issue that all.
Energy Transformation for Green Growth Pathways for Sustainable Energy Security to Power India’s Economic Growth 29 August 2015, Kolkata.
X Hospital’s Sustainable Energy Management Plan. Prescription for Energy Savings Agenda 1. Overview of Duke Energy’s Prescription for Energy Savings 2.
Ayumi Konishi Director General, East Asia Department Asian Development Bank CCICED Annual General Meeting 2015 Forum G20 and Green Finance 11 November.
Ice Storage for Peak Load Reduction Chris Smith NYSERDA NARUC 2007 Summer Meeting.
An Introduction to the U. S
Economic Assessment of Implementing the 10/20 Goals and Energy Efficiency Recommendations – Preliminary Results Prepared for : WRAP, AP2 Forum Prepared.
POSITIVE ENERGY TOGETHER ® Industry Trends Discussion MEC Conference San Antonio Texas, October 19 th, 2009 Jesse B. Langston.
Ideas to engage GEF and carbon finance under GEF-5 Input from IDB Washington D.C. 15 November 2010.
Szilárd Árvay Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Hungary.
Organization  As a member of the Strategy & Business Development team, this position will support the development and execution of Corporate, Sector,
Planning for LEED ® © 2010 Project Lead The Way, Inc.Civil Engineering and Architecture Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design LEED ® and its related.
Traversing New Waters: Eight Years Post-Crisis A Panel on the Impact of the Regulatory Tsunami on Securities.
Welcome Carol Berrigan Nuclear Energy Institute July 13, 2015.
RENEWABLE ENERGY REGULATION IN KENYA KENYA-SPAIN MULTILATERAL PARTNERSHIP MEETING HELD AT CROWNE PLAZA Presented by Caroline Kimathi Asst Manager, Licensing.
The future of the capital markets in Guyana
IREM® Fall Conference San diego, Ca 10/21/2016.
LEED Defined Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design
Company Selection: Integrating sustainability criteria
Energy Savings Insurance
Energy Savings Insurance
Sustainable buildings
Anna Garcia Air Innovations Conference August 2004
How Small Developers and EPC Contractors Can Add PPA Financing to their Arsenals John Langhus, VP Business Development Midwest Solar Expo 2019 New Energy.
Presentation transcript:

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Capital Markets and Green National Green Building Underwriting Standard

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Overview What is green as it applies to real estate finance Capital markets requirement of a national standard Which green aspects are important

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 What is Green in the Real Estate Industry? 1.Best business practices –Maximize efficiency aspects in construction / operations –Minimize waste and costs –Capture free inputs from natural environment –Increased architect / engineer / contractor coordination 2.Mark of high-quality construction and asset value via several third-party verification processes 3.A product differentiation marker based on: –Energy and water operational cost savings –IEQ and associated health benefits –Amenities –Asset quality (perceived / real)

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Why Are Investors / Companies Going Green? Its just business…… 1.Operational cost efficiency 2.Risk reduction 3.Best management practices 4.Halo effect

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Capital Markets Focus Financially Tangible Asset Attributes Energy efficiency Water efficiency Location aspects –Transit orientation –Pedestrian accessibility –Neighborhood amenities Indoor environmental quality

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Capital Market Relevance INVESTOR / LENDER Fiduciary Responsibility Effective risk management –Energy/water price increases – risk exposure –Energy/water price volatility – risk exposure –Litigation / liability – risk exposure Transparent information / reporting –Provide additional relevant data points –Third-party verified OPERATOR / BORROWER Maximize Business Opportunities Improves competitiveness Improves operational efficiency –Cash flow and material risk factors Promotes market differentiation Enhances brand value Facilitates progress –Societal –Business

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 CFO Research Services / Jones Lang LaSalle Report March 2008 Top Sustainability Priorities Improve energy efficiency Reduce carbon footprint Reduce environmental impact of operations Manage risk Barriers Lack of decision framework / tool Inability to measure effect on shareholder value / investor returns Not integrated into financial management and control systems Respondent Quote As more efficient measuring tools are created and utilized, finances role in sustainability efforts will be greatly enhanced. Survey Metrics: 175 responses – senior finance executives 95% from companies w/ over $500MM revenue

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Green Building Underwriting Standard ReportingDecision Tool Investment Performance Risk Management

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Capital Markets Partnership – Members Partial List City of San Francisco City of Chicago City of Dallas City of Denver City of Miami City of New York City of Oakland City of San Jose City of Santa Monica City of Seattle

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 US Conference of Mayors Resolution June 2008

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Principals – Green Building Underwriting Standard 1.Performance based 2.Easy to analyze / simple to implement 3.Disciplined Tangible financial impacts Acknowledgement of intangible value 4.Utilize/recognize consensus industry standards 5.Third-party verified IN PRACTICE: Underwriting Overlay Does not materially change current underwriting practices Request additional key information pieces during underwriting process Incorporate information data points –Decision processes –Reporting If you cannot measure, report, and verify……you cannot manage it

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Structure – Green Building Underwriting Standard Recognizes and incorporates existing industry standards –Comprehensive –Transparent –Market-driven –Consensus-based Standards include –EPA EnergyStar –USGBC LEED Rating System –MTS Climate Neutral Performance based –Energy –Water –Indoor environmental quality Third-party verification requirement –Self-Regulation = No Regulation = Wild West

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 EPA EnergyStar Government-backed program helping businesses and individuals achieve superior energy efficiency Energy performance rating tools –EnergyStar Portfolio Manager (existing buildings) –EnergyStar Target Finder (new construction) Scoring system of –Commercial buildings Bell curve based on statistically significant comparative data set Higher score is better –Median = 50 –EnergyStar Certified buildings score 75 or higher –Residential buildings Based on energy consumption / HERS test Lower score is better

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 USGBCs LEED Rating System Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design Environmental Responsibility Defined For Buildings Answers question: What exactly is an environmentally-responsible building? Third party certification of environmental achievement LEED New Construction 2.2 Implementation Point-based system Broken into categories Sustainable Sites14 Points Water Efficiency 5 Points Energy & Atmosphere17 Points Materials & Resources13 Points Indoor Environmental Quality15 Points Innovation 5 Points TOTAL POSSIBLE POINTS69 Points Certified26-32 points Silver33-38 points Gold39-51 points Platinum52-69 points

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Climate Neutral certification Consensus-based national standard Certifies carbon neutrality Certification process: Audit baseline energy use Implement efficiency measures Address remaining energy use: 1.Install onsite renewable energy; 2.Purchase Green-e renewable energy; 3.Purchase/retire Green-e RECs; and/or 4.Purchase annual emissions offsets based on the Cleaner and Greener® program requirements Certify by accredited 3 rd party professional

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Mechanics Green Building Underwriting Standards I. Information Disclosure at time of debt financing 1.Energy Star score (Portfolio Manager or Target Finder) 2.LEED certification and scorecard 3.Climate Neutral certification 4.Commissioning report (recommended) II. Analyze LEED scorecard for specific LEED points achieved Focus placed on a subset of specific LEED credits –Energy efficiency –Water use –Indoor environmental quality III.Rate revenue/expense impacts of strategies employed Relative scale compared to a market asset LOWMEDIUM HIGH XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Example Scoring – Specific LEED Point LEED Water Efficiency WE-3.1/3.2 – 20%/30% Water Use Reduction LEED scorecard analysis –Achieved both WE-3.1 and WE-3.2 Asset analysis –Dual flush toilets –Waterless urinals –Faucet aerators Positive score on financial impact = 2 UNDERWRITING 30% reduction applied to market asset water utility costs LOWMEDIUM HIGH X

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Final Analysis Capital Markets Partnership Commercial Green Score Formula C M P GREEN SCORE

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Risk Management Lower operating expenses –Energy / water price volatility –Energy / water efficiency and conservation –Energy – peak load demand –Insurance –Waste disposal –Maintenance –Capital expenditures Commercial - Evolving corporate green policies –Impact on tenant demand Potential for two-tiered market Obsolescence risk –Improved tenant satisfaction / retention Future regulatory compliance CO2 trading –Cost increases based on CO2 / ton used to power asset –Value capture Current / future tax incentives Building health / IAQ liability Informs investment consideration, capital access and pricing Real Estate Value 1.Cash Flow 2.Timing of Cash Flow 3.Risk of Receiving Cash Flow

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Summary – Green Underwriting Standard Incorporates performance-based tangible attributes –Energy use /efficiency –Water use / efficiency –Location attributes –Indoor environmental quality Simple due diligence requirements –EnergyStar score –LEED scorecard –Commissioning report Straightforward implementation Transparent Third-party verified

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Crude Oil – Actual (Jan 1997 thru July 28, 2008) World oil production flat since 2004 / China and Indias consumption surging / domestic consumption in oil producing countries increasing Energy traders / OPEC now publicly refer to the proper price of $85 / barrel at which point OPEC reduces production to support prices

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 US Electricity Prices (1982 – 2006) Source: US Department of Energy / kwh

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 US Electric Power Generation Sources (2007)

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 DOE Coal Prices June 2003 to July 2006 Source: Central Appalachia +88% Northern Appalachia +41% Illinois Basin 38% Uinta Basin 114% Powder River Basin 100%

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 DOE Coal Prices June 2003 to July 2008 Current Price = $149 / ton Current Price = $140 / ton Source: % - Central Appalachia +452% - Northern Appalachia +200% - Illinois Basin +254% - Uinta Basin +127% - Powder River Basin

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Serious Grid / Infrastructure Challenges There will need to be $350 billion invested in power generation over the next decade. Transmission represents another $150 billion of needed investment -- the distribution infrastructure in our cities has really deteriorated. Environmental retrofits on existing plants are going to cost another $50 billion, and that doesn't include carbon capture. Efficiency investments are going to be another $50 billion." Mac MacFarland VP of Corporate Development Exelon Energy Source: Knowledge at Wharton

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Whats Your Prediction? Source: US Department of Energy / kwh

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Natural Gas Spot Prices (Oct 83 – Apr 08)

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Energy Market Drivers 1990 Market Restructuring Aging Power Grid Globalization Digital Economy Emissions and Climate Change Energy Reliability and Security Resource Scarcity

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Final Thought: Finance Industry and Sustainability The finance industry prides itself on seeing the road ahead…… It cannot be done while using the rear view mirror……

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Perspective – Evolution Partners Work with asset owners and developers across North America –Strategy Pragmatic industry analysis Advise on what competitors are doing Portfolio analysis – buy/hold/sell –Asset positioning (development / existing) LEED-NC / LEED-EB audit EnergyStar benchmarking Environmental audit Recommend best practices –Financing Raise debt/equity capital for LEED projects Articulate asset features during underwriting (ie – resistance to mark-to-market) –Leasing and Marketing Communication strategies Green Lease Addendum Industry Work –Industry speaking – ULI / NAIOP –Green financial underwriting standards Clients Regional developers Public REITs Private equity firms Investment banks Start-up firms

Evolution Partners Copyright 2008 Green Homes and Sustainable Communities August 7, 2008 Dan Winters, Managing Principal 1511 Wisconsin Avenue NW #200 Washington, DC