Altered Hydrology & Vegetation: Effects on the Transport and Breakdown of Organic Matter in Urban Streams Kenneth T. Belt 1, Christopher Swan 2, Richard Pouyat 1, Sujay Kaushal 3, Peter Groffman 4, Istvan Turcsanyi 5, William Stack 6, and Gary Fisher 7 1 USDA Forest Service, 2 UMBC Dept. of Geography and Environmental Systems 3 UMCES Appalachian Lab, 4 Institute of Ecosystem Studies, 5, UMBC Center for Urban Environmental Research & Education, 6 Baltimore City DPW, 7 USGS BES Annual Meeting, Baltimore, UMBC, October 19, 2006 UMBC
Outline Urban Drainage Networks Leaf Breakdown DOC Export (preliminary) POM Export (preliminary) Ongoing Work
Support… Phyl (my wife)…arthritic bag making sessions, field work…putting up with me. Rich Pouyat (USFS)…Guidance, encouragement, bag making…field work (the infamous blind rainstorm drive) Chris Swan (UMBC GES)…guidance, encouragement, nutrient analysis, bug picking support Sujay Kaushal (UMCES)…guidance, encouragement, DOC analyses Peter Groffman/Dan Dillon, Gio et al. (IES)…sampling support, nutrient data; loan of an “ISCO” Claire Welty (CUERE)…facilities, guidance; loan of 2 “ISCOs” Istvan Turcsanyi (CUERE)…guidance and endless filtering and weighing UMBC GES interns: Bill Greenwood, Yaakov Birnbaum, Heather Modic All those technicians & colleagues…..
Motivation Leaves (and breakdown products & leachate) in streams are an important energy (food) source They also are habitat They are important in a variety of BGC reactions and pathways They also likely carry significant, not heretofore considered, elemental/pollutant loads
Urban Drainage Networks
Buried Urban Streams
Increased Effective Drainage Density in Urban Streams Curb & Gutter Network
“Upland Riparian” Streams…
….Deliver Particulate & Dissolved Loads to Streams
Urban Landscapes & Organic Matter Transport
The Gutter Subsidy
Civil Infrastructure and Organic Matter POM Pollutants Outputs To Stream Outputs To Stream Forest StandUrban Landscape
Leaf Breakdown
How quickly do leaves breakdown in the stream benthic environment?
Mass Loss from Leaf Bags
Breakdown Rates: Mass Loss Coefficients Exponential decay model: W t W 0 -1 = e -kt W 0 = the initial leaf mass (g) W t is the mass (g) remaining on day t k is the rate of breakdown (day -1 )
Leaf Breakdown: Basic Questions…Streams, Sources & Landscape Position 1.Do leaves breakdown faster in suburban than in forested streams? 2.Do leaves from upland portions of the urban landscape breakdown faster than riparian leaves? 3.Do leaves from gutter sources break down faster than leaves from higher points in the landscape and riparian leaves? 4.Do riparian leaves from different locations along the urban- rural gradient differ in their breakdown rates?
Stream Study Sites Baismans Run (Forested) Gwynns Falls At Gwynnbrook (Suburban) 10 kilometers Leaf Litter Breakdown Study Streams
Baltimore City Gwynns Falls at Gwynnbrook (Suburban) Baismans Run (Forested) Baismans Run Gwynns Falls at Gwynnbrook Study Stream Catchments
Riparian Source Sites (Sycamore) Distal Riparian (rural) Suburban Riparian Urban, Riparian Proximal Riparian (rural)
Suburban Landscape Urban Landscape Urban, Gutter Suburban, Gutter Lawn (“Landscape”) & Gutter Source Sites (Planetree)
Study Streams: Light Green- Forested, Dark Green- Suburban Suburban Stream Forested Stream Leaf Mass Loss Rates (Sycamore) (Planetree) Litter Sources
Urban Streams… Faster Mass Loss: Urban vs. Suburban Streams Leaf Mass Loss Rates
Riparian sources Slower Mass Loss Rates: Upland vs. Riparian Leaf Mass Loss Rates
“Gutter”… about the same as “Landscape” Litter Sources: Gutter vs. Landscape Leaf Mass Loss Rates Urban… Much faster than Suburban
No Effect for Riparian Leaves? The Riparian Urban-Rural Gradient Leaf Mass Loss Rates
DOC Export
DOC Export in Urban Streams 1.How do urban DOC concentrations and export rates compare to “natural” systems ? 2.How much does DOC transport vary temporally (seasonal); how important is hydrology (storms)? 3.Is drainage density (and its attendant features) important?
Preliminary DOC & Flow Data 8 of 13 sites 15 to 20 samples at each site July to November 2005 Grab sampling…every few weeks Mostly dry weather Some with recent storm runoff activity (within days)
More ISC… More Runoff
More ISC… Higher DOC Conc
More ISC… Higher Catchment DOC Exports
Urban catchments… High DOC exports at higher flows
Urban catchments produce large DOC loads…including at elevated flows And these loads may be related to to impervious area cover & infrastructure…?
POM Export
POM Export in Urban Streams 1.How do urban POM concentrations and export rates compare to “natural” systems ? 2.How much does POM transport vary temporally (seasonal); how important is hydrology (storms)? 3.Is drainage density (and its attendant features) important?
AFDM & TSS at 3 Sites Baismans R, GFalls at Gwynnbrook, Dead R; Apr to Sep 2006 % Organic Matter Forested: 31 % Suburban: 39 % Urban: 52% % Organic Matter Apr-MayJun-Sep Forested: 40 %29 % Suburban: 50 %37 % Urban: 42 %54% TSS AFDM Forested Suburban Urban
AFDM & TSS at 11 Sites Spg-Sum 2006
Ongoing/Future Work
Organic Matter…the Urban Dilemma Urban streams: faster particle breakdown …greater export rates from the benthic ecosystem…carbon poor benthos But…. Higher urban imports (gutter subsidy)? Smaller particles? Leached loads (DOC)?
Organic Matter in Streams: Types of OM DOC- dissolved OM FPOM- fine particulate OM CPOM- coarse particulate OM
Organic Matter in Streams: Basic Transport Pathways DOC CPOM FPOM Groundwater Surface & Shallow Groundwater Leaching Surface Waters DOC Riparian & Upland Litterfall
13 gauged BES catchments…an urban-rural gradient Storm and dry weather sampling Intensive sampling with auto samplers at 3 catchments Particulate and dissolved organic matter Urban hydrology approach Sediment exports (% organic matter) Basic Approach
Bridge Dry Weather Flow Storm Flow Discrete Storm FPOM Samples Discrete Storm CPOM Samples 24 hr CPOM Sampler (Dry Weather Flow) Whole Storm CPOM Sampler Peak Storm Flow CPOM Sampler (stationary) Intensive Site Sampling Conceptual Scheme Automated Sampler FPOM Grab (Dry Weather Flow) USGS Stage Recorder
Gwynns Falls Main Channel Stream Sites Small Headwater Stream Sites Subcatchment Stream Sites Baismans Run Gwynns Falls BES Stream Sites: Routine & Intensive GFGB GFVN GFCP BARN POBR DRKR 3 Intensive Monitoring Sites 13 Routine Sampling Sites:
Gwynns Falls Main Channel Stream Sites Small Headwater Stream Sites Subcatchment Stream Sites Baismans Run Gwynns Falls BES Stream Sites: Auto Storm Composites GFGB GFVN RGHT BALT & LANV 7 Auto Sampler Storm Composite Samplers (including the 3 OM intensive Sites) 13 Routine Sampling Sites:
A Multidisciplinary, Cooperative Effort… US Forest Service UMBC Geography & Environmental Systems UMCES Appalachian Lab Center for Urban Environmental Research and Education Baltimore Ecosystem Study/Institute of Ecosystem Studies City of Baltimore DPW US Geological Survey …and more partners to come