CONFIDENTIAL www.mcguirewoodsconsulting.com Virginia WaterJAM 2010 Christopher D. Lloyd September 22, 2010 Public Private Partnerships – Statutory Frameworks.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Statutory Frameworks for Public Private Partnerships HMFA Lone Star Chapter 2009 Winter Institute Dallas, TX Christopher.
Advertisements

July 15, 2008 – GB Work Session Discussion of Mayor Thomas E. Swisstack’s Priority List Recommendations.
Presentation to Montgomery County Rapid Transit System (RTS) Steering Committee July 30, 2013 Purple Line Private Public Partnership Initiative.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot PPEA Primer Southampton County Board of Supervisors Christopher D. Lloyd November 26, 2007.
A Match made in Heaven? Connecting you with a builder.
Marcy Mealy Procurement Specialist CDBG Program
1. Virginia’s Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) Northern Border Finance Workshop December 11, 2006 Thomas W. Pelnik III, P.E. Director, Innovative.
COMPLIANCE WITH PROCUREMENT VEHICLES AND PROTESTING THOSE WHO DON’T COMPLY William J. Cea, Esq. Becker & Poliakoff, P.A. Deborah Bovarnick Mastin, Esq.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd SMPS – Southeastern Regional Conference March 11, 2009 PPP 101: A Primer on Public Private.
Click to edit Master title style Romania - Financing Opportunities for Investors State Aid Schemes September.
Presentation By: Chris Wade, P Eng. Finally … a best practice for selecting an engineering firm.
PROJECT DELIVERY SYSTEMS
PROCEDURES FOR SELECTING THE CONTRACTOR
TIA Solid Waste Consultants, Inc.1 Presented by Miriam Zimms, Senior Consultant TIA Solid Waste Consultants, Inc. Tampa, Florida Pollution Prevention Conference.
WELCOME TO THE PROCUREMENT SEMINAR Procurement and Contracts An Overview of Contract Administration.
The Importance of the Qualifications Based Selection (QBS) Process
The Public Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act of 2002 Construction Owners Association of America, Inc. – Virginia Chapter Spring Seminar.
CONFIDENTIAL Susan Liberty and Christopher D. Lloyd June 4, 2009 Public Private Partnerships – Statutory Frameworks for.
Public Works Contracting Marsha Reilly Office of Program Research House of Representatives recommended.
VIRGINIA PUBLIC-PRIVATE EDUCATION FACILITIES AND INFRASTRUCURE ACT OF 2002 (PPEA) Augusta County Board of Supervisors Wednesday, January 6, 2009.
CONFIDENTIAL U.S. – Korea Pharma CEO Forum Christopher D. Lloyd November 4, 2010 Economic Considerations for U.S. Operations.
PPEA and Other Alternative Funding Programs for Public Works American Public Works Association Annual Meeting, Hampton, Virginia Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Policy Trends Christopher D. Lloyd September 24, 2008.
CONFIDENTIAL Chesapeake Economic Development Advisory Council Christopher D. Lloyd April 9, 2010 Economic Development Accomplishments.
Best Value for Clients Presented to the Canadian Public Procurement Forum by Glenn Martin, Executive Director Consulting Engineers of BC November 4, 2009.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Virginia’s Public Private Partnership Law Toyo University Tokyo, Japan Christopher D. Lloyd September 29, 2008.
Design–Build Contracts G. Hardy Acree Director of Airports Sacramento County Airport System Advantages of of During Turbulent Times.
Legislative Opportunities and Impediments - The Virginia Experience Virginia Public Private Partnerships ATRA TECHNIX Program Phil Bomersheim “Activist”
Public-Private Partnership Program 2015 Update 2015 American Council of Engineering Companies ACEC – Los Angeles Chapter Luncheon, July 8, 2015.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd NCPPP Annual Conference November 19, 2009 Changes in the P3 World – Law and Policy.
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act 2002 (PPEA) Joe Damico.
1. 2 Route 895 PPTA (2002) 3 Communication Dilbertian [v. Newtonian] Logic: We know that communication is a problem, but the company is not going to.
Texas Turnpike Authority Division AASHTO Right of Way & Utilities Committee Conference Wednesday – April 22, 2009.
Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act Acquisition of professional architectural, engineering, landscape architectural, or surveying and mapping.
Two Heads are Better Than One Patrick Callahan, Snyder & Associates Handouts and presentation are available online at
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd Virginia Educational Facility Planners 2009 Annual Conference March 3, 2009 What the Federal.
CONFIDENTIAL Council for Resource Development Christopher D. Lloyd November 3, 2010 Public Private Partnerships – How They.
Innovations in Water and Wastewater Infrastructure Procurement – The Virginia Experience Water Finance and Investment Summit New York, NY Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd DBIA Water & Wastewater/Transportation Joint Program April 21, 2010 Emerging Policy Trends.
FLORIDA COUNCIL OF PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS Lee A. Weintraub, Esq. Becker & Poliakoff, P.A Stirling Road Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33311
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using the PPEA for Infrastructure Development Design-Build Institute of America Mid-Atlantic Chapter Christopher D. Lloyd.
Alternative Procurement Tools for Historic Revitalization Projects Local Government Attorneys of Virginia Association Presentation Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods.
Innovations in Infrastructure Procurement – The Virginia Experience Design-Build Institute of America Washington, DC Chapter Chris Lloyd McGuireWoods Consulting.
CONFIDENTIAL Christopher D. Lloyd Urban Land Institute – Richmond Urban Marketplace May 4, 2009 Role of Transportation and.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using Public Private Partnerships Parkland Blue Ribbon Panel Christopher D. Lloyd October 22, 2007.
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act.
Click to add a subtitle 1 expect the best Briefing to the ITIB April 7, 2004 The VITA Process for the Management and Governance.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Statutory Frameworks for Public Private Partnerships NCPPP/AGC Conference Phoenix, AZ Christopher D. Lloyd January 27,
CONFIDENTIAL Virginia’s PPEA, NC SB 822, and Lessons Learned Institute for Emerging Issues North Carolina State University.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Using the PPEA for Downtown Revitalization Virginia Downtown Development Association Christopher D. Lloyd October 4, 2007.
LEGISLATIVE REQUIREMENTS FOR UNSOLICITED PROPOSALS FLORIDA COUNCIL FOR PUBLIC/PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS OCTOBER 3, 2013 Lee A. Weintraub, Esq. Becker & Poliakoff,
Governor’s Commission on Job Creation and Economic Development – An Update Chris Lloyd July 22, 2010.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Trends Christopher D. Lloyd March 23, 2008.
CONFIDENTIAL Montgomery County Board of Supervisors Christopher D. Lloyd October 25, 2010 Public Private Partnerships for.
CONSULTANT SELECTION ACEC-Illinois/ IDOT-Region 1 Local Roads Seminar March 7, 2013.
CONFIDENTIAL VASCUPP Conference Christopher D. Lloyd September 25, 2013 Is the PPEA Process Right for You?
Public Private Partnership Guidelines Task Force Update Presented By George M. Burgess.
Solving Challenges Others Cannot Economic Development Policy Trends Christopher D. Lloyd June 18, 2008.
Virginia Office of Public-Private Partnerships (VAP3) Adopted Public-Private Transportation Act (PPTA) enabling legislation in 1995 Public-Private Education.
CONFIDENTIAL 9 th Annual Focus Northwest Florida Christopher D. Lloyd October 16, 2010 Economic Development Policy Trends.
Progressive Design-Build: Examining the Structure, Procurement and Contracting Principles Michael C. Loulakis, Esq., DBIA Capital Project Strategies, LLC.
Real Property Policy Update Planning and Development Committee August 4, 2015.
Southeast Rail Extension FasTracks Monitoring Committee July 14, 2015.
One East Broward Blvd., Suite 1800
BOT LAW (R.A. No. 6957, as amended by R.A. No. 7718)
PRESENTER Jose A. Galan ▸ Division Director, Internal Services Department, Real Estate Development Division ▸ Current Chair of the Florida Council For.
QBS: The Process Selecting a Design Firm
A Primer on Virginia’s PPEA
Virginia’s Public Private Partnership Law
Virginia’s PPEA and Water and Wastewater Partnerships
Presentation transcript:

CONFIDENTIAL Virginia WaterJAM 2010 Christopher D. Lloyd September 22, 2010 Public Private Partnerships – Statutory Frameworks for Alternative Project Delivery

2 Design-Build Originated in private sector, began public sector use in 1980s/1990s Design-Build Review Board created in 1996 to grant project specific approvals Law amended in 2006 to allow one-time board approval to certain public entities (localities over 100,000) Engineer and contractor propose as a common team with shared risks and rewards Public entity often uses on-call or in-house expertise to scope project and assist with team evaluation Widely used by VDOT, about other projects statewide

3 Design-Build: Pros Budget certainty Qualifications based selection, price is not the sole factor Reduces project delivery time Collaboration between engineer and contractor can result in project efficiencies/value engineering Contract forms (DBIA models) becoming generally accepted Turnkey project delivery Single point of contact

4 Design-Build: Cons Authority would have to seek approval from the Virginia Design-Build Review Board Design and construction methods often feel fluid and decisions made “on the fly” Project price could have significant contingency costs to cover risks shifted from the public entity Procurement costs are borne by the public entity

5 PPEA Law passed in 2002 Allows for both solicited and unsolicited proposals for development and/or operation of “qualifying projects” Public entity must adopt guidelines to consider project proposals 2 phase process – conceptual and detailed Results in a de facto design-build procurement Nearly 100 projects completed or underway statewide

6 PPEA: Dispelling the Myths Not a panacea Not free money Not a finance tool Not secret negotiations Not necessarily cheaper Not privatization

7 PPEA: Project Examples - Utilities Bedford County Public Service Authority (completed) Prince William Service Authority (completed) City of Fredericksburg (completed) Southampton County (under construction) Virginia Beach pump stations (rejected) Northampton County/Cape Charles (rejected) Prince Edward County (entering IA phase) Petersburg pump station (pending) Augusta County Service Authority (under construction) Hampton Roads Sanitation District (pending)

8 PPEA: Process Public entity solicits for proposals or accepts unsolicited proposals Minimum of 45 day open competition period for unsolicited proposals FOIA protections for confidential information are negotiated Conceptual proposal outlines team qualifications, proposed scope, proposed scope and public benefits Public entity may levy a proposal review fee on both solicited and unsolicited proposals Proposal review fee is used to cover procurement costs

9 PPEA: Process All competing proposals are reviewed, followed by a downselect Detailed proposals are requested – often relies on recommendations of outside/inside advisors Detailed proposals start to lock in project scope, costs, schedule Leads to an interim or comprehensive agreement with one firm Significant requirements for public notification and hearings

10 PPEA: Pros Many of the same benefits as design-build PPEA has a certain “cachet” with state regulatory and funding bodies No non-local approvals necessary Public entity retains right to reject, modify, expand, or amend proposals at any time Project review costs can be covered by proposers Staff augmentation and single point responsibility

11 PPEA: Cons Project scope and cost may not be defined until late in the negotiation process Learning curve for public officials and public Suspicions about “competitive negotiations” Did I get the best possible price? Negotiations can be lengthy and complex

12 Mitigating PPEA Risks Use of strong outside advisors with PPEA experience Two step solicitation process Establishing clear goals, particularly related to price Use of interim agreement process Circulate proposed comprehensive agreement at detailed review phase Prepare contingency budgets and plans that share risk and rewards

13 Business Expansion | Federal Public Affairs | Strategic Communications & Grassroots Mobilization State & Local Government Affairs | Emerging European Markets Atlanta Charlotte Charlottesville Chicago Columbia Norfolk Raleigh Springfield Tyson’s Corner Washington, D.C. | Bucharest, Romania THE END