Synthesis of Lamellarin D A Novel Potent Inhibitor of DNA Topoisomerase I Wenhui Hao March 16 th, 2006
Outline Biological activities Structure-activity relationship Identification of LAM-D as an inhibitor of Topo I Three synthetic routes 2
Background Cancer Normal cells-- new cell growth balance with old cells die Cancer cells-- loss of normal growth control loss of ability to undergo programmed cell death 3
Cancer Treatment Surgery Radiation Chemotherapy : Alkylating agents Antimetabolites Plant alkaloids Antitumour agents Topoisomerase inhibitors 4
Topoisomerases Maintaining the topographic structure of circular DNA Topo I: transient single-strand break (Lam D) Topo II: double-strand break Breaking--Uncoiling--Replication DNA helix 5
DNA Structure DNA Double Strand Helix 6
A,T, G, C bases can extend away from chain stack at top each other dA-dT, dG-dC base pairs are the same length Occupy the same space The distance between the two bps is 3.4Ǻ Base Pairs 7
Topoisomerase I Activity Topo I : 100 KD monomeric protein,breaks single strands, by cleaving a phosphodiester bond form a phosphotyrosine topoI-DNA complex 8
Topoisomerase I Activity Religation is faster than cleavage → DNA-Topo I complex concentration remains low Drugs stabilize the complex and Block DNA religation, converting Topo I into a DNA damaging agent 9
Topo Inhibitors Mechanism of Action Covalent binding to double-stranded DNA Cleavable complex by binding to DNA-Topo I or II Uncoiling of double-strande DNA, prevents resealing Replication halted at Topo-DNA complex stage Replication fork collides with trapped complex double strand breaks and cell death 10
Activity does not change with growth of the cells Topo I levels in tumor specimens are higher than normal tissues and Topo II making inhibition of Topo I an attractive target for anticancer agents Significant activity against a broad range of tumors Advantages of Topo I Inhibitors 11
Camptothecin (CPT) and Its Analogs First isolated from the Chinese tree Camptotheca acuminata, Nyssaceae. in 1966 CPTs inhibit Topo I as cytotoxic agents Clinical test against colon, ovarian cancers Serious side effects, poor water solubility Wall M et al J.Am.Chem.Soc 1966,88:
Topotecan (TPT) Water-soluble CPT derivative Significant activity against tumor cell lines (breast, lung ) Stabilizes DNA-drug-Topo I complex and inhibits Topo I function causing DNA strand breakage. Approved in 1996, first Topo I inhibitor treating ovarian cancer John Nitiss Nurrent Opinion In Investigational Drugs 2002, 3 (10) :
Bart Staker et al PNAS Vol. 99, No , Crystal Structures of Topo I-DNA-TPT Complex Topo 70-DNA Binary ComplexTopo 70-DNA-Topotecan Ternary Complex 3.6 Ǻ 7.2 Ǻ Mimic bp Extends bp distance 14
Hydrogen bond contact to the active site of Topo I and phosphotyrosine Free-OH displaced 8Ǻ from phosphotyrosine of Topo I Mechanism of Topo I Inhibitor- TPT 15
Marine Alkaloid- Lamellarins Isolated in 1985 from a Lamellaria sp. of marine prosobranch mollusc Lam A,B,C,D were obtained C and D inhibition of cell division A and B were inactive Raymond J. Andenen et al J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1985, 107,
The main pentacyclic array is essentially planar The aromatic ring attached to C1 is rotated 90°to the main plane Structure properties 17
A Growing Family --Three Groups Open Chain Fused: S or D * 35 lamellarins have been isolated, from ascidian and sponge species * A pentacyclic core, variation from hydroxy, methoxy substitution 18
Biological Activities Common activities Inhibition of cell division Cytotoxicity Immunomodulatory activity Recent findings Lamellarin D : Antitumor activity against MDR cell lines Selective cytotoxicity for prostate cancer cells 19
Ishibashi’s Synthesis of LAM-D Fumito Ishibashi et al. Tetrahedron, 1997, 53(17): N-ylide- mediated pyrrole ring formation of a quaternary ammonium salt followed by lactonization 20
Model Study 7a:7b = 92:8 21
Ishibashi’s Synthesis of LAM-D 6-Benzyloxy-l-(4-benlzyloxy-3-methoxybenzyl)-7-methoxyisoquinoline(3) 22
Ishibashi’s Synthesis of LAM-D Methyl 4-Benzyloxy-5-methoxy-2-methoxymethoxybenzoate(4) 23
Ishibashi’s Synthesis of LAM-D 24
Ishibashi’s Synthesis of LAM-D 4% 14 steps 25
26 Activity of Lam D and Lam 11 Cytotoxicities against tumor Cell Lines, IC 50 ( μ M) compound Hella XC lamellarin D Lam mitomycin C 68.0 ND a 26
27 Structure-Activity Relationship Study of Lamellarin Derivatives Fumito Ishibashi et al. J. Nat. Prod. 2002, 65, OH at C-8 C-20 essential OH at C-14 MeO at C-13, C-21 less important 27
28 Effect of OH at C-20 28
29 Effect of OH at C-8 C-8 OH, lacks C-14 OH, maintains high activity Methylation of OH at C-8, C-14 decrease activity 29
30 Banwell’s Synthesis- Lamellarin Parent Ring System An intramolecular [3 + 2] cycloaddition between an isoquinoline-based azomethine ylide and a tethered tolan Martin Banwell, et al. Chem. Commun. 1997:
31 Christian P. Ridley, et al. Bioorg. Med. Chem., 2002, 10: Application of Banwell’s Approach 31
32 Application of Banwell’s Approach 32
33 Application of Banwell’s Approach 17% 12 steps 33
34 Identification of LAM-D as an Inhibitor of TopoI Michael Facompre et al. Cancer Research 2003, 63,
35 DNA Relaxation Experiment – Topo I Inhibition Efficacy c Nck:nicked form II,single-strand break 35 a d b
36 Detectation of the Extents of Cleavage LAM D induced dose dependent stimulation of DNA cleavage by topo I Equally effective at 2 μM 70% of the DNA single-strand breaks 36
37 Topo I Inhibition: Site Selectivity Cleavage of DNA fragment by Topo I (increasing concentrations of LAM-D) Common site Side numbers of gels show nucleotide positions determined with reference to guanine(G) tracks 37
38 Topo I Inhibition: Site Selectivity CPT specific 38
39 Topo I Inhibition: Site Selectivity LAM D specific 39
40 Molecular Modeling Theoretical model of LAM-D covalently bound to topoisomerase I–DNA complex. 40
41 Summary of the Study of SAR Planar conformation of LAM-D suited for intercalation into DNA OH at C-8, C-20 : Essential OH at C-14, MeO at C-13, C-21 : Less important Essential 41
42 Olsen-Pla’s Open Chain-Modular Synthetic Route to Lamellarins Christian A. Olsen, et al. Tetrahedron Letters, 2005, 46: N-alkylation with p-toluenesulfonate and intramolecular Heck cyclization from Methyl pyrrole-2-carboxylate to Scaffold 1 42
43 For all compounds R 1 =Oi-Pr,R 2 =OMe Olsen-Pla’s Open Chain-Modular Synthetic Route to Lamellarins 43 Synthesis of open chain analogues
44 27% 9 steps 35% 9 steps Olsen-Pla’s Open Chain-Modular Synthetic Route to Lamellarins 44
45 Daniel Pla, et al. J.Org.Chem.2005,70: Modular Synthesis of Lamellarin D 45 Two sequential and regio-selective bromination and cross-coupling reactions using different substituted arylboronic ester
46 Modular Synthesis of Lamellarin D 46
47 Modular Synthesis of Lamellarin D 47
48 9% 13 steps Modular Synthesis of Lamellarin D 48
49 Comparison of Three Synthesis 1. Ishibashi’s N-ylide approach · Prepared and evaluated 10 derivatives · Lam D: 14 steps, overall yield 4% · Ring substitution limited 2. Banwell’s Intermolecular 3+2 approach · Most direct method to the lamellarins · 12 steps, overall yield 17% · Prepared Lam D and Lam Olsen-Pla’s Open chain-Modular synthesis approach · More flexible, effective method · Open chain analogues: 9 steps, 27-35% yield · Lam D: 13 steps, overall yield 9% 49
50 Conclusion A novel class of marine alkaloids – Lamellarins isolated Lamellarin D Identified as a lead candidate for Topo I targeted antitumor agent Structure-activity relationship studied Three different synthetic methods compared Ishibashi’s synthesis Banwell’s synthesis Olsen-Pla’s synthesis 50
51 Acknowledgment Dr.Wang Hadizad Tayebeh Dr. Jane Gao Shidi Xun Dr. Hongding Tang Xun Sun Dr. Xianzhen Li Xianguo Wu Yuxing Cui Ying Xiong Gaetan LeClair 51