Decoherence in the Brain Faculty of Physics University of Vienna, Austria Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Pressure and Kinetic Energy
Advertisements

Ben Gurion University of the Negev Week 3. Electric potential.
Heavy Atom Quantum Diffraction by Scattering from Surfaces Eli Pollak Chemical Physics Department Weizmann Institute of Science Coworkers: Dr. Jeremy M.
B.Macukow 1 Neural Networks Lecture 2. B.Macukow 2 Biological and Neurological Background Human Nervous system.
Neurones Dendrites Axon Facilitated diffusion Schwann cells Active transport Myelin Na + /K + pump Synapse.
6.5 (part 1)The nervous system
Introduction to Quantum Biology Are biologic systems quantum mechanical?
Chapter (6) Introduction to Quantum Mechanics.  is a single valued function, continuous, and finite every where.
Electric fields 電場 (chap. 22) The Coulomb’s law tells us how a charge interact with other charged particles, but how does the charge “know” of the presence.
Exam and Assignment Dates Midterm 1 Feb 3 rd and 4 th Midterm 2 March 9 th and 10 th Final April 20 th and 21 st Idea journal assignment is due on last.
Course Business Extra Credit available through Psych Subject Pool (and occasionally other experiments) –Up to 2 extra points (i.e. two experiments) –Some.
First, some philosophy I see, I hear, I feel… Who is I - Do you mean my brain sees, hears, and feels or do you mean something else?
Lecture 2: Forces and Potentials. What did we cover in the last lecture? Microscopic and nanoscale forces are important in a number of areas of nanoscience,
Crystal Lattice Vibrations: Phonons
Suprit Singh Talk for the IUCAA Grad-school course in Inter-stellar medium given by Dr. A N Ramaprakash 15 th April 2KX.
Lecture 10 Energy production. Summary We have now established three important equations: Hydrostatic equilibrium: Mass conservation: Equation of state:
By Po-Han Chen  Creatures on the world can feel the surrounding in order to adapt the environment for survival. Animals relies on Endocrine system and.
Lecture 5: Electron Scattering, continued... 18/9/2003 1
Monte-Carlo simulations of the structure of complex liquids with various interaction potentials Alja ž Godec Advisers: prof. dr. Janko Jamnik and doc.
Electric field Electric field intensity Electric potential Membrane potential Electric fields organs and tissues Electrocardiography.
Computational Biology, Part 20 Neuronal Modeling Robert F. Murphy Copyright  1996, 1999, All rights reserved.
ATOM-ION COLLISIONS ZBIGNIEW IDZIASZEK Institute for Quantum Information, University of Ulm, 20 February 2008 Institute for Theoretical Physics, University.
Chapter 41 The Nervous System.
Nervous System Electrical Conduction & Impulse to Control Body Function.
Electric Charge and Electric Field
Electricity and Magnetism  Electric forces hold atoms and molecules together.  Electricity controls our thinking, feeling, muscles and metabolic processes.
Tipler: 21-7 Electromagnetism I Electric Dipoles and their Interactions in Electric Fields.
Correlation-Induced Oscillations in Spatio-Temporal Excitable Systems Andre Longtin Physics Department, University of Ottawa Ottawa, Canada.
Physics II: Electricity & Magnetism Sections 21.9 to
Glasma Definition: The matter which is intermediate between the Color Glass Condensate and the Quark Gluon Plasma It is not a glass, evolving on a natural.
110/29/2015 Physics Lecture 4  Electrostatics Electric flux and Gauss’s law Electrical energy potential difference and electric potential potential energy.
- The central nervous system consists of the brain and the spinal cord - sensory information is received by them and interpreted and then processed (responded.
From Last Time: Electric field of a single charge Electric field from multiple charges Superposition Ex: calculate electric field of dipole Oct. 1, 2009Physics.
(1) Experimental evidence shows the particles of microscopic systems moves according to the laws of wave motion, and not according to the Newton laws of.
Body Systems Nervous System. Nervous System Functions  Sensory input – sense organs, receptors, –afferent neurons  Integration – Central Nervous System(CNS)
Nervous System Structure and Function Pt 1. Nervous System Function The nervous system controls and coordinates functions throughout the body, and responds.
The Nervous System Anatomy and Physiology Nervous System Functions 1. Sensory-receptors gather information and pass it on toward the CNS 2. Integrative-in.
Quantum Physics II.
Course Business Exam schedule confirmed: –Midterm 1: Feb 6 – 9 –Midterm 2: March 5 – 8 –Final Exam: April
Nervous communication.  Nervous system provides fast communication and coordination  Mammalian nervous system:  Central nervous system (CNS): brain.
How neurons communicate ACTION POTENTIALS Researchers have used the axons of squids to study action potentials The axons are large (~1mm) and extend the.
Unit 3: Biological Bases of Behavior 3-A (The Neuron) Mr. Debes A.P. Psychology.
Neurons Structure and Function G.Burgess. Neuron Specialized cells that send electric signals as impulses through the body.
Nervous System. Neuron (nerve cell) StructureFunction Cell BodyCentral part of the neuron. It contains the nucleus of the cell. where most protein.
Chapter 17 The nervous system.
Nerve Impulses.
Energy, Stereoscopic Depth, and Correlations. Molecules Levels of Information Processing in the Nervous System 0.01  m Synapses 1m1m Neurons 100 
Neurons.
The Electrochemical Impulse Action Potential Threshold Level All-or-None Response.
Oct. 4, From last time(s)… Work, energy, and (electric) potential Electric potential and charge Electric potential and electric field. Electric charges,
1 Cell Potential Presented by- Md. Bashir Uddin Roll: Dept. of BME KUET, Khulna-9203.
Lecture 3. INTRODUCTION TO PLASMA PHYSICS
An equation for matter waves Seem to need an equation that involves the first derivative in time, but the second derivative in space As before try solution.
Fall 2010 Prof. Yong Chen Prof. Michael Manfra Lecture 2 Slide PHYS 272:
The Neuron Functions of the nervous system Two parts to the nervous system: Peripheral nervous system – nerves and supporting cells that collects.
Department of Physics & Astronomy Institute for Gravitational Research Scottish Universities Physics Alliance Brownian thermal noise associated with attachments.
NEUROPHYSIOLOGY. OBJECTIVES: Describe resting membrane potential. Explain how action potentials are generated and propagated along nerves. Explain how.
Nervous System. The nervous system is broken down into two major parts:
Today’s groups. Physics 414: Introduction to Biophysics Professor Henry Greenside August 31, 2017.
The Nervous System Allows communication between cells & tissues of the body. Acts like a telephone or computer network with a complex central control.
Production of an S(α,β) Covariance Matrix with a Monte Carlo-Generated
6.5 Nervous System.
Neurons, Synapses, and Signaling
Action Potential 6.5.
Effects of Excitatory and Inhibitory Potentials on Action Potentials
Neuronal Signals.
Nerve cells and their support system
Neurons and Nerves Impulses
The Biological Basis of Behavior
Do Now: 1. What is 1 of the characteristics of nerve signals that you defined from the “dominos” lab? 2. What is the role of the axon? 3. What creates.
Presentation transcript:

Decoherence in the Brain Faculty of Physics University of Vienna, Austria Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information Austrian Academy of Sciences Seminar “Quantum Physics and Biology” University of Vienna June 16 th, 2008 Johannes Kofler

Motivation Mainstream biophysics Brain is modeled as a neural network obeying classical physics Conjecture Sufficiently complex network can explain consciousness Consciousness as a quantum effect? Wigner, Stapp, Penrose, … Arguments that decoherence destroys superpositions in the brain Zeh, Zurek, Hawking, Hepp, … Settle the issue by detailed calculations Tegmark [Refs.]M. Tegmark, Phys. Rev. E 61, 4194 (2000) M. Tegmark, Inf. Sci. 128, 155 (2000)

Introduction System is decomposed into subsystem 1 and subsystem 2 Effects of interactions Hamiltonian: 1.Fluctuation(e.g. Brownian motion) 2.Dissipation(e.g. friction) 3.Communication(increase of mutual information) 4.Decoherence(pure quantum effect) exchange of energy exchange of information (  ) Example: Spatial superposition of colloid of mass M (system 1) in water molecules of mass m (system 2)  dec   coll single collision leads to decoherence  diss   coll M/m   dec many collisions are necessary for dissipation

Classification of systems  dyn   dec quantum system  dyn   diss not independent  dec   dyn   diss familiar classical system  dec ~  diss microsystem (never classical)  dec   diss macrosystem (can be quantum)  diss /  dec  dyn /  dec

Subject, object, environment 1.Subject: degrees of freedom of subjective perceptions of the observer; not other degrees of freedom of the brain 2.Object: the degrees of freedom the observer is studying 3.Environment: everything else H se causes decoherence directly in the subject system, e.g. finalizing a “quantum decision”

Superpositions of neuron states? 1.Brain consists of  neurons 2.Nonlinear coupling via synapses (in average  10 3 per neuron) 3.Linked to subjective perceptions 4.If H s or H so puts subject into superposition of two mental states, then some neurons are in superposition of firing and not firing 5.How fast does such a superposition of neuron states decohere? Neuron “resting state”: U 0  –0.07 V across axon membrane (pos. outside) If the potential becomes slightly less negative, sodium channels open:  Na + ions come in and make the potential even less negative  chain reaction  propagates with up to 100 m/s  changing potential difference to U 1  V  the neuron recovers quickly (it can fire over 1000 times per second)

Neuron, myelinated axon, axon membrane h thickness of axon membrane  surface charge density L,d length and diameter of axon ffraction of bare area A active surface area  10 6 Number of Na + ions migrating in:

Neuron decoherence mechanisms In superposition of firing and not firing we have N  10 6 ions in superposition of being inside and outside the axon membrane, separated by h  10 nm. Sources of decoherence: 1.Collisions with other ions 2.Collisions with water molecules 3.Coulomb interaction with distant ions 4.… If then the density matrix for the position r 1 = x of a single Na + ion evolves to where f depends only on H int.

Ion-ion collisions Environmental particles (Na + ions) at 37°C have de Broglie wavelength The density matrix becomes with Scattering rate Density of scatterers n, cross section , velocity v (thermal distribution) Since (i.e. h  ) a spatial superposition decays exponentially on the time scale  –1.

For N  10 6 ions a superposition gets destroyed on a time scale Coulomb scattering between two ions of unit charge has a cross section with v the relative velocity and In thermal equilibrium: Ion density: where Ion-ion collisions thus destroy the superposition on the time scale Similar time scales for ion-water collisions and Coulomb interactions with nearby ions.

Microtubules Component of the cytoskeleton, hollow cylinders (diameter D = 24 nm), made of 13 filaments out of tubulin dimers Dimers can make transitions between two states corresponding to different electric dipole moments along the tube axis. – Penrose/Hameroff: microtubules are quantum computers Calculation of decoherence rate: Coordinate along the tube axis: x Tubulin dimer x-component of electric dipole moment: p(x) Propagating kink like excitations (kink location x 0 ):

Total charge around the kink: Thus, (18 Ca 2+ ions in each filament contributing to p 0 ) Suppose: kink is in superposition of two different places, separated by |r’–r|, where |r’–r|  D = 24 nm Decoherence (due to Coulomb interaction with nearby ions) takes place on a time scale 12 orders of magnitude smaller than reported by Hameroff (screening effects?) Decoherence summary (conservative estimates)

Classical nature of brain processes Cognitive processes:  dyn ~ 10 –2 s – 1 s Neuron firing:  dyn ~ 10 –4 s – 10 –3 s Microtuble excitation:  dyn ~ 10 –6 s The brain is a (hyper)classical system (  diss ~  dyn ) Subject-object-environment decomposition Subject states: Object states: Joint system:   dec ~ 10 –20 s – 10 –13 s

HoHo H oe H so

H se Reducing object decoherence would not help, since decoherence takes place before the input through sensory nerves is completed. HsHs  dec   dyn

1.Assumption: Consciousness is synonymous to brain processes (Hobbes, 17 th century). 2.Subject degrees of freedom constitute a “world model”. 3.H so keeps correlations with outside world; produces mutual information between subject and surrounding. 4.“Binding problem”: Consciousness does not seem to be localized, but feels like a coherent entity (holisitc effect). 5.Can be explained in classical physics: e.g. oscillation in guitar string or water waves (Fourier space). 6.Decoherence calculations indicate that there is nothing fundamentally quantum mechanical about cognitive processes. 7.The brain seems to be a classical (dissipative) computer. Conclusion