How Can We Deal with Risks from the Internet: Why Privacy Legislation Is Hot Right Now Professor Peter Swire Ohio State University/Center for American.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
FDA Public Hearing Promotion FDA Public Hearing Promotion of FDA-Regulated Medical Products Using the Internet November 12, 2009 Testimony of Interactive.
Advertisements

Why the Financial Privacy Law is Better than People Think Professor Peter P. Swire Ohio State University University of Minnesota Symposium February 9,
The United States, Privacy, and Data Protection Peter P. Swire Dutch Embassy Presentation January 19, 2001.
Privacy and the Internet Professor Peter P. Swire Ohio State University National Press Foundation February 14, 2001.
Electronic Surveillance, Security, and Privacy Professor Peter P. Swire Ohio State University InSITes -- Carnegie Mellon February 7, 2002.
Better Security and Privacy for Home Broadband Peter P. Swire Moritz College of Law The Ohio State University Morrison & Foerster LLP Privacy 2002 Conference.
The Role of the Federal Government in Privacy Policy Professor Peter P. Swire The Ohio State University Center for American Progress The Privacy Symposium,
Trustwrap: The Importance of Legal Rules to E-Commerce and Internet Privacy Professor Peter P. Swire Moritz College of Law The Ohio State University Enforcing.
Why the Right to Data Portability Likely Reduces Consumer Welfare: Antitrust and Privacy Critique Peter Swire Moritz College of Law Yale Law School Information.
Liability Issues in Anti-Spyware Software Peter P. Swire Ohio State University Center for American Progress Anti-Spyware Coalition Public Workshop January.
Online Profiling and Consumer Choice Peter P. Swire Center for American Progress Ohio State University ATL Hill Briefing April 28, 2008.
Reflections on the White House Privacy Office Peter P. Swire Ohio State University Center for American Progress N.C. State Privacy Day January 29, 2008.
A New Framework for Protecting Consumers on the Internet Peter P. Swire Ohio State University & Center for American Progress Center for American Progress.
EU Privacy Directive. What is a directive? A piece of European legislation, passed by bureaucrats, addressed to member states Member states must ensure.
29e CONFÉRENCE INTERNATIONALE DES COMMISSAIRES À LA PROTECTION DES DONNÉES ET DE LA VIE PRIVÉE 29 th INTERNATIONAL DATA PROTECTION AND PRIVACY COMMISSIONERS.
The EU self-regulation of online behavioural advertising May 2014.
Country-Of-Destination In international e-commerce many countries use a "country-of- destination" approach for governing cyberspace. Country-of- destination.
1 Marketing Violent Entertainment to Children The FTC’s Reports on Self-Regulation and Industry Practices in the Motion Picture, Music Recording & Electronic.
Silicon Valley Apps for Kids Meetup Laura D. Berger October 22, 2012 The views expressed herein are those of the speaker, and do not represent the views.
Consumer Privacy and Information Access Professor Matt Thatcher.
Chapter 11 Privacy Policies and Behavioral Marketing.
Children's Online Privacy Protection Act and the Video Privacy Protection Act By: Alana Rushing.
CONFIDENTIAL1 TRUSTe Certification & APEC FTC Workshop on Enforceable Codes of Conduct Panel on APEC’s CBPR System November 29, 2012.
Global Information Systems
Handle with care : Digital marketing and online behavioural advertising Global guidance to help improve consumer trust in practice, techniques and messages.
Disclaimer This Presentation is provided “as is” without any express or implied warranty. This Presentation is for educational purposes only and does not.
Privacy as an International Information Issue MD823 October 18, 2004.
A European View of Privacy Protection John Woulds Director of Operations UK Data Protection Commissioner National Conference on Privacy, Technology & Criminal.
 Digital marketing: Uses digital media to develop communications and exchanges with customers  Electronic media (E-marketing): Refers to the strategic.
Why Privacy Now Goes Far Beyond Complying With Your Privacy Policy Peter Swire Facebook: June 3, 2015.
Per Anders Eriksson
The Privacy Tug of War: Advertisers vs. Consumers Presented by Group F.
“Social Networks, Privacy and Freedom of Association” Professor Peter Swire Ohio State University Social Media & the Law UNC Chapel Hill November 18, 2011.
Global Information Systems
LAW SEMINARS INTERNATIONAL New Developments in Internet Marketing & Selling November 13 & 14, 2006 San Francisco, California Moderator : Maureen A. Young.
Data Privacy and Security Prof Sunil Wattal. Consumer Analytics  Analytics with consumer data to derive meaningful insights on actions and behaviors.
“Social Networks, Privacy and Freedom of Association” Professor Peter Swire Ohio State University Center for American Progress TPRC September 25, 2011.
“Privacy and the Future of Justice Statistics” Peter P. Swire Chief Counselor for Privacy OMB/OIRA National Conf.on Privacy, Technology & Criminal Justice.
INHOPE Partnership Model
Privacy Codes of Conduct as a self- regulatory approach to cope with restrictions on transborder data flow Dr. Anja Miedbrodt Exemplified with the help.
Privacy Hot Topics Discussion August 18, 2011 The Corporate Privacy Forum Sharing practical solutions to today’s privacy challenges 1.
INDUSTRY COMMITMENT TO INNOVATION IN NOTICE AND CHOICE AAAA, ANA, CBBB, DMA, IAB Convene Task-Force (April 2008) Coalition begins drafting industry principles.
Lecture 17 Page 1 CS 236 Online Network Privacy Mostly issues of preserving privacy of data flowing through network Start with encryption –With good encryption,
“Social Networks, Privacy and Freedom of Association” Professor Peter Swire Ohio State University Privacy Working Group April 25, 2012.
IAPP KnowledgeNet Los Angeles “Thinking Outside the Cookie Jar” The Second Wave of Global Privacy Protection: Why This Year Is Different Peter Swire, Senior.
Privacy issues By: Joshua Junious Date: December 4, 2012 Course: CpSc 420 Instructor: Dr. Grossman.
Norton UniversityBusiness Concepts and Social Issues 1 PART TWO Business Concepts and Social Issues.
Location, Location, Location: The Emerging Crisis in Wireless Data Privacy Ari Schwartz & Alan Davidson Center for Democracy and Technology
Chapter 9: The Internet and World Wide Web Two contrasting views: Media Critic Marshall McCLuhan: the Internet would help create a “global village” of.
EPrivacy & Consenting Cookies Rakuten LinkShare Symposium 2012 Liz Robertson Jones Day 17 April 2012.
U.S. Self-Regulatory Principles for Online Behavioral Advertising – Status Update IAB Global Summit 2012: The Future of Public Policy First introduced.
Federal Trade Commission U.S. Rules on Privacy and Data Security Organization for International Investment General Counsel Conference October 16, 2009.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. BUSINESS PLUG-IN B19 Global Information Systems.
ECT 455/HCI 513 ECT 4 55/HCI 513 E-Commerce Web Site Engineering Legal Issues.
Student Financial Assistance. Session 55-2 Session 55 Internet Privacy Laws.
Privacy Concerns and Behavioral Advertising Ronald W. Del Sesto, Jr. Partner Bingham McCutchen, LLP (202)
PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION OF ADVERTISING.COM, INC. 1 ONLINE MARKETING SOLUTIONS FOR.
28/01/20161 The Future of Online Privacy: Online advertising and behavioral targeting Kristina Irion Third Internet Governance Forum Thursday, 5/12/2008.
Privacy Déjà Vu: Crypto, Government Surveillance and Safe Harbor, Peter Swire Georgia Tech/Alston & Bird IAPP Summit April 4, 2016.
1 Privacy & Preference Committee Update Ensuring a healthy ecosystem via transparency & trust Date: January 13, 2009 Alan Chapell, President.
How Technology is Prompting US/EU Tension on Mutual Legal Assistance Peter Swire Huang Professor Law and Ethics Georgia Tech Scheller College of Business.
Update from the Faster Payments Task Force
Big Data Considerations
Online platforms Brussels, September 2016.
Information Governance and Data Privacy: A World of Risk
Big Data Considerations
Sameer Sharma, ITU 7 August, 2018 Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Peter Swire Engage CISO Roundtable with the
Privacy Issues part 4 Information/data privacy
The Impact of Digitization on Global Alignment of Product Safety Regulations ICPHSO International Symposium November 12, 2018.
Presentation transcript:

How Can We Deal with Risks from the Internet: Why Privacy Legislation Is Hot Right Now Professor Peter Swire Ohio State University/Center for American Progress 5 th TransAtlantic Market Conference: Protecting Critical Technology & Infrastructure October 16, 2011

The Internet Then

The Internet Now

Overview Privacy legislation: – U.S. - Numerous bills, hearings now, most in a decade – E.U. - Directive update, first since 1995 Theme: – E.U. pattern of broad privacy laws, based on human rights, with exceptions in practice – U.S. pattern of narrow laws, based on consumer protection, with extra enforcement through jawboning and the press Why now? How to draw on the best of both worlds?

Brief History German and other national data protection laws in 1970s and 1980s Twin goals of the E.U. Directive, 1995/1998 – Assure transborder data flows within EU – Permit only legitimate processing of personal information – Data to other countries only if “adequate” protection U.S. laws – Sectoral laws since 1970 (Fair Credit Reporting Act) – HIPAA, GLB, children’s online in late 90’s – FTC enforces for “deceptive” practices online – But, no framework legislation EU/US “Safe Harbor” in 2000 – Many E.U. protections, but with clarity on practical exceptions Privacy less prominent after 9/11, but implementation continued

Changing Privacy Challenges 1990s – the Internet – User goes to a web site – Privacy policies created in 1990s Now – Social networks – Mobile privacy – location based services – Online behavioral advertising & “tracking” across sites

Social Networking Facebook was founded 7 years ago Today, over 500 million users/day What privacy controls and laws for social media?

Legal Response to Social Networking U.S. – Legislative hearings, but no legislation – No “deception” enforcement to date – Lots of public commentary, market pressures (new competitors) will help preserve privacy E.U. – Schleswig-Holstein ordered all businesses in that state “to shut down their fan pages on Facebook and remove social plug-ins such as the ‘like’-button from their websites.” – Irish DPA announces comprehensive privacy audit of Facebook after “Europe vs. Facebook” lists 22 violations of E.U. privacy law

Mobile privacy Not long ago few people carried cell phones Today they are pervasive globally They track our location. What are the privacy issues?

Mobile Privacy U.S. – No legislation to date Hearings on Apple/Google – surprise that phones were mapping location – Small % of aps that collect location information had any privacy policy, spring 2011 Self-regulatory effort now by FPF/CDT and industry E.U. – Article 29 Working Group Opt in consent, specific to location General data protection rules apply to location information

Online Behavioral Advertising U.S. – Steady push from FTC for industry self regulation Browser modifications for user control Opt out icon on ads WSJ and other scrutiny of “What They Know” – New laws? “Do Not Track” suggested by FTC – limit display of targeted ads, maybe more DNT for Kids legislation proposed – Privacy advocate concern that built-in technology will over-collect and use information, with few safeguards on how data is used Concern about possible under-reaction by legal system to major increase in tracking

The EU Cookie Law in 2.5 Minutes

OBA and Trans-Atlantic U.S. and slow ramp up of self-regulation – Significant press and political concern – Legislation difficult – few things pass Congress E.U. and possible dual Internet – Will sites in U.K. put up all those notices? Reminds me of – U.S. and interest in stronger government response – E.U. and criticism that regulation outstrips what is practical or desirable – Renewed Trans-Atlantic dialogue on privacy and data

Why Internet Rules Matter Today

Conclusion How get the best results from European scrutiny of industry practices? – Don’t just say “individual rights” but work toward practical solutions – Much easier to say “opt in” instead of “opt out” than it is to build the systems that do it, especially for OBA How get the best results from U.S. innovation and benefits to users? – Social networks – Mobile – Internet eco-system that provides free content I suggest government-level engagement, together with privacy agency engagement, to seek the best from both approaches – Keep the current “Safe Harbor” but consider how to update for today’s issues Together, imagine how to get a wonderful Internet for individuals, and also for economies on both sides of the Atlantic