Surface study at KEK 1) sponge cleaning 2) special single-cell cavity with de-toutchable Nb-samples T. Saeki on behalf of Jlab-FNAL-KEK S0 study collaboration.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
T. Saeki (KEK) 15 May 2014 AWLC2014 at FNAL
Advertisements

Superconducting rf test facility STF Mechanical grinding development Ken Watanabe ( KEK ) ILWS08 in Chicago 17-Nov-08.
KEK cavity status, March 2011 H. Hayano, ALCPG11, WG3, Eugene.
Stain appeared after EP acid renewal Field emission at low gradient happened on MHI-06, MHI-07, in VT. Kyoto-camera found brown stain trace in beam pipes,
Status of Nb sample study TILC09 Main Linac S0 session 18 April 2009 T. Saeki on behalf of SRF surface analysis group at KEK.
Proposed Button Design for a Series of High Power Button Tests Arash Zarrebini-Esfahani 22 nd August 2007.
Safety Review: RF Issues Derun Li Absorber Safety Review December 9-10, 2003 Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Berkeley, CA
SPSU Progress on coatings and grooves M.Taborelli -Progress on C based coatings -Progress on rough coatings -Progress on SEY instrument -Grooves.
The HiLumi LHC Design Study (a sub-system of HL-LHC) is co-funded by the European Commission within the Framework Programme 7 Capacities Specific Programme,
Recent Surface Studies in KEK-STF
Cleanroom refurbishment in SM18 Upgrade for the SPL high gradient resonators 26/11/2010J. Chambrillon - CERN BE/RF1.
9-cell Nb cavity seminar Dec.01, 2009 Facilities for 9-cell Nb cavities.
Series Tests of High Gradient Single- cell Superconducting Cavity for the Establishment of KEK Recipe T. Saeki (1), F. Furuta (1), K. Saito (1), M. Ge.
CEA DSM Irfu May 28th A RD 05: SURFACE PREPARATION STUDIES FOR SUPERCONDUCTIVE CAVITIES F. Eozénou, T. Saeki - F. Eozenou / T. Saeki - A_RD_05.
EP parameter comparison between JLab and KEK 28 Mar ILCW2010 at Beijing, GDE/Main Linac session T. Saeki.
Cavity status; recent KEK activities : Hayano (1) STF CM-1 cavities are; MHI-014: 3-rd VT:36MV/m (finished) MHI-015: 3-rd VT: > 18.4MV/m.
1 BCD/ACD developments for Cavities Several improvements are needed on both BCD/ACD A significant amount of R&D work is needed to resolve issues –Quality.
IHEP SRF Lab Upgrade & Facilities Jianping Dai on behalf of SRF lab upgrade and facilities group 2 nd Workshop of the IHEP 1.3GHz SRF R&D Project, December.
Mechanical Issues SPL cavities/cryomodules Workshop CERN 30 Sep. 2009
High Sucrose Soybean Thin-Layer Chromatography (TLC)
Cornell SRF New Materials Program Nb 3 Sn Development Sam Posen and Matthias Liepe Cornell University TTC Meeting 6 December 2011 Beijing, China.
STF EP, VT commissioning by FNAL AES001 H. Hayano, KEK
Field emission issue and strategy to improve H. Hayano.
Parallel session summary ML/SCRF L. Lilje, H. Hayano, N. Ohuchi, S. Fukuda, C. Adolphsen (with help of Chris Nantista) TILC09,
Global Design Effort 1 S0 Status High-Gradient cavities Lutz Lilje DESY supplement by H. Hayano 04Sep2008 EC
Sample tests for stain problem at KEK LCWA2009 at Albuquerque 01 Oct T. Saeki 1.
TTC Meeting, Frascati, 5-7 December Summary of EP discussions at Oct SMTF meeting at FNAL T. Tajima (LANL), C. Boffo (FNAL)
OzMagic Ozone Water Purification System Plestia Health Care Services U.A.E. AL AIN Industrial Area TEL : FAX : P.Box: Web.
Americas Cavity Specification C.M. Ginsburg (Fermilab) On behalf of the Fermilab cavity crew October 20, 2010.
F Fermilab ANL/FNAL SCPF EP/HPR Processing Status and Plan Allan Rowe TD/SRFDD.
CRAB for HL-LHC KEK activity 2010DEC Yoshiyuki MORITA.
Superconducting rf test facility LCWS 2010 in Beijing, 28 Mar 2010, Ken Watanabe Replica-method and local grinding repair K. Watanabe (KEK) LCWS 2010 in.
(1)[12~13/Dec/2009] Optical inspection (2)[14/Dec] frequency & field flatness measurement (3)[10/Mar/2010] pre-EP (5μm) (4)[11/Mar] EP1 (100μm) (5)[11/Mar]
1 Lead analysis performed at CERN with EST division group S.Buontempo Lead cleaning procedure Surface analysis Ca-Lead Surface analysis of Lead in contact.
Update on S0 Work in the Americas Region Mark Champion 17 June 2008.
Current study status of high gradient at KEK Fumio Furuta KEK SCRF meeting Fermilab. Apr
MHI#16 号機の2回目の EP2  Process log  Status of working  Monitor data during EP & Rinsing process  Comparison of EP2 Period : 2011/5/10 ~ 5/16 Process :
Standard EP recipe at KEK T. Saeki KEK Hot topics session SRF – 29 July 2011, Chicago.
Quality control of EP in KEK-STF TTC meeting April 21 st 2010 FNAL Motoaki SAWABE.
Preparation procedure and RF processining of cERL-ML power coupler at KEK Hiroshi Sakai, Takaaki Furuya, Masato Sato, Kenji Shinoe, Kensei Umemori, Kazuhiro.
Guillaume Olry, Sébastien Bousson CNRS/IN2P3/ IPN Orsay – Paris-Sud University Experience on Spiral2 cavity cleanliness degradation during clean room assembly.
MHI#19 号機の1回目の EP2  Process log  Condition of EP2 & Rinsing process  Status of working  Monitor data during EP & Rinsing process Period : 2012/2/17~
The problem of incrustation on Nb surface after CP or EP processing. STF Surface Research Group. M.Sawabe, H.Hayano, H.Monjushiro, S.Kato, T.Saeki, & T.Kubo.
Dark Current in ILC Main Linac N.Solyak, A.Sukhanov, I.Tropin ALCW2015, Apr.23, 2015, KEK LCWS'15, Tsukuba, 04/2015Nikolay Solyak1.
Developments of new treatment techniques for SRF cavities at KEK HORIZONTAL HPR FOR PERFORMANCE RECOVERY Yoshiyuki MORITA Motivation of developing HHPR.
Field emission in SRF Cavities
CEA DSM Irfu 16/05/2008- F. Eozénou, T. Saeki - FJPPL 2009 A_RD_051 A RD 05: SURFACE PREPARATION STUDIES FOR SUPERCONDUCTIVE CAVITIES F. Eozénou, T. Saeki.
Summary of STF-EP facility at KEK.
Field Emission Minimization for LCLS-II
Re-entrant BPM R&D for ILC Main Linac
Electropolishing of Dressed ILC 9-cell Cavity
Condition of electron beam welding toward a high gradient application
STF Plan of gradient improvement
DESY Experiences on Use of Gas overlay during Assemblies
Vertical Electropolishing at Marui & KEK
A. Navitski, S. Lagotzky, G. Müller
Operating SRF systems reliably in a “dirty” accelerator
TTC Topical Workshop on SRF Cryomodule Clean Room Assembly
Mathieu, Gabriel, Max, Spyros, Guillaume
S0 Status report from KEK
Effort Torwards Improving Large Scale Production for SC Cavities
Recent results of Vertical-EP at KEK-Marui
A COMMON R&D ON THE HIGH GRADIENT Nb CAVITIES
Cost reduction activities in cavity fabrication at MHI
a Printed Circuit Board
Quality control study with single-cell cavities
IMP Cryomodule Assembly and Alignment
ON THE HIGH GRADIENT Nb CAVITIES
FOR SUPERCONDUCTIVE CAVITIES
SNS PPU CRYOMODULE PDR Cleanroom Assembly Katherine Wilson
Presentation transcript:

Surface study at KEK 1) sponge cleaning 2) special single-cell cavity with de-toutchable Nb-samples T. Saeki on behalf of Jlab-FNAL-KEK S0 study collaboration LCWS08 at Chicago 17 Nov. 2008

Sponge cleaning study with Nb samples HPR + ethanol rinse / degreaser were introduced recently because HPR-only seems not enough to eliminate FE. And quality control of HPR is still very difficult. Usage of high- pressure water (~10 Mpa), UPW quality control ….etc. Direct physical/mechanical sponge wipe can improve the performance? Even shorten the duration of HPR / reduce the load of HPR? Prepare four Nb samples, sample-1, -1’, -2, -2’. Sample-1, -1’: BCP(30um)+EP(70um) + U.P.W. rinse. Sample-2, -2’: BCP(30um)+EP(70um) + U.P.W. rinse + sponge cleaning. Compare sample-1 and sample-2 by FS-SEM at Jlab. Compare sample-1’ and sample-2’ by XPS at KEK.

EP(70 um) of Nb samples at Nomura Plating Repetition of EP (2 min) + Rotation of sample w/o EP (2 min) Jlab-type Nb sample Al cathode Rotation V = 8 ~ 13 (V), I = 3 ~ 23 (A) with oscillation, T= 25 – 50 0 C w/o T control. [Nb] in EP acid = 4.0 ~ 6.2 g/L during the EP of two samples. We expected sulfur contamination by aged EP acid. 100 mm

U.P.W. rinse and sponge cleaning Packing in transportation container Moving into a clean-room (class- 1000) after EP(70 um) sponge cleaning with U.P.W. + Ultra Pure Water rinse (5 min) Wipe 10 times for each arrow = 40-times wipes in total Nb-sample-2 Ultra Pure Water rinse (20 min) Packing under U.P.W. Nb-sample-1

Sample#1: many field emitters Low FE onset ~ 10 MV/m Sample#2: much less field emitters Higher FE onset Area inside circle is scanned by FS-SEM. Nb-sample-1 w/o sponge-cleaningNb-sample-2 w/ sponge-cleaning

Lots of Nb x O y particles (white)Significantly reduced Nb x O y particles Suspected bacteria (black worm) Somehow less bacteria growth, but new type of Contamination (black particulate) Nb-sample-1 w/o sponge-cleaningNb-sample-2 w/ sponge-cleaning

XPS Analysis of KEK-type Nb-sample-1’ & 2’ (BCP+EP w/ & w/o sponge cleaning) at KEK Oxygen Carbon from the air Nb Sulfur Nb Sulfur ~ 0% for both samples w/ and w/o sponge-cleaning. No significant difference of A.P. for both samples. A.P. for sample-1’ w/o sponge-cleaning = Nb:19%, O:55%, C:25% A.P. (Atomic Percentage) was estimated from the colored peaks. (Depth of analysis ~ 0.5 nm) Sample-1’ w/o sponge-cleaning Sample-2’ w/ sponge-cleaning A.P. for sample-2’ w/ sponge-cleaning = Nb:20%, O:57%, C:23%

Poly-Ethylene (PE) sponge wipe handle Sponge mechanics Insertion Sponge Expansion and Wipe by rotation UPW + detergent inlet UPW + detergent outlet PE sponge First wiping/fitting test of proto-type sponge-cleaner for single-cell cavity

Insertion of sponges Expansion and rotation of sponges inside cavity The single-cell cavity was EP’ed and UPW-rinsed before the sponge-cleaning test.

UPW Feeding UPW during the rotation of sponges for 1 – 2 minutes. Draining UPW inside the cavity Drained UPW was kept in a container to analyze the components/contamination. Drained UPW to a container

Analysis methods Filtering drained UPW (10L) through the filter-paper of 0.20μm → Condensation of filtered UPW (10L) to 70 ml. → Ion Chromatography (IC) analysis for filtered /condensed UPW (70 ml). Residuals on the filter-paper → Optical Microscope → Component-analysis by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyzer Optical Microscope XRF

Result of IC analysis 4.9 mg/L of F - was detected from filtered/condensed UPW (70ml). Sulfur ion (S, SO 4, etc) was not detected. The components were different from that of EP acid. Time (minutes) IC analysis of drained UPW after sponge test Cl ion is normally contaminated in this kind of analysis. Tap water and sweat contain lots of Cl ions.

Residuals on the filter-paper 1 mm Residuals look like fibers/particles

Poly-Ethylene (PE) Sponge 1 mm Blue particles in PE sponge fibers. We are not sure what these particles are, but vendors normally mix non-flammable materials in chemical products. Anyway, we need to ask the vendor what they are. PE sponge fibers

Results of XRF Sponge test UPW (residuals on filter-paper) Beaker sponge test UPW (residuals on filter-paper) PE sponge (used in the sponge test) KαKα Peak Position Peak intensity Sample /Blank Peak position Peak intensity Sample /Blank Peak position Peak intensity Sample /Blank (deg) (kcps ) (Ratio) (deg) (kcps ) (Ratio) (deg) (kcps ) (Ratio) Mo-Kα Ga-Kα Zn-Kα Cu-Kα Ni-Kα Fe-Kα Mn-Kα Cr-Kα Ca-Kα K-Kα - - Cl-Kα S-Kα P-Kα Si-Kα Al-Kα Mg-Kα Na-Kα - - ? Phosphorus (P) contamination might come from the pipes and flanges, other BCP’ed cavities?

PE sponge rinse test in a beaker Pour 400 ml UPW into a 500ml-beaker. Wipe inside the beaker by PE sponge for 10 minutes. Filter the UPW in the beaker by filter-paper. Analyze residuals on the filter-paper. PE sponge

Residuals on filter-paper from beaker UPW 1 mm Residuals look like fibers/particles

UPW Feeding UPW during the rotation of sponges for 1 – 2 minutes. Draining UPW inside the cavity Drained UPW was kept in a container to analyze the components/contamination. Drained UPW to a container Pipes and flanges are commonly used for other BCP’ed cavities. This caused the contamination of Phosphorus (P) in the drained water. We will come back this later.

Summary of sponge cleaning study Two samples w/ and w/o sponge cleaning after EP-process were analyzed by FS-SEM and XPS. lots of field emitters (NbxOy) were found on the sample w/o sponge cleaning. Few field emitters were found on the sample w/ sponge cleaning. Sulfur was not found by XPS on the samples. First wiping/fitting test of sponge-cleaner was done with a single-cell cavity after EP process. UPW was fed during sponge wipe, and drained water was analyzed by IC and XRF. Sponge fibers/particles and S, P, Cl, F were found in the drained water. Next step: Can fibers/particles be removed by HPR? Selection of new sponges? Collaboration with sponge vendor for special (contamination-free) sponge? More detailed information can be found at

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study Machining of 6 holes done Nb samples and all parts were already delivered. (17 Oct. 2008).

Analysis of EP’d surface by using single-cell cavity with de-toutchable button Nb-samples KEK button sample back holder O-ring seals for analysis of production-EP 2 for equator 2 for near iris 2 for beam pipe under fabrication

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study 6 Nb-samples BCP(10um) Weight and thickness measurements Special cavity with 6 sample-holes on the EP bed. First EP at STF/KEK Recipe: BCP(10um)+EP(20um) + UPW rinse

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study EP 20 um + UPW rinse (No ultrasonic-rinse) 6 samples were dressed on the special cavity 2 samples on a beam-pipe 2 samples at iris 2 samples at equator

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study Disassembly in class-10 Clean-Room 6 Nb-samples A sample A sample holder

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study A sample A sample holder 6 Nb-samples + sample-holders 6 Nb-samples were stored in the vacuum chamber Ion pump Gate-valve

Sample transportation suitcase Nb-samples + sample- holders are inside the suitcase. Pumping down inside the suitcase. Pressure = 5E-5 Pa Ion pump. Sample transportation suitcase Open gate-valve Class-1000 Clean-Room

Nb-samples + sample-holders are inside the suitcase. Pumping down inside the suitcase with ion pump powered by battery. Pressure = 5E-5 Pa Gate-valve is closed. sample transportation suitcase Transportation of samples to XPS analysis room

Plan for KEK-type samples in special cavity November 3November 10November 17November24 December 1 December 7 Fitting test on the EP bed at STF/KEK KEK-samples First XPS / SEM analysis at KEK First EP at STF/KEK Recipe: BCP(10um)+EP(20um) + UPW rinse

Backup slides

Melting test of sponges for EP solution Poly Vinyl Chloride (PVC) Poly Vinyl Alcohol (PVA) Melamine Melamine, cross-section 20 micro litter of EP solution (no dilution) was dropped on each sponge. PVC, cross-section We used PVC sponge for the first Nb-sample test (EP + Sponge cleaning). PVA, cross-section July 2008

Poly-Ethylene (PE) sponge test with EP acid Almost no corrosion of PE sponge by the EP acid. EP acid No corrosion after dropping EP acid on PE sponge. Let’s made a sponge-cleaning tool for single-cell cavity with PE sponge. PE sponge October 2008

Special single-cell cavity for sample-study Nb-sample at beam-pipe Nb-sample at iris