Trading out of trouble: Urban water price and trading opportunities Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Cross-Border Infrastructure: A Toolkit Tariff and Rate Setting Session on Regulation & Accountability Max Bradford Castalia The views expressed here are.
Advertisements

The Single Electricity Market in Ireland
Trading resources to highest value use Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics & Management School of Earth and Environmental Sciences The University.
DEVELOPERS PERSPECTIVE 5 th Annual Banking Summit Banking Association South Africa 31 October 2014, Empire Hotel, Sandton.
Trading into and out of trouble Australian water allocation & trading experience Zaragoza, 29 July 2008 Water Economics and Financing Prof Mike Young,
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide "Irrigation Technology to Achieve Water Conservation,” Zaragoza,
Texas Electricity: Forever in transition Robert Michaels Professor of Economics California State University Fullerton CA 92834
University of South Australia – School of International Business Water Markets: Lessons From Australia Dr. Henning Bjornlund School of International Business.
The Continuing Evolution of U.S. Electricity Markets
Water policy reform – moving ahead Presentation for the Water Policy in the MDB Workshop 22 October 2010 Will Fargher, General Manager Water Markets and.
1 Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission Tariff Regulation Gocha Shonia Department of Methodology and informational provision.
July 2008 Brett Mathieson Manager Regulation & Planning Yarra Valley Water, Melbourne, Australia The Australian Water Industry.
1 Recent and Emerging Water Policy Reforms in Australia Paper presented at National Taiwan University – Taipei 14 September 2006 Dr. Henning Bjornlund.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia 5005 OECD Expert Meeting on “Sustainable.
Mexico’s experiences with Wind Energy Clean Energy, Good Governance and Electricity Regulation Cape Town, Cape Milner Hotel Thursday 20 th May, 2010 Francisco.
IAAE 2006 Water Resource Policy. IAAE Who is winning? Who is bravest?
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide CPA Congress, Adelaide, 20 th November 2008 The business of.
An Overview of the Australian National Electricity Market Brian Spalding Chief Operating Officer.
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Putting a price on water Will markets work? Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment Institute.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide “Water, wine and horticulture: A Scholefield Robinson Horticultural.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide 26 th July 2007 Water market regulation, infrastructure access.
Life Impact The University of Adelaide Prof. Mike Young Executive Director The Environment Institute The University of Adelaide Singapore 3 rd Tuesday,
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Running out of water What would a robust allocation system look like? Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Climate Change and Business, Brisbane 30 th August 2007 Reducing.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide NSW Farmer’s Federation Coleambally 14 th February 2008 Water.
Without Water Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics & Management School of Earth and Environmental Sciences The University of Adelaide Wednesday.
Economics of Restricting Rural-Urban Trade Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics & Management School of Earth and Environmental Sciences The.
An option for Australia? Prof. Mike Young, # Jim McColl* and Tim # Research Chair, The University of Adelaide * Research Fellow, CSIRO Land and.
Retro-fitting Commercial Buildings A Financing Perspective Date: April 2011 Prepared by: Carbon Solutions Group.
Facilitating and Expediting Adaptation: Learning from Australia Adaptation to climate change in the desert Southwest, Tucson Arizona, January 2009 Prof.
Rural - Urban Water Inter-Dependence Mike Young The University of Adelaide.
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Lessons about water trading from across the ditch and elsewhere Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment.
The Environment Institute Life Impact The University of Adelaide Water Governance Reforms Lessons from Australia Institute of Water Policy, LKY School.
The Environment Institute Life Impact The University of Adelaide Fixing the River Murray What still needs to be done? IRR Regional Water Conference, Adelaide.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Water Where is your future headed?
Life Impact The University of Adelaide Prof. Mike Young Executive Director The Environment Institute The University of Adelaide Melbourne 25th June 2009.
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Securing our Water Supplies Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment Institute.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Berri, 5 th November 2008 Buying water.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide “EPI” Water Conference, Berlin, 26 th January 2012 Unbundling.
Water Security and Regional Development in Australia ARCRNSISS-ANZRSAI Conference Adelaide, 2 nd December 2008 December 2008 Prof Mike Young, The Environment.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Research Tuesday Lecture University of Adelaide, 9 th October.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide AMCHAM Luncheon, 15 th February 2008 Water fundamentals.
1 Instruments for Adaptive Water Management R. Quentin Grafton Crawford School of Economics and Government Australian National University
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide MBI 30 th September 2008 Water Markets: Trading into and out.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Kyabram 17 th June 2008 Your future: Where is it headed?
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Environmental Policy Water Policy & Water Trading Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment Institute.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide NSW Country Press Association AGM, 26 th October 2007 Water.
Water What can the nut industry learn from Australia? Peanut and Tree Nut Processors Association Convention Bahamas, January 2009 Prof Mike Young Executive.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide CEDA Water Forum, Adelaide, 7 th April 2008 An implementation.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide NRM Committee, SA Parliament, 27 th February 2008 A future-proofed.
SA Banker’s Briefing on the MDB Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide SA Banker’s Briefing, Friday.
Your Competitive Edge In Energy. Designing Liquid, Transparent, Reliable Wholesale Markets Nigel Evans Executive Vice President Head of Global Energy.
The Role of the Government and Markets in Water Reform: Learning from Australia Alberta, November 2008 Prof Mike Young, The University of Adelaide.
Prof. Mike Young* and Jim McColl** * Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide ** Research Fellow, CSIRO Land and Water.
Housing in London - the current state of play Christine Whitehead London School of Economics Next steps for housing policy in London - supply, standards.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Extract from Griffith University Lighthouse Lecture on Future.
BUILDING A LEVEL PLAYING FIELD FOR DISTRIBUTED ENERGY WITH LOCAL NETWORK CREDITS AND VIRTUAL NET METERING Jay Rutovitz, Institute for Sustainale Futures.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide AARES Symposium, Climate, Water & Adaptive Responses, Adelaide.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide "Irrigation Technology to Achieve Water Conservation,” Zaragoza,
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Almond Growers Conference, Barossa Valley, 30 th October 2008.
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Managing water across the full range of stakeholders Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment Institute.
The Environment Institute Where ideas grow Chewing over the CEWH Mike Young Executive Director, The Environment Institute.
Melbourne, 17 th November 2008 Future-proofing the Basin Prof Mike Young, The University of Adelaide Where are water markets taking us?
ECONOMIC BASICS.
Water science gaps & media messages? Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics & Management The University of Adelaide 5 th World Conference of.
Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Policy.
Water for Good Prof. Mike Young Director, The Environment Institute
water Water Trading: Supporting resilient regional communities
A future-proofed MDB? Prof. Mike Young
Water Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Some Like it Hot, Renmark, 6th November 2008.
Presentation transcript:

Trading out of trouble: Urban water price and trading opportunities Prof. Mike Young Research Chair, Water Economics and Management The University of Adelaide Urban water Policy Conference, Brisbane Thursday 7th March 2007

2 Urban-rural trade is cost effective Current Water price* No new supply Rural - Urban Trade Sydney Melbourne Brisbane-Moreton Adelaide Perth ACT million people (+25%) & 15% less water in Eastern & Southern Australia

3 Urban v’s rural water pricing Urban  Nearly all Australian urban supply is on restriction  Price rises, where they have occurred, have been small => no scarcity signal Rural  Water scarcity has meant a 700+% price increase  River Murray allocations from $44/ML to $380/ML Scarcity pricing  Changes behaviour  Drives innovation  Drives investment

4 Trading opportunities & design? “What’s good for the goose is good for the gander?” Unfettered Urban – rural trading by utilities? Urban trading?  For city utilities?  For large users?  For all metered users? Issues  Design issues => low transaction and administrative costs  Policy questions of equity and efficiency

5 Water supply management 1.Regulated demand management  Block tariff charging  Postage stamp pricing  Regulations in times of scarcity 2.Scarcity pricing  Set a cap  Use market to reveal scarcity and to determine who gets to use “discretionary” water  Delivery cost is still charged Complex equity and political issues associated with both approaches – especially during the transition when the mix is changed

6 Urban water price tensions Subsidies v’s full cost pricing v’s scarcity pricing NWI implicitly commits Australia to full cost pricing and through trading to scarcity pricing But governments continue to subsidise water use  Rainwater tank subsidies  Shower head subsidies  Leaking infrastructure subsidies Low subsidised prices cause under-investment The more governments make water their problem, the less others can get involved.

7 Experience with scarcity pricing 1.Gayndah Shire sells surplus water to irrigators 2.SA Water has been buying River Murray entitlements 3.Several rural town water suppliers have bought water. 4.Arizona requires developers to certify 100 year supply and is now running an auction for access to recycled water 5.Beijing allocates water on a per capita basis. 6.Salisbury Council is selling access to “its” storm water. In Australia, urban water markets are starting to emerge but most is under the table and hidden from policy makers

8 Allocating commercial & industrial water Could make all large users hold water entitlements and contract a water utility to deliver any allocations they hold Level playing field with irrigators Need to decide on the initial entitlement  Maximum volume used in last 3 years? Build a market that allows growth

9 A simple household system Simple model (two tier charging system)  Define first 200 KL as a basic entitlement  Issue 200 KL allocation in all but most severe conditions  Supply at marginal cost, say, $1.00  Allow households to trade  Unused allocations  Voluntary reductions in their 200 KL entitlement Sell access entitlements to the second tier  Houses who want more than 200 KL must either  buy their water entitlement or  buy allocations from an investor  Utilities required to sells shares in the remaining pool of water  Users without an allocation are charged the cost of sourcing one for them

10 Administrative implications Add a column to each water account enabling households to change “their” entitlement Establish capacity for each householder to access their account and electronically transfer their entitlement or allocation to another account holder Leave private enterprise to set up trading sites  E-Bay  Waterfind  A purpose built site

11 Possible variants 1.Tie first 100 KL entitlement to each house  No house can sell permanently sell its basic water entitlement  Supply at, say, $0.50/KL  A house could still sell first tier allocations 2.Limit trading to tier two water => KL  Supplied at marginal cost supply, say, $1.00/KL 3.Use scarcity pricing for water above 200 KL  Supplied at, say, $5.00/KL 4.Allow third parties to create tier two entitlements and/or supply allocations

12 Trading scenarios & opportunities 1.Sell some tier one water  Install a water tank and plumb rainwater into a house  Sell 50 KL of tier one entitlement permanently to a swimming pool owner 2.Increasing the supply  Buy 1000 ML water from a rural area and convert to an urban water entitlement  Sell entitlements in 50+ KL lots to developers, households & industry  Sell allocations to households without enough allocation

13 Water industry implications 1.Utilities still charge users for delivery 2.Bulk water entitlements transferred to users without compensation Who owns the entitlement? (the govt or the people? 3.Industry needs to negotiate supply contracts with exit conditions Should industry exit be free? 4.Infrastructure management (wholesale supply) may need to be separated from retail supply – as with gas and electricity supply 5.Increased competition from small and large scale investors Significant household initiative and investment Significant private investment Desalination, Storm water Private rural/urban trade 6.Revenue stream much less predictable

14 Droplet Questions and Answers 1.Why not allocate to persons rather than households? Administrative costs would be too high. 2.What about tenants, strata corporations, etc? Trading would create an incentive for individual household metering. 3.Would participation be compulsory? No but you would need to stay inside your allocation. 4.What happens if some-one uses more than their allocation?  You would have the choice of buying more water or leaving your utility to do it for you.

15 Where to from here? Would urban trading enable movement past water restrictions? A Trial  Large user trading?  Household trading? Where  Toowoomba, Goulburn, Bendigo?  Canberra, Gold Coast, Adelaide, Melbourne?

Cheap water cheapens Australia! Contact: Prof Mike Young Water Economics and Management Phone: Mobile: