Effectiveness of Interactive Web-Native Content vs. Online Textbooks Alex Edgcomb and Frank Vahid Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering University.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Using CONNECTschool ™ McGraw Hill Ryerson. What is CONNECTschool™? CONNECTSchool™: A web-based program that includes a searchable eBook, interactive teaching.
Advertisements

Using CONNECTschool McGraw Hill Ryerson. What is CONNECTschool? CONNECTSchool: A web-based program that includes a searchable eBook, interactive teaching.
Using CONNECTschool ™ McGraw-Hill Ryerson. What is CONNECTschool™? CONNECTSchool™: A web-based program that includes a searchable eBook, interactive teaching.
Serway/Jewett, Physics for Scientist and Engineers 6th Edition
Feature Extractors for Integration of Cameras and Sensors during End-User Programming of Assistive Monitoring Systems Alex Edgcomb Frank Vahid University.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. Your course materials Solomon/Berg/Martin Biology, 8th Edition You will… —be tested —receive homework assignments —have.
IDAHO DIGITAL CARAVAN CURRICULUM MATERIALS ADOPTION FOR SCIENCE – ANATOMY & PHYSIOLOGY (A&P) THANKS FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION Eve Lancaster National Accounts.
Learn by doing Less is more Frank Vahid (UC Riverside) Tony Givargis (UC Irvine)
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS N. Gregory Mankiw’s Principles of Economics, 4e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Roger Arnold: Economics, 8th Ed. You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments — have reading.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Craig Wright Listening to Music, 5e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments — have.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Hall/Lieberman: Economics: Principles and Applications, 4th Ed. You will… — be tested — receive.
Copyright © Allyn & Bacon 2008 POWER PRACTICE Chapter 6 Academic Software START This multimedia product and its contents are protected under copyright.
Digital in Teaching and Learning Gaining ground Digital in Teaching and Learning Gaining ground Carla Aerts Cambridge University Press Carla Aerts Cambridge.
Copyright © Curt Hill Marshalling Technology for Education Curt Hill Computer Systems and Software Engineering Valley City State University
Zyante’s zyBooks: Animated Interactive Learning
Does Student Crowdsourcing of Practice Questions and Animations Lead to Good Quality Materials? Alex Edgcomb, Joshua Yuen, and Frank Vahid University of.
Copyright © Curt Hill Never Teach Naked! But still flip your class.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Kirszner & Mandell The Wadsworth Handbook, 8e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Plotnik/Kouyoumdjian: Introduction to Psychology, 8e You will… — be tested — receive homework.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Brym/Lie Sociology: Your Compass For A New World, Brief, 2e You will… — be tested — receive homework.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Mowen/Hansen, Cornerstones of Managerial Accounting, 2e You will… — be tested — receive homework.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Adler/Proctor II Looking Out, Looking In 12e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Warren/Reeve/Duchac, Accounting: 22E You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments — have.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Welch/Gruhl/Comer/Rigdon Understanding American Government, 11e You will… — be tested — receive.
SKU3033 / SKF3033 NETWORK & SYSTEM ADMINISTRATOR.
Welcome to (Insert Course info) Use Your Required Materials and Own Your Grade.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Lamb/Hair/McDaniel MKTG You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments — have reading assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Sprague/Stuart The Speaker’s Handbook, 8e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Weiten, Psychology: Themes and Variations, 7e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Student Performance Improvement using Interactive Textbooks: A Three-University Cross-Semester Analysis Alex Edgcomb*, Frank Vahid*, Roman Lysecky°, Andre.
Towards Independence: Major Purchases Mobile Phones – Part 1.
Welcome Course Name Faculty Name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Schmidt, American Government & Politics Today, ed. You will… — be tested — receive homework.
The required text for this course is Essentials of Strategic Management, The Quest for Competitive Advantage 1 st Edition by Gamble/Thompson Required Materials.
WELCOME TO STATISTICS The required textbook for this course is: Introduction to the Practice of Statistics Seventh Edition by Moore/McCabe/Craig (W.H.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Hall/Lieberman: Economics: Principles and Applications, 4th Ed. You will… — be tested — receive.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Albrecht/Stice/Stice/Swain Accounting: Concepts and Applications, 10e You will… — be tested —
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Strong/Devault/Cohen The Marriage & Family Experience: Intimate Relationships in a Changing Society,
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Haviland/Prins/Walrath/McBride Cultural Anthropology: The Human Challenge, 12e You will… — be.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Earl Babbie The Basics of Social Research, 4e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Jurmain/Kilgore/Trevathan/ Ciochon Introduction to Physical Anthropology, 11e You will… — be tested.
Students Learn More with Less Text that Covers the Same Core Topics Frank Vahid 1,3, Alex Edgcomb 1,3, and Roman Lysecky 2,3 1 Dept. of Computer Science.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Moore/Stanitski/Jurs Chemistry: The Molecular Science, 3e You will… — be tested — receive homework.
The required textbook for this course is David Myers’ Psychology, Eighth Edition. ( © 2007, Worth Publishers)
Simplify! 1 Frank Vahid Prof. of CS&E, Univ. of California, Riverside Alex Edgcomb Research Specialist, Univ. of California, Riverside Both also with zyBooks.com.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Chuck Williams Effective Management, 3e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments —
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Gaines/Miller Criminal Justice in Action: The Core, 4e You will… — be tested — receive homework.
Computer Science Department Web Portal - support for educational process M.Stanković, Ivan Petković Faculty of Electronic Engineering, University of Niš.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Anderson/Sweeney/Williams Statistics for Business and Economics, 10e You will… — be tested — receive.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Cheryl Hamilton Communicating for Results, 8e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course Name Faculty Name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Schmidt et al. American Government & Politics Today, Texas Edition, ed. You will… —
Welcome to (Insert Course info) Use Your Required Materials and Own Your Grade.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Jean Wyrick’s Steps to Writing Well, 10e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Weiten, Psychology: Themes and Variations, Briefer Edition, 7th Ed. You will… — be tested — receive.
The required textbook for this course is Discovering the Universe 7/e by Neil Comins (©2006, W.H. Freeman & Company)
1Jun. 20, 2016 © 2016 Alex Edgcomb / Frank Vahid – UCR / zyBooks Simplifying a Course to Reduce Student Stress so Students Can Focus Again on Learning.
Welcome Course name Faculty name. YOUR COURSE MATERIALS Mary Ellen Guffey’s Business English, 9e You will… — be tested — receive homework assignments.
Are You Connected? Education companies can no longer ignore that you, the students, are demanding a more effective, more efficient, less expensive education.
Are You Connected? Education companies can no longer ignore that you, the students, are demanding a more effective, more efficient, less expensive education.
Course name Faculty name
An Analysis of Using Many Small Programs in CS1
Are You Connected? Education companies can no longer ignore that you, the students, are demanding a more effective, more efficient, less expensive education.
by Joe Michael Allen, Frank Vahid, Kelly Downey, and Alex Edgcomb
Are You Connected? Education companies can no longer ignore that you, the students, are demanding a more effective, more efficient, less expensive education.
An Analysis of Using Many Small Programs in CS1
by Joe Michael Allen, Frank Vahid, Kelly Downey, and Alex Edgcomb
Nabeel Alzahrani1, Frank Vahid1,2, Alex Edgcomb1,2
Coral: An Ultra Simple Language for Learning to Program
Presentation transcript:

Effectiveness of Interactive Web-Native Content vs. Online Textbooks Alex Edgcomb and Frank Vahid Dept. of Computer Science and Engineering University of California, Riverside Also with Zyante Inc. ( Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb, UC Riverside / Zyante 1 of 18

Traditional use of the web: e-books and video Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).2 of 18 X

Interactive tools teach key topics Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).3 of 18

Interactive tools teach key topics Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb, UC Riverside.4 of 18

Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).5 of 18

Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).6 of 18

Self-assess with embedded question sets Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb, UC Riverside.7 of 18

Visualize the hard concepts Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).8 of 18

Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb, UC Riverside.9 of 18 Visualize the hard concepts

Student activity completion Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).10 of 18 55%

Zyante in 100 schools, 20k students 182,000+ interactive tools used 460,000+ animations viewed 9,094,000+ questions answered Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).11 of 18 Professor formed company. Materials released in 2013.

Is interactive content effective? Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).12 of 18 Traditional static textbookInteractive web nativevs.

Traditional static textbook w/ easy-to-use IDE Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).13 of 18 Big C++, 2 nd Edition by Cay Horstmann and Timothy Budd 1,236 words

Interactive web-native content: Zyante’s Programming In C++ Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).14 of words, 1 animation, 3 programming exercises, and 3 questions sets

Experimental setup 136 participants 72% freshmen 79% engineers Work as long as like Work alone Pre-lesson quiz, lesson on basic output in C++, then post-lesson quiz Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).15 of 18 Post-lesson quiz

Results: Interactive vs. static content 64% better (p-value < 0.001) 16% better (p-value = 0.016) Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).16 of 18 (68) (60) (18) (16) Students chose to spend more time (p-value < 0.001) with interactive (17.5 mins) than static (9.4 mins).

Further analysis Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).17 of 18 ZyanteTraditional textbook 8.6% more students pass (p-value = 0.08) (124) (133) UCR book purchase rate: 70% buy required textbook 98% buy required zyBook

Conclusion Porting paper textbooks to electronic form, even with some additional tool support, may be a poor approach Writing new material natively for the web, using less text and more interactive items, may enable higher learner engagement and more-effective learning Copyright © 2014 Frank Vahid and Alex Edgcomb (UC Riverside / Zyante).18 of 18