Decoding Dusty Debris Disks AAAS, Februrary 2014 David J Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Debris disks with CCAT Jane Greaves: ~2012??
Advertisements

Spitzer IRS Spectroscopy of IRAS-Discovered Debris Disks Christine H. Chen (NOAO) IRS Disks Team astro-ph/
Astromineralogy of Protoplanetary Disks (and other astrophysical objects) Steve Desch Melissa Morris Arizona State University.
Circumstellar disks: what can we learn from ALMA? March ARC meeting, CSL.
Signatures of Planets in Debris Disks A. Moro-Martin 1,2,3, S. Wolf 2, R. Malhotra 4 & G. Rieke 1 1. Steward Observatory (University of Arizona); 2. MPIA.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris Disks Stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) ( 1) Observatorio Nacional.
Are Planets in Unresolved Candidates of Debris disks stars? R. de la Reza (1), C. Chavero (1), C.A.O. Torres (2) & E. Jilinski (1) (1) Observatorio Nacional.
1 Concluding Panel Al Glassgold Sienny Shang Jonathan Williams David Wilner.
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
High-resolution Imaging of Debris Disks Jane Greaves St Andrews University, Scotland.
1 Debris Disk Studies with CCAT D. Dowell, J. Carpenter, H. Yorke 2005 October 11.
Origin of the Solar System Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 8.
SMA Observations of the Herbig Ae star AB Aur Nagayoshi Ohashi (ASIAA) Main Collaborators: S.-Y. Lin 1, J. Lim 2, P. Ho 3, M. Momose 4, M. Fukagawa 5 (1.
Physics and Astronomy University of Utah Extreme Solar Systems II Fall 2011 The Evolution of Protoplanetary Disks and the Diversity of Giant Planets Diversity.
10Nov2006 Ge/Ay133 More on Jupiter, Neptune, the Kuiper belt, and the early solar system.
Spitzer Space Telescope Observations of the Fomalhaut Debris Disk Michael Werner, Karl Stapelfeldt, Chas Beichman (JPL); Kate Su, George Rieke, John Stansberry,
Origin of the Solar System
Habitable Planets Astronomy 315 Professor Lee Carkner Special Topic.
Origin of the Solar System Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 8.
Nov PALM 3000 Requirements Review Imaging of Protoplanetary and Debris Disks Karl Stapelfeldt Jet Propulsion Laboratory.
« Debris » discs A crash course in numerical methods Philippe Thébault Paris Observatory/Stockholm Observatory.
The Origin of the Solar System
Origin of the Solar System. Stars spew out 1/2 their mass as gas & dust as they die.
Origin of the Solar System. Stars spew out 1/2 their mass as gas & dust as they die.
Planet Formation through Radio Eyes A. Meredith Hughes Wesleyan University Kevin Flaherty (Wesleyan), Amy Steele (Wesleyan), Jesse Lieman-Sifry (Wesleyan),
A New “Radio Era” for Planet Forming Disks K. Teramura UH IfA David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics thanks to S. Andrews, C. Qi,
Doug Johnstone: Former Associate Director JCMT, NRC Herzberg, Univ. Victoria JCMT: Debris Discs and Miscellaneous Sciences.
How Unique Are Nearby Debris Disks? Alycia Weinberger (DTM/CIW)
Is there evidence of planets in debris disks? Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy University of Cambridge La planètmania frappe les astronomes Kalas, P.
Debris Belts Around Vega 0 Topic: Exoplanets Concepts: Infrared observations, debris disks, exoplanet detection, planetary systems Missions: Spitzer, Herschel.
Discoveries in Planetary Sciencehttp://dps.aas.org/education/dpsdisc/ The First Images of Exoplanets New images show planets orbiting bright young nearby.
Peering into the Birthplaces of Solar Systems Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array Expanded Very Large Array Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope.
Infrared Signatures of Planetary Systems Amaya Moro-Martin Department of Astrophysical Sciences, Princeton University.
Modeling Planetary Systems Around Sun-like Stars Paper: Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems: Cold Outer Disks Associated with Sun-like Stars,
ALMA Timeline  Design and Development Phase Jun Dec 2001  International partnership established 1999  Prototype antenna contract Dec 99  ALMA/NA.
Debris Disks and the Formation and Evolution of Planetary Systems…
October 27, 2006US SKA, CfA1 The Square Kilometer Array and the “Cradle of Life” David Wilner (CfA)
ALMA Observations of proto-planetary disks I HD – P.I. Casassus 2013 Nature 493, 191 Herbig Ae star 140 pc, 2 Myr, 1.9 M , disk mass 0.1 M  Left:
The AU Mic Debris Ring Density profiles & Dust Dynamics J.-C. Augereau & H. Beust Grenoble Observatory (LAOG)
New Views of Planet-Forming Disks Radio Imaging from SMA to ALMA David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics K. Teramura UH IfA Wesleyan.
The Origin of the Solar System. I. The Great Chain of Origins A. Early Hypotheses B. A Review of the Origin of Matter C. The Solar Nebula Hypothesis D.
Parallels: Proto-Planetary Disks and rings 30 November 2015.
Parallels: Proto-Planetary Disks and rings 2 December 2015.
Searching for extra-solar planets in Infrared J. Serena Kim Steward Observatory, Univ. of Arizona In collaboration with FEPS Spitzer legacy team (
Millimeter Observations of the  Pic and AU Mic Debris Disks David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle S.Andrews,
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?  Pic, A5V star AU Mic, M1Ve star.
Submillimeter Observations of Debris Disks Wayne Holland UK Astronomy Technology Centre, Royal Observatory Edinburgh With Jane Greaves, Mark Wyatt, Bill.
High Dynamic Range Imaging and Spectroscopy of Circumstellar Disks Alycia Weinberger (Carnegie Institution of Washington) With lots of input from: Aki.
Origin of the Solar System Astronomy 311 Professor Lee Carkner Lecture 8.
Protoplanetary and Debris Disks A. Meredith Hughes Wesleyan University.
Herschel images of Fomalhaut An extrasolar Kuiper belt at the height of its dynamical activity B. Acke, M. Min, C. Dominik, B. Vandenbussche, B. Sibthorpe,
Theoretical difficulties with standard models Mark Wyatt Institute of Astronomy, University of Cambridge.
Kate Su, George Rieke, Karl Misselt, John Stansberry, Amaya Moro-Martin, David Trilling… etc. (U. of A) Karl Stapelfeldt, Michael Werner (NASA JPL) Mark.
Grain Growth and Substructure in Protoplanetary Disks David J. Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics S. Corder (NRAO) A. Deller.
Circumstellar Disks at 5-20 Myr: Observations of the Sco-Cen OB Association Marty Bitner.
Terrestrial Planet Bombardment & Habitability Jane Greaves St Andrews, Scotland.
Making Our Solar System: Planetary Formation and Evolution
Extended debris discs around nearby, Sun-like stars as a probe of disc-planet interactions Astronomical Society of Australia ASM 5th July 2016 Dr. Jonty.
ALMA User Perspective: Galactic Studies
Young planetary systems
The HR 4796A, Fomalhaut, & HD Narrow Planet-Building Ring Systems
The Universe in the Infrared
ALMA does Circumstellar Disks
Bell Ringer What is the order of the planets?
Ge/Ay133 Can we study extrasolar Kuiper Belts?
Who was here? How can you tell? This is called indirect evidence!
Formation of the Solar System and Other Planetary Systems.
Debris disks Basic properties Observational methods & constraints
2. THE SOLAR SYSTEM’S EARLY HISTORY
Aigen Li1, Fangzhou Liu2, You Zhou3 1. University of Missouri
Presentation transcript:

Decoding Dusty Debris Disks AAAS, Februrary 2014 David J Wilner Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics

Debris Disk Primer far-infrared surveys of nearby stars reveal thermal dust emission from reprocessed starlight, F dust /F * < Stapelfeldt et al Fomalhaut star dust images show disks Hubble, Kalas et al dust must be replenished  reservoirs of large bodies

Descendents of Protoplanetary Disks Protoplanetary DiskDebris Disk age< 10 Myr10 Myr to 10 Gyr dust mass> 10 M Earth < 0.1 M Earth gas mass100x dust mass<< dust mass physical picture primordial dust colliding, growing into planetismals planetismals colliding, generating secondary dust 3 Fomalhaut

The Solar System Debris Disk 4 Kuiper Belt (42-48 AU) and asteroid belt (2-3.5 AU) dust-producing bodies in stable belts and resonances ESA A. Felid/STScI encodes planetary system architecture and dynamical history

Debris Disks and Planetary Systems outcomes of planet formation Solar System configuration in context planet detection from disk perturbations habitability of terrestrial planets 5 Fomalhaut  Pictoris HR 8799 HD HD

Millimeter Emission traces Planetesimals collisional cascade creates smaller and smaller fragments micron-size dust blown out large dust can’t travel far  = F * /F grav Krivov Nature/ISAS/JAXA

20 Myr-old Sister Stars with Debris Disks 7  Pictoris R optical > 800 AU AU Microscopi R optical > 200 AU Kalas 2004

Scattered Light Midplane Profiles “birth-ring” of planetesimals predicted at break in power-law profile Keck, Liu 2004 Hubble, Golimowski et al  Pic break at R =130 AU AU Mic break at R = 40 AU 8 Strubbe & Chiang 2006 scattered light

ALMA Reveals Millimeter Emission Belts 9 Dent et al., submitted  Pic R mm =130 AU MacGregor et al AU Mic R mm = 40 AU Cycle 0, 20+ antennas, 2 hours, <1 arcsecond resolution

AU Mic Millimeter Emission Modeling contours: ±4,8,12,.. x 30 μ Jy outer belt + central peak 10

outer edge at 40 AU, matches break in scattered light profile surface density of planetesimals rises with radius, an outward wave of planet formation? no detectable asymmetries in structure or position (still compatible with presence of a Uranus-like planet) AU Mic Outer Dust Belt Properties 11 T. Pyle/NASA

AU Mic Central Peak Emission unresolved and 6x stronger than stellar photosphere! stellar corona? models can match millimeter and X-ray asteroid-like belt at R<3 AU? compatible with infrared limits 12 Cranmer et al. 2014

AU Mic Higher Resolution Simulations easy to resolve an asteroid belt with 0.25 arcsec resolution a stellar corona will remain unresolved we’ll find out from ALMA in Cycle 1 (PI M. Hughes) 13 Inner Dust BeltStellar Corona

ALMA Observes (half) the Fomalhaut Disk millimeter emission belt narrower than optical scattered light 14 Boley et al Hubble (blue) ALMA (orange) planetesimals confined by shepherding planets? Saturn F Ring

Secondary Molecular Gas in  Pictoris 15 ALMA detects CO J=3-2 emission 30% from one compact clump icy planetesimals shattered by collisions? – destruction of large comet every 5 minutes – trapping in the resonances of an outer planet could account for localized gas production sputtering? colliding Mars-mass bodies? Dent et al., submitted

HD 10647: A Very Dusty Debris Disk similar to our Solar System – Sun-like star, F9V type – a Jupiter-like planet at 2 AU – 1000x Kuiper Belt dust at 80 AU What could ALMA see (in an hour)? 16 Stapelfeldt et al Liseau et al ALMA Cycle 2 simulations

Summary debris disks result from collisional cascades of planetesimals, relics of planet formation millimeter emission traces the planetesimals early ALMA observations reveal Kuiper-like belts and (the first of many) surprises 17 ESA

18 END