The Right to the City RTC Coalition Sept. 7, 2014.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Building bridges: integrating the work of public health and urban planning Rajiv Bhatia, MD, MPH San Francisco Department of Public Health January 27 th,
Advertisements

March 23, 2004Building a Democratic City: How Participatory Budgeting Can Work in Toronto Don’t just sit there! On the piece of paper you receive, please.
Chapter Four A Tradition of Democracy Rights and Responsibilities
T RANSFORMING C APITALISM T HROUGH R EAL U TOPIAS.
The Glorious Revolution of England pt. I Setting the Stage for Political Revolutions.
1- Textbook: Gender Planning & Development Chapter 3 Practical & Strategic Needs.
Explorations in Economics
T RANSFORMING C APITALISM T HROUGH R EAL U TOPIAS Erik Olin Wright ClassCritsV November 2012.
Plan for Today: What do we mean by democracy?
Related Issue 3 looks at the viability of liberalism So when we look at this related issue, we have to ask ourselves, how well have the underlying beliefs.
John Locke’s Contribution to American Democracy
GREAT BRITAIN- PUBLIC POLICY AND CURRENT ISSUES AP COMPARATIVE GOVERNMENT.
Theme: Basics of administrative law.
What can we do? What should we do? RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE UNITED STATES CITIZEN.
is the idea that governments draw their powers from the governed.
Cluster 2 Unit 6.  Democracy is: 1) A process 2) People listen to one another 3) People say what they think 4) People make decisions together by accepting.
Definitions and Models DEMOCRACY AND DEMOCRATIZATION.
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
The US Constitution and World Governments
Innovation Systems Research Network MCRI Theme III: Social Inclusion and Civic Engagement David A. Wolfe, Ph.D. Program on Globalization and Regional Innovation.
Democracy and the World: South America. Making Democracy Work Common PracticesConditions that Foster those Practices Free Elections Having more than one.
Social Quality in Hong Kong: Who cares? Which quality? Raymond K H CHAN City University of Hong Kong.
Chapter 1 Principles of Government and Politics
Challenges to freedom of expression The right to freedom of expression is a “foundation right” in society. Defined in Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Parliament’s Role in Peace-Building and Development.
Water for Growth and Development IWRM in Service Delivery Community Projects & Funding Conference “Water for Resource Limited Farmers and Reform”
Constitutions The Master Institution January 31 st, 2006.
Content Statement 14 Roosevelt and Progressivism Mr. Leasure 2014 – 2015 Harrison Career Center.
Economic Systems. The purpose of economics The purpose of economics  Economics seeks to answer the basic question of how to deal with SCARCITY.
Chapter 1, Section 1 “ If men were angels no government would be necessary. ” --James Madison, Federalist Paper No. 51.
American Government: An Introduction. Compose a list of at least 5 items for the following question: – What should should be the function of government?
Civil Law. Law that governs private property, contracts and disputes involving individuals and businesses.
Corporatism Origins and Development Forms of Corporatism
GEOG 347: Public Space & Cultures of Democracy The right to the city is far more than the individual liberty to access urban resources: it is a right to.
Definitions, Principle, and Evolution DEMOCRACY AND DEMOCRATIZATION.
Ideologies What are Political Ideologies?. An ideology is an organized collection of ideas. The word ideology was coined by Count Antoine de Tracy in.
Types of Government Chapter 1 Section 3 Aristotle Three types of Government Autocracy: rule by one person Oligarchy: rule by a few people Democracy:
90 The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. 90 Background The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms was entrenched (safeguarded) in the Canadian.
THE LINKS BETWEEN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL POLICIES JOSÉ ANTONIO OCAMPO UNDER-SECRETARY GENERAL ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL AFFAIRS.
What is Government?. What Government Does We all have routines, take a few seconds and make a list what you do on a typical day Take a second look at.
Do Now: Your Essay Rewrite is due today! Submit in Drop Box and old essay in In-Box!! Grab today’s Agenda (5:5). Follow the directions on the Agenda.
Foundations of American Government. The Functions of Government  Government is an institution in which leaders use power to make and enforce laws. 
 An ideology is:  A set of aims and ideas, especially in politics/government.  A comprehensive vision; a way of looking at the world.  Proposed by.
The Democratic Republic ADVANCED PLACEMENT UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT CHAPTER 1.
Role of Government in a Free Society. Question Slide 1 1.What role should government play in a free society? 2.What should be the measure of whether it.
Drill: What is a human right? What is the most important human right?
Participatory Budgeting Cambridge Real Money! Real Power!
What is a Government? Defining governments in general…
Existing Programs to support development of micro-enterprise for informal economy workers and other poverty reduction programs 16 March 2012 Banyan tree.
1 Purposes and Origins of Government What is the purpose of government? What is the purpose of government? How is government defined? How is government.
In Defense of Regulated Market Economy 32E28000 Legal Environment of Business PhD, Jukka Mäkinen Senior University Lecturer Aalto University School of.
Unit 1 People, Politics and Participation Political Parties Conservatism (1): traditional conservatism.
Lesson 1 – Foundations of Government
Dictators, War and Revolution
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Principles of Government and Politics
Chapter 1 Sect. 3 Mr. Gordon.
Morality in International Contexts
Government Notebook You will be required to have a notebook (a spiral) for this class It would be best if you only used the notebook for this subject since.
LECTURE 26 DEMOCRACY FROM BELOW December 9, 2010.
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Chapter 1: People and Government
Definitions, Principle, and Evolution
Lost & found Civic uses and new policy tools for the community
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Lesson 1 – Foundations of Government
Government Notebook What must be in the notebook: Chapter Vocabulary
Lesson 1 – Foundations of Government
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Presentation transcript:

The Right to the City RTC Coalition Sept. 7, 2014

Henri Lefebvre The Right to the City (1967) – Context: social crisis in France Material reorganization of the city, consumerism, boredom – “One only has to open one’s eyes to understand the daily life of the one who runs from his dwelling to the station, near or far away, to the packed underground train, the office or the factory, to return the same way in the evening and come home to recuperate enough to start again the next day. The picture of this generalized misery would not go without a picture of ‘satisfactions’ which hides it and becomes the means to elude it and break free from it.” – People need play, sexuality, physical activities, creative activities, art and knowledge “which can more or less overcome the fragmentary division of tasks.” – Proposal to politicize urban reform and shift ideas in urban planning view/lefebvre-The+right+to+the+city.pdf

Outcomes of 60s (and 70s) Urban Crises? Neoliberalism – “the mobilization and extension of state power in the contradictory extension and reproduction of market(-like) rule” (Tickle and Peck, 2003) – Capitalism reorganized itself with the help of technology to double-down on its structuring premises: eat away (or sell off) public institutions, destroy institutions that served as hot beds for radicalism, (i.e. privatizing universities, student debt), destroying employment security and protections, and privatizing social relations. – The production of a highly competitive and individualistic subjectivity Our crises/context – Debt – Low wages – No social safety net – A society of rents – No democracy beyond the purely formal – Environmental decline – Overwhelming anxiety and moral conflictedness – The “precariat” replaces the traditional proletariat Expression through Occupy and associated movements – More grin without a cat?

David Harvey “The right to the city is far more than the individual liberty to access urban resources: it is a right to change ourselves by changing the city. It is, moreover, a common rather than an individual right since this transformation inevitably depends upon the exercise of a collective power to reshape the processes of urbanization. The freedom to make and remake our cities and ourselves is, I want to argue, one of the most precious yet most neglected of our human rights.” The right to the city is an empty signifier – Everything depends on who gets to fill it with meaning – Politics and struggle!

David Harvey Harvey attributes the return of the idea of a right to the city to developments in Brazil (not to a revival of Lefebvre) – Constitutional guarantees that created a new legal-urban order to provide land access and equity in large urban cities (2001) Social function of urban land is put before commercial value: “the prioritization of use value over exchange value” (however, see recent World Cup and Olympic developments) Ensure democratic city management: “a path to plan, produce, operate and govern cities subject to social control and participation.” – Participatory Budgeting (i.e. Belo Horizonte & Porto Alegre) Citizens are incorporated into public processes where they decide how to allocate public funds (up to 100% in some cases) Spread throughout the US in a Right to the City Alliance – Housing, houselessness, LGBTQ issues, etc. – “the coalition sought a clearer and broader definition of that public that not only can truly access so-called public space, but can also be empowered to create new common spaces for socialization and political action.” Also notes recent urban uprisings around the world.

Rights Individual – We are familiar with individual rights and we have established methods for enforcing them with the help of the state – Invented as a response to the Divine Right of Kings – Property rights is the emblematic example; highly emphasized since the mid-1800s Collective – Basically what we mean by “public” Common – Right to access and use resources – Includes some traditional content like the 1 st Amendment (right to assemble) – The right to decide as a democratic body – The right to a less deterministic politics

Formal Attempt at Common Rights: People’s Water Trust

Potential Strategy Take the claims of liberal democracy seriously and attempt to fulfill them. – i.e. expand human rights beyond those with privilege (housing for all, basic income, access to healthcare) Result: – Exposes the rifts in the way our system fails to substantively live up to its own vision; identifies the hypocrites (i.e. Dem Party) – To the extent reforms succeed, or are even partially implemented, we’re better off than we were before – Build strong coalitions in the process to make greater claims in the future

Question How should we define a right to the city in our locale?