RESULTSINTRODUCTION Accuracy of Screening Tests for Autism Spectrum Disorder in Primary Care Settings Marjolaine M. Limbos 1, PhD & David P. Joyce 2, MD,

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Developmental Screening and Surveillance DENVER II
Advertisements

Va-LEND: Collaborating with Rural School Divisions to Train Interdisciplinary Autism Assessment Teams Donald Oswald, 1 Joann Bodurtha, 1 Donna Gilles,
PDD Behavior Inventory™ Screening Version (PDDBI™-SV)
Cognitive, neurological and adaptive behaviour functioning among children with perinatally-acquired HIV infection Anita Shet, Smitha Holla, Vijaya Raman,
+. June 2007: ADEPP Objectives Heighten public awareness of early signs of autism Heighten public awareness of early signs of autism Improve access to.
Determining Presumptive Eligibility for Early Intensive Behavioral Intervention Using Two Positive Screens: A South Carolina Act Early Work in Progress.
Developmental Screening Tools Michelle M. Macias, MD D-PIP Training Workshop June 16, 2006 I have no relevant financial relationships with the manufacturer(s)
Developmental and Autism Screening Tools: What are they ? Donald R. Burgess, MD, FAAP SMMC Developmental Pediatrics First Steps Conference Improving Developmental.
Filling a Need to Reduce Wait Time for Autism Assessments: The Autism Spectrum Assessment Program at Connecticut Children’s Medical Center Jennifer Twachtman-Bassett,
By Vicki Lopes. Purpose Vicki Lopes is in her first year of her Ph.D. in Clinical Psychology at Queen’s University Investigate the role of child characteristics,
Visit our websites: PhD Study: Evaluation of the Efficacy of the Incredible.
Primary Care Physician (PCP) is notified ASAP about the evaluation result and service plans in order to have a follow-up with the family. PCP shares results.
Targeting Evidence Based Practices: Tools And Resources In Serving Students with Autism Spectrum Disorders Marilyn Gense and Annette Skowron-Gooch, Willamette.
Pervasive Developmental Disorders (Autism Spectrum Disorders): Early Screening & Diagnostic Assessment Laura Grofer Klinger, Ph.D. University of Alabama.
Enhancing Local Diagnostic Capacity: The Autism Initiative Nicky Jones-Stokreef, MD, FRCPC CTN and Orillia Soldier’s Memorial Hospital Amber Bartlett,
Dan Farkas Project Manager Autism Diagnosis Education Pilot Project. Ohio Chapter, American Academy of Pediatrics.
Parent Perspectives on Screening Young Children for Autism Within the Medical Home Paul Carbone, M.D., Tracy Golden, Ph.D., Jeff Hall, Ph.D., Elizabeth.
Copyright restrictions may apply JAMA Pediatrics Journal Club Slides: Improving Parenting Skills Perrin EC, Sheldrick RC, McMenamy JM, Henson BS, Carter.
Nebraska Early Development Network (EDN) or Iowa Early Access EDN and Early Access provide early intervention services that: Supports children birth to.
Journal Club Alcohol and Health: Current Evidence July–August 2005.
Introduction of child assessment  一、 What is child assessment ( or evaluation )?  二、 Purposes or goals of child assessment  Educational and clinical.
Screening for Autism Spectrum Disorder Autism Case Training: A Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics Curriculum 1 Authors Rebecca Scharf, MD, Children’s.
Quality Management Update March 18, New Performance Improvement Project (1) Title: Controlled Substance Prescription Monitoring Program Database.
Developmental Screening Tools: What they are and do they work Alison Schonwald MD Children’s Hospital, Boston Harvard Medical School Massachusetts Developmental.
First steps in identifying children with neurodevelopmental disabilities: First steps in identifying children with neurodevelopmental disabilities: Developmental.
PICO Presentation By: amy fox rn Cohp 450.
REAL-START : Risk Evaluation of Autism in Latinos (Screening Tools and Referral Training) Assuring No Child Enters Kindergarten With an Undetected Developmental.
Developmental Surveillance and Screening - Implementation Cathy Huang, MD FAAP Dept of Pediatrics, BHC/CCRMC Epic Physician Builder July 2013.
Pre-work Baseline Data Analysis I. Quality Measures (Annual Dental, Dental Varnishing, ED Utilization, WCV) II. New Measures (BMI, ABCD, Autism, Soc-Emot)
RESULTS INTRODUCTION Laurentian_University.svgLaurentian_University.svg‎ (SVG file, nominally 500 × 87 pixels, file size: 57 KB) Screening for Developmental.
Introduction In March of this year, the Center for Disease control estimated the incidence of Autism Spectrum Disorders to be 1 in 50, an increase from.
How To Make Developmental Services Easy to Use Judith S. Palfrey MD Alison Schonwald MD Children’s Hospital Boston Opening Doors Initiatives.
Chapter 7 Autism Spectrum Disorders
CHIPRA Quality Demonstration Grant and Pennsylvania’s Early Intervention Strategies David Kelley MD, MPH Chief Medical Officer Office of Medical Assistance.
Implementing an Innovative Model of Care to Reduce Wait Times and Add Value to the Family and Clinicians Experience Tracy Conley BC Autism Assessment Network.
Early Indicators of Autism in Young Children Early Childhood Educators of BC Provincial Conference, May 13, 2004 Pat Mirenda, Ph.D. University of British.
Screening Implementation: Referral and Follow-up What Do You Do When the Screening Test Is of Concern? Paul H. Lipkin, MD D-PIP Training Workshop June.
Discussion The Effect of Auditory Sensory Abnormalities on Language Development in Young Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder  Autism Spectrum Disorder.
Effects of Pediatric Asthma Education on Hospitalizations and Emergency Department Visits: A Meta-Analysis June 3, 2007 Janet M. Coffman, PhD, Michael.
‘PARENT’S IN PARTNERSHIP’ Carol Cuffe Disability Manager Kildare West Wicklow.
The New Autism Guidelines Daniel L. Coury MD. Faculty Disclosure Information In the past 12 months, I have had the following financial relationships with.
Initial validation of the Schedule of Growing Skills (SGS) Margiad Elen Williams, Judy Hutchings, Tracey Bywater, David Daley, & Chris Whitaker Background.
RESULTS INTRODUCTION Laurentian_University.svgLaurentian_University.svg‎ (SVG file, nominally 500 × 87 pixels, file size: 57 KB) Comparison of the ASQ.
Special Education Process: Role of the School Nurse Marge Resan, Education Consultant Special Education Team Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.
Pathways to Identification, Diagnosis, and Treatment of Autism Spectrum Disorder in Young Children Patricia O. Towle, Ph.D 1,2 Mariel Taratunio, MSW 1,3,4.
The Earlier The Better: Developmental Screening for Connecticut’s Young Children Lisa Honigfeld, Ph.D. Judith Meyers, Ph.D. Child Health and Development.
Sarah Cordett, M.A. CE240 - Young Children with Special Needs: Unit 3.
Part C Eligibility (Part H). Eligibility Criteria: Children ages birth through two who are developmentally delayed or are at established risk for developmental.
Issues and Strategies for Measuring Outcomes for Children with “Speech-Only’ Eligibility Jim J Lesko, Ed.D. Delaware Department of Education
Abstract CHADIS-DSM, a web-based questionnaire for making provisional DSM-PC diagnoses, was administered to 85 caregivers of inner city children aged 3-12.
The Center for IDEA Early Childhood Data Systems National Meeting on Early Learning Assessment June 2015 Assessing Young Children with Disabilities Kathy.
Rad kat B A Y C T H E R S Kayci
Screening for Autism Spectrum Disorder Autism Case Training: A Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics Curriculum 1 Authors Rebecca Scharf, MD, Children’s.
AUTISM & APPLIED BEHAVIORAL ASSESSMENT. AUTISM PERVASIVE DEVELOPMENTAL DISORDER - NOT OTHERWISE SPECIFIED PDD-NOS  A condition on the spectrum that.
Pediatric Screening Stacey Cobb, MD Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics Assistant Professor of Pediatrics University of South Carolina School of Medicine.
Practice Key Driver Diagram. Chapter Quality Network ADHD Project Jeff Epstein PhD CQN ADHD National Expert/CQN Data Analyst The mehealth Portal and CQN.
Screen, Investigate, Evaluate: Early Screening and Assessment for ASD Lauren K. Giovingo Florida State University.
What Is Child Find? IDEA requires that all children with disabilities (birth through twenty-one) residing in the state, including children with disabilities.
Discussion Background Objectives Office Based Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect: Lessons Learned from the Practicing Safety QuIIN Project Diane Abatemarco,
The CRİTERİON-RELATED VALIDITY of the TURKISH VINELAND – II on CLINICAL GROUPS (Autism, Pervasive Developmental Disorder Not Otherwise Specified - PDD.
Is suicide predictable? Paul St John-Smith Short Courses in Psychiatry 15/10/2008.
1 Screening Mental Health In Primary Care: Cradle to Grave Toolkit Mary R. Talen, Ph.D. Director, Behavioral Health Science MacNeal Family Medicine Berwyn,
PARENTAL RECOGNITION OF EARLY SIGNS OF ASD IN VENEZUELAN CHILDREN Cecilia Montiel-Nava, María Soto, Mayte Marín, José A. Chacín, Zoila González-Ávila,
Early Diagnosis of ASD In a Community Sample: Who Refers and Why?
ASD Teacher knowledge of ABA
Case-finding of lifestyle and mental health problems in primary care: validation of the 'CHAT' tool NAPCRG Vancouver 2007 Felicity Goodyear-Smith, Bruce.
Early Diagnosis of ASD In a Community Sample: Who Refers and Why?
Developmental Screening Learning Collaborative
Evidence Based Diagnosis
Presentation transcript:

RESULTSINTRODUCTION Accuracy of Screening Tests for Autism Spectrum Disorder in Primary Care Settings Marjolaine M. Limbos 1, PhD & David P. Joyce 2, MD, Karen Deng 3 1 Department of Psychology, B.C. Children’s Hospital, Vancouver, BC, 2 Department of Family Practice, University of British Columbia, 3 Queen’s University  Primary care physicians provide health care services to young children on a regular basis and may be ideally suited to screen for developmental and behavioral problems.  Autism spectrum disorders are more common than originally estimated, affecting as many as 1 in 400 children  There is mounting evidence that early intervention improves outcomes for children and their families in terms of behavioral, social and cognitive competence.  The M-CHAT is a brief, parent-administered measure that is widely available in North America, and has been demonstrated high sensitivity (100%) and specificity (88%) in primary care based samples and is recognized as the ideal screening test in young children.  The purpose of this study was to :  Evaluate the clinical utility of this brief parent-administered screening tool in primary care settings.  Determine the accuracy of the M-CHAT in detecting autism in children. Aims: The Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers (M-CHAT) is a brief, parent-administered developmental screening tool that has been recommended for routine use in family practice. Although the measure has been validated in large standardization samples, little is known about its accuracy when used in primary care samples. The current study aims to determine the accuracy of the M-CHAT for developmental screening in primary care settings. Materials & Methods: Three hundred and four children aged 12 – 60 month were recruited from the offices of 80 primary care providers. Parents completed the M-CHAT, and all children concurrently underwent an evaluation by a clinical psychologist. This evaluation included a battery of standardized psychological measures including measures of: (1) Cognition/Development; (2) Speech/Language; (3) Adaptive Functioning; and (4) Behavioral Functioning. Results: A total of 5 children were identified as having autism spectrum disorder on the criterion measures. NEEDS MORE Conclusions: The M-CHAT when used in its entirety shows good promise as a tool for screening for developmental delays in primary care settings. Benefits include ease of use (administration by the parent prior to the visit), and high sensitivity and specificity when concerns emerge in any subscales of the screening test. These findings support recent recommendations on developmental screening in family practice.  M- CHAT had high sensitivity (100%) and specificity (88%) for detecting autism in an unselected sample of children presenting for primary care  The M-CHAT is a suitable screening tool for autism in primary care settings as evidenced by its high sensitivity and specificity when concerns are raised in 2 critical items or, 3 non-critical items.  Furthermore, the ease of administration of the M-CHAT, as well as its role in stimulating discussion about a child’s development may be other benefits of the M-CHAT.  These findings support recent recommendations for routine use of the M-CHAT as a screening tool in primary care settings. DISCUSSION METHODS 334 Children Aged months (Mean = 32.4 months) Presenting for Routine Primary Care Screening Test: Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers (M-CHAT) CONCLUSIONS  Approximately 1.1% of individuals presenting for routine primary care were identified as having autism spectrum disorder.  The M-CHAT had 100% sensitivity and 88% specificity for the detection of autism spectrum disorder.  All of the broadband screening measures showed moderate to high sensitivity and specificity when 1 or more abnormal items or predictive concerns were used as the cut-off for an abnormal screen. 80 Primary Care Providers : 70 Family Physicians 7 Nurse Practitioners 3 Pediatricians Criterion Measures: Cognition/Development: Bayley III (12-30 months) WPPSI III (30-60 months) Speech and Language: Preschool Language Scale IV Adaptive Functioning Vineland II Clinical Assessment by a Registered Psychologist Autism Spectrum Disorder: DSM-IV TR Criteria for Autism Spectrum Disorder as assessed by structured interview with a registered psychologist Accuracy of the M-CHAT: Sensitivity = TP/TP+ FN Specificity = TN/TN+FP Table 1. Figure 2. Sensitivity and Specificity of the Screening Measures for Detection of Autism Spectrum Disorder Note: The total number of participants was 334. A total of 5 children received a diagnosis of autism and 34 children received a diagnosis of a developmental delay using the criterion measures. Autism is defined by DSM-IV TR Criteria and assessed by structured interview with a registered psychologist. Figure 1. Sensitivity and Specificity of the ASQ in Detecting Autism in Children Notes: The gold standard for the clinical diagnosis of autism was the assessment of the clinical psychologist. However, all children diagnosed with autism also met criteria for a developmental delay (i.e. ≤ 10 th percentile on either the cognitive or speech language criterion measures AND ≤ 10th percentile on the measure of adaptive functioning). NPV = Negative Predictive Value; PPV = Positive Predictive Value; LR= Likelihood Ratio (3.7 on this graph) ABSTRACT