2008 May 315th Italian-Sino Workshop Yu-Huei Wu and Chih-Hung Wang Accept by Classical and Quantum Gravity without correction Provisionally scheduled to.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Jo van den Brand, Chris Van Den Broeck, Tjonnie Li
Advertisements

F. Debbasch (LERMA-ERGA Université Paris 6) and M. Bustamante, C. Chevalier, Y. Ollivier Statistical Physics and relativistic gravity ( )
Hot topics in Modern Cosmology Cargèse - 10 Mai 2011.
The Unification of Gravity and E&M via Kaluza-Klein Theory Chad A. Middleton Mesa State College September 16, 2010 Th. Kaluza, Sitzungsber. Preuss. Akad.
Rainbow Gravity and the Very Early Universe Yi Ling Center for Gravity and Relativistic Astrophysics Nanchang University, China Nov. 4, Workshop.
Spinor Gravity A.Hebecker,C.Wetterich.
Weyl gravity as general relativity Conformal gauge theories of gravity Midwest Relativity Meeting 2013 James T Wheeler Work done in collaboration with.
{Based on PRD 81 (2010) [ ], joint work with X.-N. Wu}
ASYMPTOTIC STRUCTURE IN HIGHER DIMENSIONS AND ITS CLASSIFICATION KENTARO TANABE (UNIVERSITY OF BARCELONA) based on KT, Kinoshita and Shiromizu PRD
Lattice Spinor Gravity Lattice Spinor Gravity. Quantum gravity Quantum field theory Quantum field theory Functional integral formulation Functional integral.
Improved constrained scheme for the Einstein equations: an approach to the uniqueness issue in collaboration with Pablo Cerdá-Durán Harald Dimmelmeier.
Cosimo Stornaiolo INFN-Sezione di Napoli MG 12 Paris July 2009.
July 2005 Einstein Conference Paris Thermodynamics of a Schwarzschild black hole observed with finite precision C. Chevalier 1, F. Debbasch 1, M. Bustamante.
Non-Localizability of Electric Coupling and Gravitational Binding of Charged Objects Matthew Corne Eastern Gravity Meeting 11 May 12-13, 2008.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2005 Dr Geraint F. Lewis Rm 557, A29
General Relativity Physics Honours 2007 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 557, A29 Lecture Notes 4.
Classical Mechanics and Special Relativity with GA Suprit Singh.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2010
GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF BRANE KINEMATICS AND DYNAMICS Introduction Strings, branes, geometric principle, background independence Brane space M (brane kinematics)
Construction of gauge-invariant variables for linear-order metric perturbations on general background spacetime Kouji Nakamura (NAOJ) References : K.N.
Cosmological post-Newtonian Approximation compared with Perturbation Theory J. Hwang KNU/KIAS
2次ゲージ不変摂動論定式化の進行状況 Kouji Nakamura (Grad. Univ. Adv. Stud. (NAOJ)) References : K.N. Prog. Theor. Phys., vol.110 (2003), 723. (gr-qc/ ). K.N. Prog.
Cosmological Post-Newtonian Approximation with Dark Energy J. Hwang and H. Noh
Gravitational Waves (& Gravitons ?)
Forming Nonsingular Black Holes from Dust Collapse by R. Maier (Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Físicas-Rio de Janeiro) I. Damião Soares (Centro Brasileiro.
Conformally flat spacetimes and Weyl frames Carlos Romero Cargèse - 11 Mai 2010.
On noncommutative corrections in a de Sitter gauge theory of gravity SIMONA BABEŢI (PRETORIAN) “Politehnica” University, Timişoara , Romania, .
Vincent Rodgers © Vincent Rodgers © A Very Brief Intro to Tensor Calculus Two important concepts:
General Relativity Physics Honours 2005 Dr Geraint F. Lewis Rm 557, A29
Crash Course of Relativistic Astrometry Four Dimensional Spacetime Poincare Transformation Time Dilatation Wavelength Shift Gravitational Deflection of.
General proof of the entropy principle for self-gravitating fluid in static spacetimes 高思杰 (Gao Sijie) 北京师范大学 (Beijing Normal University)
THERMAL EVOLUION OF NEUTRON STARS: Theory and observations D.G. Yakovlev Ioffe Physical Technical Institute, St.-Petersburg, Russia Catania, October 2012,
COOLING OF NEUTRON STARS D.G. Yakovlev Ioffe Physical Technical Institute, St.-Petersburg, Russia Ladek Zdroj, February 2008, 1. Formulation of the Cooling.
Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2007PHYS 5326, Spring 2007 Jae Yu 1 PHYS 5326 – Lecture #9 Wednesday, Feb. 28, 2007 Dr. Jae Yu 1.Quantum Electro-dynamics (QED) 2.Local.
Super Virasoro Algebras from Chiral Supergravity Ibaraki Univ. Yoshifumi Hyakutake Based on arXiv:1211xxxx + work in progress.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2009
Y.K.Lau Institute of Appl. Maths, CAS. Bondi Sachs Formulation of the Kerr Metric Gravitational Wave Physics of a Kerr Black Hole.
Hawking radiation for a Proca field Mengjie Wang (王梦杰 ) In collaboration with Carlos Herdeiro & Marco Sampaio Mengjie Wang 王梦杰 Based on: PRD85(2012)
Quantum Gravity and emergent metric Quantum Gravity and emergent metric.
Wednesday, Mar. 5, 2003PHYS 5326, Spring 2003 Jae Yu 1 PHYS 5326 – Lecture #13 Wednesday, Mar. 5, 2003 Dr. Jae Yu Local Gauge Invariance and Introduction.
General Relativity Physics Honours 2008 A/Prof. Geraint F. Lewis Rm 560, A29 Lecture Notes 9.
General proof of the entropy principle for self-gravitating fluid in static spacetimes 高思杰 北京师范大学 (Beijing Normal University) Cooperated with 房熊俊
Gravitational wave memory Winnipeg, May 22, 2014.
Possible Enhancement of noncommutative EFFECTS IN gravity Objective Look for consequences of gravity on noncommutative (NC) space-time Chamseddine In particular,
Motions of Self-Gravitating bodies to the Second Post- Newtonian Order of General Relativity.
General Relativity and Cosmology The End of Absolute Space Cosmological Principle Black Holes CBMR and Big Bang.
Spin-orbit Gravitational Radiation Reaction for Two-body Systems Jing Zeng Washington University Gravity Group November
Research Interests 2007: John L. Fry. Research Supported BY: Air Force Office of Scientific Research Air Force Office of Scientific Research R. A. Welch.
First Steps Towards a Theory of Quantum Gravity Mark Baumann Dec 6, 2006.
Yoshinori Matsuo (KEK) in collaboration with Hikaru Kawai (Kyoto U.) Yuki Yokokura (Kyoto U.)
Non-Commutative Einstein Equations and Seiberg–Witten Map Paolo Aschieri,Elisabetta Di Grezia, Giampiero Esposito, INFN, Turin and Naples. Friedmann Seminar,
1 Bhupendra Nath Tiwari IIT Kanpur in collaboration with T. Sarkar & G. Sengupta. Thermodynamic Geometry and BTZ black holes This talk is mainly based.
The effect of Gravity on Equation of State Hyeong-Chan Kim (KNUT) FRP Workshop on String Theory and Cosmology 2015, Chungju, Korea, Nov ,
Based on Phys. Rev. D 92, (R) (2015) 中科大交叉学科理论研究中心
Gravity on Matter Equation of State and the Unruh temperature Hyeong-Chan Kim (KNUT) 2016 FRP workshop on String theory and cosmology Seoul, Korea, June.
Relativistic Quantum Mechanics Lecture 1 Books Recommended:  Lectures on Quantum Field Theory by Ashok Das  Advanced Quantum Mechanics by Schwabl  Relativistic.
A TEST FOR THE LOCAL INTRINSIC LORENTZ SYMMETRY
Quantum Field Theory (PH-537) M.Sc Physics 4th Semester
Equation of State and Unruh temperature
Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea
Einstein’s Zurich Notebook
Special Theory of Relativity
A Beautiful MOND ? G B Tupper U C T Beyond 2010.
QUASI-SPHERICAL GRAVITATIONAL COLLAPSE Ujjal Debnath Department of Mathematics, Bengal Engineering and Science University, Shibpur, Howrah , India.
Solutions of black hole interior, information paradox and the shape of singularities Haolin Lu.
Quantized K
Canonical Quantization
A New Approach to Equation of Motion for a fast-moving particle
Normal gravity field in relativistic geodesy
Don Salisbury Austin College
Presentation transcript:

2008 May 315th Italian-Sino Workshop Yu-Huei Wu and Chih-Hung Wang Accept by Classical and Quantum Gravity without correction Provisionally scheduled to publish for June 2008 Yu-Huei Wu and Chih-Hung Wang Accept by Classical and Quantum Gravity without correction Provisionally scheduled to publish for June 2008 Quasi-local mass in the covariant Newtonian space time Yu-Huei Wu 吳育慧 Institute of Astronomy, NCU

Mass in General Relativity Equivalence principle forbids us to have a localized gravitational energy- momentum expression in GR. Unlike Newtonian theory, we cannot separate background and dynamics in GR General relativity is not a gauge field theory and highly non-linear. All other fields can have proper energy density definitions in curved space-time. G ab = 8  G /c^4 T ab Unlike Newtonian theory, there’s no unique definition of quasi-local mass in GR. Mass is formulated in various ways.  Dark energy: back to Newtonian Lucy Calder and Ofer Lahavn 2008

Quasi-local mass construction Quasi-local idea is to define gravitational energy- momentum associated to a closed 2-surface We examine (1) Komar integral, (2) Brown-York expression and (3) Dogan-Mason mass expression in this work source sphere

Quasi-local mass energy? What does it mean physically? Bondi's prolate and oblate mechanism. Gravitational wave can transfer energy locally (GW carry mass loss and radiate radiate to null infinity.) Bondi put it: 'one can heat water with them'. Tidal heating Io & Jupiter [Both + Creighton 2000]

General Relativity v.s. Newtonian General Relativity: 10 field equations and 10 potentials Non-linear equations Intrinsically geometrical Horizons of black holes Gravitational waves Newtonian Gravity: 1 field equation and 1 potential Linear equation Absolute space and time No horizons or no black hole No gravitational waves Have localized mass and energy

What does it mean by the Newtonian limit? Post-Newtonian theory depends on the choice of the coordinate and background Minkowski metric is required. Not a covariant fashion ! Can these quasi-local expressions directly go back to the unique surface integration in Newtonian space time? Can spinor field has a Newtonian correspondence?

Newtonian and post-Newtonian approximations are asymptotic to general relativity by using the Newtonian sequence method [Futamase and Schutz ’83]. Hence Jeffryes use it to verify the Newtonian limit of Penrose quasi-local mass. Unfortunately, it can return to the Newtonian mass and energy only by using transaction between 2-surface twistors and 3-surface twistors. All these are from GR aspect

Can a purely Newtonian type of star distort the geometry of 3-space, i.e., generate pseudo- Riemannian curvature on it? A more consistent transition between relativistic and Newtonian theory of gravity is needed.

Neutron star Outer crust: Newtonian theory or flat background V.S. Inner core: General Relativity Equation of State (EOS) of inner core ?? ?

1. For the ordinary pulsars, the magnetic field is sufficiently low. a purely Newtonian framework. 2. For the magnetars, the magnetic field is sufficiently strong. relativistic treatment will be indispensable even locally.

Covariant Newtonian Theory  How to write the Newtonian theory in terms of space- time geometry?  Newtonian space time is handicap, therefore cannot give an unique connection unless we introduce the ether frame e. The covariant Newtonian theory is developed by Kunzle ’72, and Carter ’04. The purpose is to show how to set up and apply a fully covariant formulation of the kinds of non-relativistic multiconstituent fluid dynamical models and relativistic correspondence.

 Newtonian (Galilean) space-time is considered as a direct product of a flat Euclidean 3-space and one dimensional Euclidean time line t, i.e., four dimensional fiber bundle. Each fiber t contains a Euclidean (contravariant) flat metric γ.  Each fiber t contains a Euclidean (contravariant) flat metric γ and one-form d t where γ is a degenerate metric and cannot upper or lower indices, i.e. no metric-dual definition of tensor fields. It has been found that conditions ∇ γ = 0 and ∇ d t = 0 with vanishing torsion cannot give an unique connection ∇ in the Newtonian space-time.

Milne gauge in the Newtonian space time Equivalence principle in the Newtonian space time [Milne 1934]. In the Milne structure of Newtonian space-time, ∇ is not gauge invariant and has the following gauge transformations Milne gauge invariant connection D (Newton-Cartan connection) Newtonian gravitational equation Gauge invariant

Mass expression in the covariant Newtonian space time From volume integration to surface integration Gauge invariant!!

Relativistic correspondence From Newtonian to GR Carter et al.'03 considered the following four dimensional non-degenerate metric where

The generalization of can be written as We further restrict deformations of as following It is sufficient to represent a deformation generated by a star. Einstein field equation gives

(1) Komar integral In terms of a asymptotic time-like Killing vector field, Komar integral yields It gives exactly the same covariant expression as Newtonian surface integration without choosing a specific closed 2-surface.

(2) Brown-York quasi-local energy Einstein field equation gives BY mass in Newtonian limit then becomes If it is spherical symmetry with, then

(3) Dogan-Mason mass: Twistor program Twistor is a geometrical object that is more fundamental than spinors. Space-time themselves can be regarded as derived objects [Penrose ‘67]. We can use the spinors to define mass or angular momentum. The Newtonian limit of spinor field is shown here. Metric:

Spin frame in Newtonian limit The asymptotic constant spinor can be expressed as They satisfy the holomorphic condition

The key NP coefficients are: The first order spinor solutions are

The second order spinor solutions are

The mass expression can be expanded as

Conclusion Since general relativity has a well known Newtonian limit, it is reasonable for us to argue that it should yield the Newtonian expression for all of quasi-local expressions in the covariant Newtonian space-time. In this work, we verify that Komar integral can yield the Newtonian quasi-local mass expression without choosing a specific 2-sphere or referring to spherical symmetry of the Newtonian potential, however, the Brown-York expression and Dougan-Mason mass can give Newtonian expression with spherical symmetry

Whether this problem is due to the expressions themselves or some other technical problems requires a further investigation. Brown D and York J W Quasilocal energy and conserved charges derived from the gravitational action 1993 Phys. Rev. D (Preprint gr-qc/ ) Carter B, Chachoua E and Chamel N Covariant Newtonian and Relativistic dynamics of (magneto)-elastic solid model for neutron star crust 2006 Gen. Rel. Grav Carter B and Chamel N Covariant analysis of Newtonian multi-fluid models for neutron stars: I Milne-Cartan structure and variational formulation 2004 Int. J. Mod. Phys. D (Preprint astro-ph/ ) Dougan A J and Mason L J Quasi-local mass constructions with positive energy 1999 Phys. Rev. Lett Künzle H P Galilei and Lorentz structures on space-time: comparison of the corresponding geometry and physics 1972 Annales de l’institut Henri Poíncare Futamase T and Schutz B 1983 Phys. Rev. D Jeffryes B 1986 Class. Quantum Grav

Escher: Relativity