ASSISTED DYING Some medico-scientific and ethical aspects John Bryant Plymouth CiS, Feb 2013.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Decisions at the end of life
Advertisements

Should euthanasia be legalised?
Euthanasia CS301 Should voluntary assisted death be legalized? This presentation deals in nearly all fields of Legal, Professional, and Natural Human Ethics.
Nunu Poe PHIL 1722 Section- 60 Diana Pretty From England Not allow assisted suicide in England Have family Was rejected from both England and European.
Issues with Diane Pretty. Contravention of human rights by not allowing husband to help her commit suicide. She said after decision “The Law has taken.
“MERCY KILLING” Euthanasia. Euthanasia – when someone other than the patient, usually a physician performs the act.
Kant’s Categorical Imperative and Euthanasia
Euthanasia Michael Lacewing © Michael Lacewing.
Euthanasia in the 21 st century CD. Background eeuthanasia: the act of putting to death painlessly or allowing to die tthe law and medical profession.
Euthanasia.
Applied Ethics Ethical Issues Section 2 Computer Science.
Euthanasia The central problem of medical ethics.
Euthanasia Anagrams Find your folder and a piece of scrap paper
Alcohol and the Disease. Alcoholism Over 100,000 deaths per year in the U.S. due to alcohol and alcoholism Over 100,000 deaths per year in the U.S. due.
Chapter 14 Death and Dying. Death and Society Death as Enemy; Death Welcomed A continuum of societal attitudes and beliefs Attitudes formed by –Religious.
Bioethics I: Euthanasia Presented by Rebecca Austen Director of Advocacy World Youth Alliance.
Biomedical Ethics An overview of ethics in health care.
Ethics and End-of-Life Care Part 2: Autonomy and Futility Michael Wassenaar, PhD February 9, 2012.
Advanced Higher RMPS Medical Ethics. The Sanctity of Life Many religious people believe that life is sacred, this means that it is holy and given by God.
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 About those who are not able to make decisions for themselves (But not children or people who are mentally ill) About all.
Can a mediator create a balance between self-determination and procedural and substantive fairness – A discussion on an ethical framework for decision.
Clinical Ethical Issues: Principles, Range of Cases, History Lessons Robert L. Perkel, M.D. Chair, Thomas Jefferson University Ethics Committee The 2 nd.
Ethical issues in old age medical care. The Four-Principles Approach developed in the early 1980’s by well-known American bioethicists Tom Beauchamp and.
End of Life Decisions WMA – SEYCHELLES BASIC CONCEPTS IN ETHICS SEMINAR, 10 TH & 11 TH JULY 2015 (July 2015) Professor A Dhai Immediate Past-President.
Euthanasia. Terms Voluntary Euthanasia (patient’s consent) Voluntary Euthanasia (patient’s consent) Involuntary euthanasia (no consent) Involuntary.
Euthanasia Parveen Kaur (11) Phuah Zhi Yi (12) Yeoh Ee Ping (21)
Euthanasia Part I Ethics Dr. Jason M. Chang. Euthanasia Directly or indirectly bringing about the death of another person for the person’s sake Examples.
Introduction to Medical Ethics Paul Dassow, MD, MSPH MD 815 November 15, 2006.
1 Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia Michael Wassenaar, PhD February 16, 2012.
By: Ronald F. White, Ph.D. Professor of Philosophy College of Mount St. Joseph.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. PRIMA FACIE DUTIES AUTONOMY BENEFICENCE NON - MALEFICENCE JUSTICE UTILITY.
What the Catholic church believes & why (evidence) Pro Choice Arguments (philos, moral, practical) Pro-life arguments (philos, moral, practical) What the.
Chapter Five: Euthanasia Review Applying Ethics: A Text with Readings (10 th ed.) Julie C. Van Camp, Jeffrey Olen, Vincent Barry Cengage Learning/Wadsworth.
Euthanasia ‘ A gentle, easy death; the bringing about of this especially in the cases of incurable and painful disease’
Euthansia. Some Background: Voluntary Involuntary Passive Active Voluntary Passive Euthanasia Involuntary Passive Euthanasia Voluntary Active Euthanasia.
Developing an Argument: Assisted Suicide.  Euthanasia is the intentional killing by act or omission of a dependent human being for his or her alleged.
Social problems in our actual world THE BEGINNING AND THE END OF HUMAN LIFE. Euthanasia THE BEGINNING AND THE END OF HUMAN LIFE. Euthanasia.
EUTHANASIA VALENTINA ARIAS 11°2 ENGLISH WORKSHOP.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. ETHICAL THEORIES DEONTOLOGY CONSEQUENTIALISM VIRTUE ETHICS.
To assess the arguments for and against euthanasia. To reflect on the moral dilemma surrounding euthanasia.
Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide
The perfect person 2. Worthwhileness of life in the face of progressive disease and disability. Euthanasia- including assisted suicide David Carpenter.
Chapter 24 Ethical Obligations and Accountability Fundamentals of Nursing: Standards & Practices, 2E.
Euthanasia and Physician Assisted Suicide Week Four Seminar HU245 Ethics.
Chapter Five: Euthanasia
Introduction to Bioethics Learning Objectives (SWBAT) Students will be able to engage in respectful dialogue to come to a group decision about a conflict.
Chapter 10: Euthanasia Confusion can come over questions like: - Whether someone is dead or ought to be considered dead - Whether it is permissible to.
What are We Talking About? What is Morality? Chapter 1.
Law in Britain. 1. an offence to commit suicide. Anyone who attempted suicide and failed could be prosecuted and imprisoned for up to a period of two.
Introduction to Medical Ethics Ray Noble Centre for Reproductive Ethics and Rights UCL Institute for Women’s Health University College London.
BIOETHICAL PRINCIPLES Beauchamp and Childress 2001;Gillon 1986
Is the Euthanasia right or not? (
Is the Euthanasia right or not? (
Ethics: Theory and Practice
Starter for 5! Which key term means that life is sacred because it is God given? Which key term refers to the general well-being of a person in relation.
Self-Determination Learning Objective: To explore the concept of self-determination. I can share my initial views on whether humans have the right to self-determination.
Ethics in Critical Care Medicine: Withdrawal and withholding treatment
What topics would you most like to revise as a
BMA on end of life decisions

Lecture 10: A Brief Summary
BY Muteb Alshayban Hamad Alshageri Zaied Alharithi
Pick 4 words to define. TPS their meaning and importance to this topic.
Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide: Concepts and Issues
Medical Ethics – the end of life
Euthanasia and the challenges for a chaplain in Europe
Natural Laws applied to voluntary euthanasia
The Morality of Euthanasia
Medical Ethics -frameworks
Presentation transcript:

ASSISTED DYING Some medico-scientific and ethical aspects John Bryant Plymouth CiS, Feb 2013

WHEN MAY I DIE AND WHEN AM I DEAD? Ethical frameworks Medical ethics Science, Medicine and Demographics Issues and Implications

A THOUGHT WITH WHICH TO BEGIN There are two ways to live your life. One is as though nothing is a miracle. The other is as though everything is a miracle. Albert Einstein

ETHICAL FRAMEWORKS Deontology (Duty-based; Kantian Ethics) Consequentialism (Results-based) Virtue (Character-based -Aristotle, Aquinas) [Natural Law – Aristotle, Aquinas] Communitarian Aspects –Michael Sandel, Stanley Hauerwas

David Sharp Died, May m below summit Thanks to Dr Donal O’Mathuna for this example

MEDICAL ETHICS  Beneficence, Do good  Non-malificence Don’t do harm  Justice Treat people fairly  Autonomy Respect individual rights Beauchamp & Childress, Principles of Biomedical Ethics  What type of ethical system is this?  What about wisdom and compassion?

THE STATE OF PLAY Life expectancy Medical progress Defining death Difficult dying

LIFE EXPECTANCY Life-spans are increasing each day by an average of two hours. Great Britain, averages 1930, Men – , Men – 68, Women , Men – 79, Women – 83 But note huge differences, even within one city, eg Glasgow

CountryAverage life expectancy, years Monaco89.7 Singapore83.8 Switzerland81.2 Denmark78.8 USA78.5 Sri Lanka75.9 Jamaica73.4 India67.1 Kenya63.1 Botswana55.7 Zambia52.6 Swaziland49.4 Republic of South Africa 49.4 Note: In Africa, averages are lowered by childhood deaths and by HIV/AIDS Data from CIA World Fact Book

THE DOWNSIDE Frequencies of dementia in the UK, 2012 Age 40–64 1 in 1400 Age in 100 Age in 25 Over 80 1 in 6

HEART LUNGSBRAIN It used to be easy: when the heart had stopped beating and breathing had ceased, the person had died. Since 1976 in the UK, cessation of brain stem function has also been taken as an indication of death. However, with our increased understanding of the relationship between heart, lung and brain function and our technological ability to provide replacements for at least some of those functions, defining death has become more difficult and this has led in turn to cases in which deciding about continuing or stopping treatment is very problematic.

Dúirt mé leat go raibh mé breoite Spike Milligan

THE ISSUES Voluntary euthanasia Involuntary euthanasia Assisted suicide Withdrawing or withholding treatment

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS Can euthanasia ever be justified? Can killing ever be caring? When should medical treatment be withdrawn or withheld? Is there a difference between killing a person and letting them die? Is there a moral difference between euthanasia and assisted suicide?

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS Why shouldn’t I decide when I want to die? Isn’t it my right to make decisions about my own life?

IMPORTANT QUESTIONS What about the doctor’s part in all this? How does euthanasia / assisted suicide relate to the commandment ‘You shall not kill’? Is there a ‘Christian view’?

LEGAL EUTHANASIA Belgium Netherlands Luxembourg In Belgium and Netherlands, teenagers as young as 13-years old may opt for euthanasia

OTHER LEGAL ASPECTS Assisted suicide is legal in Switzerland, and in three US states But withdrawing or with-holding treatment, where further treatment is deemed ‘futile’, is legal in most countries. Some call this ‘passive euthanasia.’

MEDICAL ETHICS  Beneficence, Do good  Non-malificence Don’t do harm  Justice Treat people fairly  Autonomy Respect individual rights  What about wisdom and compassion?

HOW DO WE APPLY MEDICAL ETHICS? Compassion – ‘condemned to life’ (does beneficence exclude ‘mercy killing’?) Autonomy – it’s my life Openness – it happens anyway But... Is ending someone’s life the only way to show compassion? Does my exercise of autonomy affect other people?

A SLIPPERY SLOPE? What ‘form’ might a slippery slope take in this instance?

Coming out in March Publisher: Lion A bargain at £9.99! Chapter 7 is entitled Medical Technology: from Gamete to Grave