doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide TGac Editors Report Date: Authors:

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 2 Abstract This document summarises editorial activities on the TGac Draft since the last meeting Status of the draft Status of the comments This document is cumulative, newer data at the front – i.e., it will be revised per meeting to show updated status.

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 (San Antonio) November 2012 Slide 3 Robert Stacey, Apple

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Draft status LB190 (D4.0) closed 1 November votes: –242 yes (94.2%) –15 no (+2 without comments) –14 abstain Motion passes We received 400 comments Ad-hoc meeting held in the Bay Area, 8 November Developed resolutions for 66 comments November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 4 LB188 (D3.0): 273 votes: -233 yes (90.7%) -24 no (+2 without comments) -14 abstain

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Comment database snapshot Duplicate of CIDDraftCID All state1state UnresolvedOtherGrand Total UnassignedAssignedTotalResolvedApprovedDuplicateTotal LBOwning Ad-hocComment GroupCount EDITOR(Blank) Total MAC(Blank) 110 MAC Total MU(Blank) 23 MU Total PHY(Blank) 51 PHY Total Total Grand Total November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 5

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Assignees Duplicate of CIDResn StatusMotion Number (Blank) Owning Ad-hoc MACMUPHYGrand Total AssigneeCount of CID Adrian33 Allan Zhu66 Andrew Myles/Dan Harkins44 Brian ChaoChun11 Eldad11 Eric Wong10 Jae Seung77 Mark11 Matt15 Menzo16 Nihar13 Nihar/Joonsuk10 Osama22 Reza10 Robert11 Vinko11 Youhan11 Yusuke14 Grand Total November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 6

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission July 2012 (San Diego) November 2012 Slide 7 Robert Stacey, Apple

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Draft status At the May session, the WG approved a 20 day LB: –Should P802.11ac D3.0 be forwarded to sponsor ballot? LB188 closed 25 June votes: –233 yes (90.7%) –24 no (+2 without comments) –14 abstain Motion passes We received 855 comments November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 8 LB187: 271 votes: -223 yes (88.8%) -28 no -19 abstain

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Comment break down 855 comments: –261 editorial –18 general –576 technical The general and technical have been assigned to ad- hocs November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 9

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Status following July ad-hoc November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 10 See 12/752r5 (LB188 comments TGac D3.0) Duplicate of CIDDraftCID All state1state UnresolvedOtherGrand Total UnassignedAssignedAd-hoc NotesTotalResolvedApprovedDuplicateTotal LBOwning Ad-hocComment GroupCount COEX(Blank) 12 COEX Total EDITOR(Blank) 1 11 Editorial Total GEN(Blank) 4 44 GEN Total MAC(Blank) MAC MAC Total MU(Blank) MU Total PHY(Blank) _f2f_SP_passed _f2f_SP_passed 12 Total Total Grand Total

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Comment assignment (unresolved comments) Duplicate of CIDResn StatusMotion Number (Blank) Owning Ad-hoc COEXGENMACMUPHYGrand Total AssigneeCount of CID Adrian44 Adrian Stephens145 Allan Zhu, Liwen Chu32 Bo Sun12 Brain Hart, Kaz11 Brian Hart ChaoChun77 Dan Harkins, Brian Hart22 Eldad Perahia20 Eric Wong35 James Wang88 Kaiying66 Liwen Chu9110 Mark Rison167 Matt Fischer112 Minho28 Nihar11718 Osama257 Reza Robert Stacey18 Sandhya99 Sandyha11 Simone Merlin26816 Vinko Erceg32 Vish22123 Yong Liu13738 Yongho Seok37 Youhan66 Youhan Kim66 Yusuke Asai13 Grand Total November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 11

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission May 2012 (Atlanta) No report November 2012 Slide 12 Robert Stacey, Apple

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission March 2012 (Hawaii) November 2012 Slide 13 Robert Stacey, Apple

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Draft status At the January session, the WG approved a 30 day LB: –Should P802.11ac D2.0 be forwarded to sponsor ballot? LB187 closed 18 February votes: –223 yes (88.8%) –28 no –19 abstain Motion passes We received 1492 comments November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 14

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Initial comment break down 1492 comments: –655 editorial –59 general –778 technical The general and technical have been assigned to ad- hocs Some editorial comments have since been reclassified technical and assigned to ad-hocs November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 15

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Status following March 7-9 ad-hoc November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 16 Duplicate of CIDDraftCID All state1state UnresolvedOtherGrand Total UnassignedAssignedAd-hoc NotesTotalResolvedDuplicateTotal LBOwning Ad-hocComment GroupCount 187COEX(Blank) COEX_2012_03_09_adhoc 4 44 COEX_2012_03_10_adhoc 3 33 Total EDITOR(Blank) Editorial Total GEN(Blank) 1 11 PICS 22 Total23 MAC(Blank) MAC_2012_03_08_adhoc 90 MAC_2012_03_09_adhoc 55 MIB Total MU(Blank) MU Total PHY(Blank) PHY_ _adhoc_SP_passed 72 PHY_ _adhoc_SP_passed 19 Total Total Grand Total Corresponds to 12/223r7 (LB187 comment TGac D2.0)

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 17 January 2012 (Jacksonville)

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Draft status At November session, the TG instructed the editor to produce a D2.0 for ballot based on resolved comments and a few motions (y/n/a=59/1/4=98.3%) However, the WG motion to take the draft to ballot failed (y/n/a=33/12/9=73.3%) As a result, D1.4 (instead of D2.0) was released following the November session D1.4 is effectively the draft motioned by the TG for D2.0 at the November session November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 18

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Expectation for D2.0 D2.0 = D1.4 plus the following –Incorporate revised resolution for CID 3398 in 11/1566r1 (Antenna Indication in VHT Capabilities Info) Editor missed this when preparing D1.4 –Any additional changes approved this session November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 19

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 20 November 2011 (Atlanta)

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Database status LB All state UnassignedAssignedResolvedApprovedEditorial UnresolvedDuplicateEditorial ApprovedEditorial ResolvedGrand Total Owning Ad-hocCount COEX 45 9 EDITOR MAC MU PHY Grand Total November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 21

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Comment status Comments resolved since the September session: 260 Unresolved comments: –GEN: 0 –COEX: 4 –MU:3 –PHY: 18 –MAC: 59 See 11/1430r2 LB178 D1.0 comments for motion November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 22

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Process for motioning resolutions Change from what we did last time A single document, 11/1430 LB178 D1.0 comments for motion, will contain resolutions ready for motion 11/1430r2 reflects resolutions through end of ad-hoc last week Tabs in the spreadsheet list comments awaiting motion Tabs labeled with ad-hoc name (GEN, MU, COEX, MAC, PHY) and the date the resolution was strawpolled November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 23

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Draft status D1.2 was released 7 October 2011 –Reflects resolutions that passed motion during the September 2011 session D1.3 is available in the members area –Reflects resolutions that passed strawpoll during the telecons since September and a few resolutions from November ad-hoc at Cisco –See spreadsheet in 11/1430r2: Look for non-blank Edit status –I = implemented, N = not implemented Also, look at Edited in draft column –Indicates draft revision where change was made November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 24

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 25 Sept 2011 (Okinawa)

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Current Database Status November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 26 LB All state UnassignedAssignedResolvedApprovedEditorial UnresolvedDuplicateEditorial ApprovedEditorial ResolvedGrand Total Owning Ad-hocCount COEX EDITOR GEN MAC MU PHY Grand Total

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Resolved Comments At the ad-hoc in Seoul we resolved: –4 GEN comments see 11/1236, GEN AD-HOC tab –76 MAC comments see 11/1132, MAC ADHOC and MAC ADHOC tabs –23 MU comments See 11/1245, MU-Seoul tab –10 COEX comments See 11/yyyy, Coex for Motion tab –40 PHY comments See 11/yyyy, PHY_09_14_11 and PHY_09_15_11 tabs These will be motioned this week November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 27

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved: GEN 28 Security (GCMP) 18 PICS 2 Misc November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 28

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved MAC (assignees) Matt: 21 Hongyuan: 28 Illsoo: 16 Peter Loc: 13 Osama: 12 Jae Seung: 14 Chao-Chun: 10 Reza: 6 Liwen: 6 Mark Rison: 3 Simone: 4 Robert: 4 Tianyu: 2 Minho: 2 David Yang: 1 Kaiying: 1 Yongho: 1 Yong Liu: 1 Unassigned: 7 November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 29

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved PHY (assignees) Minho: 65 Sean: 30 Vinko: 24 Roy: 19 Youhan: 3 Brian: 8 Mark Rison: 6 Raja: 5 Reza: 5 Yongho: 5 Illsoo: 3 Peter Loc: 2 November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 30

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved MU (assignees) Yong Liu: 18 Illsoo: 14 Brian: 11 Joonsuk: 7 David Yang: 5 Wei Shi: 3 Robert: 2 Osama: 1 November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 31

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved COEX (assignees) Yongho: 8 Peter Loc: 5 Jae Seung: 5 Brian: 2 November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 32

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 33 Sept 2011 Ad-hoc (Seoul)

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Current Database Status LB All state UnassignedAssignedResolvedApprovedEditorial UnresolvedDuplicateEditorial ApprovedEditorial ResolvedGrand Total Owning Ad-hocCount COEX EDITOR GEN MAC MU PHY Grand Total November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 34

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Resolved Comments At the July meeting we adopted resolutions to 237 comments The editor has resolved a further 587 editorial comments The motioned and resolved editorial comments are captured in D1.1 On the subsequent teleconferences, we have resolved a further –31 MAC, 11 PHY, 1 COEX November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 35

doc.: IEEE /1184r7 Submission Unresolved Comments EDITOR –42 comments GEN –28 comments on GCMP restriction (unassigned, TG discussion) –17 comments on PICS assigned to Osama –7 others assigned MAC –240 comments (7 unassigned) PHY –227 comments (2 unassigned) MU –91 comments COEX –31 comments November 2012 Robert Stacey, AppleSlide 36