America’s History Seventh Edition

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The New Deal. Restoring the Nation’s Hope “The only thing to fear is fear itself” “The only thing to fear is fear itself” The First Hundred Days The First.
Advertisements

Objectives Learn how Franklin Roosevelt won the presidential election.
Early New Deal Policies Terms and People Franklin D. Roosevelt – American President elected at the height of the Great Depression Eleanor Roosevelt.
Chapter 37 The Great Depression and the New Deal
Managing the Great Depression, Forging the New Deal, 1929‒1939
Chapter 9: New Deal Section 1: FDR Offers Relief & Recovery (Part 2)
15.1 – A New Deal Fights the Depression. A New President 1932: Franklin D. Roosevelt (Democrat) beats Hoover – Overwhelming victory Election = proof of.
Promised to give each American family 5,000, taxing the rich Dust Bowl Radio programs FDR used to explain his plan to Americans Hoovervilles Civilian Conservation.
Roosevelt’s New Deals: Relief from the Great Depression Copy the words in RED.
The New Deal FDR’s Fireside Chats.
The New Deal President Roosevelt Had the greatest impact on American life & politics than any other U.S. President. Elected to an unprecedented.
The Cold War BeginsFDR Offers Relief and Recovery Section 1 Analyze the impact Franklin D. Roosevelt had on the American people after becoming President.
Restoring Confidence What is significant about Roosevelt’s first 100 days in office?
Bringing Back the Economy. * New York State Senator * Assistant Secretary of the Navy * 1920 ran as the Vice Presidential Candidate * Caught Polio in.
A New Deal Fights the Depression. I. Americans get a New Deal A. New Deal A. New Deal 1. Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) proposed the New Deal. 1. Franklin.
FDR and The New Deal Unit 4 Part 3.
ROOSEVELT AND THE NEW DEAL
The New Deal New Deal – Franklin Roosevelt’s plan to fix the depression. Consisted of a group of programs that would provide direct relief to the people.
 United States History.  Political Career o NY Senate, Assistant Sec of Navy under Wilson, NY Gov.  Personal Life o Battle with polio o Wife Eleanor.
American History Chapter 16: The New Deal
The New Deal Chapter 16, section 1
The New Deal. Background 1929-Stock Market Crash Unemployment skyrocketing Bank failures, businesses close Rising poverty Hoover’s actions ineffective.
The Great Depression The 1930’s The Crash Black Tuesday Boom market>increased speculation>great sell-off Oct ‘29 America enters the Great Depression.
Chapter 16 Section 1.  What led to the Stock market crash of 1929?  Who was the president at the time?  Did he do anything to help American citizens.
APUSH Review: The New Deal Everything You Need To Know For Your APUSH Exam.
Roosevelt’s Inauguration President Roosevelt.
The Great Depression The New Deal. Federal Emergency Relief Administration 1933 Sent millions of dollars to states to use in direct relief payments and.
The New Deal and its Legacy
Relief, Recovery, Reform.  Franklin D. Roosevelt (D) vs. Herbert Hoover ®  FDR wins  promised a New Deal  aided by experts – “Brain Trust”  20 th.
ELECTING FRANKLIN DELANO ROOSEVELT –Wins 1932 Presidential Election (Democrat) –Democrats control Congress (majority in Senate and House) –Defeated.
By Sharon Gorman and Anna Karpiej-Szczepanski.  President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal programs stimulate the economy and the arts.  The New Deal.
The Great Depression & the New Deal Part II. The Hundred Days FDR’s New Deal had three goals: FDR’s New Deal had three goals: Provide relief for the needy.
ALPHABET SOUP FDR AND THE NEW DEAL. “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people”
Chapter 15 Vocab The New Deal. Roosevelt’s policies for ending the Great Depression.
Lesson 3 New Deal and Second New Deal Unit 3 the Period Between the Wars.
The New Deal.  New Deal = Relief, Recovery, and Reform programs  1 st Hundred Days – FDR pushed programs through to provide relief, create jobs, & stimulate.
Chapter 23 – Section 2 Roosevelt and the New Deal
CH. 23.1: A New Deal Fights the Depression OBJECTIVES: 1. Summarize some of the steps Roosevelt took early in his presidency to reform banking and finance.
First New Deal.
Chapter 33 The New Deal and Its Legacy
FDR AND THE NEW DEAL New Deal Election of 1932 New President New Ideas.
The New Deal CCC CWA WPA TVA NRA AAA. The Election of 1932 Presidential elections are held in November Inauguration was in March 20 th Amendment – Ratified.
When FDR became president be promised decisive gov’t action to fight the depression FDR believed the gov’t should use deficit spending (spending that.
Ch. 33 Great Depression and The New Deal. Election of 1932; FDR v. Hoover; General Rhetoric?; Father Charles Coughlin; Huey Long (Share Our Wealth.
The New Deal Chapter 16, section Election - Turning Point The choice of FDR over Hoover was an American choice for the federal government to provide.
The Depression and The New Deal. Causes of the Depression Stock Market Crash Uneven Distribution of Wealth Overproduction in industry and agriculture.
The New Deal. What is the New Deal? President FDR’s policies designed to end the depression.
The New Deal How does FDR try to end the Depression while expanding the Federal Gov’t?
CONCLUSION: NEW DEAL 1. Compare and contrast the first and second New Deals and evaluate the success and failures 2. How effective was the New Deal in.
The New Deal SWBAT: Explain the government response to the Great Depression.
 Most Americans disillusioned by President Hoover’s reluctance to do much about Depression.  Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) elected with promise to.
Political Response to Great Depression From Hoover’s inaction to Roosevelt’s New Deal.
A New Deal Fights the Depression Chapter 15, Section 1 Based on the textbook The Americans, 2006.
NOTES: FDR AND THE NEW DEAL. How to Deal with the Depression  First, trickle down economics  Help the businesses and they will in turn hire more people.
Chapter 15 A New Deal Fights the Depression. Americans Get a New Deal Electing Franklin Delano Roosevelt --Franklin Delano Roosevelt Waiting For Roosevelt.
The New Deal FDR supported “bold, persistent experimentation” FDR supported “bold, persistent experimentation” Addressed 3 R’s (Reform, Recovery, Relief)
America’s History Sixth Edition
A New Deal Fights the Depression
Section 1 A New Deal Fights the Depression
A New Deal Fights the Depression
FDR and the New Deal.
Tens of thousands of businesses failed and unemployment rose to 25%
Inauguration of FDR, March 4, 1933
Who is the intended audience for this poster?
America’s History, Chapter 23
Unit 6 - Roosevelt Saves the Day
Managing the Great Depression, Forging the New Deal, 1929‒1939
Roosevelt and the New Deal
The 2nd New Deal………. The Welfare State Comes into Being
The New Deal, Chapter 23 – Sect. #1
Presentation transcript:

America’s History Seventh Edition James A. Henretta Rebecca Edwards Robert O. Self America’s History Seventh Edition CHAPTER 23 The Great Depression and the New Deal, 1929-1939 Copyright © 2011 by Bedford/St. Martin’s

1. Who is the intended audience for this poster? (Answer: girls and women who are unemployed and willing to work as domestic servants.) 2. What emotions did the illustrator hope to evoke with this depiction of a young woman drying a dish? (Answer: this young woman appears happy to have a job; the ad tells women that they will be paid, fed, and provided with good working conditions; this young woman appears to appreciate the opportunity the Illinois State Employment Service has provided.) 3. How is this poster representative of what President Roosevelt hoped to provide the nation with his New Deal programs? (Answer: while he may not have been able to provide immediate economic comfort and security to all Americans, he could improve the spirit of the people through work and other relief programs, which in turn had the potential for improving consumer confidence and getting the economy moving again.)

2. What emotions did the illustrator hope to evoke with this depiction of a young woman drying a dish? 1. Who is the intended audience for this poster? (Answer: girls and women who are unemployed and willing to work as domestic servants.) 2. What emotions did the illustrator hope to evoke with this depiction of a young woman drying a dish? (Answer: this young woman appears happy to have a job; the ad tells women that they will be paid, fed, and provided with good working conditions; this young woman appears to appreciate the opportunity the Illinois State Employment Service has provided.) 3. How is this poster representative of what President Roosevelt hoped to provide the nation with his New Deal programs? (Answer: while he may not have been able to provide immediate economic comfort and security to all Americans, he could improve the spirit of the people through work and other relief programs, which in turn had the potential for improving consumer confidence and getting the economy moving again.)

3. How is this poster representative of what President Roosevelt hoped to provide the nation with his New Deal programs? 1. Who is the intended audience for this poster? (Answer: girls and women who are unemployed and willing to work as domestic servants.) 2. What emotions did the illustrator hope to evoke with this depiction of a young woman drying a dish? (Answer: this young woman appears happy to have a job; the ad tells women that they will be paid, fed, and provided with good working conditions; this young woman appears to appreciate the opportunity the Illinois State Employment Service has provided.) 3. How is this poster representative of what President Roosevelt hoped to provide the nation with his New Deal programs? (Answer: while he may not have been able to provide immediate economic comfort and security to all Americans, he could improve the spirit of the people through work and other relief programs, which in turn had the potential for improving consumer confidence and getting the economy moving again.)

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Down and Out: Life in the Great Depression 1. Private Charity churches and synagogues were first to aid by winter 1931 they were overwhelmed by demand few states (8) had any kind of insurance for the unemployed no public support for the elderly, who had to rely on family. 2. Family Life Herbert Hoover Responds 1. American Traditions 2. Hoover’s Failures The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Down and Out: Life in the Great Depression Private Charity – churches and synagogues were first to aid; by winter 1931 they were overwhelmed by demand; few states (8) had any kind of insurance for the unemployed; no public support for the elderly, who had to rely on family. Family Life – delaying age of marriage, reduction in the number of pregnancies; three quarters of American school districts banned married women from working as teachers to give men job opportunities; nonetheless, female employment increased; unemployment rates worse among African American men and women. Herbert Hoover Responds American Traditions – Hoover followed two American traditions: 1) economic outcomes were the product of individual character; 2) through voluntary action business could regulate itself; encouraged Americans to remain confident; Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) cautiously provided federal loans to railroads, banks. Hoover’s Failures – reluctant to break with tradition of limited government; private charity could not handle massive amount of unemployment; perceived by Americans as insensitive even though he had done more than previous presidents in time of economic need.

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Down and Out: Life in the Great Depression 2. Family Life delaying age of marriage, reduction in the number of pregnancies three quarters of American school districts banned married women from working as teachers to give men job opportunities nonetheless, female employment increased unemployment rates worse among African American men and women. Herbert Hoover Responds 1. American Traditions 2. Hoover’s Failures The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Down and Out: Life in the Great Depression Private Charity – churches and synagogues were first to aid; by winter 1931 they were overwhelmed by demand; few states (8) had any kind of insurance for the unemployed; no public support for the elderly, who had to rely on family. Family Life – delaying age of marriage, reduction in the number of pregnancies; three quarters of American school districts banned married women from working as teachers to give men job opportunities; nonetheless, female employment increased; unemployment rates worse among African American men and women. Herbert Hoover Responds American Traditions – Hoover followed two American traditions: 1) economic outcomes were the product of individual character; 2) through voluntary action business could regulate itself; encouraged Americans to remain confident; Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) cautiously provided federal loans to railroads, banks. Hoover’s Failures – reluctant to break with tradition of limited government; private charity could not handle massive amount of unemployment; perceived by Americans as insensitive even though he had done more than previous presidents in time of economic need.

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Herbert Hoover Responds 1. American Traditions Hoover followed two American traditions: 1) economic outcomes were the product of individual character 2) through voluntary action business could regulate itself encouraged Americans to remain confident Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) cautiously provided federal loans to railroads, banks. 2. Hoover’s Failures reluctant to break with tradition of limited government; private charity could not handle massive amount of unemployment perceived by Americans as insensitive even though he had done more than previous presidents in time of economic need. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Down and Out: Life in the Great Depression Private Charity – churches and synagogues were first to aid; by winter 1931 they were overwhelmed by demand; few states (8) had any kind of insurance for the unemployed; no public support for the elderly, who had to rely on family. Family Life – delaying age of marriage, reduction in the number of pregnancies; three quarters of American school districts banned married women from working as teachers to give men job opportunities; nonetheless, female employment increased; unemployment rates worse among African American men and women. Herbert Hoover Responds American Traditions – Hoover followed two American traditions: 1) economic outcomes were the product of individual character; 2) through voluntary action business could regulate itself; encouraged Americans to remain confident; Reconstruction Finance Corporation (RFC) cautiously provided federal loans to railroads, banks. Hoover’s Failures – reluctant to break with tradition of limited government; private charity could not handle massive amount of unemployment; perceived by Americans as insensitive even though he had done more than previous presidents in time of economic need.

1. Examine the crowd greeting presidential candidate Franklin Roosevelt in West Virginia. In your opinion, why was Roosevelt photographed shaking the hand of a coal miner? 1. Examine the crowd greeting presidential candidate Franklin Roosevelt in West Virginia. In your opinion, why was Roosevelt photographed shaking the hand of a coal miner? (Answer: the image portrays FDR as connected with the working man, a critical visual for his campaign since his opponent, President Hoover, was perceived by many Americans to be out of touch with the working class.)

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Rising Discontent 1. Hoovervilles the public connected Hoover’s name to the shanty towns erected by the homeless in urban areas farmers sought to collectively resist the banks and sheriffs who tried to evict them creation of the Farm Holiday Association to cut off supplies to urban areas as a result of low prices violent labor confrontations at Ford’s River Rouge Plant and among coal miners in Kentucky. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Rising Discontent Hoovervilles – the public connected Hoover’s name to the shanty towns erected by the homeless in urban areas; farmers sought to collectively resist the banks and sheriffs who tried to evict them; creation of the Farm Holiday Association to cut off supplies to urban areas as a result of low prices; violent labor confrontations at Ford’s River Rouge Plant and among coal miners in Kentucky. The Bonus Army – summer 1932 15,000 unemployed World War I veterans traveled to Washington to demand their soldiers’ pension; camped near the Capitol building; Hoover called in the U.S. Army to evict them from the land; Hoover’s already weak popularity could not withstand public’s anger at the Army injuring veterans and burning their encampment. The 1932 Election Franklin D. Roosevelt – governor of New York, wealthy, served as assistant secretary of the navy during World War I, 1921 polio attack left him wheelchair-bound for life; easily defeated Hoover. The Worst Winter – FDR elected November, took office in March 1933; unemployment grew to 50% in Cleveland, 60% in Akron, 80% in Toledo; state governors began temporarily closing banks.

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Rising Discontent 2. The Bonus Army summer 1932 15,000 unemployed World War I veterans traveled to Washington to demand their soldiers’ pension camped near the Capitol building Hoover called in the U.S. Army to evict them from the land Hoover’s already weak popularity could not withstand public’s anger at the Army injuring veterans and burning their encampment. The 1932 Election 1. Franklin D. Roosevelt governor of New York, wealthy, served as assistant secretary of the navy during World War I, 1921 polio attack left him wheelchair-bound for life easily defeated Hoover. 2. The Worst Winter FDR elected November, took office in March 1933 unemployment grew to 50% in Cleveland, 60% in Akron, 80% in Toledo state governors began temporarily closing banks. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Rising Discontent Hoovervilles – the public connected Hoover’s name to the shanty towns erected by the homeless in urban areas; farmers sought to collectively resist the banks and sheriffs who tried to evict them; creation of the Farm Holiday Association to cut off supplies to urban areas as a result of low prices; violent labor confrontations at Ford’s River Rouge Plant and among coal miners in Kentucky. The Bonus Army – summer 1932 15,000 unemployed World War I veterans traveled to Washington to demand their soldiers’ pension; camped near the Capitol building; Hoover called in the U.S. Army to evict them from the land; Hoover’s already weak popularity could not withstand public’s anger at the Army injuring veterans and burning their encampment. The 1932 Election Franklin D. Roosevelt – governor of New York, wealthy, served as assistant secretary of the navy during World War I, 1921 polio attack left him wheelchair-bound for life; easily defeated Hoover. The Worst Winter – FDR elected November, took office in March 1933; unemployment grew to 50% in Cleveland, 60% in Akron, 80% in Toledo; state governors began temporarily closing banks.

I. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 The 1932 Election 1. Franklin D. Roosevelt governor of New York, wealthy, served as assistant secretary of the navy during World War I, 1921 polio attack left him wheelchair-bound for life easily defeated Hoover. 2. The Worst Winter FDR elected November, took office in March 1933 unemployment grew to 50% in Cleveland, 60% in Akron, 80% in Toledo state governors began temporarily closing banks. The Early Years of the Depression, 1929-1932 Rising Discontent Hoovervilles – the public connected Hoover’s name to the shanty towns erected by the homeless in urban areas; farmers sought to collectively resist the banks and sheriffs who tried to evict them; creation of the Farm Holiday Association to cut off supplies to urban areas as a result of low prices; violent labor confrontations at Ford’s River Rouge Plant and among coal miners in Kentucky. The Bonus Army – summer 1932 15,000 unemployed World War I veterans traveled to Washington to demand their soldiers’ pension; camped near the Capitol building; Hoover called in the U.S. Army to evict them from the land; Hoover’s already weak popularity could not withstand public’s anger at the Army injuring veterans and burning their encampment. The 1932 Election Franklin D. Roosevelt – governor of New York, wealthy, served as assistant secretary of the navy during World War I, 1921 polio attack left him wheelchair-bound for life; easily defeated Hoover. The Worst Winter – FDR elected November, took office in March 1933; unemployment grew to 50% in Cleveland, 60% in Akron, 80% in Toledo; state governors began temporarily closing banks.

II. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days 1. Banking Reform day after inauguration FDR declared a bank holiday to close all banks passed Emergency Banking Act calling for the Treasury Department to reopen banks that had enough reserves to operate in the first “fireside chat” FDR reassured Americans that the system would be stable created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to insure deposits up to $2,500 and prohibited banks from making risky investments removed U.S. Treasury from the gold standard, Federal Reserve then lowered interest rates. 2. Agriculture and Manufacturing 3. Unemployment Relief 4. Housing Crisis The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days Banking Reform – day after inauguration FDR declared a bank holiday to close all banks; passed Emergency Banking Act calling for the Treasury Department to reopen banks that had enough reserves to operate; in the first “fireside chat” FDR reassured Americans that the system would be stable; created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to insure deposits up to $2,500 and prohibited banks from making risky investments; removed U.S. Treasury from the gold standard, Federal Reserve then lowered interest rates. Agriculture and Manufacturing – Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA): direct governmental regulation of the farm economy, provided subsidies to farmers to cut production so that prices would rise (wheat, cotton, corn, hogs, rice, tobacco, dairy); money mostly helped those with large farms, not sharecroppers; National Industrial Recovery Act created the National Recovery Administration (NRA) to create self-governing private associations in 600 industries. Unemployment Relief – Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), led by Harry Hopkins; avoided direct payouts (a “dole”) and instead put people to work in the Public Works Administration (PWA), Civil Works Administration (CWA), Civilian Conservation Corp (CCC). Housing Crisis – Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) created to refinance mortgages; Housing Act of 1937 changed the mortgage system.

II. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days 2. Agriculture and Manufacturing Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA): direct governmental regulation of the farm economy, provided subsidies to farmers to cut production so that prices would rise (wheat, cotton, corn, hogs, rice, tobacco, dairy) money mostly helped those with large farms, not sharecroppers National Industrial Recovery Act created the National Recovery Administration (NRA) to create self-governing private associations in 600 industries. 3. Unemployment Relief 4. Housing Crisis The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days Banking Reform – day after inauguration FDR declared a bank holiday to close all banks; passed Emergency Banking Act calling for the Treasury Department to reopen banks that had enough reserves to operate; in the first “fireside chat” FDR reassured Americans that the system would be stable; created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to insure deposits up to $2,500 and prohibited banks from making risky investments; removed U.S. Treasury from the gold standard, Federal Reserve then lowered interest rates. Agriculture and Manufacturing – Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA): direct governmental regulation of the farm economy, provided subsidies to farmers to cut production so that prices would rise (wheat, cotton, corn, hogs, rice, tobacco, dairy); money mostly helped those with large farms, not sharecroppers; National Industrial Recovery Act created the National Recovery Administration (NRA) to create self-governing private associations in 600 industries. Unemployment Relief – Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), led by Harry Hopkins; avoided direct payouts (a “dole”) and instead put people to work in the Public Works Administration (PWA), Civil Works Administration (CWA), Civilian Conservation Corp (CCC). Housing Crisis – Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) created to refinance mortgages; Housing Act of 1937 changed the mortgage system.

II. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days 3. Unemployment Relief Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), led by Harry Hopkins avoided direct payouts (a “dole”) and instead put people to work in the Public Works Administration (PWA), Civil Works Administration (CWA), Civilian Conservation Corp (CCC). 4. Housing Crisis Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) created to refinance mortgages Housing Act of 1937 changed the mortgage system. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 Roosevelt and the First Hundred Days Banking Reform – day after inauguration FDR declared a bank holiday to close all banks; passed Emergency Banking Act calling for the Treasury Department to reopen banks that had enough reserves to operate; in the first “fireside chat” FDR reassured Americans that the system would be stable; created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to insure deposits up to $2,500 and prohibited banks from making risky investments; removed U.S. Treasury from the gold standard, Federal Reserve then lowered interest rates. Agriculture and Manufacturing – Agricultural Adjustment Act (AAA): direct governmental regulation of the farm economy, provided subsidies to farmers to cut production so that prices would rise (wheat, cotton, corn, hogs, rice, tobacco, dairy); money mostly helped those with large farms, not sharecroppers; National Industrial Recovery Act created the National Recovery Administration (NRA) to create self-governing private associations in 600 industries. Unemployment Relief – Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA), led by Harry Hopkins; avoided direct payouts (a “dole”) and instead put people to work in the Public Works Administration (PWA), Civil Works Administration (CWA), Civilian Conservation Corp (CCC). Housing Crisis – Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC) created to refinance mortgages; Housing Act of 1937 changed the mortgage system.

II. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 The New Deal under Attack 1. Critics on the Right Republicans created the “Liberty League” with conservative Democrats to fight the New Deal creation of National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) produced radio, pictures, billboards, and direct mailing to promote free enterprise 1935 Schechter v. U.S. ruled the NIRA unconstitutional because it gave legislative powers to the executive Supreme Court struck down AAA, Railroad Retirement Act, and debt relief efforts. 2. Critics on the Populist Left The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 B. The New Deal under Attack Critics on the Right – Republicans created the “Liberty League” with conservative Democrats to fight the New Deal; creation of National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) produced radio, pictures, billboards, and direct mailing to promote free enterprise; 1935 Schechter v. U.S. ruled the NIRA unconstitutional because it gave legislative powers to the executive; Supreme Court struck down AAA, Railroad Retirement Act, and debt relief efforts. Critics on the Populist Left – Dr. Francis Townsend argued for an Old Age Revolving Pension Plan (1933) of $200/month to people over 60 who did not work; Father Charles Coughlin, Detroit priest, organized the National Union for Social Justice and took his argument that the New Deal was not doing enough to the radio; Sen. Huey Long (D-LA) became critical of the New Deal in 1934, created the “Share Our Wealth Society” to argue for the equal distribution of wealth and a 100% tax on all income over $1 million. 15

II. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 The New Deal under Attack 2. Critics on the Populist Left Dr. Francis Townsend argued for an Old Age Revolving Pension Plan (1933) of $200/month to people over 60 who did not work Father Charles Coughlin, Detroit priest, organized the National Union for Social Justice and took his argument that the New Deal was not doing enough to the radio Sen. Huey Long (D-LA) became critical of the New Deal in 1934, created the “Share Our Wealth Society” to argue for the equal distribution of wealth and a 100% tax on all income over $1 million. The New Deal Arrives, 1933-1935 B. The New Deal under Attack Critics on the Right – Republicans created the “Liberty League” with conservative Democrats to fight the New Deal; creation of National Association of Manufacturers (NAM) produced radio, pictures, billboards, and direct mailing to promote free enterprise; 1935 Schechter v. U.S. ruled the NIRA unconstitutional because it gave legislative powers to the executive; Supreme Court struck down AAA, Railroad Retirement Act, and debt relief efforts. Critics on the Populist Left – Dr. Francis Townsend argued for an Old Age Revolving Pension Plan (1933) of $200/month to people over 60 who did not work; Father Charles Coughlin, Detroit priest, organized the National Union for Social Justice and took his argument that the New Deal was not doing enough to the radio; Sen. Huey Long (D-LA) became critical of the New Deal in 1934, created the “Share Our Wealth Society” to argue for the equal distribution of wealth and a 100% tax on all income over $1 million. 16

III. The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being 1. The Wagner Act and Social Security FDR moved left to combat critics NIRA, section 7a, gave workers the right to unionize voided by Supreme Court in 1935, new legislation proposed by Sen. Robert Wagner (D-NY) which upheld workers right to join unions outlawed industries’ ability to fire workers for organizing and suppress unions created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to protect workers and guarantee the right to collective bargaining Social Security Act (1935): old-age pension, federal-state system of compensation for the unemployed, payments to widowed mothers, blind, deaf, disabled. 2. New Deal Liberalism From Reform to Stalemate 1. 1936 Election 2. Court Battle and Economic Recession 3. Keynesian Economics The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being The Wagner Act and Social Security – FDR moved left to combat critics; NIRA, section 7a, gave workers the right to unionize; voided by Supreme Court in 1935, new legislation proposed by Sen. Robert Wagner (D-NY) which upheld workers right to join unions; outlawed industries’ ability to fire workers for organizing and suppress unions; created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to protect workers and guarantee the right to collective bargaining; Social Security Act (1935): old-age pension, federal-state system of compensation for the unemployed, payments to widowed mothers, blind, deaf, disabled. New Deal Liberalism – to preserve individual liberty, government must assist the needy and guarantee the peoples’ basic welfare. From Reform to Stalemate 1936 Election – Works Progress Administration (WPA) put 8.5 million people to work on construction/repair of roads, bridges, public buildings, parks, airports; new voters were energized by the Democratic Party under FDR; the party was able to attract voters from the North, the Midwest, organized labor, white ethnic groups, northern blacks, middle class, and many southerners. Court Battle and Economic Recession – FDR asked for changes to the Supreme Court; wanted to add a new member for every Court member over age 70; fears that the president wanted to “pack” the court with supporters; effort failed, though FDR did get to make appointments with subsequent retirements; “Roosevelt Recession”: 1937-1938, FDR increased spending to get out of the recession. Keynesian Economics – John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates.

III. The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being 2. New Deal Liberalism to preserve individual liberty, government must assist the needy and guarantee the peoples’ basic welfare. From Reform to Stalemate 1. 1936 Election Works Progress Administration (WPA) put 8.5 million people to work on construction/repair of roads, bridges, public buildings, parks, airports new voters were energized by the Democratic Party under FDR; the party was able to attract voters from the North, the Midwest, organized labor, white ethnic groups, northern blacks, middle class, and many southerners. 2. Court Battle and Economic Recession 3. Keynesian Economics The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being The Wagner Act and Social Security – FDR moved left to combat critics; NIRA, section 7a, gave workers the right to unionize; voided by Supreme Court in 1935, new legislation proposed by Sen. Robert Wagner (D-NY) which upheld workers right to join unions; outlawed industries’ ability to fire workers for organizing and suppress unions; created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to protect workers and guarantee the right to collective bargaining; Social Security Act (1935): old-age pension, federal-state system of compensation for the unemployed, payments to widowed mothers, blind, deaf, disabled. New Deal Liberalism – to preserve individual liberty, government must assist the needy and guarantee the peoples’ basic welfare. From Reform to Stalemate 1936 Election – Works Progress Administration (WPA) put 8.5 million people to work on construction/repair of roads, bridges, public buildings, parks, airports; new voters were energized by the Democratic Party under FDR; the party was able to attract voters from the North, the Midwest, organized labor, white ethnic groups, northern blacks, middle class, and many southerners. Court Battle and Economic Recession – FDR asked for changes to the Supreme Court; wanted to add a new member for every Court member over age 70; fears that the president wanted to “pack” the court with supporters; effort failed, though FDR did get to make appointments with subsequent retirements; “Roosevelt Recession”: 1937-1938, FDR increased spending to get out of the recession. Keynesian Economics – John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates.

III. The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 From Reform to Stalemate 2. Court Battle and Economic Recession FDR asked for changes to the Supreme Court wanted to add a new member for every Court member over age 70 fears that the president wanted to “pack” the court with supporters effort failed, though FDR did get to make appointments with subsequent retirements “Roosevelt Recession”: 1937-1938, FDR increased spending to get out of the recession. Keynesian Economics – John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates. 3. Keynesian Economics The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being The Wagner Act and Social Security – FDR moved left to combat critics; NIRA, section 7a, gave workers the right to unionize; voided by Supreme Court in 1935, new legislation proposed by Sen. Robert Wagner (D-NY) which upheld workers right to join unions; outlawed industries’ ability to fire workers for organizing and suppress unions; created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to protect workers and guarantee the right to collective bargaining; Social Security Act (1935): old-age pension, federal-state system of compensation for the unemployed, payments to widowed mothers, blind, deaf, disabled. New Deal Liberalism – to preserve individual liberty, government must assist the needy and guarantee the peoples’ basic welfare. From Reform to Stalemate 1936 Election – Works Progress Administration (WPA) put 8.5 million people to work on construction/repair of roads, bridges, public buildings, parks, airports; new voters were energized by the Democratic Party under FDR; the party was able to attract voters from the North, the Midwest, organized labor, white ethnic groups, northern blacks, middle class, and many southerners. Court Battle and Economic Recession – FDR asked for changes to the Supreme Court; wanted to add a new member for every Court member over age 70; fears that the president wanted to “pack” the court with supporters; effort failed, though FDR did get to make appointments with subsequent retirements; “Roosevelt Recession”: 1937-1938, FDR increased spending to get out of the recession. Keynesian Economics – John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates.

III. The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 From Reform to Stalemate 3. Keynesian Economics John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates. The Second New Deal and the Redefining of Liberalism, 1935-1938 The Welfare State Comes into Being The Wagner Act and Social Security – FDR moved left to combat critics; NIRA, section 7a, gave workers the right to unionize; voided by Supreme Court in 1935, new legislation proposed by Sen. Robert Wagner (D-NY) which upheld workers right to join unions; outlawed industries’ ability to fire workers for organizing and suppress unions; created the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) to protect workers and guarantee the right to collective bargaining; Social Security Act (1935): old-age pension, federal-state system of compensation for the unemployed, payments to widowed mothers, blind, deaf, disabled. New Deal Liberalism – to preserve individual liberty, government must assist the needy and guarantee the peoples’ basic welfare. From Reform to Stalemate 1936 Election – Works Progress Administration (WPA) put 8.5 million people to work on construction/repair of roads, bridges, public buildings, parks, airports; new voters were energized by the Democratic Party under FDR; the party was able to attract voters from the North, the Midwest, organized labor, white ethnic groups, northern blacks, middle class, and many southerners. Court Battle and Economic Recession – FDR asked for changes to the Supreme Court; wanted to add a new member for every Court member over age 70; fears that the president wanted to “pack” the court with supporters; effort failed, though FDR did get to make appointments with subsequent retirements; “Roosevelt Recession”: 1937-1938, FDR increased spending to get out of the recession. Keynesian Economics – John Maynard Keynes, British economist, argued that government intervention could aid the business cycle through deficit spending and manipulating interest rates.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy 1. Organized Labor increased numbers and political power; Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) brought together all workers in an industry. 2. Women and the New Deal generally enhanced women’s welfare but not directly Frances Perkins, first woman named to a cabinet post (Labor) Eleanor Roosevelt had high profile position in the White House as the “conscience of the New Deal.” 3. African Americans under the New Deal 4. Indian Policy 5. Struggles in the West The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy Organized Labor – increased numbers and political power; Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) brought together all workers in an industry. Women and the New Deal – generally enhanced women’s welfare but not directly; Frances Perkins, first woman named to a cabinet post (Labor); Eleanor Roosevelt had high profile position in the White House as the “conscience of the New Deal.” African Americans under the New Deal – FDR was extremely popular among African Americans, but did little to aid them directly; CCC camps were segregated, Social Security and the Wagner Act excluded domestic and agricultural workers; no federal anti-lynching law; Scottsboro Boys case revealed how unfair the southern justice system was to African Americans; southern Democrats controlled the states where most blacks lived. Indian Policy – John Collier, head of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), pushed through the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 (“Indian New Deal”): reversed the Dawes Act, gave Indians increased religious freedom and more power to tribal governments; government still financially controlled reservations. Struggles in the West – government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens; others left voluntarily; in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds; discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn; many were ineligible for citizenship and aid.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy 3. African Americans under the New Deal FDR was extremely popular among African Americans, but did little to aid them directly CCC camps were segregated, Social Security and the Wagner Act excluded domestic and agricultural workers no federal anti-lynching law Scottsboro Boys case revealed how unfair the southern justice system was to African Americans southern Democrats controlled the states where most blacks lived. 4. Indian Policy 5. Struggles in the West The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy Organized Labor – increased numbers and political power; Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) brought together all workers in an industry. Women and the New Deal – generally enhanced women’s welfare but not directly; Frances Perkins, first woman named to a cabinet post (Labor); Eleanor Roosevelt had high profile position in the White House as the “conscience of the New Deal.” African Americans under the New Deal – FDR was extremely popular among African Americans, but did little to aid them directly; CCC camps were segregated, Social Security and the Wagner Act excluded domestic and agricultural workers; no federal anti-lynching law; Scottsboro Boys case revealed how unfair the southern justice system was to African Americans; southern Democrats controlled the states where most blacks lived. Indian Policy – John Collier, head of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), pushed through the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 (“Indian New Deal”): reversed the Dawes Act, gave Indians increased religious freedom and more power to tribal governments; government still financially controlled reservations. Struggles in the West – government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens; others left voluntarily; in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds; discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn; many were ineligible for citizenship and aid.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy 4. Indian Policy John Collier, head of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), pushed through the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 (“Indian New Deal”): reversed the Dawes Act, gave Indians increased religious freedom and more power to tribal governments government still financially controlled reservations. 5. Struggles in the West government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens others left voluntarily in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn many were ineligible for citizenship and aid. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy Organized Labor – increased numbers and political power; Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) brought together all workers in an industry. Women and the New Deal – generally enhanced women’s welfare but not directly; Frances Perkins, first woman named to a cabinet post (Labor); Eleanor Roosevelt had high profile position in the White House as the “conscience of the New Deal.” African Americans under the New Deal – FDR was extremely popular among African Americans, but did little to aid them directly; CCC camps were segregated, Social Security and the Wagner Act excluded domestic and agricultural workers; no federal anti-lynching law; Scottsboro Boys case revealed how unfair the southern justice system was to African Americans; southern Democrats controlled the states where most blacks lived. Indian Policy – John Collier, head of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), pushed through the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 (“Indian New Deal”): reversed the Dawes Act, gave Indians increased religious freedom and more power to tribal governments; government still financially controlled reservations. Struggles in the West – government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens; others left voluntarily; in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds; discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn; many were ineligible for citizenship and aid.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy 5. Struggles in the West government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens others left voluntarily in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn many were ineligible for citizenship and aid. The New Deal’s Impact on Society A People’s Democracy Organized Labor – increased numbers and political power; Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) brought together all workers in an industry. Women and the New Deal – generally enhanced women’s welfare but not directly; Frances Perkins, first woman named to a cabinet post (Labor); Eleanor Roosevelt had high profile position in the White House as the “conscience of the New Deal.” African Americans under the New Deal – FDR was extremely popular among African Americans, but did little to aid them directly; CCC camps were segregated, Social Security and the Wagner Act excluded domestic and agricultural workers; no federal anti-lynching law; Scottsboro Boys case revealed how unfair the southern justice system was to African Americans; southern Democrats controlled the states where most blacks lived. Indian Policy – John Collier, head of the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), pushed through the Indian Reorganization Act of 1934 (“Indian New Deal”): reversed the Dawes Act, gave Indians increased religious freedom and more power to tribal governments; government still financially controlled reservations. Struggles in the West – government promoted “repatriation “ of Mexicans (deportation), about 60% of those deported were U.S. citizens; others left voluntarily; in California Mexican American Movement (MAM) organized with help from New Deal funds; discrimination against Asians and Asian Americans worsened with economic downturn; many were ineligible for citizenship and aid.

1. According to these farm workers, what has the state of California done to alleviate their suffering during the Great Depression? 1. According to these farm workers, what has the state of California done to alleviate their suffering during the Great Depression? (Answer: signage indicates that the governor has sent sheriffs and patrolmen but no direct aid, food to the people.) 2. What unique challenges did farm workers, such as the men and women photographed here, face during the Great Depression? (Answer: some were not American citizens – government aid was not available to non-citizens, faced deportation; migrant nature of farm work made it difficult for these workers to organize the way that faculty workers could in urban areas.)

2. What unique challenges did farm workers, such as the men and women photographed here, face during the Great Depression? 1. According to these farm workers, what has the state of California done to alleviate their suffering during the Great Depression? (Answer: signage indicates that the governor has sent sheriffs and patrolmen but no direct aid, food to the people.) 2. What unique challenges did farm workers, such as the men and women photographed here, face during the Great Depression? (Answer: some were not American citizens – government aid was not available to non-citizens, faced deportation; migrant nature of farm work made it difficult for these workers to organize the way that faculty workers could in urban areas.)

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment 1. Dust Bowl 1930-1941 severe drought on the Great Plains approx. 350,000 “Okies” sought to leave the region for California Soil Conservation Service tried to work with farmers to prevent future soil erosion, stop producing certain crops and plant grasses. 2. Tennessee Valley Authority 3. Grand Coulee The New Deal and the Arts 1. The Federal Art Project 2. “Documentary Impulse” The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment Dust Bowl – 1930-1941 severe drought on the Great Plains; approx. 350,000 “Okies” sought to leave the region for California; Soil Conservation Service tried to work with farmers to prevent future soil erosion, stop producing certain crops and plant grasses. Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) – begun 1933, flood control, reforestation, electricity generation, agricultural and industrial development, dams; Rural Electrification Administration (REA) helped bring electricity to the region with loans to farmers. Grand Coulee – building of the Grand Coulee Dam on the Columbia River in Washington State; largest electricity producing structure in the world. The New Deal and the Arts The Federal Art Project – “Art for the Millions”; provided work for artists; Jackson Pollack, Alice Neel, Willem de Kooning among others; Federal Music Project and Writers’ Project further employed musicians and writers; Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God and Richard Wright’s Native Son both supported by these programs. “Documentary Impulse” – a focus by artists on actual events relevant to peoples’ lives; examples included John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath and John Dos Passos’s USA trilogy.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment 2. Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) begun 1933, flood control, reforestation, electricity generation, agricultural and industrial development, dams Rural Electrification Administration (REA) helped bring electricity to the region with loans to farmers. 3. Grand Coulee The New Deal and the Arts 1. The Federal Art Project 2. “Documentary Impulse” The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment Dust Bowl – 1930-1941 severe drought on the Great Plains; approx. 350,000 “Okies” sought to leave the region for California; Soil Conservation Service tried to work with farmers to prevent future soil erosion, stop producing certain crops and plant grasses. Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) – begun 1933, flood control, reforestation, electricity generation, agricultural and industrial development, dams; Rural Electrification Administration (REA) helped bring electricity to the region with loans to farmers. Grand Coulee – building of the Grand Coulee Dam on the Columbia River in Washington State; largest electricity producing structure in the world. The New Deal and the Arts The Federal Art Project – “Art for the Millions”; provided work for artists; Jackson Pollack, Alice Neel, Willem de Kooning among others; Federal Music Project and Writers’ Project further employed musicians and writers; Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God and Richard Wright’s Native Son both supported by these programs. “Documentary Impulse” – a focus by artists on actual events relevant to peoples’ lives; examples included John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath and John Dos Passos’s USA trilogy.

IV. The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment 3. Grand Coulee building of the Grand Coulee Dam on the Columbia River in Washington State largest electricity producing structure in the world. The New Deal and the Arts 1. The Federal Art Project “Art for the Millions” provided work for artists Jackson Pollack, Alice Neel, Willem de Kooning among others Federal Music Project and Writers’ Project further employed musicians and writers Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God and Richard Wright’s Native Son both supported by these programs. 2. “Documentary Impulse” The New Deal’s Impact on Society Reshaping the Environment Dust Bowl – 1930-1941 severe drought on the Great Plains; approx. 350,000 “Okies” sought to leave the region for California; Soil Conservation Service tried to work with farmers to prevent future soil erosion, stop producing certain crops and plant grasses. Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) – begun 1933, flood control, reforestation, electricity generation, agricultural and industrial development, dams; Rural Electrification Administration (REA) helped bring electricity to the region with loans to farmers. Grand Coulee – building of the Grand Coulee Dam on the Columbia River in Washington State; largest electricity producing structure in the world. The New Deal and the Arts The Federal Art Project – “Art for the Millions”; provided work for artists; Jackson Pollack, Alice Neel, Willem de Kooning among others; Federal Music Project and Writers’ Project further employed musicians and writers; Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God and Richard Wright’s Native Son both supported by these programs. “Documentary Impulse” – a focus by artists on actual events relevant to peoples’ lives; examples included John Steinbeck’s The Grapes of Wrath and John Dos Passos’s USA trilogy.

1. Examine these two photographs by Dorothea Lange 1. Examine these two photographs by Dorothea Lange. What did Lange hope to convey to her audience about life in California during the Great Depression through these images? 1. Examine these two photographs by Dorothea Lange. What did Lange hope to convey to her audience about life in California during the Great Depression through these images? (Answer: both images attest to the sheer sense of loss and disillusion Americans felt during this period. Drought refugees – all of their possessions loaded on a truck and likely no place to go; the mother sits with an infant on the side of a dirt road. “Migrant Mother” – the desperation in this woman’s eyes as her children lean against her shoulders, shielding their eyes.)

1. How is the Grand Coulee Dam representative of New Deal programs? (Answer: as tangible evidence of the work done by Americans in the Roosevelt administration’s Public Works Administration; the dam, like the New Deal, didn’t end the Great Depression, but the construction of the structure served multiple purposes: put men to work, harnessed water power for the betterment of local communities, and improved the Depression-era morale of the men paid to do the work who were previously unemployed.)

1. Examine Shahn’s work, The Promise of the New Deal 1. Examine Shahn’s work, The Promise of the New Deal. What is the central action of this third panel of the three-part mural? 1. Examine Shahn’s work, The Promise of the New Deal. What is the central action of this third panel of the three-part mural? (Answer: top left corner a teacher lectures to students about the AFL, CIO and other unions; lower right planners study the blueprints for the community they are creating; lower and upper centers of mural show men and women who will soon be residents; top right a COOP building.) 2. In your opinion, what message was Shahn presenting to his audience about the New Deal? (Answer: taken together, the three panels portray the New Deal in a positive light; this third panel displays the work of educators and city planners in creating a community that will offer a haven from the hardship of life in the city; the overall message is hope and a more promising future for the men and women who will populate Roosevelt.) 3. How might critics of the New Deal have responded to Shahn’s work? (Answer: to those on the political Right, the presence of pro-union education for the residents, a COOP, and government planning of a community might have appeared radical, even socialist.)

2. In your opinion, what message was Shahn presenting to his audience about the New Deal? 1. Examine Shahn’s work, The Promise of the New Deal. What is the central action of this third panel of the three-part mural? (Answer: top left corner a teacher lectures to students about the AFL, CIO and other unions; lower right planners study the blueprints for the community they are creating; lower and upper centers of mural show men and women who will soon be residents; top right a COOP building.) 2. In your opinion, what message was Shahn presenting to his audience about the New Deal? (Answer: taken together, the three panels portray the New Deal in a positive light; this third panel displays the work of educators and city planners in creating a community that will offer a haven from the hardship of life in the city; the overall message is hope and a more promising future for the men and women who will populate Roosevelt.) 3. How might critics of the New Deal have responded to Shahn’s work? (Answer: to those on the political Right, the presence of pro-union education for the residents, a COOP, and government planning of a community might have appeared radical, even socialist.)