Stress Testing and You: A Guide for the Interventionalist Matthew Schumaecker, MD Carilion Clinic April 7, 2014
Disclosures I read stress tests for a living The only reason I am not an interventionalist:
Trends in PCI
Trend in Nuclear Stress Test Results Rozanski et al J Am Coll Cardiol. 2013;61(10):
Part I: Why do We Perform Stress Tests? Diagnose coronary disease? Avoid lawsuits? Make money?
You Can’t Cath Everyone with Chest Pain!
Stress Testing for Detection of CAD
Are we really trying to predict CAD? If not, what are we doing here?
Why Detecting (asymptomatic) CAD Might Not Matter
Why Detecting (Asymptomatic) CAD Might Not Matter
All-Cause Mortality — As Randomized HR 0.86 (0.72, 1.04) P = HR 0.86 (0.72, 1.04) P =
Is there any role to stress testing asymptomatic individuals? NOT USUALLY
“Special” Asymptomatic Indications Consideration for class Ic antiarrhythmic Newly diagnosed cardiomyopathy CT calcium score > 400 Agatston units MAYBE – high risk (>20%/10 year) diabetics
Cumulative Event-Free Survival by SPECT Degree of Normalcy Hachamovitch R, Berman DS, Shaw LJ, et al. Circulation Feb 17;97(6): n=5534
Elhendy et al Cumulative Event-Free Survival by Stress Echo Degree of Normalcy
Cardiac Death Rate Stratified by Revascularization vs. Medical Therapy and by SPECT Degree of Normalcy Hachamovitch R, Berman DS, Shaw LJ, et al. Circulation Feb 17;97(6): Black boxes – Medical Therapy White boxes – Revascularization
Incremental Prognostic Value of MPI Hachamovich et al. Circulation Feb 19;105(7):823-9
Incremental Prognostic Value of Echo Marwick J Am Coll Cardiol.Marwick J Am Coll Cardiol Jul;30(1):83-90.
Prognostic Value of an Equivocal Study Berman DS, Hachamovitch R, Kiat H, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol Sep;26(3):
Part II: Advances in Nuclear Cardiology
PET Advantages of PET over SPECT – Higher energy resolution – Mandatory attenuation correction – Quantification of coronary blood flow Disadvantages of PET over SPECT – Camera is MUCH more expensive – Radioisotopes are very short-lived
SPECT vs PET Tc 99m 140 keV ɣ ray F 18 E=mc 2 511keV photon 511keV photon e-e- β+β+
Cardiac PET Half life of currently utilized cardiac PET perfusion agents: AgentT 1/2 N seconds O seconds Rb-8275 seconds
Cardiac PET 18 F Fludeoxyglucose has t 1/2 of 110 minutes BUT This is a viability agent, not a perfusion agent
18 F-Flurpiridaz PET Jamshid Maddahi, M.D., FACC, FASNC, and René R. S. Packard, M.D.
123 I-BMIPP 99m Tc can be used to evalulate chest pain at rest but only if patient is having pain at the time.
Cardiac Memory Myocytes preferentially metabolize FFA In ischemia millieu, switch to glycolysis
Cardiac Memory Substrate switch can last up to 24 hours If injected with 123 I-BMIPP, SPECT images will show defect if patient has been ischemic within 24 hours Dilsizian et al, Circ 2005;112:
BMIPP Trial J Am Coll Cardiol Jul 20;56(4):290-9
D-SPECT
CZT Much more photosensitive than Na-I
Stress First/Only 60-70% nuclear studies normal If stress images are normal, rest images are not clinically valuable In lower risk patients, we could do stress imaging and only if abnormal bring back for rest
Radiation Exposure Normal BMI ProcedureRadiation Exposure Dual Isotope Imaging traditional SPECT24mSv Same Isotope (Tc-Tc) Imaging/ traditional SPECT 12mSV Same Isotope (Tc-Tc) Imaging / D-SPECT4 mSv Stress Only (Tc) / D-SPECT1 mSv
Part III: Discuss