Leveling the Carbon Playing Field Beijing, September 2008 Rob Bradley Climate, Energy and Pollution Program World Resources Institute

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Unlocking global market opportunities Vienna, Austria, 31 January 2008 Mr. Tony Clark Commercial Counsellor, Embassy of Sweden, Beijing Head of the Swedish.

Advertisements

Group Integrating CDM and PoA structures into a NAMA: Case-Studies by South Pole Group September 5 th 2014 Christian Dannecker Director Forestry and Land.

Consumption based Accounting and Energy and Climate Policy Professor John Barrett.

Sectoral Approaches to the Post-2012 Climate Change Policy Architecture Jake Schmidt, Director of International Programs Center for Clean Air Policy *******

Ann Gordon Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment Belmopan Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions in the post 2012.

INDONESIAN THEMATIC RESEARCH ON UTILIZATION OF ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS: Case Study on Pulp and Paper Industry Ministry of Environment Indonesia.

Sustainable Development Policies and Measures: Putting development first in a carbon-constrained world. COP11 December 5, 2005 Rob Bradley Climate and.

© OECD/IEA Sectoral approaches to greenhouse gas mitigation In-session workshop AWG – UNFCCC – Bangkok 2 April 2008 Richard Baron – IEA Baron, Reinaud,

Beyond CDM: Options for the wind industry 21 April 2010, Warshaw EWEC 2010 Marion Vieweg.

11th Asia-Europe Business Forum Beijing, 22 October 2008 Marcin Korolec Deputy Minister of Economy Poland.

China’s Policies on Climate Change: a Perspective of Development Ji ZOU Renmin University of China The Harvard Alumni Association and the Harvard Clubs.

Derek Eaton Division of Technology, Industry & Economics Economics & Trade Branch Geneva, Switzerland “Designing the Green Economy” Centre for International.

PRME Seminar “Responsible Management of GHG Emissions” Fri 14 October 2011 Gujji Muthuswamy Department of Management Faculty of Business and Economics.

Sustainable Development, Policies, Financing October 9, 2011

Environmental Sustainability in the Extractive Industry: The Case for Climate Change Mitigation Dr Uwem E. Ite.

OECD Model simulations for OECD’s Environmental Outlook: Methods and Results Presentation at the Fourth Annual Conference on Global Economic Analysis Purdue.

Agenda Markus Amann Methodology Fabian Wagner Initial results for emissions from energy use and industrial activities Ian McCallum Estimates of mitigation.

“Transforming construction in Mongolia using Supplementary Cementitious Materials” Mr. YEROOLT BAYART Director of International Cooperation Division, Ministry.

1 WORKSHOP ON THE PREPARATION OF THE FOURTH NATIONAL COMMUNICATION FROM ANNEX I PARTIES Dublin, 30 September – 1 October 2004 National circumstances in.

Climate change, trade and competitiveness – A European perspective Geneva Annual China Dialogue November, 27-28, 2008 Fredrik Erixon European Centre for.

Global Air Quality: Policies for Ozone Depletion and Global Warming Chapter 13 © 2004 Thomson Learning/South-Western.

Trade and Climate Change: International Perspective Mac Callaway, Ph.D UNEP-RISØ Center Technical University of Denmark CPA International.

CGE Analysis of Border Tax Adjustments for Imported/Exported Steel Products Masato YAMAZAKI National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology,

An Introdution of Energy Situation and Policy of ROK September 2010 Park, Jimin.

CO 2 Emissions Embodied in Austrian International Trade Kurt Kratena, Ina Meyer Austrian Institute of Economic Research – WIFO 11. FIW-Workshop Studien.

Two Approaches to Measuring “Green” Mark Doms Chief Economist Department of Commerce Association of Public Data Users, September 19, 2010.

Experiences and lessons learned from the TNA of China WANG Can Tsinghua University, China UNFCCC workshop on Technology Needs Assessments Bonn, Germany.

Viet Nam Green Growth Strategy

A Sectoral Approach for the Cement Sector The Cement Sustainability Initiative (CSI) Patrick Verhagen, Holcim Group Support Ltd Keidanren/WBCSD joint seminar,

Gas Development Master Plan Structure of the Demand and Supply Scenarios (DASS) Component Capacity Building Workshop Bali, 1-2 July 2013.

Nov , GenevaPost Kyoto Protocal and Technology Transfer1 China’s Engagement in Post-2012 Negotiations: Issues of Technology Transfer and Intellectual.

Economies on Transition: At the Crossroads of Development Olga Gassan-zade Center for Clean Air Policy, Ukraine SB-18, Bonn, June 9.

World Bank Energy Sector Lending: Encouraging the World’s Addiction to Fossil Fuels Heike Mainhardt-Gibbs Bank Information Center – March 2009.

Chapter Twenty- Nine: The Global Economy and Policy.

Carbon tax policy BUSA submission to Portfolio Committee on Trade and Industry August 2013.

Low carbon scenarios for the UK Energy White Paper Peter G Taylor Presented at “Energy, greenhouse gas emissions and climate change scenarios” June.

EU Environmental Standards: What can Ukraine expect? Ihor BOHATYRIOV Project manager, “A strategy for Ukraine’s integration into the European Energy Community”

INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY AGENCE INTERNATIONALE DE L’ENERGIE IEA industrial efficiency work Paul Waide Energy Efficiency and Environment Division International.

The Cement Sustainability Initiative A Sectoral Approach for the Cement Sector December 2007 Patrick Verhagen, Holcim DEDICATED TO MAKING A DIFFERENCE.

OECD work on fossil fuel subsidies Helen Mountford Acting Deputy Director OECD Environment Directorate 14 December 2009.

1 Input by South Africa on responses to climate change Seminar of Governmental Experts 16 & 17 May 2005, Bonn.

SEAN WALSH FEBRUARY 24, 2010 China and Climate Change.

Technology Development and Transfer for Climate Change Mitigation and Adaptation: Imperatives for South Africa 26 th September 2011 Kwa-Zulu Natal Pre-COP.

Integrating Climate Change with Core Business Activities Jonatan Pinkse & Ans Kolk University of Amsterdam Business School The Netherlands.

Comparison of GHG mitigation efforts between Annex 1 countries Markus Amann International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis (IIASA)

WHAT IS NEW : PERCEPTION & POLITICS NATIONAL ACTION PROGRAMMES SHIFTS IN GROWTH PATHWAYS WOULD RESULT IN AVOIDANCE OF EMISSIONS, NOT THE OTHER WAY ROUND.

Informal Thematic Debate of the General Assembly Climate Change as a Global Challenge 31 July 2007, United Nations The way forward: International Context.

WHY ENERGY MATTERS? Energy is central to nearly every major challenge and opportunity the world faces today. Be it for jobs, security, climate change,

Policy questions to be addressed and structures of IMACLIM-CHINA Wang Yu Institute of Energy, Environment and Economy Tsinghua University 29 January 2015.

Ann Gordon Ministry of Natural Resources and the Environment Belmopan Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions in the post 2012.

Dutch presidency agenda on ensuring industrial competitiveness Erik Janssen, Ministry of Economic Affairs The Netherlands.

Carbon Capture and Storage Potentials and Barriers to Deployment.

Green jobs policy instruments and approaches. Research Relevance to Policy Jobs, Economic Growth, Poverty, Productivity, Eco. Diversification, Import.

Is climate change mitigation an obstacle for development? Michael Jakob and Jan Steckel Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research April 19, 2012.

Korea-Australia FTA and Business opportunities Vice President Heung chong Kim Korea Institute for International Economic Policy.

International Energy Workshop Venice, June Energy and CO 2 Efficiency in the European Manufacturing Sector: A Decomposition Analysis Dirk.

European Commission Enterprise and Industry Title of the presentation | Date | ‹#› EWI Workshop Europese vergroeningseconomie: uitdagingen en kansen Didier.

Competitiveness effects of environmental tax reform ( COMETR ) Paper read to the seminar: “ Environmental Tax Reform ” Institute of European Affairs M.

Technology Oriented Agreements: five examples Stefan Bakker side event COP/MOP3, Bali, December 7 th, 2007.

Post 2012 Carbon Market Development Global Carbon Markets 9. August 2011 Jørgen Fenhann.

Impact of Climate Change on South Africa’s Future Trade Relations

CICULAR ECONOMY GLOBAL SUSTAIN Barcelona, October 19

LEVERAGING US EXPERIENCE: INDIA’s ENERGY PRODUCTIVITY ROAD MAP

Association of Textile and Clothing Industry of SR

Energy and Economic Competitiveness

Roadmap for moving to a competitive low carbon economy in 2050

VIEWS FROM THE ENERGY INTENSIVE INDUSTRIES

Key elements of Finnish Climate change strategy

Adapting to Climate Change with ICTs

China Dialogue, Geneva, 28th NOV, 2008

Presentation transcript:

Leveling the Carbon Playing Field Beijing, September 2008 Rob Bradley Climate, Energy and Pollution Program World Resources Institute

Trade measures in US climate policy Concern about heavy industry jobs is politically central Prevent “leakage” of emissions Encourage trading partners to take action on climate

Sector and Product Coverage 2005 Source: IEA, BEA, BLS and ILO. Emission data is 2004, Employment and GDP data is SITC Codes of included products (version 2): Steel (672, 673, 674, 675, 676, 677, 678, 679), Chemicals (51111, 51112, 51113, 51122, 51123, 51124, 51211, 52218, 52323, 52213, 52251), Cement (6612), Aluminum (6841, 6842), Paper (641, 642) Sector Products included in study Direct Emissions share of US total Total Emissions share of US total Economic Output share of US GDP Employment share of US total Ferrous Metals Steel ingots, bars, rods, plates,sheets, tubes 36 mtCO2 0.62% 96 mmtCO2 1.65% $36.7 billion* 0.29% 250, % Non-ferrous Metals Aluminum ingots, bars, rods, plates,sheets, tubes 15 mmtCO2 0.25% 75 mmtCO2 1.29% $24.4 billion* 0.20% 144, % Chemicals Olefins, Aromatics, Inorganics, Ammonia 146 mmtCO2 2.50% 377 mmtCO2 6.48% $ billion 1.68% 872, % Paper & Pulp Paper and Paperboard, cut and un-cut 64 mmtCO2 1.11% 159 mmtCO2 2.74% $54.6 billion 0.44% 484, % Non-metal Mineral Products Hydraulic cement 66 mmtCO2 1.14% 97 mmtCO2 1.66% $53.3 billion 0.43% 505, % Sub-total 327 mmtCO2 5.62% 804 mmtCO % $378.2 billion 3.04% 2,253, % All Manufacturing 631 mmtCO % 1,369 mmtCO % $1,512.5 billion 12.14% 14,226, %

Carbon-Intensive Imports by source and share of domestic consumption Source: UN Comtrade, IISI and CSA estimates As Share of ConsumptionBy Country of Origin

US Imports by Origin 2005 Rank SteelAluminumChemicalsPaperCement SourceShareSourceShareSourceShareSourceShareSourceShare 1Canada18.56%Canada51.02%Trinidad41.58%Canada66.89%Canada16.06% 2EU17.25%Russia17.08%Canada19.30%EU16.82%China14.04% 3Mexico13.08%EU6.24%Ukraine7.34%China3.53%EU13.87% 4Brazil8.24%OPEC5.10%OPEC6.60%Korea2.24%OPEC9.97% 5China7.11%Brazil3.79%EU4.49%Mexico2.20%Thailand8.60% 6Korea5.67%China3.07%Korea4.36%Brazil1.84%Greece8.28% 7Russia5.12%S. Africa2.50%Brazil3.79%Chile1.50%Korea7.94% 8Turkey4.16%Tajikistan2.43%Russia3.19%Japan0.96%Mexico6.49% 9Japan4.12%Argentina1.54%Eq. Guinea2.76%Norway0.85%Columbia5.49% 10India2.70%Australia1.27%Chile1.52%OPEC0.71%Peru3.11% AnnexI54.42%77.57%34.46%86.66%34.61% Source: UN Comtrade SITC Codes of included products (version 2): Steel (672, 673, 674, 675, 676, 677, 678, 679), Chemicals (51111, 51112, 51113, 51122, 51123, 51124, 51211, 52218, 52323, 52213, 52251), Cement (6612), Aluminum (6841, 6842), Paper (641, 642)

The Extent of US Trade Leverage US Imports as Share of Global Trade and Production Source: UN Comtrade, IISI, IAI, FAOStat, OGJ, USGS and CSA estimates US Supply and Demand as Share of Global Total US Imports and Exports as Share of Global Trade

Bali and sectors Developing country mitigation actions Technology development and transfer International sectoral approaches

Developing country actions Art. 1 (b) (ii) Nationally appropriate mitigation actions by developing country Parties in the context of sustainable development, supported and enabled by technology, financing and capacity-building, in a measurable, reportable and verifiable manner;

Conclusions There is real potential for multilateral engagement in international instruments. US policy will aim to protect energy intensive sectors against relocation. At present the trade measures being proposed are unlikely to be effective on their own.