The Cigarette Withdrawal Scale CWS-21 Jean-François E T T E R, PhD Institute of social and preventive medicine Faculty of Medicine University of Geneva Switzerland
Valid measurement is essential to science Comprehensive validation studies are lacking, for most withdrawal scales Available scales were developed in UK or USA, and may not reflect situation in other countries Some widely used scales are not recent: - Minnesota Withdrawal Scale (Hughes) = Shiffman-Jarvik = 1976 Background
To develop and assess the validity of a new, self-administered scale measuring cigarette withdrawal symptoms, using state-of-the-art psychometric methods Objective
Questionnaires sent out by mail to a representative population sample in Geneva, n=2,000 "Please describe how a smoker feels when he is deprived of nicotine" 404 answers from smokers and ex-smokers Qualitative survey: methods
Nervous, impatient 288 Irritable, bad mood, frustrated158 Urgent, strong need to smoke116 Somatic signs (various)91 Anxiety, fear72 Stressed57 Difficulty concentrating51 Increased appetite48 Depressed, sad29 Insomnia, fatigue26 Qualitative survey: results
Qualitative data + theory (DSM, ICD) = 61 items 5-point Likert scales (agree-disagree) Survey on STOP-TABAC.CH, in French N=3,050 Retest after 17 days (n=118) Follow-up after 41 days (n=1,119) Methods
21-item scale 6 dimensions, cover DSM-IV and ICD-10 Sound factor structure (bootstrap resampling) Depression-Anxiety Craving Irritability- Nervousness-Impatience Appetite-Weight Gain Insomnia Difficulty Concentrating Results
Reliability
Relapse at 41 days: odds ratios
Change 0-17 days in recent quitters
Scores for various intervals post-quit
CWS-21 is a reliable withdrawal scale, performed well on tests of construct validity, is sentitive to change over time predicts relapse Conclusions
STOP-TABAC.CH => Documents Get these slides and CWS-21 at: