Case COMP/39.315 – ENI (Abuse of Dominant Position) International Competition Law Dushanka Dovichinska 24 Nov 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
GREETINGS TO CHARTERED ACCOUNTANTS FOR ICAIS POST QUALIFICATION COURSE VIDEO CONFERENCE FROM HYDERABAD 26 AUGUST 2005.
Advertisements

The role of competition authorities in utilities regulation. Co-operation with sector regulators. The role of Competition Council of Latvia Valdis Latkovskis.
National implementation of REMIT Henrik Nygaard, Wholesale and transmission (DERA)
1 Licensing in the Energy Sector Georgian National Energy And Water Supply Regulation Commission Nugzar Beridze June 27 – July 3, 2008.
European Commission Decision Relating to proceeding under Article 82 - EC Treaty (Case COMP/ – RWE Gas foreclosure) Master of International Management.
MAIN PREMISES TO THE FINANCIAL SECURITY RULES USED BY THE GAS TRANSMISSION OPERATOR GAZ-SYSTEM S.A. IN TRANSMISSION CONTRACTS AND NETWORK CONNECTION AGREEMENTS.
Liability and Procedure in European Antitrust Law The EU Damages Directive Does the European Union overstep the mark again?
1 The Regulatory Authority for electricity and gas:, The Regulatory Authority for electricity and gas: objectives, tasks, independence, accountability.
1 Access to file An effective right of defence? Karen Williams Hearing Officer EUROPEAN COMMISSION.
Tamara Ćapeta  Comparable to evolutive federations : Article 1 TEU:  “By this Treaty, the HIGH CONTRACTING PARTIES establish among themselves.
1 Georgian National Energy and Water Supply Regulatory Commission Tariff Regulation Gocha Shonia Department of Methodology and informational provision.
Introduction to EU Law Cont.d. ECJ – TFI (Arts ) “The Court of Justice and the Court of First Instance, each within its jurisdiction, shall ensure.
Märt Ots Estonian Competition Authority Baltic Electricity Market Fora Vilnius Latest developments in Estonia.
1 THE ENFORCEMENT OF EU COMPETITION LAW IN THE ENERGY SECTOR THROUGH NON-ADVERSARIAL COMMITMENTS Yane Svetiev and Lucila de Almeida (EUI)
European Commission Taxation and Customs Union Brussels, 10 November Taxation of International Artistes and Community Law European Commission
1 The Regulatory Approach to Fostering Investment David Halldearn Ofgem 28 September 2006.
LUMSA – International Commercial Law 30 October 2014 Prof. Avv. Roberto Pirozzi
Development of Competition Enforcement in Poland – 2009 Commitment Decisions Morvan Le Berre Competition Enforcement in.
LUMSA – International Commercial Law 24 October 2014 Prof. Avv. Roberto Pirozzi
EU 3 rd Energy Package in the context of the tax problems of cross-border energy supplies REPORTER: KUROCHKIN DENIS ALEKSEEVICH EURASIAN RESEARCH CENTRE.
Small-Scale Embedded Generation (AMEU and its Work Group Input) Gerrit Teunissen 18 April 2013.
Emergency Briefing Remote Gambling - European Update THIBAULT VERBIEST Attorney-at-law at the Brussels and Paris Bars Founding Partner of ULYS LawFirm.
Asta Sihvonen-Punkka Director General of EMA Vice-Chair of ERGEG Baltic Electricity Mini-Forum 24 th of April, 2009 Riga The 3 rd Package – implied changes.
EU Sanctions Regulation published in the Official Journal EU Council and Commission agree package of restrictive measures 29 July 2014 Sanctions 31 July/12.
1 THE THIRD ENERGY PACKAGE – THE ENERGY COMMUNITY APPROACH Energy Community Secretariat 20 th Forum of the Croatian Energy Association and WEC National.
1 INTRODUCTION OF THE LAWS ON ABUSE OF DOMINANT POSITION AND ABUSE OF MONOPONY POSITION IN VIETNAM Speaker: Mr. Trinh Anh Tuan Official Vietnam Competition.
Ricardo CARDOSO DE ANDRADE, DG COMP B-1 6 September 2006 Competition Directorate-General Energy Sector Inquiry – findings and the way forward Presentation.
ANRE ROMANIAN ENERGY REGULATORY AUTHORITY - ANRE Challenges in transitioning to a liberalised, competitive market – Romanian experience.
Gas Regional Initiative North - North West DG COMP’s perspective Walter Tretton, DG Competition, Energy & Environment Unit 4th Stakeholder Group Meeting,
The 3rd package for the internal energy market Key proposals EUROPEAN COMMISSION Heinz Hilbrecht Directorate C - Security of supply and energy markets.
1 Workshop on the Directive 96/61/EC concerning (IPPC) Integrated pollution prevention and control INFRA Public participation & access to environmental.
Best Practices on the conduct of proceedings concerning Articles 101 and 102 TFEU: Talking business, or real business? GCLC Lunch Talk Series, Hilton Hotel,
BIIC London, 16 November 2007 The new EU merger remedies policy Dr Johannes Luebking Deputy Head of Unit, Directorate C-5, DG Competition The views expressed.
1 Remedies under Article 82 EC Per Hellström DG Competition, European Commission (speaking in a personal capacity - the views expressed are not necessarily.
1 The Regulatory Authority for electricity and gas: an overview of the legislation The Regulatory Authority for electricity and gas: an overview of the.
Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Energy Infrastructure Package ERGEG preliminary.
1. Law of Ukraine on “Natural Monopolies”, Order of the President of Ukraine “On National commission providing energy state regulation ”, NERC Order “On.
Directorate General for Energy and Transport European Commission Directorate General for Energy and Transport Regulation of electricity markets in the.
1. Main types: 1. Formal International and Supranational Organizations -WTO: the world trade agreements provide for binding obligations of the Member.
XVI th Madrid Forum Madrid, 28 May 2009 Walter Boltz (Gas Working Group Chair) Transparency guidelines and GRI transparency work.
3 rd Stakeholders Group Meeting Project status and details of the ongoing development of the load-flow based capacity calculation/allocation system CEE.
1 Second Annual Conference on Competition Enforcement in the Recently Acceded Member States Brno 23 April 2010 Development of Competition Enforcement in.
Gas sales – Competition aspects Petroleumsrett - JUR oktober Catherine Banet, Stipendiat. Nordisk Institutt for Sjørett – Avdeling for.
INVESTIGATION AND ENFORCEMENT Presentation by Duncan T. Morotsi 15 th March
LUMSA – International Commercial Law 30 October 2015 Prof. Avv. Roberto Pirozzi
1 The Spanish Gas Industry and the 3 rd Package Antoni Peris Mingot – Sedigas President GIE Annual Conference – Madrid.
RULES GOVERNING PRIVATE MEMBERS’ LEGISLATIVE PROPOSALS Presentation by NA Table to Committee on Private Members’ Legislative Proposals and Special Petitions.
FEDERAL ANTIMONOPOLY SERVICE Moscow 2006 New Antimonopoly Law of the Russian Federation.
Independence and powers of regulators: legal and institutional requirements Heinz Hilbrecht, Director, European Commission World Forum on Energy Regulation.
Lars Kjølbye, Head of Unit, DG COMP B-1 22 February 2007 Competition Directorate -General The Energy Sector Inquiry Identified problems and future action.
1 NERSA CEO: Smunda Mokoena 14 September 2010 Presentation to the Portfolio Committee on Energy and the Select Committee on Economic Development PUBLIC.
Florence Forum, November 2008 Regulation (EC) 1228/ ERGEG Compliance Monitoring.
Energy Community Secretariat Committee on Industry, Research and Energy, European Parliament Energy Community Activities and Outlook for the Future Brussels,
International Association of Oil and Gas Producers Stakeholder view of EFET R_ISO Proposal Prague – 21 January 2008.
Eon/Ruhrgas and Eon/Endesa: A comparative analysis The Legitimacy of the “Change of Control clause”
EU Business Law: Anticompetitive agreements (Art. 101 TFEU) Dr. Agata Jurkowska-Gomułka.
Evaluation of restrictions: art. 15 and art TAIEX Seminar on the EU Service Directive, 3 May 2007 Carlos Almaraz.
Sangmin Song, Director, Anti-Monopoly Div., KFTC MRFTA & IP Rights 1.
Legal Foundations of European Union Law II Tutorials Karima Amellal.
ROMANIA NATIONAL NATURAL GAS REGULATORY AUTHORITY Public Service Obligations in Romanian Gas Sector Ligia Medrea General Manager – Authorizing, Licensing,
The failure of IA in the Council- case of the climate change package Malgorzata Kaluzynska Office of the Committee for European Integration.
European Union Law Week 10.
Competition Law and its Application: European Union
Dispute Resolution Between ICT Service Providers in Saudi Arabia
The 3rd package for the internal energy market
Interactive Gaming Council Board Meeting I-Gaming Legal status
Competition Law in the Energy Sectors
The competition enforcement in regulated sectors
Commissioner’s Legal Advisor - Italian Competition Authority
Parental liability & investment firms
Presentation transcript:

Case COMP/ – ENI (Abuse of Dominant Position) International Competition Law Dushanka Dovichinska 24 Nov 2010

Outline 1. Subject matter 2. The Addressee 3. Procedural Steps under Regulation (EC) No 1/ Opening of the proceedings 5. Preliminary Assessment 6. Proposed Commitments 7. Commission Notice 8. Proportionality of the Final Commitments 9. Conclusion

1. Subject Matter The Decision was addressed to ENI Spa ("ENI") and concerned ENI's conduct on the gas transportation market to Italy and on the gas supply markets in Italy. Commission came to the conclusion that ENI hold a dominant position on the market for transport of gas to Italy and on the gas supply markets in Italy and might had foreclosed competition in the Italian gas supply markets by way of a refusal to supply gas transport services to third parties by:  Capacity hoarding (refusing to grant competitors access to capacity available on the transport network)  Capacity degradation (granting access in an impractical manner)  Strategic underinvestment (strategically limiting investment)

2.The Addressee ENI is an Italian-state controlled company active at multiple levels of the production, transportation and supply chains in the energy sector, predominantly in natural gas and oil; it is a fully integrated gas company, with activities in the production and import of gas, in the gas transmission and storage, in the downstream gas distribution business and in the business of international transportation services. In 2008, ENI had net profit of EUR 8.8 billion

3. Procedural Steps  May 2006, an inspection in ENI’s premises  On 20 Apr 2007, the Commission initiated proceedings against ENI  On 6 Mar 2009 the Commission adopted a Statement of Objections  On 4 Feb 2010, ENI submitted commitments to the Commission in response to the concerns raised in the Statement of Objections  On 5 Mar 2010, a notice was published in the Off. Journal of the EU  On 8 July 2010 ENI submitted revised commitments (the "Final Commitments")  On 9 Sep 2010, the Advisory Committee on Restrictive Practices and Dominant Positions was consulted  On 13 Sep 2010, the Hearing Officer issued his final report.

4. Opening of the Proceedings On 20 April 2007, the Commission initiated antitrust proceedings concerning: capacity hoarding and strategic underinvestment against ENI S.p.A. and its subsidiaries No conclusive proof of infringement

5. Preliminary Assessment The system of infrastructures to import gas into Italy Relevant markets  The relevant product markets (supply of gas vs. gas transport services)  The relevant geographic markets (the routes constitute one relevant market) ENI's dominant position on the relevant markets Substantial part of the internal market The competitive concern of a refusal to supply strategy  Capacity hoarding (reduced access despite a steady demand)  Capacity degradation (e.g. delayed allocation of capacity, short-term basis)  Strategic limitation of investment (kept a tight control over transport)  Conclusion (protected profit, negative effects on competition) Effect on trade between Member States

6. Proposed Commitments ENI did not agree with the findings of the Commission’s Statement of Objections, but offered commitments to divest:  its current shareholdings in companies related to international gas transmission pipelines to a suitable purchaser  its stakes in the transmission system operators (the TSO's)  its entire shareholding in Eni Gas Transport GmbH  its entire shareholding in Eni Gas Transport Deutschland S.p.A  auxiliary equipment necessary for the operation of the transmission network  intangible assets necessary for the operation of the transmission network  not to renew or prolong contracts

7. Commission Notice The Commission received 14 responses from interested third parties, namely from shippers, some vertically integrated TSO's and two regulators. In response to the market test, ENI submitted a revised proposal for commitments ("Final Commitments") on 8 July 2010, which took account of the comments received. The Commission considered the Final Commitments sufficient to effectively remove the competition concerns expressed in the Statement of Objections.

8. Proportionality of the Final Commitments Principle of proportionality: the measures adopted by EU institutions must be suitable and not exceed what is appropriate and necessary for attaining the objective pursued. Commitments were not imposed by the Commission for an established infringement but voluntarily proposed by the undertaking seeking to bring the procedure to an end. The Final Commitments were necessary and sufficient to address the concerns identified by the Commission without being disproportionate.

…Aside According to Article 9 of Regulation 1/2003 (the EU antitrust law), the Commission may decide in cases where it intends to conclude antitrust violations to make commitments legally binding on companies that offer them. These, so-called Article 9 settlement decisions allow the Commission to resolve competition concerns more rapidly. Because they represent a settlement, Article 9 decisions do not conclude on the existence of an infringement. But were a company to break legally binding commitments, the Commission could impose a fine of up to 10% of the total annual turnover without, in this case, having to prove the violation either.

9. Conclusion The Commission made the Commitments, offered by the undertaking concerned to meet the Commission’s concerns expressed in its Statement of Objections, binding upon it. The decision did not conclude whether or not there had been or still was an infringement. The Commission considered that there are no longer grounds for action and the proceedings in this case should therefore be brought to an end.

References Case documents, available on: etails.cfm?proc_code=1_39315

Thank You For Your Attention