A Review of Waste Needs Assessment for New Waste Treatment Processes CIWM Cymru Wales & NW Centres Autumn Event 2010.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Business Resource Efficiency and Waste (BREW) Programme Mark Atherton Head of Sustainable Development Northwest Regional Development Agency Nick Storer.
Advertisements

Delivering Urban Transformation Strategies: A Public Sector Led UDF Des Gardner Head of Regeneration (Legal) Des Gardner City Solicitors.
Planning: Can localism work in your area? Dr Michael Harris Deputy Head of Policy & Research John Romanski Senior Neighbourhood Planning Advisor, Planning.
ENERGY FROM WASTE Local Policies and Impacts on Commercialisation.
Moving to the Local Development Plan System in Bridgend County Borough.
The Wash and Fens Green Infrastructure Plan Paul Espin.
Recycling for the Future – The Dublin Waste Management Plan Mary O’Reilly RPS Consulting Engineers.
West of England Joint Waste Core Strategy Preferred Options Allan Davies Planning Policy Officer North Somerset Council West of England Partnership Office.
ENVITECH-NET Forum Thematic Session 2 Challenges of the Waste Directive Increasing recycling rates through waste management integration via the concept.
Dr Chris Boomer Development Plans Manager (DoE Northern Ireland)
Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Manual Environmental Protection Department H. M. Wong 18 June 2005.
News of the Board and Stakeholder Group Nikki Silcock Sustainable Resources Board Co-ordinator.
News of the Board and Stakeholder Group Helen Watson Sustainable Resources Board Co-ordinator.
Wenxin Zhang Department of Civic Design University of Liverpool
The Knowledge Resources Guide The SUVOT Project Sustainable and Vocational Tourism Rimini, 20 October 2005.
Leicestershire and Rutland Association of Local Councils and the Campaign to Protect Rural England Supporting Communities in Planning: Planning Workshop.
Waste measurement & improving performance trainer organisation location date.
Presentation to the Executive of the Carlisle Partnership 13 July 2009.
Copyright 2009 Northumberland County Council A Neighbourhood Plan for Broomhaugh and Riding Peter Rutherford, Northumberland.
Langdon Parish Council Site Allocation Consultation Two sites at East Langdon One site at Green Lane, Martin Mill.
A Skills and Learning Observatory for Wales Building on best practice A review of Observatory development in the UK and beyond.
Needs Assessment: Young People’s Drug and Alcohol Services in Edinburgh City EADP Children, Young People and Families Network Event 7 th March 2012 Joanne.
Mid Wales LTP Stakeholder Workshop 3 rd October Presentation by Ann Elias and Janice Hughes.
STRATEGIC DIRECTION UPDATE JANUARY THE VISION AND MISSION THE VISION: ENRICHING LIVES AND CREATING SUCCESSFUL FUTURES. THE MISSION: EDUCATION EXCELLENCE.
JOINT STRATEGIC NEEDS ASSESSMENT Rebecca Cohen Policy Specialist, Chief Executive’s.
Eccles Housing Market Report Community Committee Meeting 25 th January 2005 Shahla Zandi Strategy and Planning (Partnerships and Planning)
Marine Planning: The role of the MMO and Partnerships Steve Brooker Head of Marine Planning.
Toolkit for Mainstreaming HIV and AIDS in the Education Sector Guidelines for Development Cooperation Agencies.
The aim / learning outcome of this module is to understand how to gather and use data effectively to plan the development of recycling and composting.
West of England Joint Waste Core Strategy September 2009.
Environment (Wales) Bill Legislation to sustainably manage Wales’ resources.
Advice Strategies Advice Strategies in Bedford Borough and Central Bedfordshire Bedfordshire Advice Forum Facilitated by Organised by Supported by.
The Local Development Framework and other Planning matters Presentation to the Bradford Property Forum 19 June 2007.
Community Information Events Derry City & Strabane District Council.
Waste Development Framework. CC roles and responsibilities for waste What the WDF is (and isn't) How waste procurement fits in a parallel universe And.
Pilot Projects on Strengthening Inventory Development and Risk Management-Decision Making for Mercury: A Contribution to the Global Mercury Partnership.
Key Principles for Preparing the DCSD Community Plan 1.Integration – Social, Economic, Environmental Well-being focused on outcomes and people centred.
RTPI Conferences is managed by Kaplan Hawksmere on behalf of the Royal Town Planning Institute Strategic Planning for Renewable Energy Sarah Young MRTPI.
Dartmoor National Park Local Development Framework Presentation for South Hams Strategic Partnership Meeting Monday 8 th March 2010.
Designing a Better Walsall: An introduction Jon Lord Principal Regeneration Officer.
ROMANIA MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, RESEARCH AND INNOVATION National Centre for Development of Vocational Education and Training Implementation Unit of Phare.
Update on contaminated land A Defra view Presented by: Maggie Charnley Date: 10 September 2014.
Local Economic and Community Plans – A Regional Assembly perspective Malachy Bradley Assistant Director.
Southend Together Secretariat 21 st February Developing Southend Together’s Sustainable Community Strategy
Regional planning I local plan I design & regeneration I transport planning I research & information Southend-on-Sea Core Strategy Development Plan Document.
International Atomic Energy Agency Regulatory Review of Safety Cases for Radioactive Waste Disposal Facilities David G Bennett 7 April 2014.
Integrated Transport Policy / Regional Transport Plan Environment & Regeneration Scrutiny Committee 13 December 2006.
Know your Community Rights Localism 6 months on Neighbourhood Planning Collecting the Evidence Alyson Linnegar 16 November 2012.
Evaluation of Structural Fund Programmes – the Swedish experience Implementation of the mid term evaluation - lessons for the future Maria Eriksson NUTEK.
Neighbourhood Planning in Herefordshire An Overview by Samantha Banks Neighbourhood Planning Team Leader – Herefordshire Council.
Herefordshire Local Plan Members’ Seminar 9 October 2015.
MHPP Forum James Shuttleworth Planning and Infrastructure Manager, MCC 9 December 2015 Greater Manchester Spatial Framework.
Devon Enhanced C&I Programme. © Babcock Integration LLP, No unauthorised copying permitted. 2 Priorities To.
Warwickshire County Council WARWICKSHIRE WASTE CORE STRATEGY: PREFERRED OPTION AND POLICIES CONSULTATION 22 nd September – 18 th November 2011.
planning aid for scotland unique national charity helping people engage with planning impartial & independent not part of Scottish Government or any Local.
Waste and Minerals Core Strategy Preferred Strategy Consultation Land Disposal Workshop Uckfield 3 November 2009 Ian Blake, Team Manager – Waste and Minerals.
Neighbourhood Planning in Haringey Myddleton Road Strategic Group 7 th November 2013.
Use of Resources Lifting the burden CAA experience at Barrow in Furness Borough Council Mick McKinnell, ICT & Customer Services Manager.
Building More Homes on Brownfield Land: Local Development Orders Brownfield Land and LDO Masterclass February 2015 Mide Beaumont DCLG.
Mitigation, Enhancement and Monitoring Session 9 Health in SEA.
Neighbourhood Planning training for Parish Councils in Harborough District Session A: Setting a Vision.
Experience of collaborative working in Essex A response to changing agendas? Sarah Richards, Assistant Director Sustainable Environment and Enterprise,
Item 3 South East Plan and recent policy statements…
SW Rural Update- Royal Agricultural College, Cirencester (Fri 23 rd Nov 07) Waste Management in the Rural Sector- from Legislation.
Tom Warburton Head of Regional Strategy One NorthEast
Progressing a Single Water Utility Approach
Drivers for Welsh medium and bilingual qualifications and assessment
Neighbourhood Planning Workshop
National accounts and SDGs
© Fresh Thoughts Consulting
Presentation transcript:

A Review of Waste Needs Assessment for New Waste Treatment Processes CIWM Cymru Wales & NW Centres Autumn Event 2010

Overview Background – Role & requirements of WNA Approach - Case study Greater Manchester Authorities Conclusions

Why do we need WNA? & where does it fit?

Background England The Government introduced a new system of preparing development plans under the Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act Thus Waste Local Plans are to be replaced with a Local Development Framework, which is to be produced by any authority with responsibility for waste planning (unitary, county councils, sub-regional partnerships Greater Manchester). The framework is like a 'folder' containing a collection of waste documents known as Local Development Documents (there are 2 types: Development Plan Documents and Supplementary Planning Documents).

Background Usual documents within the Waste (& Minerals) development framework include: Development Plan Documents covering spatial planning documents which would form the development plan for the area. Usual that this results in a Waste Core Strategy and a Waste Management Development Plan Document.Waste Core StrategyWaste Management Development Plan Document Supplementary Planning Documents (which are non statutory documents) which can provide further details on policies and proposals set out in a 'parent' Development Plan Document A Statement of Community Involvement explains how the authority plans to involve the community in the preparation of the waste planStatement of Community Involvement The Waste Development Scheme sets out the programme for the preparation of the Waste planning documentsWaste Development Scheme The Annual Monitoring Report provides monitoring data on the progress of the Waste Development Scheme and the performance of policies within any adopted Development Plan DocumentsAnnual Monitoring Report Proposal maps (to show the policies and proposals for waste plans in authority on an Ordnance Survey base). AND…………………

Background AND An evidence base of studies, including a Waste Needs Assessment and Sustainability Appraisal which will support the policies and proposals of waste plansevidence baseWaste Needs AssessmentSustainability Appraisal

Background Wales Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004 (Commencement No. 4 and Consequential, Transitional and Savings Provisions) (Wales) Order 2005 Unitary plans replaced by “Local Development Plans” (same as England –Welsh Assembly for examination) Wales Waste Strategy, The Technical Advice Note (Wales) 21 Waste (TAN 21)1 provides part of the planning guidance and is intended to facilitate the introduction of a comprehensive, integrated and sustainable land use planning framework for waste management in Wales.

Background Wales TAN 21 states that the principal objective of the Regional Waste Plan for each of the three Welsh regions is to set the framework for Unitary Authority Development Plans to be prepared, and as such the Regional Waste Plan may be material to decisions on individual planning applications. Within the regional waste plan – “WNA” undertaken to establish waste arisings and capacity Wrexham – North Wales Region – “Developing a regional waste plan for the north Wales region, Strategic assessment report, 2002 ≈ “WNA”

WNA A credible evidence base is required to provide the basis for the proposed plans and policies. Robust & up to date to withstand scrutiny as evidence to support LDF at an examination Support core strategic policy development

WNA Needs to be able to support the development of planning policies for waste within the LDF by; Up to date baseline data on current dynamics of waste generation/management in authority area for ALL waste streams Ability to estimate future waste arisings for each waste stream based on set of agreed forecasting scenarios & agreed targets for recovery/recycling/re-use of waste over set plan period Assess existing waste management & disposal capacity including landfill in the authority’s area & estimate future waste management & capacity requirements

Case Study on approach for WNA Active Model Development

Model Development

Capacity Database

Model Development

Needs Assessment Scenario selected Capacity Gap Required Capacity Available Capacity Waste treatment Selection

Model - graphs

Case Study Association Greater Manchester Authorities GMGU act for AGMA in waste planning strategy – producing a JWDPD for 10 LA’s (Bolton, Bury, Manchester, Oldham, Rochdale,, Stockport, Tameside, Trafford and Wigan)

Project aims 1.To produce a model able to simulate future waste facility requirements under a range of scenarios. a clear process for updating baseline data quickly and cheaply 2.To apply the best currently available baseline data and growth forecasts to the model to estimate future capacity gaps and facilities include sensitivity analysis of results

Approach Capacity gap = Forecast arisings – existing & future planned capacity 1.Assembling and Updating the Baseline Data 2.Forecast model development  Anchor in the real economy  Reflect uncertainties  Allow view of causes of the gap

Shape of the model GMFM Households Employees Basic forecast model MSW, C&I tonnages etc to 2025 Survey data C&I CD&E Tonnages by SIC, SOC & destination MSW data Tonnages Waste streams Destinations Waste by substance Substance by destination Sensitivities Waste generated: By employee By household Economic growth: On CD&E waste Capacity data

Scenarios 1.Baseline: baseline Baseline GMFM and assumes 2006 C&I management option “proportions” remain constant. MSW targets achieved & PFI facility capacity Baseline: Maximum recycling and recovery As 1 plus high level of C&I recycling and recovery 3.Baseline: Median recycling and recovery As 1 plus median C&I recycling and recovery 4-6. As 1-3 but with GMFM Accelerated Growth figures.

Landfill (non-haz) gap – scenarios 1, 2, and 3

Recycling gap – scenarios 1, 2, and 3

From capacity gap to facilities

Facility need for Greater Manchester

Facility Need for Greater Manchester

Updated (website)

Conclusions For WNA Robust evidence base & statutory requirement LDF process Advocate “Live Model” – efficient/effective to undertake updates easy as new data comes available on arisings or new permissions granted for capacity Model advantage - Interactive – run many scenarios Graphs drawn directly – tables – evidence base report and for presentation to members Report – easily updated from running model and traceable data sets and interpretation Time & effort baseline data - Accuracy related to standard of baseline data (NW & Wales have benefit of excellent C&I primary data) Produce in partnership with stakeholders

“WNA” for Private Sector Modelling process equally appropriate to determine need for any new waste treatment/management process Support business case for a new facility Addressing planning issues when planning application for new site –robust evidence base, demonstrate need & help identify feedstock requirements.

Tel